Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why Glasgow Satantic ring isn't headline news?!

130 replies

CoastalWave · 03/08/2022 15:08

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-62384842

Not often i'm speechless.

How is this buried within the news?! Should this not be headline?

It's beyond disturbing.

Those poor children

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 05/08/2022 07:03

viques · 04/08/2022 00:08

If it is a case not due to come to trial until next year then not much can be said about it so as not to prejudice the trial/ influence possible jurors . The more idle gossip and speculation there is the more chance of the accused being able to claim the trial is unfair.

This is not accurate. All newspapers have court reporters who report on court cases in their local area which are of general public interest. There is not some magical, unofficial sensitivity filter, on certain cases. The courts are public (unless a specific court order has been approved) and therefore if someone is charged, it is a face which is in the public domain and can be reported upon. It is a vital tenet of our legal system. I'm also shocked at the number of posters who seem to think that charges brought in court should not be reported upon in the newspapers just in case they don't result in a guilty verdict - seriously? These posters support a secretive system where such charges are hushed up just in case people who are not witnesses talk about it because they wrongly think that will be enough to prejudice the verdict and lead to a mistrial? OMG...

What is likely here is that this is part of a growing and continuing trend towards poor and limited press coverage in recent years aimed at Scotland as a whole.

I follow the courts for professional reasons and therefore very much need the Scottish newspapers in the central belt to report on cases in the year to eighteen months that cases take to get published in the official case law reports. I also need these reports to keep an eye on what is happening before a trial stage. There is now a clear trend in Scotland towards a lack of reporting on Scottish issues. While not related to the political party in power, the Scottish Government probably should be making itself more aware of the issue and address it in some shape or form. After all, what is the Scottish Parliament for?

The Guardian published an article about this problem in Scotland back in 2019, and the issue will only be worse now since Covid, some of which I will quote below: www.theguardian.com/media/2019/dec/10/scotland-newspaper-cuts-the-herald-the-scotsman

The loss of staff at Scotland’s key titles has been dramatic according to any measure. In 2009, there were about 240 journalists across the Herald, its Sunday sister and the Glasgow Times. But staff at the Herald – which has been published since 1783 – have learned in the past month of restructuring plans to further reduce its news operation to consist of three general reporters, working across seven days, with no night cover, in addition to three more reporting roles across its politics and business teams.

The Scotsman newsroom has likewise more than halved over the past decade to about a dozen reporters, with staff moving from a purpose-built office close to the Scottish parliament to a block on the edge of Edinburgh.

Journalists across both titles describe the deliberate dismantling of specialisms, bringing with it a reduction in exclusive content and splashes. As the Herald in particular continues to lose experienced reporters, industry insiders are raising serious doubts about how remaining digital staff will have the capacity or expertise to scrutinise policymakers and politicians.

Comparisons are made with the first years of the Scottish parliament, when a far healthier press held newly elected representatives to account, for example prompting the resignation of the second first minister, Henry McLeish, over an expenses scandal.

David Clegg, who was named journalist of the year at the Scottish Press Awards in April for his work revealing the initial sexual harassment allegations against the former first minister Alex Salmond, applauds colleagues for “performing daily miracles” but says cuts to reporting staff across Newsquest and JPI Media can only compromise future coverage of Scotland’s shifting political landscape.
“A second independence referendum will be an event of historic significance, and it’s vital that both sides are scrutinised by a healthy and robust media. But it’s also about the decisions of local councils, health boards and courts that deserve scrutiny on a daily basis. When you don’t have dedicated reporters covering a city like Glasgow, it affects the national conversation,” he says.*

Both the Press & Journal in Aberdeen and the Courier in Dundee substantially outsell their central belt counterparts. Newquest no longer publishes audited circulation figures for its titles, but the Herald had fallen to 22,901 a day by the end of December 2018, while the Scotsman sells 14,938 copies a day.

Off the top of my head, there are 2 Scottish stories, not involving potential child sex rings that have been very poorly reported. The Edinburgh Council statutory notices scam (which led to several CofE employees being jailed and millions of pounds worth of debt being written off due to a compulsory scheme run by the Council to force homeowners to have repairs carried out which were often unnecessary or over-charged) was reported on by the BBC, but there was simply little real interest within Scotland. Many people in Edinburgh simply don't know about it, the Scottish Parliament didn't debate it and the whole issue has been poorly reported within Scotland, although it should be one of the biggest scandals of recent times.

There is also a case which was before the Court of Session last week involving a tenant of a stately home called Rossie Priory who has challenged his eviction despite stopping paying rent in early 2016, instead utilising the number of appeals against eviction and the new landlord and tenant legislation to play the system. The Courier has reported on the case at an early stage but the national Scottish newspapers didn't take it up. Its a particularly salacious case, with the unpaid rent now surely approaching 1/2 million pounds and the court fees surely not much less. I'd quite like to know the outcome of this case as has important implications for all landlords and tenants in Scotland and represents a problem for landlords in Scotland not heard of in the rest of the world. Instead, there is nothing in the newspapers anywhere.

But you just have to look at the number of posters on this thread who think that cases brought before the courts shouldn't be reported on and should instead be hushed up (a particular problem if an Accused dies before the trial as there will be no record of them being charged in the public domain) to understand why this is a growing problem.

Chouetted · 05/08/2022 03:04

wellhelloitsme · 04/08/2022 21:56

Yes so my point is that it's strange to say 'child sex' instead of 'child abuse' when the charges are child abuse...

The article says they've been charged with child abuse so it's frustrating that they went with 'child sex' in the headline.

Language matters. 'Child sex' is always abuse. The same applies for the term 'child porn' which is unfortunately still widely used.

I suppose they wanted to be more specific. I do find this argument a bit odd when the word "paedophilia" and related words are never objected to - the idea of boy-love gives me the creeps every time I see it.

JohnRokesmith · 04/08/2022 22:08

sashh · 04/08/2022 10:05

Whereas in England the last prosecution was in 1944.

That wasn’t the last prosecution of a witch, that was the last prosecution under the powers of the Witchcraft Act of 1735. Despite the name, it wasn’t designed for prosecuting witches, but for prosecuting fraudsters pretending that they had magical powers.

wellhelloitsme · 04/08/2022 21:56

Surplus2requirements · 04/08/2022 21:44

Child abuse is a much broader category, the charges include child sex which is very obviously horrific child abuse.
Why people are taking issue with the words used when the reporting is very constrained at this point by law is bizarre.

Yes so my point is that it's strange to say 'child sex' instead of 'child abuse' when the charges are child abuse...

The article says they've been charged with child abuse so it's frustrating that they went with 'child sex' in the headline.

Language matters. 'Child sex' is always abuse. The same applies for the term 'child porn' which is unfortunately still widely used.

Surplus2requirements · 04/08/2022 21:44

Child abuse is a much broader category, the charges include child sex which is very obviously horrific child abuse.
Why people are taking issue with the words used when the reporting is very constrained at this point by law is bizarre.

AffIt · 04/08/2022 21:12

bellac11 · 03/08/2022 15:33

Hiding it away to try to protect the perpetrators because of their ethnicity..... oh wait....

Ethnicity? With surnames like Brannan, Forbes and Clark, all of which are perfectly 'white' Scottish surnames?

Oh, that wasn't what you meant, though, was it?

wellhelloitsme · 04/08/2022 21:06

ImperioMarch · 04/08/2022 21:00

@wellhelloitsme no they can't. That's not what the statutory offence and at this point it's an allegation

I don't understand why the phrase "child abuse" couldn't have been used in the headline, when the body copy clearly states that they are charged with "abusing three young children".

It says:

"Seven men and four women are charged with abusing three young children in Glasgow during a 10-year period."

ImperioMarch · 04/08/2022 21:00

@wellhelloitsme no they can't. That's not what the statutory offence and at this point it's an allegation

ScreamingMeMe · 04/08/2022 20:15

bellac11 · 03/08/2022 16:30

Each time child abuse is discussed, it is insinuated that abusers in rings dont get caught or prosecuted or the children are not believed because the rings are made up of men of Muslim/asian groups and the police or social workers ignore the children because of that. Which doesnt make sense because the examples given are of rings that were prosecuted.

And that the media doesnt report it or its hidden away because of a fear of looking racist

Despite that child sex abusers are made up from all manner of communities in the UK.

I knew what you were getting at, bellac.

wellhelloitsme · 04/08/2022 20:12

ImperioMarch · 04/08/2022 19:49

@wellhelloitsme as pointed out before this is almost always down to the wording of the statutory offence with which the accused is charged. The journalist is not at liberty to state it's rape when that's not what the accused has been charged with 🙄

They can say child abuse then, no?

That's highly preferable to the phrase 'child sex'.

Not sure if the eye roll was directed at me but if it was I'm not sure why!

ImperioMarch · 04/08/2022 19:49

@wellhelloitsme as pointed out before this is almost always down to the wording of the statutory offence with which the accused is charged. The journalist is not at liberty to state it's rape when that's not what the accused has been charged with 🙄

OMG12 · 04/08/2022 18:53

This is really bizarre. How can a child fit in a microwave. Most of my plates can’t.

what this is is a drug filled peadophile ring.

so what kind of satanists put horns on their head? What do they mean by “witchcraft”? This sounds like so drugged up paedos playing dress up or someone feeding the kids things to do in some attempt to reignite the satanic panic. Watch the Paradise Lost films or more recently and the fictional equivalent in stranger things

As someone who is into the occult:western esotericism even today it’s not uncommon to feel persecution, people don’t understand it and either ridicule or paint it as evil when nothing could be further from the truth. People doing yoga don’t get this

kmblark · 04/08/2022 18:32

myyellowcar · 03/08/2022 15:42

Yep! This was my thought

What, unironically?

wellhelloitsme · 04/08/2022 17:10

Whataretheodds · 03/08/2022 16:25

Im bothered by the BBC using the term "child sex" rather than "child rape", which is what it actually is.

Me too. Disgusting of them.

I've just made a complaint online to the BBC.

It's the same as people using the phrase 'child porn' instead of child abuse pictures / videos.

Completely minimises sexual abuse and rape of children.

10HailMarys · 04/08/2022 11:36

FreyaStorm · 04/08/2022 00:34

Possibly they are devotees of the “redemption through sin” belief system. Not very well known but definitely a feature of many prominent people in society. Chilling. And perhaps why it’s not more ‘headline’ news.

It's because of this kind of speculation that the press have to close comments on their stories about court cases. It's not helpful and it can be prejudicial.

10HailMarys · 04/08/2022 11:33

I'm a media relations specialist and I've worked as a press officer in the criminal justice system so I'll share my professional perspective on this.

It's worth noting that although charges have been brought, the actual trial won't start for at least a year, so all reporting at this stage has to be very, very careful and limited to certain information, to avoid prejudicing the trial. What's been reported so far is literally all that can be said at this stage - this is the very earliest point in the proceedings and they can't really report anything more now until the trial starts, which will be September 2023 at the earliest according to the article. It's when the trial starts that the story becomes bigger news. Technically, that is when it becomes 'in the public interest' to cover it more extensively.

I suspect that when the case actually comes to court next year, it will be covered a lot more extensively in all the press, and even more so of course if the defendants are found guilty.

I understand your point because it's an extremely shocking and lurid set of allegations, but it has been reported factually in all the major news outlets and with my professional hat on, I'd it's had pretty much the amount and type of coverage that I would expect at this very early stage in the proceedings. I think there will definitely be a lot more when there's more that the press can actually say.

Karenxo · 04/08/2022 10:25

Also kids don't fit in microwaves.

They said it was a newborn. Presumably forcefully folded into unnatural shapes. They also said it didn't work, just that they tried to.

I'm also fairly sure I've heard of this happening in America with a baby. Of course older children don't fit in microwaves.

JustLyra · 04/08/2022 10:17

Sometimes this site is baffling.

How is Earth is something that’s being reported by the BBC, and multiple others, being “hushed up”?

And how are so many people so unaware of how things work that basics such as comments being closed seem suspicious?

Not to mention the fact that details are limited because they’ve not been to court yet and to protect the identities of the children.

The bloodthirst for details that is so prevalent now is one day going to destroy a trial and see someone guilty of something awful walk free. I’m convinced of it.

FayeGovan · 04/08/2022 10:10

Dotjones · 03/08/2022 16:07

The SNP are trying to hush this up because it doesn't reflect well on Scotland. Scotland has a terrible history with witchcraft (the British story of witches being persecuted is above all a Scottish one, though one wouldn't think it because the SNP do a good job of hushing it up), the last one being executed as recently as 1727, long after other countries ceased the hunt.

It is shocking to hear that witchcraft is still practiced north of the border and I'm not suprised - though disappointed - that Sturgeon & co. don't want this getting out.

Oh for gods sake ive heard it all now on mumsnet. I know the snp and nicola sturgeon are utterly vilified on here but blaming them for something that happened in 1727 is really pushing it 🤣🤣

IncompleteSenten · 04/08/2022 10:07

The satanic thing is a red herring.

This is a child abuse 'ring' sadly like many more.

I think people shouldn't be distracted by or focus on the so called witchcraft thing.

sashh · 04/08/2022 10:05

Dotjones · 03/08/2022 16:07

The SNP are trying to hush this up because it doesn't reflect well on Scotland. Scotland has a terrible history with witchcraft (the British story of witches being persecuted is above all a Scottish one, though one wouldn't think it because the SNP do a good job of hushing it up), the last one being executed as recently as 1727, long after other countries ceased the hunt.

It is shocking to hear that witchcraft is still practiced north of the border and I'm not suprised - though disappointed - that Sturgeon & co. don't want this getting out.

Whereas in England the last prosecution was in 1944.

Vivi0 · 04/08/2022 07:40

It seems that 5 of the 11 accused have died by suicide since the arrests were made last year.

ImperioMarch · 04/08/2022 07:17

JamesGetIn · 03/08/2022 20:47

The language used throughout the entire BBC article is very odd...:

Prosecutors state all 11 are said to have got the boy and the older girl to take part in "seances (and) use a Ouija board...to call on spirits and demons".

They also allegedly got the children involved in "witchcraft", leading them to believe that they themselves had "metamorphosed into animals".

The 11 are further said to have worn cloaks and devil horns as well making the young boy stab a budgie to death.

The group are also accused of killing a number of dogs, including getting the children to attack the animals.

"Got the boy", "got the children", "making the boy", "getting the children".

It's the oddest language I've ever come across in a supposedly reputable source.

Very fishy...

It's not fishy at all. You can't name children in court proceedings and they children are not the accused, therefore the adults are accused of inciting them.

ImperioMarch · 04/08/2022 07:14

it was one of the only articles that was closed to comments.
This is because it's an active court case. It's standard practice where proceedings are ongoing. Proceedings are active from first appearance on indictment through to conclusion of trial.

It's to prevent people who think accused equals guilty making comments that prejudice a fair trial and the proceedings potentially collapsing as a result.

ImperioMarch · 04/08/2022 07:08

Whataretheodds · 03/08/2022 16:25

Im bothered by the BBC using the term "child sex" rather than "child rape", which is what it actually is.

Because that's not how the statutory offence is worded, no matter how society might feel about it morally.

This is court reporting, they can't go off piste as it can be deemed to be prejudicing a fair trial. And prejudicing them is how trials have collapsed in the past.