Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel part time workers get a raw deal when it comes to progression

139 replies

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 02/08/2022 22:35

I went part time after I had my first baby, my employer that I have been with for nearly 10 years wouldn't let me reduce my hours in the current role where I had a small team I managed, so I had to take the only position available in a different department, not managerial but same pay, pro rata'd.

I have since not had any opportunities to use previous transferable skills, promotions or go back to managing, job sharing will not be considered with other part time members. Even when I have been putting in extra hours and taking on additional work and responsibilities.

So I thought Id look outside the company, there are barely any part time roles available that aren't entry level, most are MW. Ive contacted local recruitment agencies and searched online.

My options seem to be stay in a job with no progression or recognition or take something on less pay at entry level with the hope there may be a chance to progress eventually.

My AIBU is to think there doesn't seem to be any decent opportunities for someone willing to work hard with good experience or am I just doing something wrong?

OP posts:
Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 19:49

I really do think if the attitude towards part time working changed it would help but I can also see where it can be difficult to work with.

I see comments like this a lot, about changing attitudes. I'm not so sure. I am a feminist and I care enormously about supporting women to remain in the workplace. I benefitted from flexible working myself - although I never went part time - and my natural inclination is to support flexible working requests and to say yes, of course, we'll find a way of making it work. Earlier in my career, I was absolutely of the view that people just needed to be more open minded about it. Unfortunately, it is through the experience that I have had as a result of supporting multiple requests over the years that I'm now much more cautious, because I'm afraid I have been burned. I absolutely want to support people - men or women - in my team to balance their work lives and their domestic responsibilities, but I also want to balance my own life. My organisation doesn't have the resources to throw money at the problem, so I know that some part time requests can only be supported if I or another member of staff pick up the slack.

I don't know what the answer is. Maybe a shorter working week for everyone?!

brookstar · 03/08/2022 19:40

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 19:34

I was just thinking that it does mostly affect women and its because like me, we are the ones to take a back seat after having children, but also if both parents were to equally cut back to part time working and take equal parenting roles, then both would be impacted in their careers and only full time people with no kids or kids in childcare for most of the week/older kids would develop professionally and be prioritised for promotions etc.

Still not sure what the answer is!

Actually, if more men worked part time and worked flexible hours so they could be more equal parents then I think we'd find that part time workers would progress their careers.

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 19:34

I was just thinking that it does mostly affect women and its because like me, we are the ones to take a back seat after having children, but also if both parents were to equally cut back to part time working and take equal parenting roles, then both would be impacted in their careers and only full time people with no kids or kids in childcare for most of the week/older kids would develop professionally and be prioritised for promotions etc.

Still not sure what the answer is!

OP posts:
shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 19:30

No need to apologise, its been fascinating reading the opinions from different situations and the thought process over what works for different businesses.

I really do think if the attitude towards part time working changed it would help but I can also see where it can be difficult to work with.

Its definitely made me think about my situation and what options I have!

OP posts:
MerlinsButler · 03/08/2022 19:13

@shouldbesleepingnotscrolling just wanted to say sorry for hijacking your thread. It's a really pertinent issue which as always seems to penalise women more so thanks for starting this thread.

I hope you manage to find a role that allows you the flexibility.

MerlinsButler · 03/08/2022 19:11

Phineyj · 03/08/2022 18:43

Thanks @Phineyj this is actually really relevant for us as we are a consultancy. And yes - clients are the problem re part timers as they will just ring the mobiles.

MerlinsButler · 03/08/2022 19:09

GeekyThings · 03/08/2022 18:24

@MerlinsButler I've seen it managed in various ways, and usually contractors work the best on small contracts with tight turnaround times because they're able to increase or decrease hours as and when. But obviously there's no guarantee they'll stay, or even be available at the time, so it's always risky!

Some of the smaller contracts where I work at the moment have people on part-time hours, but they're actually full-time staff - they just get redeployed for their other hours onto larger contracts to fill in the gaps. So I would imagine you could possibly have a bank of full-time staff who can jump from project to project to pick up and help out when required.

But even then, you still end up with a scenario where the full-time staff end up working harder and gaining more experience and knowledge more quickly the part-time staff, meaning they're just more likely to progress overall. I don't really see how that can be avoided when most people who work, work full-time hours.

@GeekyThings yes that's kind of how it works at the moment. Contractors are great but always an issue if they have other work / aren't available. We tend to work on a monthly basis for projects so as one completed you move on to the next but as you say - this still benefits the full timers. It's a tough one. It is awkward as our projects are such tight turnaround / deadlines.

MermaidSwimming99 · 03/08/2022 18:46

I’ve worked with P/T team leaders they each had their own team but worked 4days however each one covered the others non-work day. Normally a Monday or Friday so team meetings were usually on a Tuesday or Wednesday not a Monday. It’s worked well especially as different people bring different skill sets & perspectives. In other situations I’ve seen mums work 25 hrs spread over 5 days etc. it can be done but this is in civil service or government funded organisations.

seramum · 03/08/2022 18:44

@Iamthewombat

"No, you could easily have wasted their time for your own selfish ends. I wouldn’t consider that acceptable, for the reasons I’ve already explained."

Please read my post again. I already said in the post, I was prepared to work full time, if I could not get part time. However, I preferred part time if I could get it.
Part time works better for me and my employer, because it allows me to manage my child's medical condition / disability without needing time off work. For me to work full time, employers have to give me lots of parental leave to manage all the hospital appointments. Hence they're usually prepared for me to work part time.

Phineyj · 03/08/2022 18:42

There's a really fascinating book that touches on this that I read earlier this year. I will see if I can find a link. It was American so didn't fully transfer to the UK labour market, but the gist of the author's research findings was that the more perfectly the worker could be substituted by another, the more likely they were to be able to work part time/the hours of their choice etc.

So if you are e.g. a vet then you are likely to be able to negotiate the pay and hours you want, whereas if you are in business or consultancy, you're not, because the client wants to speak to "Sarah" and not Ms A.N. Other.

I thought it translated quite well to teaching because teachers are assumed to be equally competent once qualified (even if in reality your mileage may vary).

I found it interesting though as it suggested that in some situations being too niche could work against you.

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 18:32

It's the price of them getting my skill set, which is in short supply currently.

I think this gets to the nub of it, really.

There is a price to be paid when you employ part time staff, and employers will make an assessment of the relative costs vs benefits of supporting such arrangements which will be different in each case.

Where the employee has valuable skills that are in short supply, the employer is likely to conclude that the inconvenience or costs associated with having a part time member of staff are worth it because of what the employee brings to the organisation.

Where a full time member of staff with similar skills can be sourced quite easily, then the employer doesn't feel the need to compromise and might prefer not to employ a part time member of staff who will be able to offer less flexibility/availability than a full time employee.

So if you want to progress in a part time role, the secret is to make yourself so valuable to your employer that they will do whatever they can to keep you.

GeekyThings · 03/08/2022 18:24

@MerlinsButler I've seen it managed in various ways, and usually contractors work the best on small contracts with tight turnaround times because they're able to increase or decrease hours as and when. But obviously there's no guarantee they'll stay, or even be available at the time, so it's always risky!

Some of the smaller contracts where I work at the moment have people on part-time hours, but they're actually full-time staff - they just get redeployed for their other hours onto larger contracts to fill in the gaps. So I would imagine you could possibly have a bank of full-time staff who can jump from project to project to pick up and help out when required.

But even then, you still end up with a scenario where the full-time staff end up working harder and gaining more experience and knowledge more quickly the part-time staff, meaning they're just more likely to progress overall. I don't really see how that can be avoided when most people who work, work full-time hours.

AprilRae91 · 03/08/2022 18:24

Most senior roles require more of a presence due to the responsibility lasting the whole week, unless a jobshare situation can be arranged

bumpytrumpy · 03/08/2022 18:17

TheYearOfSmallThings · 03/08/2022 15:17

I’ve found that if you go to a job interview and hint at needing some flexibility with working hours most employers find a reason not to hire you.

I also notice more and more jobs are advertised as 8:30 to 5:00 or 9 to 5:30, or anything other than 9-5, gently signalling that anyone with childcare responsibilities need not apply.

I've found the total opposite. I've taken the tactic of applying for FT roles and asking for PT at the end of the interview. 100% success rate at roles between 40 & 70k over last 10 yrs, always worked 0.6 or 0.8.

MerlinsButler · 03/08/2022 18:02

This thread actually raises some interesting points. I'm currently investigating how we staff a new team to expand our offering. On paper you would think the roles would be ideally suited to females (or males) who wanted a more flexible approach to a role. I.e fully remote with occasional face to face meetings required, interesting work, flexible hours / variety of options re hours etc. options for progression - if wanted. but. In reality. The work is project based with tight deadlines (just the nature of the industry).

It would be hard to have someone who only worked say 0.5 or 0.6 FTE as we would have to have a shadow for each employee so double costs - which I'm not sure the Board would approve. Plus the non-standard work hours etc make it unlikely to happen.

It's frustrating but if anyone has any ideas of how it works in their companies or best practice I'd love to hear them. At the moment we rely on contractors who can be allocated specific projects but that has its own issues e.g availability.

GeekyThings · 03/08/2022 17:59

@Anothernamechangeplease I really agree with your posts on this thread, they match my experience too.

Also after being on the other side of the situation (co-working with, and working under various people on part-time hours) I have to say I think the roles where part-time hours work well with the rest of the staff don't tend to be ones where you can be progressed into line management very easily. It needs to be something that can either be left or picked up quite easily by others when the part-time worker isn't there - and I've never really seen that work well in senior management. I've seen it being coped with because that was the arrangement made, but usually it's only the person doing the part-time role who seems to think it's working out. Most of the time it's been other, lower down team members picking up the slack, and they don't necessarily agree with that assessment!

Phineyj · 03/08/2022 17:58

I've found the solution is sideways moves. I'm on my third... that way I get some interest and novelty and a pay rise without needing to do the full time then drop back to part time thing. Or become part of the wallpaper.

OP - I think you need to network rather than waiting for jobs to be advertised.

I'm pretty flexible. I've worked pt hours across 4 days and 5 days, checked emails on the days I don't work, volunteered to lead things and do things, organised (and sometimes paid for) my own training etc.

But I still detect a strong sense that my employers think they're doing me a favour.

I'm sorry, but they're not. The alternative for me of PT is doing something different, freelancing or not working at all. It's the price of them getting my skill set, which is in short supply currently.

I have lasted over a decade now as a teacher because I know what I can handle on top of the other things going on in my life - and it's not 60 hours a week in termtime!

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 17:43

Thatsenoughnow · 03/08/2022 16:54

*I agree that flexibility on both sides can be beneficial, and that good will on both sides is invaluable. I myself have benefited from flexibility with regard to working patterns, but took a similar approach in terms of being contactable during non-work times in order to make that feasible.

Unfortunately, in my experience, a lot of part time staff can't or don't want to open up that option. In my experience, this has generally meant me as their manager picking stuff up in their absence.*

If a full time member of staff was on annual leave, would you expect them to be available on their non working hours? Would you begrudge having to pick up their work? The issue isn't the part time staff member. It's the way they're managed. You need to find better solutions to manage the work. They can only do what they can do, in the hours they're there. Outside of that, it isn't and shouldn't be made their problem.

I guess this reflects the lack of respect for part timers and that's kind of what op is talking about. The attitude seems to be that it's ok to go part time as long as you are still willing to work on your non contracted time, because you need to be seen to be working as much as your full time colleagues even though you have less time to do it in. But there's no expectation that a full time member of staff should be available on non work time, or if there is they'll usually be paid accordingly with a higher salary or a disturbance allowance or similar.

Not at all, I certainly don't expect PT workers to do stuff on their non-working days. I was responding to a pp who knew someone who had made it work that way.

I agree that the PT member of staff can only do what they can do in the hours that they're paid for, and that it isn't their problem outside of those hours. However, just because it isn't their problem doesn't mean that it isn't a problem, and it is partly this problem that gets in the way of part time staff being able to progress as quickly as they like. The organisation typically has to invest in an expensive job share or the PT worker's line manager ends up sucking it up themselves. This isn't always feasible or desirable, and so the organisation may decide that more senior posts are better undertaken by full time staff.

I think we need to be honest about this.... there are trade-offs on both sides. For a really talented worker with exceptional skills that would be hard to match, most employers will bend over backwards to be accommodating of their desired working patterns because retaining an excellent member of staff is the top priority - I have done this myself, knowing that the extra burden will land on me as the manager. For a fairly average member of staff, it might not be worth the hassle and I would be less prepared to suck it up because I have my own work life balance to think about as well.

Goodskin46 · 03/08/2022 16:58

But always, always shared childcare responsibilities. When I was at work I was at work IYSWIM.

Goodskin46 · 03/08/2022 16:55

FWIW I have done ft, pt, ft, pt and ft again. DCs are 18 &15 I am 46 and just moved into a £150,000 position, so got there in the end.

Thatsenoughnow · 03/08/2022 16:54

*I agree that flexibility on both sides can be beneficial, and that good will on both sides is invaluable. I myself have benefited from flexibility with regard to working patterns, but took a similar approach in terms of being contactable during non-work times in order to make that feasible.

Unfortunately, in my experience, a lot of part time staff can't or don't want to open up that option. In my experience, this has generally meant me as their manager picking stuff up in their absence.*

If a full time member of staff was on annual leave, would you expect them to be available on their non working hours? Would you begrudge having to pick up their work? The issue isn't the part time staff member. It's the way they're managed. You need to find better solutions to manage the work. They can only do what they can do, in the hours they're there. Outside of that, it isn't and shouldn't be made their problem.

I guess this reflects the lack of respect for part timers and that's kind of what op is talking about. The attitude seems to be that it's ok to go part time as long as you are still willing to work on your non contracted time, because you need to be seen to be working as much as your full time colleagues even though you have less time to do it in. But there's no expectation that a full time member of staff should be available on non work time, or if there is they'll usually be paid accordingly with a higher salary or a disturbance allowance or similar.

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2022 16:43

seramum · 03/08/2022 12:03

@Iamthewombat

"I can see that you are desperate to convince me that what you did was acceptable, which you seem to be very sensitive about, but I’d recommend that you give up."

It clearly was acceptable, and even accepted, as I've already said, I was offered two jobs this way. So at least two employers think it's acceptable as they have accepted it. Like I said, it's a good job not everyone is as narrow minded as you, as others have testified it can be a good way of getting part time work. I know plenty of people who have done it. I've had two great jobs out of it. and two very happy employers.

No, you could easily have wasted their time for your own selfish ends. I wouldn’t consider that acceptable, for the reasons I’ve already explained.

incidentally, if this is how you behave at work - personalising things, calling anyone who disagrees with you ‘narrow minded’ - I’m surprised that anyone antsnto offer you a job.

Goodskin46 · 03/08/2022 15:57

seramum · 03/08/2022 12:07

@brookstar

"That's part of the problem though.... why should one person be the primary contact for childcare emergencies? Why isn't that shared between parents?"

Totally agree with this. I have older children, but one has health condition / disability, which makes it difficult for me to work full time. My agreement with DH is that I have one day off to manage all the routine appointments, but DH does all the emergency stuff. He can work from home, I can't. So if DD gets sick (which she does, a lot) he picks up on the short notice stuff. His employer and mine have always known this is the score from the outset, and both have been happy with that: it does need to be shared imo.

This is critical from day one after maternity leave. Sick days need to be split 50:50, drop offs, pick ups regardless of part time status. In fact arguably if you are part time you need to be more " on it" as much less slack is cut.

NothingIsWrong · 03/08/2022 15:54

I got my last job part time that was advertised as full time. However, I made it clear in the interview that I was doing 4 days over 5, so I was available every day, that I expected it to be for 18 months max (children progressing to secondary school) and that my husband was generally the school emergency contact due to proximity. I was offered 30 hours, and 18 months later I've just done a flexible working request to go back to full time from this September. Not expecting it to be refused to be honest!

Swipe left for the next trending thread