Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel part time workers get a raw deal when it comes to progression

139 replies

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 02/08/2022 22:35

I went part time after I had my first baby, my employer that I have been with for nearly 10 years wouldn't let me reduce my hours in the current role where I had a small team I managed, so I had to take the only position available in a different department, not managerial but same pay, pro rata'd.

I have since not had any opportunities to use previous transferable skills, promotions or go back to managing, job sharing will not be considered with other part time members. Even when I have been putting in extra hours and taking on additional work and responsibilities.

So I thought Id look outside the company, there are barely any part time roles available that aren't entry level, most are MW. Ive contacted local recruitment agencies and searched online.

My options seem to be stay in a job with no progression or recognition or take something on less pay at entry level with the hope there may be a chance to progress eventually.

My AIBU is to think there doesn't seem to be any decent opportunities for someone willing to work hard with good experience or am I just doing something wrong?

OP posts:
Goodskin46 · 03/08/2022 21:33

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 21:26

I do think there's a fundamental thing you have to accept if you want career progression in most careers though OP, and that's that you just cannot do enough hours if you aren't using any wraparound care.

Or you can, especially if you have a very short commute, only if your DH/DP is willing to step up fully and share half of the load.

This when I went ft DC were 8 and 11. I did 9-3 Monday & Thursday. 7:30-5:30 on the other days.

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 21:26

I do think there's a fundamental thing you have to accept if you want career progression in most careers though OP, and that's that you just cannot do enough hours if you aren't using any wraparound care.

Or you can, especially if you have a very short commute, only if your DH/DP is willing to step up fully and share half of the load.

rainbowmilk · 03/08/2022 21:26

cheveux · 03/08/2022 08:45

It can be very difficult having part time managers for junior staff. I work in a company that’s very big on promoting women into senior positions, which means a lot of them are mothers who work part time. I think the ones who work 80% of full time hours are fine, but the senior PM on my current project only works 3 days a week, and one of those is short hours. Our work is entirely client-based, so when she’s not working if the client has a massive problem or needs something urgently, the rest of the team have to make senior-level decisions in her absence or involve other staff who are not working on the project to approve budget changes etc. which is pretty rubbish. I think there are some instances where part time working doesn’t fit with the actual job.

100% agree. It’s especially unfair when - as in my place - the additional pay is justified on the basis of the person having the responsibility of making those decisions. I’ve lost count of how many decisions I’ve had to make which are above my pay grade because basically all of the female managers either work very part time, or are ostensibly full time but flex their hours to the extent that they’re barely there during the day.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 03/08/2022 21:25

Yes that is the deal.

Part timers clean up the ends.

InChocolateWeTrust · 03/08/2022 21:24

I do think there's a fundamental thing you have to accept if you want career progression in most careers though OP, and that's that you just cannot do enough hours if you aren't using any wraparound care. Allowing 30 min travel time to get to & from work & a 30 min lunch break, only leaves about 4.5 hours.

I'm always amazed on mumsnet how many people have a perspective that after school care is unusual. Where I live (affluent south east commuter belt) it's a given that you can't really have a professional senior job without using wraparound at least 2-3 days a week.

NewIdeasToday · 03/08/2022 21:21

I think part of the issue is clock watching/ hours worked.

In my team I need people who will work hard at busy periods. And this does involve additional hours at times.

With a part timer who is very strictly working say 24 hours per week, where would this flexibility at peak times come from? Would others be expected to pick this up while the part timer leaves? The answer is Yes of course.

InChocolateWeTrust · 03/08/2022 21:11

It is about simply not being there when needed

I've progressed as a 4 day a weeker partly because when there's a 5 day a week deadline, I don't expect it to wait a day for me when I'm off.

I find ways to make that one crucial 20 min call, respond to that urgent email with a critical question. It's not often, but I respect the times when I have to rearrange other things to prioritise the job.

Our family dynamic also isnt that I'm the part timer so my job gets low priority - when it's my busy season, DH knows he has to be the one to cover the kids illness etc.

thecatsthecats · 03/08/2022 21:08

MolliciousIntent · 02/08/2022 22:37

Generally speaking, part timers in senior level roles start full time and then cut down. You usually have to put in the legwork to prove yourself at that level before you get to reap the rewards (IE going part time).

That, or going freelance.

I'm following in the footsteps of a few of my friends who've worked their skills up to a point where we can sell our time in day long chunks.

We're working in a small network who do skill sharing, giving each other backdoor support for free in our specialisms. Best of both worlds in many ways.

