Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Large house- you must have lots of children?

421 replies

MarmiteCoriander · 03/08/2022 22:13

AIBU that people assume that if you have a 3 bed house and a small study- that you must have multiple children?

Currently renovating a derelict house for DH, myself and dog to live in. Yes, its much larger than than the 2 bed flat we lived in, but doesn't have acres of land! We have TTC 12 yrs, 3 losses and rounds of IVF, but people assume we must have lots of kids to have 'such a big' house!

Would you assume someone living in a 3 bed with small study had multiple children?

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 05/08/2022 10:17

You’re all being apogogical now - I never said couples should live in bedsits, or that housing should be ‘regulated’ as to who can buy it. All I said is I find people who buy houses which are excessively bigger than they need (aka not OP) - to be a bit greedy. Because it means a lot of housing doesn’t get lived in, which is its main purpose. And no I don’t think keeping a hat collection in a room counts as ‘living in it’. I feel the same about ‘investment’ properties, buy to let landlords etc. It’s clearly touched a nerve.

Bubblebubblebah · 05/08/2022 10:07

What about families who are not hardeorking? Where will they live?

Bubblebubblebah · 05/08/2022 10:06

rainbowmilk · 05/08/2022 09:57

@PriamFarrl There won’t be any competition anymore, so house prices will come down to the level of hard working families’ choosing and we’ll all live happily ever after.

Well good luck to all of them going from 0 to 4 bed detache houses because anything in between will be ethically taken by us non worthy. And no, prices will not come own to compete eith 2 beds😂

PriamFarrl · 05/08/2022 10:03

rainbowmilk · 05/08/2022 09:57

@PriamFarrl There won’t be any competition anymore, so house prices will come down to the level of hard working families’ choosing and we’ll all live happily ever after.

I see. So because people who have lost a baby or have had years of failed fertility treatment instantly move to a tiny house with one bedroom all house prices suddenly become affordable.

rainbowmilk · 05/08/2022 09:57

@PriamFarrl There won’t be any competition anymore, so house prices will come down to the level of hard working families’ choosing and we’ll all live happily ever after.

PriamFarrl · 05/08/2022 09:39

LadyVictoriaSponge · 04/08/2022 22:59

A house? for a childfeee couple? I think that would be incredibly greedy and selfish, surely a one bed flat would suffice? and let’s only allocate bedsits for “older ladies past their childbearing years”.

And when all these child free couples and dried up old women are living in their appointed one bedroom flats who knows what young couples just starting out are going to live in.
But that doesn’t matter because ‘hard working families’ will have houses to live in (just like they do now) and as we know from listening to politicians ‘hard working families’ are the only people who matter and are effected by rising prices.

DixonD · 05/08/2022 00:24

I know someone who has 11 bedrooms and lives alone! He doesn’t want children.

DixonD · 05/08/2022 00:14

I wouldn’t describe a three bedroom house as large. I would say it is the average actually, and many of those have just couples or singles in!

DixonD · 05/08/2022 00:13

Not at all.

We have a five bed house and one child. Before that; just me and DH for quite some years! It’s amazing how you can fill up that space even without children.

saraclara · 05/08/2022 00:02

CounsellorTroi · 04/08/2022 23:52

It’s often an emotional attachment. My mum’s only ever marital home and my childhood home was a 1950s built detached house, bought off plan so no one else ever lived there, only three beds one bath and downstairs cloakroom, but all double bedrooms, and a large hall and landing, so it felt big, and a huge garden which my dad had made from scratch. My mum lived there for nearly 56 years in total - 36 of those after my father died. Leaving that house for her would have been like leaving my father behind. I can understand why she didn’t want to.

Exactly. This isn't just my home. It's the nest I brought my babies to. It's where most of my adult memories reside, and where the majority of my life with my late husband happened.
It's not an attachment to material stuff, it's an attachment to memories. And of course it's my home, not just bricks and mortar.

I get that people have different attitudes to houses. My cousin, of my age, has barely stayed now than three years in any house. He and his wife are barely moved into one before they're planning their next move. It works for them. But I get my kicks from traveling to far off places, and having my home to return to.

This is where I want to be for now. I'm not going to give it up decades before I need to.
I'm not averse to moving one day, and I have plans in place to make it as financially simple as it can be when that time comes, and I'm already decluttering as a stage forward. But it needs to be at a time that works for me.

CounsellorTroi · 04/08/2022 23:52

Kendodd · 04/08/2022 22:58

I really don't understand how living in a different house is giving up decades of your life. It's just a house, it's background, just wallpaper, to your life. It's what goes on in your life that's important, the people you know, the things you do. I'll never understand this attachment to material stuff as if it's important.

It’s often an emotional attachment. My mum’s only ever marital home and my childhood home was a 1950s built detached house, bought off plan so no one else ever lived there, only three beds one bath and downstairs cloakroom, but all double bedrooms, and a large hall and landing, so it felt big, and a huge garden which my dad had made from scratch. My mum lived there for nearly 56 years in total - 36 of those after my father died. Leaving that house for her would have been like leaving my father behind. I can understand why she didn’t want to.

LadyVictoriaSponge · 04/08/2022 22:59

Goatinthegarden · 04/08/2022 18:23

To sum up, apparently a person is only allowed to buy a multiple roomed house if they pop out a child to put in every room. They are entitled to fill every inch of that space with all the stuff that those children (that they presumably chose to have) need/want. Those children will probably have all manner of nice items bought for them to enrich their lives. Furniture, toys, sports equipment, technology, clothes, food, holidays, etc. They’ll need to be registered with doctors and dentists, they’ll need educating. Their parents might need to buy bigger cars, drive them around, etc. The children will consume throughout their childhoods, taking up resources, then grow up, possibly having more children, certainly needing another house and they will continue to consume.

But if someone choose not to have children or can’t have children, then they are not allowed to consume anything unnecessary and must live in a tiny house. Sounds fair.

A house? for a childfeee couple? I think that would be incredibly greedy and selfish, surely a one bed flat would suffice? and let’s only allocate bedsits for “older ladies past their childbearing years”.

Kendodd · 04/08/2022 22:58

Wouldloveanother · 04/08/2022 22:08

She didn’t ‘give up decades of her life’ Hmm she did the same things she did before, just in a new house. She stayed in the local area. I find this overwhelming emotional attachment to bricks and mortar - to the extent that just existing in the house is ‘your entire life’ - to be quite odd. B

I really don't understand how living in a different house is giving up decades of your life. It's just a house, it's background, just wallpaper, to your life. It's what goes on in your life that's important, the people you know, the things you do. I'll never understand this attachment to material stuff as if it's important.

UxbridgeVoteBJOut · 04/08/2022 22:17

Many of my neighbours are retired, 1-2 adults living in 4 bedrm houses. That's who I assume 4 bed houses mostly belong too.

I'd love to live in a small property, I just need to learn how to manage with less stuff. Lovely thing about small properties is they force you to have less stuff & you always know where everything is.

Wouldloveanother · 04/08/2022 22:08

saraclara · 04/08/2022 21:47

Personally I wouldn't give up decades of my life in order not to have to make a difficult adjustment in my 80s or 90s.

If she wanted to move house at that point already and the bungalow was exactly what she'd have chosen anyway, and in the exact place she wanted, great. But for most of us it wouldn't be, and it's ridiculous to lose decades of living the life you want because in thirty or forty years time it might not work.

She didn’t ‘give up decades of her life’ Hmm she did the same things she did before, just in a new house. She stayed in the local area. I find this overwhelming emotional attachment to bricks and mortar - to the extent that just existing in the house is ‘your entire life’ - to be quite odd. B

Scianel · 04/08/2022 21:56

This is probably a bad time to mention we might also be buying a holiday cottage.

maddening · 04/08/2022 21:51

We have a 5 bed but only us and ds, 2 bedrooms used as offices and another as a playroom and 2 as bedrooms. So glad to have the room as we were in a 2 bed cottage before.

saraclara · 04/08/2022 21:47

Wouldloveanother · 04/08/2022 18:20

I wont.

My other nan moved into a bungalow when she was 50. Everyone said it was way too early, teased her for being an ‘old lady’ etc.

25 years later, it’s fantastic - she hasn’t had to worry about a move in later life, it’s perfectly set up for if she needs care, it feels like her home not just ‘somewhere to live her last days in’ as it has seen so many memories. Shes surrounded be neighbours shes known for years. She’s a very pragmatic woman though.

My other grandparents insisted on staying in their 4 bedroom two-story house until they were nearly 90. Their health deteriorated rapidly, mentally and physically, and they had to hurriedly deal with a house sale and move into a retirement flat. My granddad died several years later having spent a tough last few years getting his head around his ‘new’ surroundings, away from neighbours he knew etc. My gran still lives there, still gets confused about where she is and basically never adapted. It’s still hard on here.

Personally I wouldn't give up decades of my life in order not to have to make a difficult adjustment in my 80s or 90s.

If she wanted to move house at that point already and the bungalow was exactly what she'd have chosen anyway, and in the exact place she wanted, great. But for most of us it wouldn't be, and it's ridiculous to lose decades of living the life you want because in thirty or forty years time it might not work.

Wouldloveanother · 04/08/2022 21:41

Scianel · 04/08/2022 21:40

I intend to live in a beautiful spacious 2 bedroom flat, preferably one of those converted warehouse jobs with lots of character and huge arch windows

Sounds lovely. Doesn't sound like you're doing it to be moral though, more that you really fancy it. Which is more than fair, but don't judge when others do likewise.

oh please 😂

Scianel · 04/08/2022 21:40

I intend to live in a beautiful spacious 2 bedroom flat, preferably one of those converted warehouse jobs with lots of character and huge arch windows

Sounds lovely. Doesn't sound like you're doing it to be moral though, more that you really fancy it. Which is more than fair, but don't judge when others do likewise.

DaphneduM · 04/08/2022 21:28

@MarmiteCoriander It sounds fantastic - I'm sure it will be absolutely lovely when you've finished it. Our house was the same in terms of lack of buyers - only us interested apparently. Enjoy your home - a massive achievement by the sounds of it. Don't ever worry about what other people think or assume.

MarmiteCoriander · 04/08/2022 21:12

Gosh, I didn't expect SO many replies in less than 24hrs!!!! To answer some questions:


  • The house was empty for 8+yrs and in probate. Prior to that, next to no maintenance had been done on it for over 20yrs. It was uninhabitable and in need of complete overhaul from new roof down to new flooring and almost everything in between

  • Of course other people had the chance to buy it. It had been on the market sometime, so I don't feel we took away a chance for a family with children to buy it

  • Yes, technically its a 4 bed, but the 4th room is very small

  • I was still having rounds of IVF when we bought it, hence thought we'd have at least 1 child.

  • DH and I have both worked from home for years

  • We anticipate at least one of our parents needing to move in with us in coming years

  • The house is detached, on 1/3 acre plot. It has high ceilings, and 2 reception rooms, so I agree that it is a larger house/land compared to the 2 bed flat we had. Its significantly larger than the caravan we have been living in onsite for 2yrs too!

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 04/08/2022 21:10

Something like this will do

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/124931966#/?channel=RES_BUY

Wouldloveanother · 04/08/2022 21:08

I have zero intention to live in a dingy small flat. I intend to live in a beautiful spacious 2 bedroom flat, preferably one of those converted warehouse jobs with lots of character and huge arch windows where I can look down on the city lights and sip champagne. I am going to go to shows and pubs and art exhibitions and stay mentally young with my best friend living down the road.

that’s the plan anyway…

WitchesAbroad · 04/08/2022 21:07

One big issue is that a lot of properties with fewer rooms are simply not designed for long term living. They are sold as a stepping stone ‘starter flat’ fgs.

We’re fully grown adults. I want to be able to have a small garden; outside storage / garage to support hobbies; a kitchen big enough to cook proper meals in and we need 2 bathrooms. I don’t think that’s unreasonable given I have the money to do so.

Thus DH and I find ourselves in a 4 bed detached. It’s not huge but has more rooms than we needed. That said, we now both WFH since pandemic and the space is fully utilised. If we ‘downsized’ DH would have to find office space 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread