Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my contributions to our family home count for anything?

395 replies

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 15:12

I know that I have few rights as per current legislation but am I being unreasonable to think I have earned a segment of our next family home (I'm talking in terms of ethical principles not legality)

Living with partner of 15 years and our 4 children. He is buying a house outright which will be paid for by selling the house we have lived in for 10 years and is also owned by him. I have worked and contributed to running the household for 15 years and have, of course, sacrificed career progression to support my family and his career, not to mention, I have also grafted on the current house, helping to increase its value and spent small amounts of money on it when I have been able to.

Partner thinks I'm ludicrous to even have these thoughts as I've not put in any big amounts of money. I had hoped I might be able to aim for a small mortgage on our next home that I could pay off myself to give me some security and to just feel like I have a place in the world that I have earned but he wants to own it outright.

Marriage not on cards right now for various reasons.

OP posts:
AhNowTed · 05/08/2022 09:51

I missed the bit where his family paid for the house.

If I funded a house for my son I'd want it protected from a short term relationship.

But this is 15 years and 4 children later, and that is completely different.

I think I'd want the mother of my 4 grandchildren to have a stake in the house.

AhNowTed · 05/08/2022 09:33

No you are not being unreasonable.

I'm staggered you've allowed this to happen though.

You have 4 children with this man and zero security. Fucking hell.

STOP paying a single penny into this house. Start savIng because you're going to need it.

Oh, and your "partner" is a complete shit.

IrisVersicolor · 05/08/2022 09:24

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 09:12

Well yes, anything could be argued, but is there any precedent of it being argued successfully under these circumstances?

I’m not a lawyer, but I do know someone who gained a beneficial interest in their partner’s property through paying rent and contributing to renovations.

A key question is whether DP in this case has always maintained he was the sole owner, or whether he has given OP informal assurance in the past that she could have an interest in it, and whether she relied on that when contributing to the house.

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 09:12

IrisVersicolor · 05/08/2022 09:11

She’s been paying into the household (as well as the children) 50:50, depending on what that covers it could be argued to be a form of rent.

Well yes, anything could be argued, but is there any precedent of it being argued successfully under these circumstances?

IrisVersicolor · 05/08/2022 09:11

StillHappy · 04/08/2022 22:50

But that needs to be offset by the living there rent-free.

Is there any relevant case law to support your view when there was no expectation of acquiring ownership and no rent was paid?

She’s been paying into the household (as well as the children) 50:50, depending on what that covers it could be argued to be a form of rent.

Greenlife1 · 05/08/2022 08:09

So yabu wins! It is interesting but not surprising.

OP posts:
Greenlife1 · 05/08/2022 08:02

@StillHappy not entirely correct. "Ethics" can also refer to the set of guiding principles we all live by, based on our own interpretation of morality, or rather, "what is right" (our feeling).

Which makes way for interesting debate!

OP posts:
Hermione101 · 05/08/2022 05:53

If you are the higher earner, why has your career taken a hit? If he is a lower earner, why has childcare not been organized in a way that enables you to maximize your earnings? If you have not been paying rent for 15 years, have you been saving? Do you have a pension pot?

SD1978 · 05/08/2022 05:10

You've stated you're the higher earner, and the it's 50/50- where does your earnings on top then go? He has made it obvious he sees the property as his, and you really need to work on getting on that's yours- if that means being stricter wit h your money, you'll have to- all children expenses come out of the joint pot and your money, like his house, is yours to do with as you want

ArcticSkewer · 05/08/2022 04:16

rwalker · 04/08/2022 21:06

Your update changes it for me basically his family gave him the money for the house It's his.
TBH if I was ever in the position to give my kids money for a house . I'd want it protecting . Not someone pay billing a few bills and waltzing off with a chunk of it .
He's not bought a house of the back of your input.

Me too.

His house has nothing to do with you or your silent contribution to the relationship.

That's a really big factor to miss out!

silentpool · 05/08/2022 02:38

OP, you say you have the potential to be the higher earner. Go back to work full time and buy yourself a house and make him share the parenting load. Fill up your pension and feather your own nest.

Don't marry him now, it's probably too late and he clearly doesn't want to. If you will make more than him, you may do better not marrying him as any divorce will cost you (once you have assets). I'd probably leave him too but maybe he has some redeeming qualities that you haven't shared...

Mally100 · 04/08/2022 23:38

BeanieTeen · 04/08/2022 23:10

We normally don’t cheat on our husbands or wives, not because of legalities, but because of morals. Why the reticence from posters to not want to say clearly that it is morally wrong for her partner, not to make her an equal parter and to instead hoard all the power?

Yeah but this is more comparable with ‘my partner cheated on me five times before we got married, now we’re married and he’s cheated on me again a sixth time. AIBU in thinking he should stop cheating on me?’

The cheating has become irrelevant, because the OP is a muppet for marrying him in the first place. This was foreseeable and the OP needs to take some personal responsibility for her choices.

Here, the OP has lived for years with someone she isn’t married to, who doesn’t want to marry her, in a house that is not in her name. In that whole time, a conversation about joint home ownership never seems to have been had. It’s irresponsible. Whether the OPs DH has morals or not has become irrelevant. You don’t have control over someone else’s morals, you do have control over your own choices and decisions.

Perfectly said. Why is there no accountability these days? Absolutely everything is a victim mentality. You sleepwalked through having 4 kids? Op has a career so presumably she can engage her own mind at work.

Mally100 · 04/08/2022 23:35

TailSpinner · 04/08/2022 20:33

You are the victim. As was I. It therefore isn’t your ‘fault’. Of course we should have married. But it’s still not our fault that we trusted human nature to be decent. All the blame is on your partner.

Yes, poor little women who can’t possibly think with their brains rather than their trusting hearts…
You are not children, you are grown women, responsible for your own lives, and who can think ahead to make adult decisions. You didn’t do so, then I’m afraid, yes of course you are in part to blame. Wise up. If we all just sit around waiting for men to become more ‘decent’ instead of taking some initiative then women’s circumstances will never improve.
So OP can wallow in her victimhood, or wake up and take responsibility for herself now and maybe challenge her partner on why marriage is ‘off the table’ and consider whether this guy is worth having in her currently very insecure future.

This reply should be posted on each thread of this nature. Op you and you alone are solely responsible and accountable for your choices. You have a brain, a voice and agency. Stop hiding behind this mentality where men are these powerful, untouchables and you are a victim. Even now, you still have choices to make. You had 4, 4!! Kids before this occurred to you? That is on you.

RenegadeMatron · 04/08/2022 23:27

We normally don’t cheat on our husbands or wives, not because of legalities, but because of morals. Why the reticence from posters to not want to say clearly that it is morally wrong for her partner, not to make her an equal parter and to instead hoard all the power?

Couldn't agree more, which is why I said upthread that the OP’s beef should not be with the system.

It should be with her shitty partner.

But 🤷🏻‍♀️ he now has exactly what he wants, and isn’t obligated to anyone (least of all the OP).

So why - when he is clearly of questionable morals - would he change now?

StillHappy · 04/08/2022 23:27

A minor point, I know, but ethics don’t come into this. Ethics is generally referring to an actual codified set of rules that a group (doctors, lawyers etc.) need to abide by which are in addition to laws. Ethics have little room for argument, everyone agrees what the rules are, they are written down and enforced by an official body.

This isn’t just a semantic point; a question like this one is about morals, which aren’t so set in stone. There’s plenty of room for disagreement about what the right thing to do morally is here.

butterflied · 04/08/2022 23:23

How he got the house also matters. Everyone on here would be screaming that you should protect your asset if he had lived in your house for more than a decade. Not many would tell you he had a right to anything. He protected himself, you need to do the same.

MsPincher · 04/08/2022 23:12

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 20:44

@Haffiana @CherryBlossomAutumn
I don't feel like I've made any mistakes either. Our children are financially provided for and have college fund and whilst I'd like to be further along I my career I still have (the remnants of) one :)

It does feel like the person whom takes more responsibility within the home and with the children is in a really vulnerable position but at the moment I am not interested in being anyone's wife for financial reasons. No thanks! That being said, I wouldn't blame anyone for marrying for security if necessary. I feel fortunate that my children's financial future is secure and I think if I didn't have this I may feel very differently about the whole marriage thing.

I don’t want to be dependent on someone financially either. So I didn’t get married either. But I worked full time and built my career. And I’m now a single mum but financially successful.

You made a choice not to work full time and to spend time with your kids instead. That’s great. But of course that will financially disadvantage you.

however it’s not all bad - it does sound like he has financially supported you so you are in a better position than if he had no money or you were on your own.

BeanieTeen · 04/08/2022 23:10

We normally don’t cheat on our husbands or wives, not because of legalities, but because of morals. Why the reticence from posters to not want to say clearly that it is morally wrong for her partner, not to make her an equal parter and to instead hoard all the power?

Yeah but this is more comparable with ‘my partner cheated on me five times before we got married, now we’re married and he’s cheated on me again a sixth time. AIBU in thinking he should stop cheating on me?’

The cheating has become irrelevant, because the OP is a muppet for marrying him in the first place. This was foreseeable and the OP needs to take some personal responsibility for her choices.

Here, the OP has lived for years with someone she isn’t married to, who doesn’t want to marry her, in a house that is not in her name. In that whole time, a conversation about joint home ownership never seems to have been had. It’s irresponsible. Whether the OPs DH has morals or not has become irrelevant. You don’t have control over someone else’s morals, you do have control over your own choices and decisions.

CherryBlossomAutumn · 04/08/2022 22:58

Most people do seem to think that you are not being unreasonable by the poll vote.

I don’t know what the motivation is amongst posters who have labelled the OP


  • entitled

  • foolish

  • to blame

  • to be grateful he even ‘gave’ her and the kids a home

  • lazy


Women blaming other women. Rather than the man. It’s sad to see.

Some have replied to my posts to say that blaming the man is wrong. Why? That is not to say the OP should not fight for her moral equality, of course she should. There is more than the legal system. We normally don’t cheat on our husbands or wives, not because of legalities, but because of morals. Why the reticence from posters to not want to say clearly that it is morally wrong for her partner, not to make her an equal parter and to instead hoard all the power?

StillHappy · 04/08/2022 22:50

IrisVersicolor · 04/08/2022 20:48

You may be able to establish a beneficial interest in the home if you can show the money you spent on the home and the work you did on it. Do you have bank statements and receipts? Have you done work yourself - painting, DIY etc?

But that needs to be offset by the living there rent-free.

Is there any relevant case law to support your view when there was no expectation of acquiring ownership and no rent was paid?

StillHappy · 04/08/2022 22:48

bloodyunicorns · 04/08/2022 20:37

Your p is morally wrong. Very wrong.

How so, though? It sounds as though he’s provided a home, fed and housed their children, and provided for her means for many years.

If that’s the case, where does the entitlement come from to also have a share of the house that he bought?

Ginger1982 · 04/08/2022 22:33

FinallyHere · 04/08/2022 22:04

she's lived rent free for 15 years

@rwalker

As I said, at his whim, with absolutely no rights or power.

She should have insisted on marriage then.

Decidualcast · 04/08/2022 22:33

What’s the point of your post exactly?

Decidualcast · 04/08/2022 22:27

SallyWD · 04/08/2022 16:28

This is awful! When my parter (now DH) and I bought our first house together he was listed as having a greater share of the house which I completely understood as he paid for the deposit and was paying the mortgage. However as soon as we had a child together he felt very uncomfortable owning more of the house than me because he saw us as equals - despite the fact he was paying more financially. We changed things so we both owned 50% of the house. This was HIS idea. We're now married. I can't believe your partner is treating you like a second class citizen after 15 years and raising a family together. You're in a very vulnerable position.

You are one lucky person to have such a considerate man. Give him a big hug.

NrlySp · 04/08/2022 22:26

Why can’t your name be on the deeds. Or a will where you are the beneficiary of the house if your partner dies

Swipe left for the next trending thread