Rainyday4321 · 03/08/2022 21:05

Threads like this leave me wondering where where people get career advice from… (mumsnet obvs)

Without knowing your role/ industry/ career aspirations a few things seem fairly obvious from a distance- and were clear to me aged 23/24 in my second job

80% of an FTE is usually manageable and doesn’t massively hinder progression
70% is tricky
60% and you will be seen as job rather than career mindset.

most senior jobs don’t lend themselves to managing pick up/ drop offs every day/ most days

the more senior you are pre kids the better from a career perspective. Yes there is the odd exception - but it really is the exception

The school day in the UK is bonkers from a working parent perspective. what’s the point of finishing at 3 and only having 30/45 mins for lunch? Much more sensible to have a longer lunch break, with lots of playing/ clubs and a later finish time. Lots of countries do this btw.

Regardless of that, after school clubs are fine a few days a week.

there is more to life than careers- but you can’t have it all..if career progression is important to you- and it doesn’t have to be- but if it is then something has to give on the part time front.

Paigeworkerx · 03/08/2022 20:51

If you husband works 4 days can you not work 4 days as well. You both have different days off and that would mean you’d need childcare on 3 days? Or you could do 3 long days again 1 day being your husbands day off, kids in childcare 2 days.

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 20:41

I guess its not just about having an efficient hand over process, its about not being physically there when required.

Yes, for me, that's often what it boils down to. I can only speak for myself, but it definitely isn't a value judgement on my part about someone's commitment, skill or worth. It's simply a practical thing based on someone not being available as much.

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 20:36

Im just as committed and focused when Im at work, if not more so now because Im in for a limited time. Also because I like being able to focus and use my brain to achieve something!

I do see how it can be hard to work around different schedules and make decisions if the team members are not in on a day that needs it. I guess its not just about having an efficient hand over process, its about not being physically there when required.

This discussion has definitely given some good perspectives.

OP posts:
Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 20:35

user1487194234 · 03/08/2022 20:29

I went part time when I had my family were born
While I worked hard no way was I as committed as I was before I had my children

I think that shift can occur in full time workers as well. People's priorities can change when their personal circumstances change. I would never make assumptions about how committed people were on the basis of how many hours they worked - I have had some incredibly committed part time staff who have given 100% during the time they they're there.

It isn't really about my perception of their commitment. It's more about the practical stuff - their availability, the proportion of their time that would be taken up by stuff, continuity when they aren't there etc.

Merryoldgoat · 03/08/2022 20:32

It depends entirely on your job and sector. I’m no high flyer but earn a decent salary over 3 days. I’ve been given progression, projects and responsibilities and my manager and I work closely together.

However I’m an accountant working as a finance manager and it’s a job that lends itself to part time work very well - no shortage of well paid senior positions.

user1487194234 · 03/08/2022 20:29

I went part time when I had my family were born
While I worked hard no way was I as committed as I was before I had my children

TheGoodDoctorTheSecond · 03/08/2022 20:28

Not the case for my organisation, one particular part time employee is worth their weight in gold. Massive contributor in the work place. Promoted and rewarded appropriately including both pay and investment in training.

InChocolateWeTrust · 03/08/2022 20:26

I'm 80% FTE and haven't had trouble progressing.

I do think if you work 60% or under it's harder. You are less visible, less available to take on projects that require more commitment. Its much easier to apply for a full time role, prove yourself at that level and then gradually reduce hours.

Testina · 03/08/2022 20:24

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 20:05

The attitudes I was talking about is how part time workers end up with the mundane responsibilities and are not included in decisions or given work/projects to increase workplace exposure because “they are just part time,” which results in demotivation and the cycle of attitudes that part timers are ‘flaky’

In my large corporate environment, that doesn’t happen “just because they’re part time” - it happens because they’re not available when they’re needed - because they’re part time.

We have 2 female board members on a job share 3 days each (one crossover day which really makes it work). We have a lot of 4 day senior managers.

In my experience, it works well at the lower level of responsibility (where people can be substituted as the work is less complex with no decision making) and at higher levels where the decisions are generally not same day - as they’re strategic, not operational.

In that middle level, we find it’s trickier to have someone less than 4 days. In some roles (mine) less than 5 is a pain - I have to make a lot of quick decisions based on lots of information and my experience. My team do the same job as me (with a different portfolio) so absolutely have the skill set to do my job - but it’s so much slower when you cover because you just don’t have the short term history that enables quick decisions. We never have part time in our team.

I often see part timers promoted here - but almost always promoted as they move into full time.

I want to champion anything that helps women - but in my experience it isn’t just an incorrect attitude to part time working. In a company that really supports it, we see that there are plenty of roles where it just doesn’t work well.

