Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my contributions to our family home count for anything?

395 replies

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 15:12

I know that I have few rights as per current legislation but am I being unreasonable to think I have earned a segment of our next family home (I'm talking in terms of ethical principles not legality)

Living with partner of 15 years and our 4 children. He is buying a house outright which will be paid for by selling the house we have lived in for 10 years and is also owned by him. I have worked and contributed to running the household for 15 years and have, of course, sacrificed career progression to support my family and his career, not to mention, I have also grafted on the current house, helping to increase its value and spent small amounts of money on it when I have been able to.

Partner thinks I'm ludicrous to even have these thoughts as I've not put in any big amounts of money. I had hoped I might be able to aim for a small mortgage on our next home that I could pay off myself to give me some security and to just feel like I have a place in the world that I have earned but he wants to own it outright.

Marriage not on cards right now for various reasons.

OP posts:
Cherchezlaspice · 05/08/2022 23:54

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 23:40

You don’t think accusing me of having narcissistic personality disorder is an attack?

That’s quite an unusual take on the accusation. Do you view is as a neutral term then?

Her: My husband has read this, he thinks your partner is a spineless coward and a puy. He also thinks anyone who sees this as morally OK, to learn what 'Narcissistic personality disorder' means. He works in the opposite sector to me; he works with the actual abusers, the criminals. He can see those traits here and thinks you need to get out.

You: That is a personal attack and I’m repeating you.

Nobody made any accusations. I think you have a quite novel and self centring approach to communication and/or the English language.

Kate0902900908 · 05/08/2022 23:42

Op you have been extremely stupid. I’m sorry it’s harsh but you could be my sister. She had to walk away 3 years ago, with nothing. You need to get married or have something written up ASAP. You have contributed 50% you have built a life together and should that end you will have absolutely nothing but 4 children to financially support primarily. My sister never ever thought it would happen to her but it did. I can happen to you to.

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 23:40

Cherchezlaspice · 05/08/2022 23:36

How on Earth have you been personally attacked? What’s the matter with you?

You don’t think accusing me of having narcissistic personality disorder is an attack?

That’s quite an unusual take on the accusation. Do you view is as a neutral term then?

Cherchezlaspice · 05/08/2022 23:36

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 23:23

@GingerWit

“My husband has read this, he thinks your partner is a spineless coward and a puy. He also thinks anyone who sees this as morally OK, to learn what 'Narcissistic personality disorder' means”

Do you want to have another run at that?

Anyway, I reported your post for the personal attack. You need to learn to try to out your point across without accusing others of having a serious psychological problem just because they don’t agree with you.

It was a nice tough though that you gave your post what you thought was more weight by telling me that that bit was a man’s input.

How on Earth have you been personally attacked? What’s the matter with you?

SofiaSoFar · 05/08/2022 23:33

Obviously having young children has limited my working and saving capacity over the recent years. Ultimately, I can earn more than my partner but it didn't make sense to work more than part-time with childcare expenses and the fact that I would see the children less.

If he's a low earner, why were you the one to give up work?

Why did it not "make sense to work more than part-time" for YOU, but not HIM?

AshtonsMummy2017 · 05/08/2022 23:30

No you’re not being unreasonable to feel that you also are entitled to that security, especially as you’ve paid in. Unfortunately it sounds like he doesn’t see the value in what you bring to the table! Typical behaviour of a male who hasn’t had to contribute as much in the child rearing. The law isn’t on your side, unfortunately as you know! But no, to answer your question without making unneeded bitchy remarks, YANBU! Hope you work it out.

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 23:23

@GingerWit

“My husband has read this, he thinks your partner is a spineless coward and a puy. He also thinks anyone who sees this as morally OK, to learn what 'Narcissistic personality disorder' means”

Do you want to have another run at that?

Anyway, I reported your post for the personal attack. You need to learn to try to out your point across without accusing others of having a serious psychological problem just because they don’t agree with you.

It was a nice tough though that you gave your post what you thought was more weight by telling me that that bit was a man’s input.

CherryBlossomAutumn · 05/08/2022 23:21

@AhNowTed I agree I am not sure why posters would say to the OP that he ‘let her and the kids live… ‘ that’s up there with ‘living rent free’.

It’s misogynistic nonsense.

GingerWit · 05/08/2022 23:17

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 22:47

I don’t really see that it’s morally wrong. The house was a gift to him, she’s paid nothing whatsoever towards it, but has lived there rent-free. Why would she get to claim part-ownership because of that?

If we are going to start giving people’s property away to their girlfriends, how is this going to work? Some sort of sliding scale, so you get a percent or so of their estate after the first date, building to half a year after they invite you to live with them, or just some sort of hard cutoff, so you acquire half of what they themselves earned at the ten year point?

We already have a really good contract in place to ensure a shared allocation of assets, it’s called marriage. If a couple make the conscious decision to not get married, knowing that this means that assets remain individually owned, then what is the reason for retrospectively changing the deal?

No, that choice should be honoured. Get married if you want to go down the route of shared assets, or write up a contract to the same effect, or choose not to get married and keep things each owned by one person.

You don't need to get married. If you genuinely love someone and want to take care of them, their name will go on the mortgage no question's asked.

When you decide to have a partner, live long term with them, stick your D**k in them, put them through 4 pregnancies- It's a 50/50 decision. Those children belong to both of them, therefore you take on the responsibility of giving your family a shared roof over their heads. Everything becomes 50/50. Otherwise what you're saying is; You can house my offspring in your body, go through severe pain pushing them out, give up your life and career to continue my line, potentially ruin your body with problems which develop after pregnancy (even years down the line), but I won't share a mortgage with you. Does that sound OK to you? Isn't it about equality? Why would you not want your partner to share equal parts of your home?

To be honest, OP - I think he's used you. I work in a sector where I see financial abuse on a daily basis, including in the form of properties. I work supporting vulnerable adults who are exploited and financially abused. This is financial abuse.

My husband has read this, he thinks your partner is a spineless coward and a pu**y. He also thinks anyone who sees this as morally OK, to learn what 'Narcissistic personality disorder' means. He works in the opposite sector to me; he works with the actual abusers, the criminals. He can see those traits here and thinks you need to get out.

You really do need to contact CAB and get yourself some legal aide. That home belongs to your children and any inheritance owed to them is actually protected by their guardian -You-.

GingerWit · 05/08/2022 23:02

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 15:12

I know that I have few rights as per current legislation but am I being unreasonable to think I have earned a segment of our next family home (I'm talking in terms of ethical principles not legality)

Living with partner of 15 years and our 4 children. He is buying a house outright which will be paid for by selling the house we have lived in for 10 years and is also owned by him. I have worked and contributed to running the household for 15 years and have, of course, sacrificed career progression to support my family and his career, not to mention, I have also grafted on the current house, helping to increase its value and spent small amounts of money on it when I have been able to.

Partner thinks I'm ludicrous to even have these thoughts as I've not put in any big amounts of money. I had hoped I might be able to aim for a small mortgage on our next home that I could pay off myself to give me some security and to just feel like I have a place in the world that I have earned but he wants to own it outright.

Marriage not on cards right now for various reasons.

If someone truly loves -- They will want to share their future with you, financially look after you, marry you and make everything legally 50% yours, there will be no question about it, they will put your name on the mortgage and make sure you're provided for.

If financial security and part ownership of a home, in a long-term relationship is denied/refused/spitefully horded...they don't love and care for you as much as they think they might do. I'm really sorry, OP obviously I don't know the whole marital problem situation, but I don't think I would want to marry someone like this.

Stop wasting your time and kick them to the curb.

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 22:50

AhNowTed · 05/08/2022 20:53

@StillHappy

"That’d really just be a waste of money though. She’s not contributed to a mortgage, or paid rent (they have only split bills) so if anything she’s been benefitting from living there for free rather than building up a beneficial interest.

