Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel part time workers get a raw deal when it comes to progression

139 replies

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 02/08/2022 22:35

I went part time after I had my first baby, my employer that I have been with for nearly 10 years wouldn't let me reduce my hours in the current role where I had a small team I managed, so I had to take the only position available in a different department, not managerial but same pay, pro rata'd.

I have since not had any opportunities to use previous transferable skills, promotions or go back to managing, job sharing will not be considered with other part time members. Even when I have been putting in extra hours and taking on additional work and responsibilities.

So I thought Id look outside the company, there are barely any part time roles available that aren't entry level, most are MW. Ive contacted local recruitment agencies and searched online.

My options seem to be stay in a job with no progression or recognition or take something on less pay at entry level with the hope there may be a chance to progress eventually.

My AIBU is to think there doesn't seem to be any decent opportunities for someone willing to work hard with good experience or am I just doing something wrong?

OP posts:
shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 15:42

TheYearOfSmallThings · 03/08/2022 15:17

I’ve found that if you go to a job interview and hint at needing some flexibility with working hours most employers find a reason not to hire you.

I also notice more and more jobs are advertised as 8:30 to 5:00 or 9 to 5:30, or anything other than 9-5, gently signalling that anyone with childcare responsibilities need not apply.

Yes I have seen this and by the time you have added travel on, the kids need to be childcare from 8am to 6pm which I feel is too long for nursery age children (and not always available!).
It seems that you should either put off having children until you have worked your way up to a senior role (but not leave it too late as the bio clock is ticking) or have kids younger and sacrifice seeing them so you can have a career or be happy in a part time role where you cant get anywhere.

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 03/08/2022 15:17

I’ve found that if you go to a job interview and hint at needing some flexibility with working hours most employers find a reason not to hire you.

I also notice more and more jobs are advertised as 8:30 to 5:00 or 9 to 5:30, or anything other than 9-5, gently signalling that anyone with childcare responsibilities need not apply.

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 14:48

Its almost a viscous cycle, part timer spends years working hard on the ‘mundane’ aspects of the job and not getting promoted and cant move on - might as well take on the child emergencies etc as it will have no impact on how they are viewed, this however contributes to the ‘flaky’ perception.

OP posts:
Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 13:42

seramum · 03/08/2022 13:17

"eg where urgent issues need to be dealt with/decisions need to be made on the days when the person isn't working. This won't apply to all roles, but it does apply to pretty much all of the more senior roles in my organisation. That means that someone has to pick up the slack when the part time staff member isn't there."

My Huband's boss is full time, but works condensed hours to give her one day off a week. It's a fairly niche role that does require flexibility and she sometimes has to work evenings and weekends. Their compromise is that they don't contact her on her day off, unless it's an emergency... her deputy can make most decisions, but if there is an urgent situation she's on standby to deal with that. I think she has family support to enable that. If she needs to come in on her day off, she claims the time back the following week or two.

But that needs flexible thinking and open communication on both sides to work.I have seen other women go part time and work strictly to rule (eg not allowing the corporation to contact them at all whilst they were on Mat leave (long before Kip days) and it really did them no favours at all.

On other times, the flexibility can really help the business. A few months back, a colleague quit their job, so a couple of us went full time to help cover the gap until a replacement was found. It really helped my employers out of a hole, and my boss really appreciated it. But again, it takes flexibility and openness on both sides to develop this. I've been really lucky to have had good employers that help me manage my needs (I have older children, but one with a serious health condition / disability) and I've always repaid that by being flexible and meeting their needs as best as I can.

I agree that flexibility on both sides can be beneficial, and that good will on both sides is invaluable. I myself have benefited from flexibility with regard to working patterns, but took a similar approach in terms of being contactable during non-work times in order to make that feasible.

Unfortunately, in my experience, a lot of part time staff can't or don't want to open up that option. In my experience, this has generally meant me as their manager picking stuff up in their absence.

Eek3under3 · 03/08/2022 13:34

And I should have said, both manager level roles paying c.70k so not junior roles…

Eek3under3 · 03/08/2022 13:34

I’ve just recruited 2 new roles in my team. Both were offered as FT or 0.8 roles. I thought we would get lots of interest in the PT option but nope. Seems such a shame as they are ideal roles for people needing flexibility.

ThatsGoingToHurt · 03/08/2022 13:17

I agree OP. I’m still working FT although I would like to be PT. Most women have a FT then cut down to PT.

I lost my job in 2020 and all the jobs in my area are advertised as FT unless I want to go back to admin and earn 50% less salary before going PT which would mean that it’s unsustainable. The only jobs I see being advertised as considering PT are public sector roles. I’ve found that if you go to a job interview and hint at needing some flexibility with working hours most employers find a reason not to hire you.

Its shit.

seramum · 03/08/2022 13:17

"eg where urgent issues need to be dealt with/decisions need to be made on the days when the person isn't working. This won't apply to all roles, but it does apply to pretty much all of the more senior roles in my organisation. That means that someone has to pick up the slack when the part time staff member isn't there."

My Huband's boss is full time, but works condensed hours to give her one day off a week. It's a fairly niche role that does require flexibility and she sometimes has to work evenings and weekends. Their compromise is that they don't contact her on her day off, unless it's an emergency... her deputy can make most decisions, but if there is an urgent situation she's on standby to deal with that. I think she has family support to enable that. If she needs to come in on her day off, she claims the time back the following week or two.

But that needs flexible thinking and open communication on both sides to work.I have seen other women go part time and work strictly to rule (eg not allowing the corporation to contact them at all whilst they were on Mat leave (long before Kip days) and it really did them no favours at all.

On other times, the flexibility can really help the business. A few months back, a colleague quit their job, so a couple of us went full time to help cover the gap until a replacement was found. It really helped my employers out of a hole, and my boss really appreciated it. But again, it takes flexibility and openness on both sides to develop this. I've been really lucky to have had good employers that help me manage my needs (I have older children, but one with a serious health condition / disability) and I've always repaid that by being flexible and meeting their needs as best as I can.

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 12:35

midairchallenger · 03/08/2022 12:28

An alternative way to look at it from a cost perspective is that hiring someone part time means your business can afford to bring in and benefit from talent/skills/experience that would otherwise be unaffordable if it were a full time role.

Yes, that's a valid point, and for some jobs, that could work really well. I think it's relatively easy to accommodate part time staff in relatively junior positions and also in specialised standalone roles where the work can be undertaken independently.

The problem in my view arises with regard to management positions where the role can't easily be contained within the specific days that a part time member of staff might work, eg where urgent issues need to be dealt with/decisions need to be made on the days when the person isn't working. This won't apply to all roles, but it does apply to pretty much all of the more senior roles in my organisation. That means that someone has to pick up the slack when the part time staff member isn't there.

midairchallenger · 03/08/2022 12:28

An alternative way to look at it from a cost perspective is that hiring someone part time means your business can afford to bring in and benefit from talent/skills/experience that would otherwise be unaffordable if it were a full time role.

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 12:27

I should add that I appreciate that there are some advantages to having PT staff as well. A job share provides better cover when one person goes on leave etc, or better continuity when one person moves on to another role. They might bring complementary strengths and skill sets as well. However, that's all very well if you can afford the additional costs of a job share arrangement and not very helpful if you can't!

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 12:21

It's a tricky one.

I do believe in supporting women to stay in the workplace, and facilitating part time work definitely helps with this. I also believe in all staff having a good work life balance, and in being a flexible employer to support this. In practice, I have bent over backwards to accommodate part time working requests from valued members of staff.

However, if I'm really honest about it, having part time staff in more senior roles can be a real pain in the arse to manage. When I agree to a member of staff going part time, I know that this will usually mean me picking up some of the slack on their non-work days as issues will crop up in their absence that need to be dealt with promptly. Job shares potentially offer a solution to this, but they tend to be more expensive - you generally need some overlap in order to ensure that they're communicating properly, so if they each do 3 days a week, that's an extra 20% cost on the role. You typically need to pay for 2 sets of equipment, 2 x training costs, even just twice the amount of my time to do 1:1s, appraisals etc. The other alternative would be to appoint a deputy for the part time member of staff so that they can cover in their absence, but that relies on having someone with the skills to take that on, and it also costs more if you're going to reward them fairly. So, as we're not flush with spare money floating around, the extra work typically just ends up with me sucking it up and doing more unpaid overtime.

I don't know what the solution is. I will continue to accommodate requests from valued members of the team to reduce their hours, because they have demonstrated that they're worthy of the hassle. I am much less inclined to make adjustments for new staff whose contribution is unproven.

Meltingsocks · 03/08/2022 12:17

@shouldbesleepingnotscrolling

'DH can't drop hours easily'

Every single woman I know, in a variety of roles, has been able to go part time.

Yet not one man. In similar or identical roles.

It's not that men can't go part time, it's that they WONT. Having a penis doesn't mean you can't drop a day.

seramum · 03/08/2022 12:07

@brookstar

"That's part of the problem though.... why should one person be the primary contact for childcare emergencies? Why isn't that shared between parents?"

Totally agree with this. I have older children, but one has health condition / disability, which makes it difficult for me to work full time. My agreement with DH is that I have one day off to manage all the routine appointments, but DH does all the emergency stuff. He can work from home, I can't. So if DD gets sick (which she does, a lot) he picks up on the short notice stuff. His employer and mine have always known this is the score from the outset, and both have been happy with that: it does need to be shared imo.

seramum · 03/08/2022 12:03

@Iamthewombat

"I can see that you are desperate to convince me that what you did was acceptable, which you seem to be very sensitive about, but I’d recommend that you give up."

It clearly was acceptable, and even accepted, as I've already said, I was offered two jobs this way. So at least two employers think it's acceptable as they have accepted it. Like I said, it's a good job not everyone is as narrow minded as you, as others have testified it can be a good way of getting part time work. I know plenty of people who have done it. I've had two great jobs out of it. and two very happy employers.

brookstar · 03/08/2022 11:53

Part timers are not available as often as full time workers so it can be annoying and are often primary contacts for child emergencies.

That's part of the problem though.... why should one person be the primary contact for childcare emergencies? Why isn't that shared between parents?

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 11:49

I can also see both sides. Part timers are not available as often as full time workers so it can be annoying and are often primary contacts for child emergencies.
On the flip side I know that I am very focused and organised at work and also used to managing time and multitasking more so than some full timers. By discouraging pt working, the workforce is effectively excluding a big chunk of potential resources.

OP posts:
Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 03/08/2022 11:28

I’ve been on both sides of the table in this situation : as an employer and an employee.

I went to four days a week when I was pretty senior and quite well known in a small profession. I had to ask about the four days at the end of the interview, because it was virtually unheard of when I did it. ( it wasn’t for family reasons). It wasn’t a problem with either clients or colleagues , because it was always the same day and I made sure there was nothing left hanging. However, my department head told me that they would like to put me on the board, but only if I went full time. Of course, I declined. The whole point of being four days a week was that I had stopped grasping the wheel.

I have also experienced working with and interviewing people ( mainly but not exclusively women) who wanted to work part time . In my field, part time as in less than four days a week was very difficult to accommodate at anything other than a fairly mundane level, because more involved and senior roles required more continuous input. There is also a perception which was all too often borne out that people who were working part time to accommodate parenting were more likely to be unreliable in the face of parenting crises.

I don’t know what your field is, but could you consider being a contractor, pitching for specific projects which you could deliver to a timescale but on which you worked at your own convenience? I had a roster of people who could for example handle a specific amount of date processing , the task was what was paid for, not how long or when they performed it.

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2022 11:28

seramum · 03/08/2022 11:02

@Iamthewombat

It's this part that I was picking up on: "role. So I don’t recommend this strategy for the OP."

For you, it's not something that's going to work, but for the OP it might. We don't know what job role or industry she is in. Both myself and at least one other poster here have found it a useful way of getting 0.8 part time roles. So it can and does work, particularly if the OP does find an otherwise perfect role that she might consider going FT on. If she applied, being prepared to work FT if necessary but asks the Q, she might well find that she doesn't need to work FT, Not all employers are as inflexible as you, thank goodness.

Likewise, I interviewed someone myself recently, they also made some specific requests, but as they were otherwise perfect for the job, we offered it and met the requests of the person. We didn't get what we advertised for, but we got something much better!

I can see that you are desperate to convince me that what you did was acceptable, which you seem to be very sensitive about, but I’d recommend that you give up.

Dotjones · 03/08/2022 11:08

Unfortunately employers who claim to be flexible rarely are. Part timers are generally seen as less committed to the role and to the company so a lack of progression isn't seen as a problem. In a previous company we weren't allowed to hire part timers, no ifs or buts (regardless of the legality lol) because the MD wanted people who were 100% focused on their job. By definition a part timer is less committed because they are not willing and/or able to commit to a full time role.

In most companies to go part time you have to demonstrate that you have been able to be a good full time employee for a few years first. Generally once you go part time your progression stops though - that's why a lot of people prefer to prioritise their career over other commitments like family until they've reached a point in their career where they are happy to stay at indefinitely.

seramum · 03/08/2022 11:02

@Iamthewombat

It's this part that I was picking up on: "role. So I don’t recommend this strategy for the OP."

For you, it's not something that's going to work, but for the OP it might. We don't know what job role or industry she is in. Both myself and at least one other poster here have found it a useful way of getting 0.8 part time roles. So it can and does work, particularly if the OP does find an otherwise perfect role that she might consider going FT on. If she applied, being prepared to work FT if necessary but asks the Q, she might well find that she doesn't need to work FT, Not all employers are as inflexible as you, thank goodness.

Likewise, I interviewed someone myself recently, they also made some specific requests, but as they were otherwise perfect for the job, we offered it and met the requests of the person. We didn't get what we advertised for, but we got something much better!

Franca123 · 03/08/2022 10:58

Apply for new jobs. When a company is really keen on you, tell them you want part time / job share.

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2022 10:52

seramum · 03/08/2022 10:35

@Iamthewombat

"Not a chance. I was really annoyed that she and the recruiter had wasted my time. I wouldn’t see that candidate again for any type of role. So I don’t recommend this strategy for the OP."

Surely that depends on whether the candidate was prepared to work FT. I was, but it was my preference not to, if that could be accommodated. I made that clear in my interview, that whilst my preference was for part time, if I felt the job was otherwise perfect, I would be prepared to go full time. I think sometimes interviewees forget you're interviewing the company to see whether you want to work there as much as you're being interviewed for the job. I've turned down a couple of jobs because on interview, I didn't like the interviewer, what they were telling me, or didn't think I'd be a good fit for the company. (nothing to do with the part time issue, btw).

Anyone can turn down any kind of job offer, for their own reasons. But that’s not what I was talking about.

If I advertise a senior finance role that is full time, and the job description clearly states that it is full time, and I brief the recruiters that I won’t consider part time because of the breadth of responsibility and volume of work involved in the role, then I’m justified in being annoyed at having wasted time reviewing and scoring the CV of, and interviewing, a candidate who is not willing to comply with the requirements of the role. Which she wasn’t, in the example I gave.

Perhaps she thought that she’d dazzle me so much that I’d say, yes, I’m prepared to have 60% of somebody (or a 50% time commitment if she’d got her 2.5 compressed days wish). Which is ridiculous. Even if she had been brilliant, I couldn’t accommodate that working pattern in a finance team run off their feet, and her deceitful behaviour, and willingness to waste my time, made me question whether she was somebody that I’d want working for me.

Polimolly · 03/08/2022 10:47

If you really want to focus on your career progression, do put your children into childcare. They will get used to it very quickly. That's what I did and I've never regretted it

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2022 10:39

Part timers are viewed as flakey and not committed to their job.

Yes, they are. I’m not saying that that is right, or fair, but that is the way things are. So the OP needs to work within the system if she wants her career to progress. @CharlesIsQueensHorcrux spells out her options concisely.

I agree with PPs who say that if more men worked part time, perceptions might change. Unfortunately at the moment part time working is either (1) mums (overwhelmingly, rather than dads) working around children, who are perceived as likely to leave at the drop of a hat in childcare crises/sickness/etc., or to be militant about their hours and unlikely to stay to help sort out problems against a deadline or (2) older people winding down before retirement, who are perceived as having been put out to pasture and aren’t considered for the interesting and visible projects.

Swipe left for the next trending thread