Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel part time workers get a raw deal when it comes to progression

139 replies

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 02/08/2022 22:35

I went part time after I had my first baby, my employer that I have been with for nearly 10 years wouldn't let me reduce my hours in the current role where I had a small team I managed, so I had to take the only position available in a different department, not managerial but same pay, pro rata'd.

I have since not had any opportunities to use previous transferable skills, promotions or go back to managing, job sharing will not be considered with other part time members. Even when I have been putting in extra hours and taking on additional work and responsibilities.

So I thought Id look outside the company, there are barely any part time roles available that aren't entry level, most are MW. Ive contacted local recruitment agencies and searched online.

My options seem to be stay in a job with no progression or recognition or take something on less pay at entry level with the hope there may be a chance to progress eventually.

My AIBU is to think there doesn't seem to be any decent opportunities for someone willing to work hard with good experience or am I just doing something wrong?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GeekyThings · 04/08/2022 17:13

@CharlesIsQueensHorcrux I think this is part of the issue really - a large company, where everyone is on the same compressed contracted hours, can work; but I know from experience that on smaller contracts, if it's less than half the people doing compressed hours or flexible working, it can be less than ideal for the staff not working on that kind of contract.

For example at the moment my company offers something similar to this, but the take up is small, meaning it's usually 1 or 2 people on a team of 6 or 7 doing it; and for cover, working at three sites, that's actually really difficult to organise without penalising the other staff for not doing it.

I'm of the opinion it really needs to be across the board, or not at all, because logistically it's a headache, and for the other staff members it does mean they have to cover, including more office time, which isn't really fair.

CharlesIsQueensHorcrux · 04/08/2022 13:30

Interestingly at BP all staff used to work compressed hours to create a nine day fortnight (every other Friday off, 50% each week) - this ended around 2005 but it’s interesting to see what a huge company can manage

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 04/08/2022 11:30

After DC1 was born I went part time and did a senior-ish role as a jobshare. After DC2 was born, I used this experience to secure a job of my "own" at this grade, P/T within the same organisation. That baby is now nearly 11, I moved from 3-4 days a week when she started school, and am currently on a 12 month assignment on a higher grade. I'm applying for permanent jobs at this grade, and am now in a position to work full time if necessary - although I'd argue for a 9 day fortnight.

Augend23 · 04/08/2022 08:52

Goodskin46 · 04/08/2022 07:41

So in summary;
You can have some flexibility and a couple of early finishes (but need to start early/finish late at other times)
Or
You can do 0.8
Or
Compressed hours

And still be perceived as committed and as good as ft
But you can only probably do one of the above and need someone else picking up the slack on your "on" time.

I'd agree with this.

From a personal point of view: I would like to, and can afford to, go part time. But I don't. Why? Because if I go to 4 days a week I'll be doing a full time job for 80% of the pay. And if I go 3 days I week I'll be too inconvenient to promote.

I think a 9 day fortnight of compressed hours might be feasible.

Goodskin46 · 04/08/2022 08:48

Also consider a nursery near work rather than near home.

Rainyday4321 · 04/08/2022 08:42

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 21:40

Unfortunately where I am, I have a 45 min commute and the business Im in only want me in during core hours so not very flexible. Id still have to leave at 5pm in the dot to pick up DS and Im not actually sure the nursery stays open past 5pm! I think maybe when both kids are in school it would be more feasible to increase hours.

When mine were very little I had an hours commute. I left 7.30, got in 8.30, and DH managed drop off at the childminders.
I left at 5 on the dot and picked up at 6.
fridays I didn’t work, but would do the odd call
it was knackering and hard work and no I didn’t see the kids as much as I would have liked.

but career was important to me and it did pay off in that sense.

Rainyday4321 · 04/08/2022 08:27

Thatsenoughnow · 03/08/2022 21:39

My kids school only offers after school clubs 2 days a week and they finish at 4p.m, if you can even get in. Mine were on the waiting list the entirety of the last school year. Childminders near me cater mainly for babies and preschoolers. If you can access affordable, high quality afterschool childcare then you're in a very privileged position.

This is why being more senior pre kids make ma it easier- more likely to be able to chuck money at the problem.
nanny/ au pair/ student who can do a few hours

I have a colleague who kept a full
time nanny/ housekeeper til the kids were teenagers.

if you are stuck with your wage not being higher than the cost of chlldcare- or you aren’t willing to invest in childcare then it is very hard.

Seeing childcare costs as an investment vs a cost is difficult I know. And that’s before the question of whether it is a household cost or a womens cost.

brookstar · 04/08/2022 08:17

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 22:22

How do people make it work when kids go to school and work full time?

I know I wouldnt be able to do do it even with wrap around care (my kids current school/nursery dont provide enough to cover with my the commute and only working core hours).

Wraparound care, flexible hours and making sure DH does his fair share of drop offs/pick ups.
It also helps that we can both wfh and I get quite a bit of flexibility during holidays.

sittingonacornflake · 04/08/2022 08:06

@Schooldil3ma I think you've nailed it. Some PT hours at my firm are so inconsistent I have no idea when certain people are in as every day presents a different working pattern.

I work .8 and have just dropped a day but I'll happily log in if required for an important meeting or something on my NWD but I'll just take the time back with a longer lunch or something another day, in a way that doesn't impact the business and I hope that no one notices.

Schooldil3ma · 04/08/2022 08:02

@Goodskin46 I think you're about right. People accept "I don't work Mondays" or "I finish at 4 every day".

When folk start talking about "I'm not available after 3pm and I work alternate Wednesdays and a half day on a Friday" eyes glaze over and I'd personally start looking for another contact to liaise with.

It would probably work for a truly stand alone role, but anything that relies on collaboration or communication not so much. Equally it could work for a "task and finish" job like answering the phone in a call centre. But anything strategic or senior needs a more present presence.

Goodskin46 · 04/08/2022 07:41

So in summary;
You can have some flexibility and a couple of early finishes (but need to start early/finish late at other times)
Or
You can do 0.8
Or
Compressed hours

And still be perceived as committed and as good as ft
But you can only probably do one of the above and need someone else picking up the slack on your "on" time.

user159 · 04/08/2022 07:05

I've found in my industry .8 is usually accepted without much fuss but anything below that and it's seen as you just want a job now and not a career - even if that's not true.

Schooldil3ma · 04/08/2022 06:53

I established myself I my role then requested part time. I wonder if perhaps the difference is the sort of hours you want? It seems to work better in my organisation if you do 3 standard or slightly longer days, rather than 5 very short ones to work around school. Your OP said you were hoping to avoid using wraparound so maybe that's part of the issue?

NothingIsWrong · 04/08/2022 06:43

Goodskin46 · 03/08/2022 21:33

This when I went ft DC were 8 and 11. I did 9-3 Monday & Thursday. 7:30-5:30 on the other days.

This is almost exactly my working pattern (except Tue/Fri short days) - I use full wraparound for 3 days and then WFH and do the school runs on 2 days. It's tiring but it works well - I do often answer my phone out of my hours, but there are one or two things that I am literally the only person in the business who can do them, as I have a very niche skill set for the role I'm in.

moimichme · 04/08/2022 06:21

Interesting discussion here OP. In my case, it's the other way round - I'm the higher earner and work ft, and I only took 6 months maternity so my DH could have 6 months parental leave with our baby - we both wanted that arrangement and financially it made more sense. But he was one of the first men in his large organisation to do it.

We then both worked ft and ds went to a lovely childminder for a couple of years, and now I've been promoted and we can afford DH to work 3 days a week (wfh - which is a huge help for us) so we only need 3 days school wraparound care for ds. DH works for a large employer and has a job where the skillset overlaps well with others'. So when he's off work, someone else can easily take over with minimal issues for the business - like you, he works hard and is very good at his job.

But if DH wanted to prioritise his career progression, now ds is in primary school, it'd be harder for us as a family. We have all benefited from DH's pt hours (he does more domestic labour than me overall, and especially during my busy periods) and his ability to easily cover some ds sick days. And juggling our holiday time to cover the weeks of summer holidays has also been easier. It's not a perfect or permanent solution, but I hope we can manage this way for at least a few years.

I did help one of my .4 pt colleagues receive a promotion which she wasn't even going to apply for - but our role is quite niche so the institution needs her/pt hours for that task. If working 4 days a week for ALL proves feasible, I really hope more employers will do it, and remove some of the stigma and lack of advancement opportunities. But I guess it depends a lot on the business needs, too.

Goodskin46 · 04/08/2022 02:01

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 22:27

How do people make it work when kids go to school and work full time?

I know I wouldnt be able to do do it even with wrap around care (my kids current school/nursery dont provide enough to cover with my the commute and only working core hours).