It’s his house, where he has let her live while they are a couple. She doesn’t and shouldn’t try to launch a claim on something that she hasn’t contributed towards."

Are you for real?

Let her live? She is the mother of his 4 children for gods sake!

And I'm willing to bet her money goes on feeding and clothing those children.

Just because his money technically pays the mortgage, does not mean she hasn't contributed.

I'm also willing to bet it wasn't him taking maternity leave and potentially sabotaging his career.

15 years and 4 children apparently count for nothing.

Yes, they count for nothing in terms of acquiring rights over his house. That’s right, as many others have pointed out.

How, legally, are you getting the impression that that’s not right?

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 22:48

SallyB392 · 05/08/2022 20:28

I don't know all the legistics, but I do know that you can place a charge on a property owned by a partner. This prevents them from selling the house from under you.

Please. Please PLEASE see a solicitor or if this is not possible CAB. I think legislation has recently changed so you may be better protected than you realise!

Of course you can’t. Not without good legal reason. Wanting to take their house is not a good legal reason.

felulageller · 05/08/2022 22:47

Stop paying anything into the household and put your earnings into a savings account to buy your own house.

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 22:47

etcher70 · 05/08/2022 19:42

But surely this situation is morally wrong? I know technically we all 'should' be married for protection, but life often doesn't work out like that and women usually look after the children, do the lion's share of the housework and consequently lack the career progression and the pay rises. Is this fair? So many women are in this situation, shouldn't we be trying to change this?!

I don’t really see that it’s morally wrong. The house was a gift to him, she’s paid nothing whatsoever towards it, but has lived there rent-free. Why would she get to claim part-ownership because of that?

If we are going to start giving people’s property away to their girlfriends, how is this going to work? Some sort of sliding scale, so you get a percent or so of their estate after the first date, building to half a year after they invite you to live with them, or just some sort of hard cutoff, so you acquire half of what they themselves earned at the ten year point?

We already have a really good contract in place to ensure a shared allocation of assets, it’s called marriage. If a couple make the conscious decision to not get married, knowing that this means that assets remain individually owned, then what is the reason for retrospectively changing the deal?

No, that choice should be honoured. Get married if you want to go down the route of shared assets, or write up a contract to the same effect, or choose not to get married and keep things each owned by one person.

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 22:44

etcher70 · 05/08/2022 19:42

But surely this situation is morally wrong? I know technically we all 'should' be married for protection, but life often doesn't work out like that and women usually look after the children, do the lion's share of the housework and consequently lack the career progression and the pay rises. Is this fair? So many women are in this situation, shouldn't we be trying to change this?!

I don’t really see that it’s morally wrong. The house was a gift to him, she’s paid nothing whatsoever towards it, but has lived there rent-free. Why would she get to claim part-ownership because of that?

If we are going to start giving people’s property away to their girlfriends, how is this going to work? Some sort of sliding scale, so you get a percent or so of their estate after the first date, building to half a year after they invite you to live with them, or just some sort of hard cutoff, so you acquire half of what they themselves earned at the ten year point?

We already have a really good contract in place to ensure a shared allocation of assets, it’s called marriage. If a couple make the conscious decision to not get married, knowing that this means that assets remain individually owned, then what is the reason for retrospectively changing the deal?

No, that choice should be honoured. Get married if you want to go down the route of shared assets, or write up a contract to the same effect, or choose not to get married and keep things each owned by one person.

Bubblegum88x · 05/08/2022 22:22

if you don’t want marriage then don’t marry him 100% but i would not be moving into the next home unless you can get your name on it, I don’t think your being unreasonable wanting that at all

nannykatherine · 05/08/2022 22:18

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 15:12

I know that I have few rights as per current legislation but am I being unreasonable to think I have earned a segment of our next family home (I'm talking in terms of ethical principles not legality)

Living with partner of 15 years and our 4 children. He is buying a house outright which will be paid for by selling the house we have lived in for 10 years and is also owned by him. I have worked and contributed to running the household for 15 years and have, of course, sacrificed career progression to support my family and his career, not to mention, I have also grafted on the current house, helping to increase its value and spent small amounts of money on it when I have been able to.

Partner thinks I'm ludicrous to even have these thoughts as I've not put in any big amounts of money. I had hoped I might be able to aim for a small mortgage on our next home that I could pay off myself to give me some security and to just feel like I have a place in the world that I have earned but he wants to own it outright.

Marriage not on cards right now for various reasons.

Why are you together when he doesn’t value you enough to make you feel secure

meditrina · 05/08/2022 21:50

I believe there needs to be far more education on subject starting in schools

Absolutely. There is already space in the timetable for SRE. The legal options for committed relationships, and how that differs from cohabitation, should be covered. Even if not all the message sticks, at least more people might remember that there important issues and therefore know to check when life decisions are being made

Dixiechickonhols · 05/08/2022 21:50

SallyB392 · 05/08/2022 20:28

I don't know all the legistics, but I do know that you can place a charge on a property owned by a partner. This prevents them from selling the house from under you.

Please. Please PLEASE see a solicitor or if this is not possible CAB. I think legislation has recently changed so you may be better protected than you realise!

The OP can’t register Matrimonial Home Rights as she’s not married. Law hasn’t changed.

Dixiechickonhols · 05/08/2022 21:47

To be fair to OP’s boyfriend she’s not said he’s against marriage or civil partnership just she doesn’t want to be a ‘wife’.

Dixiechickonhols · 05/08/2022 21:43

etcher70 · 05/08/2022 19:42

But surely this situation is morally wrong? I know technically we all 'should' be married for protection, but life often doesn't work out like that and women usually look after the children, do the lion's share of the housework and consequently lack the career progression and the pay rises. Is this fair? So many women are in this situation, shouldn't we be trying to change this?!

I believe there needs to be far more education on subject starting in schools. It’s bizarre that so many adults believe in common law marriage.
I also think there needs to be more awareness that marriage or civil partnership is a legal contract not a party. It’s £170 all in to marry.
I don’t agree that there should be rights accrued simply from living together. Lots of people live together and don’t intend to have financial obligations to other party for good reasons.
I read an article where a woman left in a mess when her fiancé died wanted legal info on cohabitation v marriage given to parents by midwife or when they registered a child’s birth as she was clueless but I can’t see that being seen as acceptable.

Retired65 · 05/08/2022 21:20

82% agree you are not being unreasonable. You need to see about getting your name added to the deeds.
I am shocked that you have had 4 children with this man.
Why isn't marriage on the cards? It can be done on the cheap at a registry office. Marriage would give you a lot more security.
I didn't understand why you cannot claim any benefits if he is on a low wage.

Topazmumma · 05/08/2022 20:57

Movingsoon21 · 04/08/2022 15:28

OP does he not love you? Does he not want the mother of his four children to have some stability and security? He’s a complete a**hole if not!

This!

Xzyon · 05/08/2022 20:55

You’re not being unreasonable at all. Both morally and legally you certainly do have a claim. If you don’t have a declaration of trust you can still have a claim on the house if you can show you have contributed to it or being there has had a detrimental effect on your life (paying bills, raising kids and not having a career etc)

read this for info

www.familylawpartners.co.uk/blog/property-rights-for-unmarried-couples

AhNowTed · 05/08/2022 20:53

@StillHappy

"That’d really just be a waste of money though. She’s not contributed to a mortgage, or paid rent (they have only split bills) so if anything she’s been benefitting from living there for free rather than building up a beneficial interest.

It’s his house, where he has let her live while they are a couple. She doesn’t and shouldn’t try to launch a claim on something that she hasn’t contributed towards."

Are you for real?

Let her live? She is the mother of his 4 children for gods sake!

And I'm willing to bet her money goes on feeding and clothing those children.

Just because his money technically pays the mortgage, does not mean she hasn't contributed.

I'm also willing to bet it wasn't him taking maternity leave and potentially sabotaging his career.

15 years and 4 children apparently count for nothing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread