Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surely two is not really easier than one?

112 replies

sarahb083 · 04/08/2022 13:15

I have one 18mo DD and not planning on having any more. People keep telling me that two is easier than one because they play together. But even if siblings are the best of friends and never fight (very unlikely 😂), you still have to care for and raise a whole other human! Am I missing something?

OP posts:
SallyWD · 04/08/2022 13:54

The honest answer is that it some ways it's easier and in other ways it's not. Obviously you have another person to look after so that's not easier - however, I do find that once you've already become a mother it's not much of an adjustment to your life to look after 2 (as you've already made such major adjustments to your life just by having 1!). It's hard and exhausting when they fight and bicker. It can really wear you down! It is easier when they play together. My two can amuse themselves together for hours and it's lovely for me! Sometimes the eldest will want to put her brother to bed, make his lunch etc. During these times I do think it's easier having 2 rather than one child who would want me to do everything.

Wishyfishy · 04/08/2022 13:53

For me it is kind of, yes.

When DC2 was a baby it was maybe 110% of the work as just having one. So a bit extra but not much. I was still preparing food for DC1, just wearing DC2 in a sling while I did it etc. There was still only one of me and one pair of hands and one thing I could be doing at the time so maybe I played a bit less because of DC2 - activities just replaced each other.
I suppose it “helped” that DC1 was still sleeping poorly when I had DC2 so it’s not like I went from sleeping through the night to up every hour. I just continued co-sleeping.

Now they are older it is absolutely easier. They play together and get what they need from each other, not me, so I can concentrate on feeding and tidying up around them and the bits of parenting I really like, like reading to them and setting up craft ideas and helping with homework. If we go out to a wood I can sit down and just watch them play. If we are at a playground they run around with each other and I’m there to hand out snacks and keep an eye. I find it MUCH harder work when one has a play date on their own.

With them running around the garden together I get to sit down with a cup of tea and a book!

IclimbedSnowdon · 04/08/2022 13:52

There's 13 months between my two. Ds had just started walking when dd arrived. I found it no more difficult than I had with just the one. They were also great company for each other when a little older, freeing up time for me to get on with things around the house.

They've remained very close into adulthood. It wasn't planned to have them so close but if I could go back, I wouldn't change a thing.

ecnatsid · 04/08/2022 13:52

For me going from 0 children to 1 DS was very intense and hard. Going from 1-2 was easier because I had a small enough gap that I was still in the baby phase and felt like I knew what was going on and what to expect.

That said, childcare costs are crippling me, DS2 hasn't slept more than 3 hours consecutively and at times it's extremely challenging.

But I wouldn't change it, kids are the best of friends, everything we do is suitable for both of them due to the small age gap, both at similar stages at the same time.

I love it, glad I had DS2 but no more babies for me, haha.

acorntotree · 04/08/2022 13:49

I definitely find it easier in the school holidays and my ds is around then when it's just me and dd. They play with each other and honestly rarely fight and I barely see them all day. When it's just me and dd I have to entertain her constantly. All children are different though and mine are very close in age so have very similar interests.

Kam610 · 04/08/2022 13:48

Nope, having 2 is more than twice as hard 🤣 especially with a short age gap. I have 22 months between my two and it's incredibly difficult. But it is getting slightly easier now that my youngest is getting bigger and not so fragile.

Riapia · 04/08/2022 13:46

It’s something said by those with two to lure some other poor sucker in.

WhatIsModeration · 04/08/2022 13:46

You think you have no time to yourself when you have a baby. You know what no time to yourself actually feels like when you have a second!

My two are almost 26 months and 5 months and it's RELENTLESS!!

Itiswasitis90 · 04/08/2022 13:46

It's a lie and they want to see you suffer 😂

RishiRich · 04/08/2022 13:45

IME two is definitely not easier than one. Mine are pre-teens and they bicker constantly. I wouldn't be without either of them now they're here but my older one would probably be happier as an only.

Bluepolkadots42 · 04/08/2022 13:38

Had #2 at start of year and can safely say 2 not easier than 1! We have found that 2 isn't as hard as we thought but that is purely down to luck that #2 has been a very easy baby so far- it is still definitely more work than 1. If you have any doubts my advice would be don't do it because you never know if you'll end up with #2 being a really tricky baby.

tinkertailor2 · 04/08/2022 13:36

Obviously all children are different and have different dynamics but my experience is that it definitely isn't twice as hard. Mine have a five year age gap so although they're not playing with the same things, they do get on and the older one helps the younger one.
The hardest few years of my life were when I had 1 and she only wanted me to play with.

Greydogs123 · 04/08/2022 13:35

No, it’s a lie people with more than one tell themselves!
i have a 9 year old and it has always been easier and less stressful for her entire life. It is important to help them
learn to enjoy their own company and play on their own, but if you do that then you’re laughing.
My dd will spend several hours happily playing in her room while listening to podcasts.

WhatNoRaisins · 04/08/2022 13:34

The initial bit is harder, managing a baby and a still dependent older sibling, meeting both their needs. It requires a lot of brainpower than you may not have due to sleep deprivation.

It can potentially be easier later if they play together well but you can't guarantee that.

As for when you're elderly, depends. We had a massive family drama with siblings of a dying parent falling out. Dealing with the situation alone would have been much easier.

PeekAtYou · 04/08/2022 13:32

My dc1 was very high maintenance where as dc2 was very easy so it wasn't twice as hard for me but it wasn't easier.
They sometimes played together but they also argued which counteracts that benefit.

Caterina99 · 04/08/2022 13:32

Mine are just 7 and nearly 5. I’d say it was more than twice as hard in the early years, but they do play nicely together without much input from me for probably the past year now.

Whether it’s less work overall than just sticking at one I don’t know. They’re very inconsistent. I can send them off to play and not have to deal with them much for hours, or I can be a constant referee to endless bickering, arguing and screaming all day.

Vikinga · 04/08/2022 13:31

I found 2 easier than one. My first needed me to entertain him all the time. Also found when I ahd my 4th on his own he was a lot harder work than when my other kids were around.

When they're teens they're much easier on their own though as they bicker a lot.

bambi1132 · 04/08/2022 13:30

Absolutely not. Mine play together nicely for about 30 seconds and spend the rest of their waking hours just bickering. It was SO much easier with one.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 04/08/2022 13:30

It depends on age gap. I have 4 years between my two so it's wasn't hard having two babies as the older one was in nursery and enjoyed "helping" with the baby. There are times they have different interests but on the whole they entertain each other and I think it's a lot easier than having only one who wants to be entertained.

Trivester · 04/08/2022 13:29

I found it much easier having two than one - maybe something to do with my (late diagnosed) adhd hyperfocus. I was able to chill a bit and take more in my stride.

I didn’t worry about the second one because the first one had gone through that and turned out ok, and then I stopped worry about the first one’s new problems too.

And being off the hook as a playmate is priceless.

One of the reasons we didn’t have a third was that I wanted a third and fourth. I wanted a fifth and sixth too … so dh sensibly drew a line 😂

But I can kinda see that for sane people, singles might be easier.

dollyblack · 04/08/2022 13:26

I don’t think its twice as hard but it depends on soooo many variables; age gap, home circumstances, everyones temperament, etc, etc.

I found one VERY hard but by 2 i was much more chilled and felt more confident, so it that respect it was easier overall, my more relaxed approach went over both kids, things i would fixate on with one kid became less significant with two, so a different perspective altogether. But yes the daily drudgery is still a lot and there’s is a lot of juggling to do. I’m a better mum
of two than was i was of one though- just a personality thing.

basilmint · 04/08/2022 13:26

Having seen friends with only one DC, the parents do have to provide a lot more entertainment. We are on holiday at the moment and I'm really glad my two have had each other to amuse themselves. However, there is a lot of fighting and arguing which drives me insane and you do have two different childrens' needs to balance. There seems to be a lot of driving children around to differ places, more homework to support with etc.

Flockameanie · 04/08/2022 13:25

Some aspects are definitely easier. Right now DCs (6 & 9) are quietly playing with each other while DH and I work (summer holidays are fun with 2 working parents 🙄). If it was just one of them they’d doubtless be pestering us more. Although they did spend a lot of the morning either winding each other up or shouting with wild abandon

But yep, mostly it’s harder. So much negotiating their relationship with each other. So much squabbling. So much doing stuff that one doesn’t really want to because the other does/ needs to. And double the number of clothes, mouths to feed, activities to pay for, etc.

Still, I’d have 2 all over again if I had to make the decision again.

JassyRadlett · 04/08/2022 13:25

The only time I've found two to be easier than one was during lockdown when having each other was a godsend compared to my friends with only children.

It's more work, especially when they're small. There's more ferrying around, more activities etc as they get older but the flipside is that they do play together a lot despite a 4-year age gap so less need for parental involvement until/unless it descends into argument.

TheCanyon · 04/08/2022 13:25

Two of different ages can be hard yes. Twins I didn't think so, apart from the cost obviously.