Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be annoyed and remove this painting?

118 replies

linslime · 02/08/2022 22:23

friend is an artist (not for money or anything, but she went to art college and enjoys dabbling when she has time around the kids) and for my birthday last month gave me a beautiful painting.

Bro and newish girlfriend were round for dinner recently and she said ‘oh I saw that painting at [art related event] and considered buying it’. I said ‘oh I didn’t buy it, friend painted it for me’ and she looked at me strangely and said oh maybe I’m mistaken etc.

when they left I googled a few key words plus our city and found the REAL artist. Friend has copied the artist’s painting pretty much brushstroke by brushstroke and passed it off as her own. I did consider that maybe she bought the painting from this artist and pretended she’d painted it but on close examination it’s not exactly the same. But a clear copy. She’s signed the corner etc.

i don’t know why I’m so annoyed. I think because I felt like an idiot in front of visitors who knew the original existed yet I insisted ‘no no that’s my friend’s work’. If she’d told me she’d copied it I would still be a bit ‘hmm’ but at least I would know.

AIBU to not want it hanging in my lounge?

OP posts:
BeanieTeen · 03/08/2022 08:48

Maybe she thought you’d know it was a copy? I agree it’s a bit of an odd thing to do as a gift - if someone gave me their own drawn copy of a Picasso or something yeah that would be weird I think. But maybe she’s just quirky like that. If your DB’s girlfriend recognised it maybe it’s a more recognisable painting than you realised. If she’d copied something more obvious like a Monet or the Mona Lisa you might be somewhat confused - but would you really be so offended?

impostersong · 03/08/2022 08:46

I'm learning to paint and practice different styles by copying artists. I have also gifted these paintings as I've been proud of them, I choose paintings of things that mean something to the recipient. A lot of time and love goes into them. Never thought to tell them the painting is copied. They aren't snobby enough to care.

Sirius3030 · 03/08/2022 08:44

Go to any artist’s stall in SE Asia and you will find a hand painted Mona Lisa. Or a Warhol. Or a Dali. Plenty of them now hanging on Home County walls. No big deal.

Darlissima · 03/08/2022 08:40

It’s fine for an amateur to copy other works as a practice piece for their own benefit. It’s more complicated if they then want to display or sell the work or (as in this case) give it away. Strictly she should have asked permission from the artist and she should have credited her. (Copyright applies as the artist is still alive.)

That said. making a single copy of a painting and giving it away isn’t the copyright infringement of the century and your friend may not have known what was required. It sounds as if the real issue is your embarrassment in front of your brother’s new girlfriend

sheildmaiden · 03/08/2022 08:40

It's lovely that she painted something that had meaning for the both of you and she obviously put a lot of work into it and for that reason I would leave it up considering how much you love it, but to not personalise it even a little bit is a bit odd. I paint and will get inspiration from other artists work, but I wouldn't out right copy it, I'd put my own spin on it and would tell people I was inspired by X by artist Y.
It's not wrong for her to copy it, Unless she was copying it and making a profit for it.

Strugglingtodomybest · 03/08/2022 08:39

I agree with the poster who said you're just embarrassed at getting caught out not knowing that it wasn't the original.

I'd get over that and think about how much time and effort went into your present, and how much you were enjoying before you found out the truth.

It's a beautiful present and you're very lucky to have a friend who would give you it.

Discovereads · 03/08/2022 08:35

darlingdodo · 03/08/2022 08:18

Just out of interest, how do people feel about artists such as Damien Hirst having a whole team of people actually producing 'his' art so signed by 'Damien Hirst', but in reality the concept may be his but the actual piece is produced by someone else entirely.

A lot of artists did this. Usually the art would then be ‘School of artists name’
Artists would take on apprentices/journeymen who’d “rough in” large parts of paintings/frescos/sculptures and the master artist would do the composition, layout, initial sketches and final touches (expression, hands, folds of clothing, etc).

Mamapep · 03/08/2022 08:32

She gave it to you, you like the painting.
She didn’t sell it to you under false pretences. You’re massively overreacting.

cansu · 03/08/2022 08:32

She signed it so it isn't forging anything. She has done something beautiful. I would just be happy actually. Who cares whether it is original??

Sunshineona · 03/08/2022 08:28

notanicepersonapparently · 02/08/2022 23:03

It's absolutely not normal for artists to copy others work except for practice to improve their technique. Most galleries would not accept such work for sale or exhibition. The copy should be signed as ,'after T Smith (being the original artists name). I can understand why you are disappointed op.

This. It may be normal to copy work for PRACTICE but it is NOT normal to discuss the work with others without acknowledging that it’s a copy, and signing it her own name was not ok. It is very weird to given it to you as a gift and have a whole discussion about it without mentioning that it’s a copy. I guess she gave it as a gift because she knew she couldn’t sell it.

Sounds to me like she was enjoying your admiration and fell into fantasy land. Bit weird. I’d be quite cautious of her!

MargaretThursday · 03/08/2022 08:25

If I decided to copy a picture, it would look nothing like the original, so she's clearly talented.

Why does it matter that she's used a picture for inspiration? She still painted it for you as a place that had meaning.

ClaireEclair · 03/08/2022 08:25

I don’t see what the problem is. My cousin is an artist and when she was learning she copied a lot of work. We have some of it but didn’t know the artists so would never have known they were copies. My aunt has her copy of a very famous painting hanging in her house. It’s never even crossed my mind to be annoyed or embarrassed.

Pibble · 03/08/2022 08:21

darlingdodo- that would be a more normal practice that I have heard of, but then theres a big difference between conceptual art and a painting

darlingdodo · 03/08/2022 08:18

Just out of interest, how do people feel about artists such as Damien Hirst having a whole team of people actually producing 'his' art so signed by 'Damien Hirst', but in reality the concept may be his but the actual piece is produced by someone else entirely.

SquirrelFan · 03/08/2022 08:07

I don't know, I'd be a little disappointed too. No art background here, so I didn't realise how common it is amongst artists to copy, but it would still take the shine off. I think if the original artist's work is that recognisable, your friend should have told you that it is a copy /homage, only to save you embarrassment.
Suppose someone had sewn the OP an extremely good copy of a Chanel jacket? OP would be very embarrassed if another friend pointed out it was a fake.

OverrunWithPigeons · 03/08/2022 08:06

I think it's a lovely gift that took time and effort. Would you prefer a Bodyshop gift set?

Discovereads · 03/08/2022 08:06

ImustLearn2Cook · 03/08/2022 07:51

This is very true. In art college you are expected to or assigned paintings to copy and learn from.

A friend of mine did an amazing job painting the Mona Lisa and I was very impressed. They showed a great deal of skill and put a lot of time into it.

Is it possible that your friend assumed that you knew of this practice?

Or maybe she assumed that you would still like it, appreciate her effort and skill (It’s not like it’s a tracing or a photocopy or a paint by number). It actually does require skill to re create another artist’s painting.

Maybe she did think you would appreciate that it is a painting of a meaningful place and that it wouldn’t bother you that it’s copied off this other artist’s painting.

She actually painted it. It’s not like she bought the original and painted over the original artist’s name so she could sign her own name on it.

Exactly. My first degree was in Art. Did tons of drawings and paintings that were copies all to learn different skills/styles, and how different artists used colour, light, space, shadow, movement, layering, etc. It can be harder to copy another artist than to do your own version.

You always sign your own name. You only have to reference the original if you are planning to sell or exhibit the work in a commercial gallery.

Some artists even have huge fan followings, like the late Bob Ross where they all copy his work and deliberately paint in his style.

Pibble · 03/08/2022 08:06

I have a degree in art and have never known anyone to make a like for like copy of another artists painting, it sounds a very odd thing to do to me! I vaguely remember people doing that at GCSE level but not since then.... it sounds like it is a thoughtful gift that you like so I wouldnt over think it in this case however

Whitehorsegirl · 03/08/2022 08:02

As a painter myself I would be seriously annoyed if someone just pretty much copied my work and then gave to someone else to display. At least she is not selling it because then the original artist would have a claim for plagiarism.

I think it is fine when you are learning to paint to copy historical paintings for example to understand the techniques but to just rip off a contemporary piece and to give it to someone to display without letting them know it is almost an identical copy of somebody else's work is a bit dodgy.

I would not display a painting like that I my home sorry. She meant well but you are also right to be annoyed.

Doingmybest12 · 03/08/2022 08:00

Doingmybest12 · 03/08/2022 07:54

This, you felt silly in front of your friends.
Perhaps your artist friend thought you'd know the original picture. I would enjoy the picture and be pleased I have something lovely on my wall

If she had asked you to pay for it when you didn't know ,that would be a different story but it was a gift.

Arrivederla · 03/08/2022 07:58

For goodness sake - what a massive drama over nothing op. 🙄

ItsSnowJokes · 03/08/2022 07:58

You sound like a snobby twat to be honest. Your friend made you a lovely gift and you are getting all precious about it now. Either give it back to your friend or hang it in pride of place like it was before.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/08/2022 07:57

It’s still her own work, whether a copy or not.
Artists have been copying each other’s work for centuries. She signed her own name - it’s not as if she was pretending it was by the original artist.

I agree, she could have said it was a copy of X by Y though.

Beachbabe1 · 03/08/2022 07:55

Who really cares! It's the thought that counts!

southlondonerhere · 03/08/2022 07:54

Is it not possible that she worked from a photo and the other artist worked from the same photo? I got an original painting done for my sister a while back, I sent the artist a photo of what I wanted (bluebell woods) and quite some time after I saw a painting of exactly the same thing, I thought 'that's the painting I got my sister!!' But it was actually just a painting by someone else who obviously worked from the same photo