Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just stay in this house forever?

34 replies

unicormb · 04/08/2022 16:44

I hate moving, HATE it. When we rented in London in our late twenties and thirties it was a constant cycle of being out priced from certain areas and having to hop around the capital to the next not-quite-so-nice place that we could afford. We did this until our second child was born, then moved out of London and bought our three bed semi, in a nice SE coastal town.

It's in a great area, v close to our DS's special school, which is Outstanding, and DD's local primary is round the corner. It's a lovely street. We have great neighbours. DH has a big garden office. We have good transport links. And we love our back garden which is bigger than the avg around here.

But our third bedroom is quite small, it's hard imagining a teenager in there. But we could go up into our loft and create a big master suite up there, as many neighbours have done (I snoop at improvements on Rightmove a lot!). We would also want to extend our kitchen out by about 2m and add a downstairs loo, as many of our neighbours have also done.

We can afford our mortgage, which is fixed for three more years. We could borrow more around remortgaging time and get some of the work done.

DH says extending and finding funds for it all is a huge hassle and maybe we should just consider moving in a few years. But I cannot get my head around moving again, it drove me insane. I love living here.

Has anybody else just stuck with the place they love and improved it? I have family nearby and we could stay with them for a while when works happen. We also have a few caravan parks around locally and could probably just hire one of them out of season for a month or two reasonably cheaply.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MiniCooperLover · 04/08/2022 18:43

Someone said to me the other day it's worth thinking of houses as if they cost £100K per bedroom to move. So I'd be extending as everything else you've said sounds lovely.

We'd love to be detached and have a driveway. We are on street parking with 4 doubles and a single with decent living space and a great garden: I can't bring myself to move just for a driveway, I just can't 🙈

chilliesandspices · 04/08/2022 18:42

I want to do the same. Just love it and extend where we need to. The biggest hassle has been trying to find a good builder to do it. They all have waiting lists as long as our arms and costs went up exponentially after brexit. We first looked at a kitchen extension in 2019 and couldn't get anyone to even come round. By 2020 we all know what happened. DH is currently looking at new properties but a big part of me thinks we should just use what we've got and pounce as soon as a recession hits and builders are scrabbling for work.

redfairy · 04/08/2022 18:42

I see someone has already said it...you should go on Love it or List it

bridgetreilly · 04/08/2022 18:41

Plenty of teenagers over the years have managed perfectly well in the small bedroom. Extend if you want to and can afford to, but it’s also fine not to.

cherryface66 · 04/08/2022 18:38

We were in a similar position - kids were becoming teens, bedrooms too small, I was adamant that I didn't want to move - spent the best part of 30k on a loft extension and then moved 6 months later. It gave us extra space but didn't put it in the right part of the house and all the other problems were still there.

Begoniasforever · 04/08/2022 18:38

I think op if I was you I’d look at some houses in your next price bracket. And then draw a comparison. Yes it’s a pain, but it’s a short lived one.

LillianGish · 04/08/2022 18:32

Love it or list it? One of my fave property programmes.

TokenGinger · 04/08/2022 18:18

We did a double storey extension on ours. The cost was far less than the cost of stamp duty, surveys, solicitor fees, increased mortgage costs etc.

I'm the same as you, OP. The thought of moving house fills me with dread. I'm quite happy staying here until DP and I are old and wrinkly.

LizzieBet14 · 04/08/2022 18:14

Like you, we've moved too many times. NEVER, EVER AGAIN. As you can improve, I think you should definitely stay put.

Theoldwrinkley · 04/08/2022 18:04

You only need to read on here about the stress that new neighbours can bring. And you'll definitely get new neighbours if you move. I'd stay put. I've only moved 4 times in my life (I'm 63) and find any prospect really daunting.

easyday · 04/08/2022 18:00

There's a reason people extend up and back! I live in a terraced house where the original third bedroom is 6' by 7' - a cot possibly (there should be a minimum size to call something a bedroom, and if there is, this ain't it)! So the vast majority have added a bedroom plus en-suite in the loft and extended 2m in to the garden. Now it's a three bed with office, front room and generous (for a terrace) kitchen/diner.
A loft conversion here (SW London) is £70k minimum. Extend out back another £50-75k depending on kitchen. But it adds over £200k to the value of the house, if no more (based on an unextended house £850k, Extended £1.1-1.2m).
You can live in situ for most of the loft conversion- might be the odd day without water. Extension is more tricky as you are likely to be redoing the kitchen. But plan it well and don't make changes and time renting can be kept to a minimum.
It's no brainer.

yomellamoHelly · 04/08/2022 17:59

We looked at other properties. Was really disappointing to see what we could get.
Extending was cheaper (though even without our house is still better than what we could find).

Plantpotpetal · 04/08/2022 17:57

Is it worth spending all that money on extending a semi? Do you get on with your neighbours? Will you still get on with them after the building work has been done?

pearandsausage · 04/08/2022 17:57

We've been having similar conversations recently as since Covid we now need 2 work spaces in the house as we now both work from home most of the time, as well as imminent 2nd baby. We like our house and the area we live in as well as our garden!

Moving would double our mortgage (and probably be in the region of £35k stamp duty) and we have quite a specific search area so we've started the process of a loft extension and had some initial plans drawn up - I'm expecting the actual build to be messy and horrible for some of it but worth the disruption, we're aiming to do it next summer.

Next up waiting on an estimate of costs, expecting it to be massive and will need to remind myself of the above...!

WinterMusings · 04/08/2022 17:53

unicormb · 04/08/2022 17:01

*a week, not a mth. But also, we are a seaside town. Lots of short term lets.

Especially 6 months over winter!!

your place sounds great! & while it undoubtedly is stressful doing a big renovation project, buying & selling is not without its serious stresses!

plus you'll get your place so much closer to exactly what you want than if you buy somewhere.

your location sounds perfect!!

lots of teens have the box room though, it's totally doable!

hoorayandupsherises · 04/08/2022 17:50

I was always in the box room until I moved out of my parents. It was totally fine. I think you'd be mad to move in your circumstances. I find it hard to believe that it really would be cheaper to move once you take all the fees and costs into account?

bellamountain · 04/08/2022 17:47

We did the same to our house OP. My eldest was a toddler at the time and we didn't need to move out. We had separate companies, so a loft company did the loft which included an en suite. It started in the month of March and we were in there by the June. We then had a break from building works over the summer and started our kitchen extension in that November and were finished by the following March. We've since had to have the garden patio re landscaped but that doesn't impact on the house.

Moonface123 · 04/08/2022 17:40

l have two double bedrooms and one box room, it works out well as eldest who has boxroom isn't around very much, either at work, over his girlfriends or out with friends, so l am glad now l never bothered extending, we have managed fine, his computor etc is downstairs.

MixedMarriageMadness · 04/08/2022 17:32

I am in the SE too in a beautiful seaside town...I moved to a new bigger house rather than extend my old lovely one and I deeply regret it. We knew all the faults in the old house but uncovered so much here that we have had to invest £1000's to get it right. Don't move...invest in the place you love and love it more than ever!!

Stripedbag101 · 04/08/2022 17:22

I bought my ideal house last year - it just needed a little extra so I have just started an extension project! Pushing out 2m at the back and adding a utility room to the side.

my perfect house simply didn’t exist in my price bracket in my area when I was looking - so I am making it!

it’s lovely to design the perfect house for your own individual needs.

i haven’t found it too stressful yes - I have a temporary kitchen and half the house is missing!

yes it is expensive - but it’s a long term investment: and like you I love my garden.

carefullycourageous · 04/08/2022 17:21

I think it is fine to stay put if there are good reasons to do so. Not wanting to move is a decent enough reason. I had two teens in a two-bed, we couldn't move for <reasons> and so we stayed until we could. It was fine. The kids have fond memories of that house, our family was a happy family.

There is far more to life than a slightly bigger bedroom.

BiddyPop · 04/08/2022 17:20

Ours was a 2 doubles, 1 box room, family bathroom upstairs, sitting room and kitchen/diner downstairs house when we bought it 20 years ago. We started by replacing the single glazing and the falling apart bathroom, and slowly improved further over the years. Including an extension across the back of the house (extended kitchen/diner/living room with a utility cupboard and a downstairs shower room off it) and converting the attic into a large bedroom (but box room is now firmly an office - would need a built-in bed as needed 5 inches from it to build the stairs up).

If it works now, and is in the location you want, and has capacity to extend - I would stay put.

TheBikiniExpert · 04/08/2022 17:18

I think it's a very UK thing to be always changing. I'm in Italy in a flat that's a bit small but we'd still rather stay put than move. I grew up in the UK and moved loads. I'm enjoying staying in one place. 😌

WatermelonSugarSigh · 04/08/2022 17:18

I think given all the lovely things you've written about where you live you'd be mad to consider moving!

Even if you couldn't do the work to extend, it's still a bedroom and own personal space for the teen. Loft beds etc as a pp said help in this situation.

Good luck whatever you decide!

Jerabilis · 04/08/2022 17:14

I found a loft conversion much cheaper than moving. I also found that it was very unobtrusive, I barely noticed they were there, although this was pre covid so I was working out of the house in the daytime.