Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my contributions to our family home count for anything?

395 replies

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 15:12

I know that I have few rights as per current legislation but am I being unreasonable to think I have earned a segment of our next family home (I'm talking in terms of ethical principles not legality)

Living with partner of 15 years and our 4 children. He is buying a house outright which will be paid for by selling the house we have lived in for 10 years and is also owned by him. I have worked and contributed to running the household for 15 years and have, of course, sacrificed career progression to support my family and his career, not to mention, I have also grafted on the current house, helping to increase its value and spent small amounts of money on it when I have been able to.

Partner thinks I'm ludicrous to even have these thoughts as I've not put in any big amounts of money. I had hoped I might be able to aim for a small mortgage on our next home that I could pay off myself to give me some security and to just feel like I have a place in the world that I have earned but he wants to own it outright.

Marriage not on cards right now for various reasons.

OP posts:
Dillydollydingdong · 05/08/2022 20:40

You should explain to him that you need protection for the future. You are worried that you could end up on the streets if your relationship ends. Which is a very real concern if you're not married, and your name isn't on the deeds. All your hard work and financial contributions will be wasted. Start saving up now so that you can afford to look after yourself if necessary.

Dahliasandtea · 05/08/2022 20:33

This is exactly why I married my partner. He was talking kids and life plans and wanted me to move in with him into his house, give up my job to move etc etc… and I said ‘yup, let’s get married and we can do all of that. But I’m not making a step towards any of it until I am legally recognised as your wife’

i don’t believe in the institution of marriage in the conventional sense. But it was the only way to make sure that when his career went interstellar (as it is now) that my contribution would be recognised. My career stagnated when I moved and then had kids and I’m having to start again now the kids are a bit older. Luckily he does recognise all of this and we are very happy and we are now buying a house together in 50/50 agreement. But having been brought up in a family which made ‘messy’ divorces look like an episode of Peppa Pig… I can’t put trust in his ‘word’ if we ever end up breaking up.

SallyB392 · 05/08/2022 20:28

I don't know all the legistics, but I do know that you can place a charge on a property owned by a partner. This prevents them from selling the house from under you.

Please. Please PLEASE see a solicitor or if this is not possible CAB. I think legislation has recently changed so you may be better protected than you realise!

justgotosleepffs · 05/08/2022 19:50

I think you have messed-up ideas of what marriage is, and that's why your in tjis terrible position. You say things like "I don't want to be someone's wife" as though its an antiquated old-fashioned institution and you want no part of it. But you've basically screwed yourself over because you've been playing the role of s wife for all these years, just without the legal protections that come with it. Marriage protects women financially. And a registry office wedding can be done incredibly cheaply with just 2 witnesses so you could literally do it by the end of thr summer holidays

Cherchezlaspice · 05/08/2022 19:49

Greenlife1 · 05/08/2022 08:09

So yabu wins! It is interesting but not surprising.

What on Earth do you mean? 81% of people have voted that you’re not being unreasonable!

Rhaenys · 05/08/2022 19:47

Greenlife1 · 05/08/2022 08:09

So yabu wins! It is interesting but not surprising.

The vast majority have voted YANBU?!

etcher70 · 05/08/2022 19:42

But surely this situation is morally wrong? I know technically we all 'should' be married for protection, but life often doesn't work out like that and women usually look after the children, do the lion's share of the housework and consequently lack the career progression and the pay rises. Is this fair? So many women are in this situation, shouldn't we be trying to change this?!

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 19:37

Mummyoflittledragon · 05/08/2022 18:30

Personally I would talk to a solicitor op about beneficial interest and how to protect yourself. This man doesn’t seem to respect you and what you’ve done for and given him at all.

That’d really just be a waste of money though. She’s not contributed to a mortgage, or paid rent (they have only split bills) so if anything she’s been benefitting from living there for free rather than building up a beneficial interest.

It’s his house, where he has let her live while they are a couple. She doesn’t and shouldn’t try to launch a claim on something that she hasn’t contributed towards.

PlopPlop · 05/08/2022 19:37

Me and DP aren’t married, but want to spend the rest of our lives together. He has a house, we won’t be getting married for reasons, I also earn more than him and pay for a lot of the household stuff.

He added me to the deeds as tenant in common because he isn’t a prick, we also have legal arrangement in place (wills, insurance etc) in the absence of a marriage certificate.

bpirockin · 05/08/2022 19:36

YANBU 81% - are you not seeing the same as I am OP ?

Spuffcat · 05/08/2022 19:21

As well as seeking legal advice, may I suggest researching tax etc as you would be classed as having a second home - so might incur sdlt.

Dibbydoos · 05/08/2022 19:10

Put a question into the Legal Queen - seen her on fb reels.

Mummyoflittledragon · 05/08/2022 18:30

Personally I would talk to a solicitor op about beneficial interest and how to protect yourself. This man doesn’t seem to respect you and what you’ve done for and given him at all.

Baaaaaa · 05/08/2022 18:30

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 15:26

No, what matters at the moment is whether I am being unreasonable!

Entirely reasonable, and he is not.

However as others have said, it makes no difference.

Honestly, I think he is being immoral.

He has deprived you of the chance to get on the housing ladder whilst accruing assets for himself and benefitting from your labour (and cash) The only reason he would do that is to protect himself in the event of a breakup.

If you are splitting everything else 50/50 on this basis, you are being fleeced.

I would be insisting on changes or making exit plans.

Mumofthreeteenagers · 05/08/2022 18:13

WinterMusings · 04/08/2022 15:29

15 years, 4 kids & he wants to own your family home on his own?

how did it come to this?

has no one ever said to you 'WTF are you doing?'

Did you have a very very rubbish upbringing, that you feel you have so little worth that you willingly accepted this arrangement & even now feel you have to BUY into it by getting a mortgage.

this wanker has taken you for a ride and you've gone along for the ride -why??

This^^

JimTheShit · 05/08/2022 18:08

AussieMozzieMagnet · 04/08/2022 18:45

My husband bought our house in my name as well. The house will one day go to our child. We are therefore united as a family and well protected. There's a reason marriage has always been so important to protect the family unit. But yeah, you just contribute your bit to the "partnership" and see how far that gets you in reality.

We are therefore united as a family and well protected

Yes, because you're married so if you split up your husband would legally be entitled to 50% of the house in your name. Or if the OP were married, it wouldn't matter whose name the house was in; she'd have the full protection of marriage.

The OP is not married. In the UK, legally she is entitled to absolutely nothing.

pigeonstreet123 · 05/08/2022 18:01

If you have higher earning potential; get yourself back to work full time. Its his turn to take over childcare. You can start saving

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 05/08/2022 12:07

I was with my ex for 15 years, unmarried, career on backburner etc - I bloody made sure that I was still on houses, mortgages etc. So when we split I got my share.

OP, YANBU, you are being the very essence of reasonable - you absolutely should have a stake in your home.

This reminds me of that lady on twitter who came out with the binder of how it was going to work financially if she were to have children with her partner, and the partner was utterly scandalised at how business-like she was being whilst all us jaded single mother were cheering her on for her nouse.

Decidualcast · 05/08/2022 11:30

Dixiechickonhols · 05/08/2022 10:17

Yes there is a possibility to try to establish a beneficial interest but it’s not easy and depends on evidence - law doesn’t readily give part of your home away to someone. It’s usually where someone can prove they paid for substantial renovations. It will cost thousands in legal fees so isn’t often done.

The I paid £1000 he paid £1000 into pot and that paid all bills inc his mortgage isn’t enough.

Agree. Establishing beneficial interest is not for the faint hearted. You’ll need forensic evidence and ££££ to fight it. There is case law for establishing beneficial interest. However, sounds like her DP never gave her reassurance of a stake in the property.

BeanieTeen · 05/08/2022 10:59

STOP paying a single penny into this house. Start savIng because you're going to need it.

I think she’s going to need it too. Just going on what’s been written it doesn’t sound like there is much spark or love in this relationship - not on either side. The OP will be out on her arse at some point. If her DH loved her and respected her and saw this as a viable relationship to last into the future, there would be no reason to not share homeownership with her. Generally, women choose not to marry because they feel it will negatively affect their independence. Men, and yes I know I’m generalising, choose not to marry when they actually don’t see the relationship lasting. They pussyfoot around saying marriage isn’t for them or use delaying tactics, when actually they are just waiting for someone better to come along. He’s avoiding a messy break up by the sound of things - he doesn’t want to be in a situation where he loses his house. When those kids are grown up, that may well be the end of it.

