Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my contributions to our family home count for anything?

395 replies

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 15:12

I know that I have few rights as per current legislation but am I being unreasonable to think I have earned a segment of our next family home (I'm talking in terms of ethical principles not legality)

Living with partner of 15 years and our 4 children. He is buying a house outright which will be paid for by selling the house we have lived in for 10 years and is also owned by him. I have worked and contributed to running the household for 15 years and have, of course, sacrificed career progression to support my family and his career, not to mention, I have also grafted on the current house, helping to increase its value and spent small amounts of money on it when I have been able to.

Partner thinks I'm ludicrous to even have these thoughts as I've not put in any big amounts of money. I had hoped I might be able to aim for a small mortgage on our next home that I could pay off myself to give me some security and to just feel like I have a place in the world that I have earned but he wants to own it outright.

Marriage not on cards right now for various reasons.

OP posts:
MsPincher · 06/08/2022 15:01

FinallyHere · 06/08/2022 14:29

But why should she not pay her share of the shopping and bills?

What payment did he make for the use of her womb and for her efforts in raising their children. I'd not be surprised if she did more than her share of general housework, too

Thought not.

That’s creepy. You don’t have the right to payment for the “use of your womb”.

he should of course contribute equally to childcare and house work. But she should contribute equally to bills (as already discussed neither party has housing costs as his parents gifted him the house). I don’t think you have any entitlement to someone else’s property that you didn’t contribute towards just because you share children.

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 14:59

FinallyHere · 06/08/2022 14:29

But why should she not pay her share of the shopping and bills?

What payment did he make for the use of her womb and for her efforts in raising their children. I'd not be surprised if she did more than her share of general housework, too

Thought not.

“Thought not” is infantile whatever post it’s appended to. Appending it to a post without a yes / no question in it just looks illiterate too.

She has no right to expect to be fed and clothed as well as housed without continuing to contribute to the costs.

SolasAnla · 06/08/2022 14:55

chilliesandspices · 06/08/2022 13:52

That is about basic contract law.

It's not basic contract law. It's based on the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996. A notoriously tricky bit of law that many dispute resolution lawyers won't touch with a barge pole.

Thanks for the reference to the act.

When i used basic i ment that it had zero to do with 'common law' marraige not that providing proof of interest in property was basic. More per Decidualcast 's point, which I believe was, that the basic stumbling block (a fundemental starting point for evidence) is that without a marraige/civil partnership contract, the presumption is of an altruistic relationship, and that there was never an intention to enter into a contract.

FinallyHere · 06/08/2022 14:29

But why should she not pay her share of the shopping and bills?

What payment did he make for the use of her womb and for her efforts in raising their children. I'd not be surprised if she did more than her share of general housework, too

Thought not.

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 14:18

Potentialscroogeincognito · 06/08/2022 14:08

No your not being unreasonable in this situation but you are unreasonable for getting yourself into this mess by not being married.
Stop paying half immediately and save as much as possible. Sounds like your going to need it.

But why should she not pay her share of the shopping and bills?

Are you saying that as well as providing a house her partner now also has to pay to feed he and keep her warm?

Potentialscroogeincognito · 06/08/2022 14:08

No your not being unreasonable in this situation but you are unreasonable for getting yourself into this mess by not being married.
Stop paying half immediately and save as much as possible. Sounds like your going to need it.

chilliesandspices · 06/08/2022 13:52

That is about basic contract law.

It's not basic contract law. It's based on the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996. A notoriously tricky bit of law that many dispute resolution lawyers won't touch with a barge pole.

wellhelloitsme · 06/08/2022 13:26

@supadupapupascupa

I'm very confused by some of these posts. My friend had to give her ex half the equity made on her property for the time they lived together as a family (no children together). She fought in court and lost. Because they lived as a family and that was that. He paid for shopping ......

This can't have happened in UK law as you describe it, there's no precedent that would make that possible.

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 06/08/2022 13:24

supadupapupascupa · 06/08/2022 12:15

I'm very confused by some of these posts. My friend had to give her ex half the equity made on her property for the time they lived together as a family (no children together). She fought in court and lost. Because they lived as a family and that was that. He paid for shopping ......

It won't be a case of "they lived as a family and that was that".

Maybe his name was on the deeds somewhere, maybe he had proof that he contributed to the value of the house (doing DIY, for example), or that he contributed regularly to the mortgage.

If all it took to stake a claim on someone's home was to pay for the shopping, nobody would have lodgers or flatmates!

Dixiechickonhols · 06/08/2022 12:45

supadupapupascupa · 06/08/2022 12:15

I'm very confused by some of these posts. My friend had to give her ex half the equity made on her property for the time they lived together as a family (no children together). She fought in court and lost. Because they lived as a family and that was that. He paid for shopping ......