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 20:21

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 20:05

The attitudes I was talking about is how part time workers end up with the mundane responsibilities and are not included in decisions or given work/projects to increase workplace exposure because “they are just part time,” which results in demotivation and the cycle of attitudes that part timers are ‘flaky’

Yes, I get that, and I do try very hard to give people fair opportunities.

However, being really honest about it, if there is an important high profile project, I want to be sure that it's going to succeed. I don't want to have to tie myself in knots having to organise meetings around a billion different part time working patterns. I want to know that the people I assign to the project will be available to deal with any issues as and when they arise, without stuff automatically defaulting back to me when they're not here. And I want to know that the person it is assigned to will be able to make sufficient time for the work without having to drop everything else that they do.

As far as decision-making is concerned, I absolutely try to ensure that management meetings are organised to be as inclusive as possible, but if you have multiple people with part time hours or other flexible working arrangements, it is sometimes the best you can do to alternate days so that everyone gets to attend sometimes. And yes, you can share paperwork in advance so that people have opportunities to feed in their views, but sometimes things come up that you can't pre-empt, and decisions do have to be made in the moment. If that means that some people aren't around to be a part of those decisions, it's just the way it is... the workplace can't stand still just because it's someone's non-work day. It's the same when full time staff are off on leave etc - sometimes decisions will be made in your absence and you have to suck it up.

Of course, some organisations are crap and they treat their PT staff like second class citizens. That isn't right. But sometimes PT staff can be unreasonable too. I have had PT staff complain about meetings that have been organised without them, but it simply isn't possible to accommodate them every time alongside the commitments of others who need to attend the meeting. Sometimes the needs of the organisation have to come first.

Hardbackwriter · 03/08/2022 20:11

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 19:34

I was just thinking that it does mostly affect women and its because like me, we are the ones to take a back seat after having children, but also if both parents were to equally cut back to part time working and take equal parenting roles, then both would be impacted in their careers and only full time people with no kids or kids in childcare for most of the week/older kids would develop professionally and be prioritised for promotions etc.

Still not sure what the answer is!

We're a couple who both work part-time and I've found it helps a lot because each of you is less part-time if that makes sense. I work 0.9 (compressed into four days) and DH works 0.8, so we only need three days of childcare, and we've both been promoted since doing this. As a few pp have said, four days seems to be the point at which it doesn't impact too much on other people so you don't get as limited - the downside is that it's hard not to end up doing a full-time job for less pay when you're that close to full-time.

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 20:10

StripeyDeckchair · 03/08/2022 19:52

But you can't have everything.

If I work full time for 5 years and you work 3 days a week part time for 5 years I will have 2 years more experience than you, which is likely to mean I have more skills and more to offer an employer.
The cost to me? I've paid out more in childcare & seen less of my kids.

The more senior you are the more likely it is that you manage a team of people, have to participate in management meetings, maybe run projects, have specific skills. All these are 5 days week thing 2 or 3 days is just not enough.

I definitely agree with this that you cannot have everything, as you said ft workers sacrifice time with their kids and money in childcare and so will become more skilled quicker than a pt.

My point is that as pt, I cant seem to get anywhere at all. Ive been with the company so long and trained new members of staff and watched them all get promoted into other teams and move on. I do a substantial amount of the work because of my experience on the team but that is as far as I can go as pt.

OP posts:
shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 20:05

The attitudes I was talking about is how part time workers end up with the mundane responsibilities and are not included in decisions or given work/projects to increase workplace exposure because “they are just part time,” which results in demotivation and the cycle of attitudes that part timers are ‘flaky’

OP posts:
yellowcarpetflair · 03/08/2022 19:58

Meltingsocks · 03/08/2022 08:17

Easiest solution is for DH to a stint at part time, you get a new full time role with progression. Why have you allowed only your career to a take a hit?

This. If one of you has to be part time, make sure it's not always you.

StripeyDeckchair · 03/08/2022 19:52

But you can't have everything.

If I work full time for 5 years and you work 3 days a week part time for 5 years I will have 2 years more experience than you, which is likely to mean I have more skills and more to offer an employer.
The cost to me? I've paid out more in childcare & seen less of my kids.

The more senior you are the more likely it is that you manage a team of people, have to participate in management meetings, maybe run projects, have specific skills. All these are 5 days week thing 2 or 3 days is just not enough.

seramum · 03/08/2022 19:51

"I don't know what the answer is. Maybe a shorter working week for everyone?!"

There's a big govt trial for that at the moment.

amp.theguardian.com/business/2022/jun/06/thousands-workers-worlds-biggest-trial-four-day-week