Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Sporty2022 · 10/08/2022 09:25

But many people earn us less than us and we’re a low income family.
No one else I speak to seems over concerned about energy bills. Are many people just being naive?

AndreaC74 · 10/08/2022 09:00

@sst1234 None of what you have written is an argument against paying wages at market rate rather than subsidizing them to keep pay artificially low

what do you mean? employers are paying the market rate, its just not enough.

There is no direct subsidy

BUT now we are seeing employees striking for higher pay, the employers and the Govt refusing to pay more.
the latest is RM and NHS workers - who dam well should go on strike, any poor patient care should be laid firmly at the door of the Govt.

You talk about arguing with oneself but you are refusing to accept the reality of the situation.

Its your party of choice that has bought about very low pay and employees reliance on working benefits - have look at the growth of WTC over the last 12 years.

Mothstoaflame · 10/08/2022 08:53

There is nothing we can do about it so I am focusing on keeping a positive attitude, living in today and buying extra/making savings wherever I can.
Yes, be sensible and forward plan where possible, but ruminating and stressing about what might happen tomorrow is exceptionally bad for your mental health.

Also, don't forget that alarming headlines is how the papers make their money. The more alarming or shocking it is, the more people read and share. The higher readership results in papers being able to sell crazy amounts of advertising. If you work in media, bad news is exceptionally good news.

That's not to say it isn't true, but there is more at play here than many realise. So for us, we will live in the 'now', prep and help our neighbours where we can and we'll deal with trouble when it arrives.

Walkaround · 10/08/2022 08:49

Wages are a bit like tax in a global capitalist system - expect a fair amount and your employer looks overseas to source cheaper labour/tax havens (unless you have good infrastructure, education, healthcare, highly trained, specialist workforce, don’t clog up your borders with lorry parks and make importing and exporting difficult, etc, etc).

BarbaraofSeville · 10/08/2022 08:45

Hope the government will be forthcoming with more help. Due to the much higher expected price cap since the £400 etc was announced, this is a possibility and something Rishi Sunak has pledged if he becomes PM.

Try to use less, so your bills don't get that high. There's loads of resources online about cutting down without suffering too much.

See if you or your partner can earn more, get a pay rise, a second or better paid job. If you have teens/older DC, can they get jobs so they can pay for their own tech, clothes, leisure activities etc?

See what other savings you can make to free up more to pay your energy bills. Sadly this will be the main solution for many, at the expense of their financial security, other essentials or non essential spending.

Never vote conservative.

Walkaround · 10/08/2022 08:44

sst1234 · 09/08/2022 23:17

None of what you have written is an argument against paying wages at market rate rather than subsidizing them to keep pay artificially low.

Same for energy market. You seem to be having an argument all of your own. None of what you have written makes any sense when the pressure is on supply side.

History shows us the market is happy to pay humans less than they need to live on.

Sporty2022 · 10/08/2022 08:35

But we’re a working family and can’t afford £300 or £400 a month for energy , if it’s get that high?
What can I do ? Don’t qualify for any extra help.
I can’t afford 4K per year!

JustAnotherManicMomday · 09/08/2022 23:30

I think they pluck the figure out of thin air. Take for example the price of milk or fuel... both have gone up by a third easily this year. That's 33%. Breadboard about 20%. My weekly food shop has gone up by at least 30% in cost. We used yo have money to spare each month now as two adults with 2 children and a fairly low morgage(until the fixed term ends in Feb) we barely have anything to spare at the end of the month. Yet we fall in the no help offered category because of our earnings. Had to start making serious cutbacks and changing the things we do buy to make allowances for when fuel prices go up even further.

sst1234 · 09/08/2022 23:17

None of what you have written is an argument against paying wages at market rate rather than subsidizing them to keep pay artificially low.

Same for energy market. You seem to be having an argument all of your own. None of what you have written makes any sense when the pressure is on supply side.

AndreaC74 · 09/08/2022 12:08

@sst1234
Thats called an adjustment or correction
If you take away benefits, and keep raising minimum wage in place, some employers who cannot afford to be business would go out of business. Their business model does not work anyway if they cannot afford to pay market rate wages. The rest either put up prices or automate. The latter is what has been missing due to low pay subsidies. And this is thread on UK productivity is lagging other advanced economies. It’s not a secret. Look it up
As for energy prices, does Ed Davey or do you have any ideas of how taxing and capping energy prices improves supply or energy security. If the wholesale price is high and you place price cap, forcing energy companies to make up the difference, they go out of business. Maybe you missed this in the last few months. Equally windfall tax can only be applied to profits. By capping price, you force them to make up the difference between the wholsesale price, hence no profits to tax
I think your theory is based on fantasy, not math

So what about the industries that we rely on that cannot make a profit without subsidising wages? or rising prices so much that people no longer buy them?

Your idea of rising the MW, will just decrease differentials, eventually we'd have most of the workforce all on 14 ph.

Automation does not work in every sector nor is it the sole answer to productivity, some UK factories, despite hi automation had lower productivity than European ones.

One energy, we will face very high prices for many more years to come, so we either cap/nationalise OR give people 100s of billions, perhaps trillions in subsidy, which feed the higher price spiral.

A cap has to be followed by making up the difference to the energy companies or they'd leave the UK market, which is why i'd prefer nationalisation i.e as we did with the banks.

E.G 3 years ago Shell might have forecast 10billion for their yearly profit, they will now make 40 billion, cost of production hasn't risen 4 fold and neither will they boost investment based on (relatively) short term price fluctuations.

So WF tax is a the only way forward.

Actually, a true Tory solution would be to have no energy help, demand would plummet, prices would drop.... Would you support that?

cuddlybear21 · 09/08/2022 10:09

@sst1234 actually i think your maths is too simplistic and doesn't understand modern economics particularly within a global context plus the British context. The global context is that extractive capitalism of global corporations i.e. American ones (and Chinese but for national security reasons that's not happening) have no interest in what happens within the UK and essentially focus on money extraction in certain places while relocating it elsewhere. The UK is not a closed system.

Productivity and increasing productivity happens by upskilling workers and automation - thats good in theory but can be disastrous for local workers unless the government intervenes. To increase productivity and not harm local workers - government either has to create local conditions for businesses being incentivized to upskill like in Germany - i.e. change of business culture, end of zero hour contracts, a culture of apprenticeships where the person is then kept by a business for ten years or so (otherwise it's not cost effective to train them) etc etc. Or a mass and genuine retraining program funded by the state - free and focused on current skills shortages.

Neither is what the Tories are interested in doing or their backers large corporations. Sadly what they are interested is to carry on in the massive transfer of public funds into private hands - look at how they've dealt with Covid if you want to see at this in practice

sst1234 · 09/08/2022 09:59

AndreaC74 · 09/08/2022 07:39

No-one is saying that farming and other critical industries should have their workers supported and left to the free market. They are arguably too important to leave to the vagaries and corruption

Thats exactly what @sst1234 was calling for.

...and you will find that almost all jobs are critical, often never thought of that until they stop doing them.... as we found out in the Pandemic.

Right, Centre and Left is used because our political system is based on that, no one can take into account an individuals politics.

I think you are missing how wages, productivity and automation work in tandem with each other. Raising wages does not mean food production stops. If that was the case the rest of G7 nations would starve.

sst1234 · 09/08/2022 09:56

cuddlybear21 · 09/08/2022 09:42

Well one way to raise wages for a Tesco worker without subsidizing businesses is by increasing the minimum wage to a reasonable amount. I would say that no one on a min wage job should be getting benefit because wages should be high enough. You could increase min wage and give subsidies to businesses for training workers and hope you end up with a higher wage better trained workforce. But the reality is the Tories really do only care about their financial backers and thats large corporations

Again, it’s this is not about party politics. That line is too rehearsed and too misleading.

Nu Labour introduced tax credits. They set up the economy to get into the low productivity and inflationary mess that it is in today. Unfortunately the Tories did nothing to reverse this.

This is not a left vs right thing. It’s down to the fact our political classes are mediocre, career civil servant types who are completely detached from the real economy.

sst1234 · 09/08/2022 09:53

AndreaC74 · 09/08/2022 07:14

"let the market adjust" more right wing nonsense.

If you took away working benefits, wages wouldn't rise to compensate, thats why we had to have MW and before that income support.

You think a farmer will compensate his worker on MW? what with magic beans? the farmer also has no money, tied in to SM contracts, input costs gone up 300% or the Care Agency will rise wages for carers? again.. how? Councils have no money to give them extra... thanks to you lot.

All wages have to rise, you have to have differentials and the Govt has made it perfectly clearly with the recent NHS rise, they have no intention of rises wages at the bottom/lower earners.

Ed Davey has a better idea, Keep the Cap as it is, retrospective Tax on Energy Industry.
Personally, i'd part nationalise the sector with that WF tax.

“All wages have to rise”.

Thats called an adjustment or correction.

If you take away benefits, and keep raising minimum wage in place, some employers who cannot afford to be business would go out of business. Their business model does not work anyway if they cannot afford to pay market rate wages. The rest either put up prices or automate. The latter is what has been missing due to low pay subsidies. And this is thread on UK productivity is lagging other advanced economies. It’s not a secret. Look it up.

As for energy prices, does Ed Davey or do you have any ideas of how taxing and capping energy prices improves supply or energy security. If the wholesale price is high and you place price cap, forcing energy companies to make up the difference, they go out of business. Maybe you missed this in the last few months. Equally windfall tax can only be applied to profits. By capping price, you force them to make up the difference between the wholsesale price, hence no profits to tax.

I think your theory is based on fantasy, not math.

cuddlybear21 · 09/08/2022 09:42

Well one way to raise wages for a Tesco worker without subsidizing businesses is by increasing the minimum wage to a reasonable amount. I would say that no one on a min wage job should be getting benefit because wages should be high enough. You could increase min wage and give subsidies to businesses for training workers and hope you end up with a higher wage better trained workforce. But the reality is the Tories really do only care about their financial backers and thats large corporations

AndreaC74 · 09/08/2022 07:44

However multinational profit driven corporations that are paying workers wages that need to be topped upped with state aid, whilst handing profits back to shareholders - outrageous

Agree but how to address it? without harming the workers in your local Tesco - i'd have graded CT rates, based on profit and the pay of their lowest paid workers.

Landlords who speculate with debt in the housing market, end up getting buggered with interest rates because they can't risk model and subsequently end up being the end recipient of state aid in the form of UC and housing benefit? Ridiculous

Privatising social housing is crazy, Tax payers money via HB and UC used to buy the Landlord a house.
Ans - Build far more Council housing.

AndreaC74 · 09/08/2022 07:39

No-one is saying that farming and other critical industries should have their workers supported and left to the free market. They are arguably too important to leave to the vagaries and corruption

Thats exactly what @sst1234 was calling for.

...and you will find that almost all jobs are critical, often never thought of that until they stop doing them.... as we found out in the Pandemic.

Right, Centre and Left is used because our political system is based on that, no one can take into account an individuals politics.

SwanBuster · 09/08/2022 07:29

AndreaC74 · 09/08/2022 07:14

"let the market adjust" more right wing nonsense.

If you took away working benefits, wages wouldn't rise to compensate, thats why we had to have MW and before that income support.

You think a farmer will compensate his worker on MW? what with magic beans? the farmer also has no money, tied in to SM contracts, input costs gone up 300% or the Care Agency will rise wages for carers? again.. how? Councils have no money to give them extra... thanks to you lot.

All wages have to rise, you have to have differentials and the Govt has made it perfectly clearly with the recent NHS rise, they have no intention of rises wages at the bottom/lower earners.

Ed Davey has a better idea, Keep the Cap as it is, retrospective Tax on Energy Industry.
Personally, i'd part nationalise the sector with that WF tax.

The problem with the world today is we see ideas and theories as 'right and left wing'.

It is almost inexplicable to me. I am socially ultra liberal - but on monetary and fiscal policy - I'd be classed as ultra conservative.

No-one is saying that farming and other critical industries should have their workers supported and left to the free market. They are arguably too important to leave to the vagaries and corruption.

However multinational profit driven corporations that are paying workers wages that need to be topped upped with state aid, whilst handing profits back to shareholders - outrageous.

Landlords who speculate with debt in the housing market, end up getting buggered with interest rates because they can't risk model and subsequently end up being the end recipient of state aid in the form of UC and housing benefit? Ridiculous.

AndreaC74 · 09/08/2022 07:24

When firms move into the UK, it creates jobs, brings in tax revenue (not just corporate profits, but also from VAT, PAYE, NIC, etc), and there's the knock on effect of them buying goods/services from local suppliers, so there's the multiplier effect of those firms also paying more in taxes etc on their greater profits and higher employment

ROI has full and free access to one of the worlds largest FTZ, the UK does not, Cross channel lorry delays at shocking, with almost no facilities.

also, judging by some posters who live there, their public services are a mess, & unemployment rate is higher than the UK.

UK has a very low CT rate, 19%, not much higher than ROI and considerably lower than, say Germany's, not yet seen VW relocate to the UK....

So many other factors matter too, like a functioning healthservice for your employees, good education system, transport, well educated workforce.... not things we are excelling at.

AndreaC74 · 09/08/2022 07:14

sst1234 · 08/08/2022 20:17

What’s so mystical about raising wages at the bottom? You remove state subsidy aka ta max credits/UC topups and let the market adjust. Wages are low and productivity poor because of state subsidy for employers so they don’t pay market rate.

"let the market adjust" more right wing nonsense.

If you took away working benefits, wages wouldn't rise to compensate, thats why we had to have MW and before that income support.

You think a farmer will compensate his worker on MW? what with magic beans? the farmer also has no money, tied in to SM contracts, input costs gone up 300% or the Care Agency will rise wages for carers? again.. how? Councils have no money to give them extra... thanks to you lot.

All wages have to rise, you have to have differentials and the Govt has made it perfectly clearly with the recent NHS rise, they have no intention of rises wages at the bottom/lower earners.

Ed Davey has a better idea, Keep the Cap as it is, retrospective Tax on Energy Industry.
Personally, i'd part nationalise the sector with that WF tax.

user1497207191 · 09/08/2022 07:06

lljkk · 08/08/2022 22:43

Reagonomics, isn't that the idea.
Idea is Cut tax and companies will "invest" the tax savings into ways of making profits: which is true. But sometimes those investments are share buybacks, or investment overseas. or some other thing that basically doesn't grow the economy at all, much less lead to higher wages.

Of course if tax cuts did lead to higher wages then that means, oh yeah, more inflationary pressure upwards.

I think it's more to get international firms to move into the UK, and to keep UK firms here, as opposed to relocating to other countries with lower taxes.

It's the main reason why Ireland had such a big economy - lots of international firms relocated to Ireland for their low corporate taxes.

When UK is wanting big firms to move their head offices or factories here, we need a carrot to dangle, and low corporate taxes is a very popular carrot!

When firms move into the UK, it creates jobs, brings in tax revenue (not just corporate profits, but also from VAT, PAYE, NIC, etc), and there's the knock on effect of them buying goods/services from local suppliers, so there's the multiplier effect of those firms also paying more in taxes etc on their greater profits and higher employment.

user1497207191 · 09/08/2022 07:02

Sporty2022 · 08/08/2022 09:40

Does anyone else think that the UK is basically fucked? In layman’s terms I mean.

Brexit, an ageing population, less people of working age, a pandemic, generation rent, cost of living. I could go on.

None of that is unique to the UK. The US, Australia, Canada, and Europe are all facing the same issues. It's a "Western" World problem!

lljkk · 08/08/2022 22:43

Reagonomics, isn't that the idea.
Idea is Cut tax and companies will "invest" the tax savings into ways of making profits: which is true. But sometimes those investments are share buybacks, or investment overseas. or some other thing that basically doesn't grow the economy at all, much less lead to higher wages.

Of course if tax cuts did lead to higher wages then that means, oh yeah, more inflationary pressure upwards.

Sporty2022 · 08/08/2022 22:35

I don’t think tax cuts is the answer? Many large businesses make big profits and can afford to pay tax. How exactly does lowering taxes benefit the economy? Less money going into essential services?
Plus it wouldn’t really affect people on lower incomes anyway.

Personally, I’d rather pay a couple of quid a year more on income tax if I know it was being spent on public services.

Id rather be taxed an extra £200 a year if it means life can be better in the UK for everyoneAnd I only earn £30 k a year so I’m hardly a high earner.

Blossomtoes · 08/08/2022 22:33

@Sporty2022, there were lots of leave voters who are young and working class. This is the profile of leave voters.

www.jrf.org.uk/report/brexit-vote-explained-poverty-low-skills-and-lack-opportunities