If in England there’s a lot more to that story that paid for shopping. He would have had to prove with evidence he had accrued a beneficial interest eg perhaps he had paid for improvements or done diy renovations your friend didn’t mention. Or perhaps there was a Deed of Trust.
No one gets a share in another persons property simply by buying shopping - no one would live as flat mates or have a lodger if you could.

SolasAnla · 06/08/2022 12:23

Decidualcast · 06/08/2022 11:29

@sue20 is correct here. There is case law for claiming beneficial interest in a property after a long relationship (not “common law marriage” though). Proving it is mightily hard but if you can prove intention to share and have the communication to back it all up, there is a sliver of hope. However, the judge will need to infer proportion if none was ever discussed, which means you could end up with 10% or less (as is the case in some of the case law).

That is about basic contract law.

There is no need for a written contract just an clear intent to create a obligation and have an agreed payment.

The bar will be high as the Judges don't want to end up in a Judge Judy style Court where they have to rule on the economic value of a shag as payment for a romantic getaway or part share in a house.

supadupapupascupa · 06/08/2022 12:15

I'm very confused by some of these posts. My friend had to give her ex half the equity made on her property for the time they lived together as a family (no children together). She fought in court and lost. Because they lived as a family and that was that. He paid for shopping ......

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 06/08/2022 12:11

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 20:44

@Haffiana @CherryBlossomAutumn
I don't feel like I've made any mistakes either. Our children are financially provided for and have college fund and whilst I'd like to be further along I my career I still have (the remnants of) one :)

It does feel like the person whom takes more responsibility within the home and with the children is in a really vulnerable position but at the moment I am not interested in being anyone's wife for financial reasons. No thanks! That being said, I wouldn't blame anyone for marrying for security if necessary. I feel fortunate that my children's financial future is secure and I think if I didn't have this I may feel very differently about the whole marriage thing.

You aren't interested in being anyone's wife for financial reasons, but you want the financial benefits of being a wife/legal partner? Then what do you want?

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 12:07

sue20 · 06/08/2022 10:53

Yes I know all this. I was in this situation 13 years ago and at the time accepted “common law doesn’t exist blah blah” we KNOW all the legal positions. I’m not making assumptions thank you!!! You don’t need to repeat all this detail.

Everyone on here is making this point sometimes in a very old fashioned moral way. But since my time I’ve noticed and known people where a precedent was won in which a long term relationship has been argued as a mitigating factor in court cases concerning money or property issues. There has definitely been a small shift In recent years I’ve noticed and regretted I didn’t get more advice hence my urging to the OP to do so.

Can you quote the precedent please? I don’t believe that you are right.

Bangolads · 06/08/2022 12:02

If you can prove you’ve contributed to repairs you have rights over house actually. I’d talk too solicitor just to see.

pollymere · 06/08/2022 11:56

This is ringing major alarmbells. He will basically own a house you have no rights over and have apparently made no financial contribution towards. There is nothing much stopping him from making your life intolerable so you have to leave or moving a girlfriend in! If he loves you, he will be happy for you to have your name in joint ownership of the house so that if he died you wouldn't be homeless or have to pay death duties on the house. If he says no, then I think you need to ask him about your relationship and him safeguarding his children. You may not be legally married but your finances and lives are entwined enough that you need to sort things out. If he's being emotionally abusive and gaslighting you saying he owes you nothing, or you've contributed nothing, you need to remind him you've been nanny, cook and housekeeper. You also sound like you've been contributing financially by buying things for the current house. If it gets messy, you might need to add up just how much including an hourly rate for cooking, cleaning and childcare.

wellhelloitsme · 06/08/2022 11:53

@sue20

Yes I know all this. I was in this situation 13 years ago and at the time accepted “common law doesn’t exist blah blah” we KNOW all the legal positions. I’m not making assumptions thank you!!! You don’t need to repeat all this detail.

Eh?! Calm down, you quite literally said:

There are now legal precedents which apply to common law marriage which you are in.

Which is absolutely false. OP cannot be in a common law marriage because they do not exist.

If you "KNOW" they don't exist enough to shout about it, saying she is in one is really odd and makes no sense.

rwalker · 06/08/2022 11:41

luxxlisbon · 06/08/2022 11:23

Please stop paying 50:50 on household bills and childcare.

I really don’t understand why so many people have been making comments like this. She hasn’t been paying for housing. It’s not like she’s been paying half the mortgage and he has refused her a stake! She hasn’t contributed anything to the house and the fact that his family money bought it outright means they have had much more disposable income over the past 15 years.
Why would the house even be relevant in terms of OP contributing towards the day to day bills and childcare? Those are still costs that the family have.

It’s also a stark difference between this situation and when a woman is given inheritance and they are told “keep it for yourself, it’s not family money, your parents wanted it to go to you”

I don't understand that logic ether about bills and child care there living expenses irrelevant of who earns what .

You wouldn't borrow a car for a month put £400 of petrol in it then try and claim you own part of the car.

Decidualcast · 06/08/2022 11:29

sue20 · 06/08/2022 10:53

Yes I know all this. I was in this situation 13 years ago and at the time accepted “common law doesn’t exist blah blah” we KNOW all the legal positions. I’m not making assumptions thank you!!! You don’t need to repeat all this detail.

Everyone on here is making this point sometimes in a very old fashioned moral way. But since my time I’ve noticed and known people where a precedent was won in which a long term relationship has been argued as a mitigating factor in court cases concerning money or property issues. There has definitely been a small shift In recent years I’ve noticed and regretted I didn’t get more advice hence my urging to the OP to do so.

@sue20 is correct here. There is case law for claiming beneficial interest in a property after a long relationship (not “common law marriage” though). Proving it is mightily hard but if you can prove intention to share and have the communication to back it all up, there is a sliver of hope. However, the judge will need to infer proportion if none was ever discussed, which means you could end up with 10% or less (as is the case in some of the case law).

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 06/08/2022 11:28

Greenlife1 · 04/08/2022 20:28

Very interesting opinions!

Very clued up on the legal side of the situation, hence highlighting that in my original post ;)

I will be working and saving to buy a property of my own. Obviously having young children has limited my working and saving capacity over the recent years. Ultimately, I can earn more than my partner but it didn't make sense to work more than part-time with childcare expenses and the fact that I would see the children less.

He owns the property outright via family money. He is a low earner which has been frustrating at times as I have not been able to claim for certain benefits etc but I haven't had to pay rent so that has been my decision.

I had hoped that I could arrange a mortgage on a portion of the new home rather than have to invest in a separate property as I don't really have an interest in being a landlord!

I think it's fair to say the majority think I am being unreasonable. Which is interesting ;)

The majority seem to think you are NOT being unreasonable

To think that my contributions to our family home count for anything?
luxxlisbon · 06/08/2022 11:23

Please stop paying 50:50 on household bills and childcare.

I really don’t understand why so many people have been making comments like this. She hasn’t been paying for housing. It’s not like she’s been paying half the mortgage and he has refused her a stake! She hasn’t contributed anything to the house and the fact that his family money bought it outright means they have had much more disposable income over the past 15 years.
Why would the house even be relevant in terms of OP contributing towards the day to day bills and childcare? Those are still costs that the family have.

It’s also a stark difference between this situation and when a woman is given inheritance and they are told “keep it for yourself, it’s not family money, your parents wanted it to go to you”

MsPincher · 06/08/2022 11:13

FinallyHere · 06/08/2022 08:07

You should explain to him that you need protection for the future.

The weakness of the OP's position is that there is no legal protection for her position. Protection in this sense is a zero sum game between him and her.

At the moment, he is sitting pretty and she is has no protection. Any protection she can gain is at his expense.

Which is why I said she has no power in this situation. It breaks my heart that there is a steady stream of women in this position on MN

I don't know how to spread the message so that people understand the implications of getting versus not getting married, while there is time to do something about it.

At the same time, discouraging women who are not financially dependent from marrying. Before anyone howls at unfairness: there are two completely separate cases

In one, a woman gives up her career and future earning potential to look after children and the household. Without marriage, there is no security for her.

In the other, there are no children involved. A woman marries a man who has few assets to start off with and/or doesn't earn much. After a long marriage, the starting point to split the assets of the marriage is very likely to start at 50:50.

In the absence of children, I would be very, very cautious about recommending the financially more secure women to get married.

Really though aren’t you just telling women to marry a rich man? Even if you have children, marrying a lower earning man with less assets will leave you worse off.

I have two children with such a man. I did not marry him and so am much better off now. Otherwise my assets would have been taken to house him and provide for his needs. Instead they can go for me and my dcs.

I think to be honest it’s fair enough that op doesn’t get a share in her dh house. It was gifted by his family and she did not contribute to its purchase.

Runnerduck34 · 06/08/2022 11:11

Morally and ethically if course you are entitled to something. Legally you are on thin ice though I think Ive read somewhere there is a ruling that could help you if you can prove you've contributed. You need legal advice.
Also I would be questioning my relationship with someone whom I had 4 DC with and who treated me with so little respect - sorry. Morally you're right but legally you are are probably screwed.
And tbh to "D"P who is mainly responsible for it, they could change it in a flash if they wanted to..

MsPincher · 06/08/2022 10:59

Pinkdelight3 · 05/08/2022 10:15

More likely you'd want your 4 grandchildren to have a stake in it, but who knows if you'd even like their mother, let alone want to give her a house you paid for? Plus as they're not married, she could leave any time and make them sell the house if she has a stake in it. I think any warm impulse to give your DIL a stake in the house might soon be snapped out of in the cold light of day. Different if they're married, but OP was vague about reasons for not marrying and she might not have wanted to herself. They don't sound particularly solid as a couple so being together 15 years might well make them more likely to split than less.

Yes I agree. I’m a single mum but I only have daughters. If I gifted them property I wouldn’t want their partners to be able to take or part of it. I would want it to go to my gc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread