Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel part time workers get a raw deal when it comes to progression

139 replies

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 02/08/2022 22:35

I went part time after I had my first baby, my employer that I have been with for nearly 10 years wouldn't let me reduce my hours in the current role where I had a small team I managed, so I had to take the only position available in a different department, not managerial but same pay, pro rata'd.

I have since not had any opportunities to use previous transferable skills, promotions or go back to managing, job sharing will not be considered with other part time members. Even when I have been putting in extra hours and taking on additional work and responsibilities.

So I thought Id look outside the company, there are barely any part time roles available that aren't entry level, most are MW. Ive contacted local recruitment agencies and searched online.

My options seem to be stay in a job with no progression or recognition or take something on less pay at entry level with the hope there may be a chance to progress eventually.

My AIBU is to think there doesn't seem to be any decent opportunities for someone willing to work hard with good experience or am I just doing something wrong?

OP posts:
seramum · 03/08/2022 10:35

@Iamthewombat

"Not a chance. I was really annoyed that she and the recruiter had wasted my time. I wouldn’t see that candidate again for any type of role. So I don’t recommend this strategy for the OP."

Surely that depends on whether the candidate was prepared to work FT. I was, but it was my preference not to, if that could be accommodated. I made that clear in my interview, that whilst my preference was for part time, if I felt the job was otherwise perfect, I would be prepared to go full time. I think sometimes interviewees forget you're interviewing the company to see whether you want to work there as much as you're being interviewed for the job. I've turned down a couple of jobs because on interview, I didn't like the interviewer, what they were telling me, or didn't think I'd be a good fit for the company. (nothing to do with the part time issue, btw).

TheYearOfSmallThings · 03/08/2022 10:29

Btw I worked in my job full-time before having DS - it would never have been offered as a part time role to a newcomer

HousePlantNeglect · 03/08/2022 10:29

I find it quite depressing that lots of people on here are saying that you shouldn’t accept it but their solution is for your husband to take a step back and you work FT!

You should be able to progress whilst working PT and it’s agonising that you can’t. I worked myself into a decent position before having kids and got head hunted for a PT role while on my first maternity leave. I accepted it only to find out that they are shit at managing PT and not only am I stressed and overloaded, I’m at the same time unappreciated and seen as flaky.

my DH also works PT (0.8 compared to my 0.6) and experiences no such issues. He’s also often congratulated for being a great role model for working families sharing the load.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 03/08/2022 10:27

I think it's true and even though I work part time (75%) I actually think it's not unreasonable. I find part time staff something of a barrier to getting stuff completed. I prefer dealing with teams who have a substantial full time presence, and I have stronger work relationships with them. Meanwhile they are probably wishing I was full time even though I deal with time sensitive stuff on my days off.

Realistically if I want to step up another grade I won't be getting it as a part timer.

Shoopshoopshoopshoopshoop · 03/08/2022 10:19

seramum · 03/08/2022 08:19

Last two jobs I've applied for have been full time, but in interview I've asked if they'd consider employing me part time (4 days). Both did and I got both jobs. Might be worth a try?

This, part time roles are extremely rare in my industry and would never be advertised as such. Usually part-timers start as FT and drop a day later into the role. More senior roles tend to do compressed hours

My current job I went for the interview then asked for 0.8FTE when they offered and they agreed.

brookstar · 03/08/2022 10:13

I think women do this because in the throes of having babies and dealing with hormones, nappies and then nursery pick ups etc it makes sense at the time to take on part time work while DH continue working and providing a constant income (or it did to me).

If you view parenting as a joint job then it doesn't make sense for one person to sacrifice their career.

Gruffling · 03/08/2022 10:08

Yanbu. I don't think PT workers should expect to progress as fast as FT workers doing equivalent jobs...but at the moment there is no progression without going back to FT.

Yerroblemom1923 · 03/08/2022 09:59

Part timers are viewed as flakey and not committed to their job. I experienced this when I returned PT after taking a year off for mat leave. While my company agreed to my request to go PT they ensured my job role was v different to my previous FT one - so much so that they had deliberately removed all the "fun" parts from my role. I should've known, they hated part timers.
Needless to say I left after a year as life's too short to do a job that you hate. I now run my own business that fits around my life.

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 09:56

Meltingsocks · 03/08/2022 08:44

You don't have to accept it! Go full time and make DH take the part time hit.

Why do women trash their careers to protect the big man jobs?

I think women do this because in the throes of having babies and dealing with hormones, nappies and then nursery pick ups etc it makes sense at the time to take on part time work while DH continue working and providing a constant income (or it did to me). Now we have 2 DC and a bigger house/higher outgoings DH cant drop hours easily as we’d both be earning less until several years down the line when Id (hopefully) caught back up.
Its not doable at this time so I guess I need to stick it out here for a bit.

OP posts:
CharlesIsQueensHorcrux · 03/08/2022 09:55

Hi - I have worked PT and FT since having kids & managed people doing both. You are looking at this the wrong way round, it’s all about what you want not what your employer needs. They are paying so they decide.

Most jobs operate approx 9-5 Mon-Fri and it’s a pain for employers not to have employees there the whole time. Some limited flex can often be accommodated for someone good eg 80% or finish early some days and log back on. But it does generally make it harder others which the employer must also consider so there has to be some payback eg retaining someone particularly good or gaining flex in return for when something kicks off at the weekend (hard to offer with young kids) etc. I personally don’t think it’s a massive conspiracy against women it’s just the reality of the demands of most jobs. Where jobs are genuinely more divisible there are more success stories for PT (men & women) eg virtually all GPs work part time because it’s easy to see 60% or whatever of the number of patients.

Options are 1) PT & make your peace 2) FT or nearly FT & progress 3) try to move towards a field where PT works better. I agree with others that both parents need to share the domestic load if they both want to progress at work and this needs to be on the radar early on or the man’s salary gets too far ahead of the woman’s and then they may not be able to afford for him to cut back if required. All choices require compromises as there are only 24 hours in the day. Good luck

cheveux · 03/08/2022 09:50

Oh sorry, I agree it’s a management issue! It’s not on anyone to find their own cover etc. If someone goes on annual leave then someone else is drafted in to take over that role - I’m doing it for someone at the moment. That has a proper handover etc. so everyone is clued in on what’s going on. My company don’t run part time working as job shares. Particularly for project management roles where not all hours are billable through the week, I think it’s seen as something that doesn’t matter if people are part time, whereas actually just because they’re not working billable hours in a block doesn’t mean they’re no needed to swoop into projects at a moments notice to troubleshoot etc.

I’m not sure job shares are always completely smooth in the sense that some clients really want consistency in their team and having different people at different meetings can creat friction and the need for constant debriefs on the state of the union, but I think job shares mostly can be great and I wish we had them more rather than assumed work can be done in shorter days.

Anyway, I was just offering a perspective from someone currently suffering from part time working not being managed properly - I guess some companies don’t see it as worth their time.

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 09:46

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2022 09:40

Someone pulled this stunt on me last year. I’d advertised a full time role on my team. I used recruiters to get what I thought would be suitable candidates, did the CV sift, set aside time for in depth Teams interviews, etc. This was for a fairly senior finance role.

One candidate, after I’d spent an hour interviewing her, dropped in at the end that she had a small child and didn’t want to work full time. Ideally she wanted three days, oh, and she wanted the hours she worked on those three days to be flexible as well, so that she could compress them into two and a half days if she felt like it.

Not a chance. I was really annoyed that she and the recruiter had wasted my time. I wouldn’t see that candidate again for any type of role. So I don’t recommend this strategy for the OP.

I can see why this would be difficult, for the ft role I interviewed for I made it clear in my cover letter and we were all aware from the start that I was looking for a pt role so was glad they still made the time to interview me.

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 03/08/2022 09:40

seramum · 03/08/2022 08:19

Last two jobs I've applied for have been full time, but in interview I've asked if they'd consider employing me part time (4 days). Both did and I got both jobs. Might be worth a try?

Someone pulled this stunt on me last year. I’d advertised a full time role on my team. I used recruiters to get what I thought would be suitable candidates, did the CV sift, set aside time for in depth Teams interviews, etc. This was for a fairly senior finance role.

One candidate, after I’d spent an hour interviewing her, dropped in at the end that she had a small child and didn’t want to work full time. Ideally she wanted three days, oh, and she wanted the hours she worked on those three days to be flexible as well, so that she could compress them into two and a half days if she felt like it.