SparrowsNest · 05/08/2022 10:40

Difficult to vote. YANBU to think your contributions should be recognised in a share of the family home. Unfortunately, legally, you don't have a leg to stand on which is sad.

SolasAnla · 05/08/2022 10:22

CherryBlossomAutumn · 04/08/2022 22:58

Most people do seem to think that you are not being unreasonable by the poll vote.

I don’t know what the motivation is amongst posters who have labelled the OP


  • entitled

  • foolish

  • to blame

  • to be grateful he even ‘gave’ her and the kids a home

  • lazy


Women blaming other women. Rather than the man. It’s sad to see.

Some have replied to my posts to say that blaming the man is wrong. Why? That is not to say the OP should not fight for her moral equality, of course she should. There is more than the legal system. We normally don’t cheat on our husbands or wives, not because of legalities, but because of morals. Why the reticence from posters to not want to say clearly that it is morally wrong for her partner, not to make her an equal parter and to instead hoard all the power?

But the OP herself has choosen not to have a husband, not to be a wife.

Even in marraige UK recognises the right of the individual to hold personal property.

In the UK, society has evolved to where 2 adults are free to make a decision to enter into a casual long term sexual relationship with no intent to form a permanent relationship.

With DNA testing the courts have the ability to identify who did (or did not) provid the sperm and make financial orders to provide for the upkeep of any children.
In fact all UK taxpayer provides financial support to childrens upkeep as a social good.

Marraige is a legal contract.

Society evolved into a situation where women were not legally recognised, they had almost no legal protection to hold property or retain custody of their children.

The contract was to ensure that the husband and his family had specific obligations to his wife and the children.

Marraige contracts always had clauses for the protection wife and ensuring that the childrens be provided for. Pre DNA any child born in a marraige was the legal responsibility of the husband irrespective of whos sperm was involved.

The OP and partner were also free to visit a solicitor and form a contract as a co-habiting couple.

The UK has decided that not all moral obligations should be legally enforceable.

Marraige removes the moral or ethical question.

JanisMoplin · 05/08/2022 10:22

AhNowTed · 05/08/2022 09:33

No you are not being unreasonable.

I'm staggered you've allowed this to happen though.

You have 4 children with this man and zero security. Fucking hell.

STOP paying a single penny into this house. Start savIng because you're going to need it.

Oh, and your "partner" is a complete shit.

All this. 4 kids!

We need education in school, I think, to teach girls that there is no such thing as a common law wife.
If you were the higher earner, why wasn't he the stay at home dad?

Dixiechickonhols · 05/08/2022 10:17

IrisVersicolor · 05/08/2022 09:24

I’m not a lawyer, but I do know someone who gained a beneficial interest in their partner’s property through paying rent and contributing to renovations.

A key question is whether DP in this case has always maintained he was the sole owner, or whether he has given OP informal assurance in the past that she could have an interest in it, and whether she relied on that when contributing to the house.

Yes there is a possibility to try to establish a beneficial interest but it’s not easy and depends on evidence - law doesn’t readily give part of your home away to someone. It’s usually where someone can prove they paid for substantial renovations. It will cost thousands in legal fees so isn’t often done.

The I paid £1000 he paid £1000 into pot and that paid all bills inc his mortgage isn’t enough.

Pinkdelight3 · 05/08/2022 10:15

More likely you'd want your 4 grandchildren to have a stake in it, but who knows if you'd even like their mother, let alone want to give her a house you paid for? Plus as they're not married, she could leave any time and make them sell the house if she has a stake in it. I think any warm impulse to give your DIL a stake in the house might soon be snapped out of in the cold light of day. Different if they're married, but OP was vague about reasons for not marrying and she might not have wanted to herself. They don't sound particularly solid as a couple so being together 15 years might well make them more likely to split than less.

Swipe left for the next trending thread