If you have a partner then you share it. As others have said either flex each end of the day or through the week (I do Mondays, you do tuesdays).

Some quid pro quo with other parents and pay for an afterschool nanny for more flexibility.But ultimately if you want to progress with your career you cannot be soley responsible for the childcare.

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2022 23:52

seramum · 03/08/2022 18:44

@Iamthewombat

"No, you could easily have wasted their time for your own selfish ends. I wouldn’t consider that acceptable, for the reasons I’ve already explained."

Please read my post again. I already said in the post, I was prepared to work full time, if I could not get part time. However, I preferred part time if I could get it.
Part time works better for me and my employer, because it allows me to manage my child's medical condition / disability without needing time off work. For me to work full time, employers have to give me lots of parental leave to manage all the hospital appointments. Hence they're usually prepared for me to work part time.

I’ve read enough from you, thanks. How can I convey more clearly how uninterested I am in reading more?

When I wrote, this morning, that you should give up on trying to convince me that it was acceptable to apply for a full time job and then announce at the end of the interview that you wanted to be part time, what do you think I meant? And yet, here you are, still going and still tagging me in your posts. With a bonus drip feed.

Anothernamechangeplease · 03/08/2022 22:27

DH and I both worked flexible hours to manage the pick-ups and drop-offs between us. I worked very locally and was in a senior role, so I had a lot of control over my diary. Dh was self employed, so was in total control of what he did. Typically, one of us would start early and finish early, the other would start and finish late. One would do the morning drop off and the other would do the pick up. We didn't use any wrap around care, but dd was naturally a bit of a joiner and used to sign up for extracurricular clubs offered by the school, so that often helped.

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 22:27

How do people make it work when kids go to school and work full time?

I know I wouldnt be able to do do it even with wrap around care (my kids current school/nursery dont provide enough to cover with my the commute and only working core hours).

OP posts:
shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 22:22

How do people make it work when kids go to school and work full time?

I know I wouldnt be able to do do it even with wrap around care (my kids current school/nursery dont provide enough to cover with my the commute and only working core hours).

OP posts:
MermaidSwimming99 · 03/08/2022 22:13

It does get harder when they are in those early years of primary school there are more holidays and sickness to cover along with random inset days compared to nursery wrap around 50wks of the year school is 39weeks.

DSGR · 03/08/2022 22:08

Everything you say is true and it’s why I’ve always worked FT. I just make it work. But I do have a DH who does 50% with the kids and at home

brookstar · 03/08/2022 22:02

Actually, you tend to have much less flexibility when they start school. Nurseries tend to be open all year round and for longer hours. The school holidays can be tough to cover.

I found it far more challenging when DS started school

shouldbesleepingnotscrolling · 03/08/2022 21:40

Unfortunately where I am, I have a 45 min commute and the business Im in only want me in during core hours so not very flexible. Id still have to leave at 5pm in the dot to pick up DS and Im not actually sure the nursery stays open past 5pm! I think maybe when both kids are in school it would be more feasible to increase hours.

OP posts:
Thatsenoughnow · 03/08/2022 21:39

Rainyday4321 · 03/08/2022 21:05

Threads like this leave me wondering where where people get career advice from… (mumsnet obvs)

Without knowing your role/ industry/ career aspirations a few things seem fairly obvious from a distance- and were clear to me aged 23/24 in my second job

80% of an FTE is usually manageable and doesn’t massively hinder progression
70% is tricky
60% and you will be seen as job rather than career mindset.

most senior jobs don’t lend themselves to managing pick up/ drop offs every day/ most days

the more senior you are pre kids the better from a career perspective. Yes there is the odd exception - but it really is the exception

The school day in the UK is bonkers from a working parent perspective. what’s the point of finishing at 3 and only having 30/45 mins for lunch? Much more sensible to have a longer lunch break, with lots of playing/ clubs and a later finish time. Lots of countries do this btw.

Regardless of that, after school clubs are fine a few days a week.

there is more to life than careers- but you can’t have it all..if career progression is important to you- and it doesn’t have to be- but if it is then something has to give on the part time front.

My kids school only offers after school clubs 2 days a week and they finish at 4p.m, if you can even get in. Mine were on the waiting list the entirety of the last school year. Childminders near me cater mainly for babies and preschoolers. If you can access affordable, high quality afterschool childcare then you're in a very privileged position.

Swipe left for the next trending thread