Not a chance. I was really annoyed that she and the recruiter had wasted my time. I wouldn’t see that candidate again for any type of role. So I don’t recommend this strategy for the OP.

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/08/2022 09:25

cheveux · 03/08/2022 08:45

It can be very difficult having part time managers for junior staff. I work in a company that’s very big on promoting women into senior positions, which means a lot of them are mothers who work part time. I think the ones who work 80% of full time hours are fine, but the senior PM on my current project only works 3 days a week, and one of those is short hours. Our work is entirely client-based, so when she’s not working if the client has a massive problem or needs something urgently, the rest of the team have to make senior-level decisions in her absence or involve other staff who are not working on the project to approve budget changes etc. which is pretty rubbish. I think there are some instances where part time working doesn’t fit with the actual job.

I totally understand this dilemma as we have similar issue at my company but I can't believe there isn't someone else who can step into the breach for the days this woman isn't working?

As a PP has mentioned, its a job share situation surely?

This is a management issue, as opposed to a PT working issue. We had a very senior woman who worked 3 days a week and a less senior but equally competent one who worked the remaining two. With seamless handover it shouldn't be this much of a problem.

Thatsenoughnow · 03/08/2022 09:23

cheveux · 03/08/2022 08:45

It can be very difficult having part time managers for junior staff. I work in a company that’s very big on promoting women into senior positions, which means a lot of them are mothers who work part time. I think the ones who work 80% of full time hours are fine, but the senior PM on my current project only works 3 days a week, and one of those is short hours. Our work is entirely client-based, so when she’s not working if the client has a massive problem or needs something urgently, the rest of the team have to make senior-level decisions in her absence or involve other staff who are not working on the project to approve budget changes etc. which is pretty rubbish. I think there are some instances where part time working doesn’t fit with the actual job.

It's not her fault though. The company have evidently decided that the "cost" of her working part time ie your other colleagues occasionally having to help out, is reasonable. It's not her working part time that's the issue. The issue is her colleagues attitude towards it. What would you do if she was on annual leave?

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 08:56

cheveux · 03/08/2022 08:45

It can be very difficult having part time managers for junior staff. I work in a company that’s very big on promoting women into senior positions, which means a lot of them are mothers who work part time. I think the ones who work 80% of full time hours are fine, but the senior PM on my current project only works 3 days a week, and one of those is short hours. Our work is entirely client-based, so when she’s not working if the client has a massive problem or needs something urgently, the rest of the team have to make senior-level decisions in her absence or involve other staff who are not working on the project to approve budget changes etc. which is pretty rubbish. I think there are some instances where part time working doesn’t fit with the actual job.

This is where a job share would work - there is another part timer at the same level of experience as me and we could easily cross over and take 3 days each but Ive raised it and its not being considered.

OP posts:
shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 08:52

Meltingsocks · 03/08/2022 08:17

Easiest solution is for DH to a stint at part time, you get a new full time role with progression. Why have you allowed only your career to a take a hit?

DH already does a 4 day week but he really cant reduce any further, he is earning a lot more than me so we would have to take a massive hit financially whilst I got any career movement going.
I dont think I realised when I went pt, how difficult it would be to keep a career going. I guess I thought it might just take longer to progress/find new positions but not that Id be stuck completely.

OP posts:
Thatsenoughnow · 03/08/2022 08:49

You are totally NBU. people are assuming you're at a high level and then you can cut your hours. What about those who didn't get to a senior level before having children. I earn less than 30k and had my children (twins) at 32. I had to go part time because there was a total lack of affordable, good childcare. I didn't plan for twins. Trying to work full time around baby twins would have left us with a deficit as well as sacrificing my mental health. It's 2022, even though pretty much everyone in my industry works remotely the majority of working patterns are still firmly fixed at 9-5 Monday to Friday. I'll tell you who that working pattern suits - men.

I'm applying for new jobs at the moment and on linked in if i search jobs in my industry i get 245 results. If i search the same thing but select part time/job share i get 2.

It's 2022 and companies still look around all wide eyed at how they've got a gender pay gap. Well, this is why. If companies can allow women to go part time at senior level, then it should be even easier to do it at my level. It's indirect discrimination because the majority of part time workers are women.

That's before we even get started on my colleagues attitudes towards me. They fully expect me to complete as much work as them and view any slight concession i get, such as slightly less work, as evidence that I'm not working as hard as them. Regularly have to defend myself in team meetings while my manager sits and watches.

cheveux · 03/08/2022 08:45

It can be very difficult having part time managers for junior staff. I work in a company that’s very big on promoting women into senior positions, which means a lot of them are mothers who work part time. I think the ones who work 80% of full time hours are fine, but the senior PM on my current project only works 3 days a week, and one of those is short hours. Our work is entirely client-based, so when she’s not working if the client has a massive problem or needs something urgently, the rest of the team have to make senior-level decisions in her absence or involve other staff who are not working on the project to approve budget changes etc. which is pretty rubbish. I think there are some instances where part time working doesn’t fit with the actual job.

Meltingsocks · 03/08/2022 08:44

You don't have to accept it! Go full time and make DH take the part time hit.

Why do women trash their careers to protect the big man jobs?

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 03/08/2022 08:42

I could have written this OP. I've been in my role for 14 years in a really niche science dept. Went part time 7 years ago after first was born as couldn't afford the childcare on my full time wage- I was the first to go part time in the department ever.... This year I finally had enough of being denied the opportunity to progress simply based on hours so I started to look elsewhere. Secured a different public sector job but frankly didn't want to leave the one I loved so I decided to fight.

A more senior post came up and I applied- was told that part time wasn't an option so I contacted the union and HR and sought advice. Funnily enough the words indirect sex discrimination really seem to focus a manager's brain and make flexible working a bit more feasible. I've now secured a permanent contract part time doing the job I love. Without going for the job and asking the awkward questions I wouldn't have got it.

Do you have a HR dept? A union rep? Look at ACAS, the flex appeal campaign (ran by motherpukka) and apply for jobs regardless- even if they say full time. Ask the awkward questions- what percentage of workers are full time/ part time in your organisation? How does that break down into sex? Fight them. It's the only way that they listen. X

brookstar · 03/08/2022 08:41

Why do you have to accept it?
Has you husbands career taken a hit after having children?

AnuSTart · 03/08/2022 08:40

You have a husband. Don't sacrifice your career over his unless you want to. Let him go part time for a while.
All women in marriages need to do this
If they want careers. If a couple has kids they should share the load, not the workplace so to speak.
I sacrificed my family time for my career, which I'm now glad of with older more expensive kids, but it wouldn't have been possible doing part time hours. It just isn't. And it would be the same for men. They just aren't usually part time workers because most couples decide between themselves that the mother takes the hit! Which is absurd really. I put earn most men now and certainly all the men in my company.
Women need to insist in equality in their relationships as well as their work! Therein lies the rub!

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 08:37

Hedonism · 03/08/2022 08:25

I'm totally stuck where I am. I went pt after dc1 and it seems that unless I want to go full time again (I don't) there are no openings at my level. Tbh I've made my peace with it now, but it's taken 10 years and a few frustrating job interviews to get here.

Same! I did manage to get an interview which was advertised as ft and they said they could try and work it out, the interview went well but they came back and said unfortunately they couldn’t accommodate pt.
I think Im just getting to the stage where I have to accept it for now until my kids are older. Its so demotivating at work tho, its not just the money/position, Id like something new that I can learn and develop in.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 03/08/2022 08:29

They do and as PPs have pointed out you usually have to be FT when you're in the "climbing the greasy pole" phase of your career.

It is frustrating: to be fair I can see how, optically, its very difficult for young, FT workers to swallow the fact that someone who works fewer hours is being promoted faster than them, however competent, so I understand how employers find it hard to justify promoting PT workers at the same pace as FT workers. It takes a very progressive workplace to do this.

But as with so many things in working life, if work were distributed more fairly between the sexes across paid and domestic work when children come along you'd find far more men wanting to go PT and you could bet your bottom dollar that would change things.

If men routinely had to go PT to do more childcare and were finding themselves being discriminated against in the promotion stakes they would kick up an almighty stink about it in a way women for the most part don't. The reason men don't usually need to is because in the vast majority of cases the woman will take the career sacrifice (thus damaging her own earning potential) and go PT so the men can carry on tearing up the career ladder.

This is one of the major things holding women back from advancing in the workplace. And one of the many reasons why the last frontier in promoting equality between the sexes isn't so much hiring more women, its getting men to do more domestic and child-related labour.