Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be annoyed and remove this painting?

118 replies

linslime · 02/08/2022 22:23

friend is an artist (not for money or anything, but she went to art college and enjoys dabbling when she has time around the kids) and for my birthday last month gave me a beautiful painting.

Bro and newish girlfriend were round for dinner recently and she said ‘oh I saw that painting at [art related event] and considered buying it’. I said ‘oh I didn’t buy it, friend painted it for me’ and she looked at me strangely and said oh maybe I’m mistaken etc.

when they left I googled a few key words plus our city and found the REAL artist. Friend has copied the artist’s painting pretty much brushstroke by brushstroke and passed it off as her own. I did consider that maybe she bought the painting from this artist and pretended she’d painted it but on close examination it’s not exactly the same. But a clear copy. She’s signed the corner etc.

i don’t know why I’m so annoyed. I think because I felt like an idiot in front of visitors who knew the original existed yet I insisted ‘no no that’s my friend’s work’. If she’d told me she’d copied it I would still be a bit ‘hmm’ but at least I would know.

AIBU to not want it hanging in my lounge?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
phishy · 03/08/2022 22:06

You sound very entitled, OP.

What thoughtful, hand made gifts do you give to her I wonder,

Ccoffee · 03/08/2022 21:55

You're ungrateful. I used to be an artist - I wouldn't have copied another artist's work when I was selling and had work on-line and in galleries.

Now, when I don't sell or put things online, yes I would consider doing it for a friend's gift. Painting is expensive and time-consuming both to do the actual painting and come up with original ideas. It takes a lot of the strain out if you are just copying something, and she sounds like she is in a position where she is short of time and wants to just enjoy painting.

Producing art is work, she just did something to make it feel a bit less like work. She still spent money and considerable time and thought in producing it.

Have you ever spent hours in producing something for her birthday?

MissShapesMissStakes · 03/08/2022 21:22

@excellentday - I totally agree with that.

I like to paint but really struggle with my own ideas/inspiration. I love to copy other artist's work.

It's somewhere that means something to you, it's a style of painting you like, and she spent a lot of time and effort to make it. Not to mentioned the expense of materials.

Enjoy it as a thoughtful gift. Which is what it is.

excellentday · 03/08/2022 15:29

Amateur artists copy other artists though. Unless she is a professional and copying stuff and selling it as her own unique work, I really can't see the issue.

I expect she saw the original painting, thought you'd like it and so painted it, signed it and gave it to you.

Not sure at all how that is odd.

linslime · 03/08/2022 15:02

Hobbesmanc · 03/08/2022 10:00

In an earlier post you said you'd met the original artist at a local event? Maybe your friend just assumed you'd appreciate a tribute to an artist you admired? Seems strange though if you have met them and liked their work, that you didn't recognise the style?

I don’t/ didn’t know the original artist’s work, I met her at an event for another artist

OP posts:
pinkyredrose · 03/08/2022 14:34

Sunshineona · 03/08/2022 08:28

This. It may be normal to copy work for PRACTICE but it is NOT normal to discuss the work with others without acknowledging that it’s a copy, and signing it her own name was not ok. It is very weird to given it to you as a gift and have a whole discussion about it without mentioning that it’s a copy. I guess she gave it as a gift because she knew she couldn’t sell it.

Sounds to me like she was enjoying your admiration and fell into fantasy land. Bit weird. I’d be quite cautious of her!

Fantasy land? Cautious? Wtf?

HeckyPeck · 03/08/2022 14:02

Hobbesmanc · 03/08/2022 10:00

In an earlier post you said you'd met the original artist at a local event? Maybe your friend just assumed you'd appreciate a tribute to an artist you admired? Seems strange though if you have met them and liked their work, that you didn't recognise the style?

I was thinking this too.

Itsincidental · 03/08/2022 13:56

OP I understand why you felt embarrassed after what your visitors said.

But you loved the painting and your friend did it for you.

Even van Gogh copied things apparently!

www.dailyartmagazine.com/van-gogh-copy/

Merryweather80 · 03/08/2022 13:42

This is perfectly normal. How do you think artists learn new techniques and grow into new mediums? By copying, and learning the style of the brushstrokes.

You are totally overthinking this.

It would have taken many hours and a lot of expensive materials to make this picture, which was done with you in mind.

You sound very ungrateful and not a good friend.

Hobbesmanc · 03/08/2022 10:00

In an earlier post you said you'd met the original artist at a local event? Maybe your friend just assumed you'd appreciate a tribute to an artist you admired? Seems strange though if you have met them and liked their work, that you didn't recognise the style?

cockandball · 03/08/2022 09:57

It takes an awful lot of skill to replicate a painting. No doubt saved you hundreds of pounds. It's not a rip off, it's a work in its own right is how the art world works

DancingUnderTheLights · 03/08/2022 09:46

I think people are being a bit unfair to the OP. I can see how if you thought it was an original piece then finding out it was a copy could take some of the specialness away from it. I do think the friend should have mentioned it was a copy. It's still a really nice thing to do and to put the time in to create it etc.

Treetops292 · 03/08/2022 09:44

YADNBU I'd feel the same.

hewouldwouldnthe · 03/08/2022 09:39

Don't be silly, it's a painting you love and others admire. It a totally reasonable thing for an artist to do. Being able to copy another artist also takes considerable skill and artistry. Painting from a photo could also be considered 'cheating'.

I was asked to copy a painting on a poster for a potential client, but she rejected my offer when I said I was a digital artist, saying she wants oils or acrylics. I did point out to her the original painting was actually a digital painting and the artist was also a digital artist. Didn't hear from her again. Lots of snobbery in the artworld.

Enjoy your painting.

Valeriekat · 03/08/2022 09:25

linslime · 02/08/2022 22:58

there sort of was. Not about her inspiration etc but when I said oh wow I love it, it’s perfect coming from you (it’s of a local place we spent a lot of time at as students) she said something like ‘yes I knew you’d love it because of our memories there’.

i didn’t realise copying and passing off as your own was normal for artists

It isn't!
She really should have told you if it was a copy of another artists work. Intellectual property and copyright violation is a big issue in the arts world and she would have known that even if it wasnt done for profit.
You will have to ask her I suppose.

Darlissima · 03/08/2022 09:22

@Discovereads Sorry, but this isn't right (or rather, it's right but it doesn't relate to what I said). Section 107 deals with criminal liability only. No one is suggesting that OP's friend has committed a crime. Copyright infringement is also a civil matter- the relevant section of the act is s. 16

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/section/16

(To be clear, I'm not suggesting it's a huge deal or that the artist would have any interest in pursuing this- very hard for her to show any loss, for one thing. But it is a copyright infringement.)

LizzieSiddal · 03/08/2022 09:12

OP I often paint birthday cards for my friends and family. None of them are “original”, I follow You Tube demonstrations, which have tens of thousands of views, should I tell people I copied these paintings every time I send them?

StoppinBy · 03/08/2022 09:11

Would it bother you if she had painted it from someone else's photo?

In my mind, that's the same thing, she saw something she knew you would like because of the place it is and used it as inspiration and made you something you loved.

Let the idea of it not being original and thus 'ruined' go and enjoy it for what it is, a friend who spent time making you something you love.

Discovereads · 03/08/2022 09:09

Strictly she should have asked permission from the artist and she should have credited her

Nope, she did not need a copyright license to make a copy for private use. No copyright infringement happened IAW the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988:

“107 Criminal liability for making or dealing with infringing articles, &c

(1) A person commits an offence who, without the licence of the copyright owner--
(a) makes for sale or hire, or

(b) imports into the United Kingdom otherwise than for his private and domestic use, or

(c) possesses in the course of a business with a view to committing any act infringing the copyright, or

(d) in the course of a business--
i) sells or lets for hire, or
ii)offers or exposes for sale or hire, or
iii) exhibits in public, or
iv) distributes, or

(e) affect prejudicially the owner of the copyright, distributes otherwise than in the course of a business to such an extent as to an article which is, and which he knows or has reason to believe is, an infringing copy of a copyright work.

(2) A person commits an offence who--
(a) makes an article specifically designed or adapted for making copies of a particular copyright work, or

(b) has such an article in his possession,
knowing or having reason to believe that it is to be used to make infringing copies for sale or hire or for use in the course of a business.

(2A) A person (“P”) who infringes copyright in a work by communicating the work to the public commits an offence if P—
(a) knows or has reason to believe that P is infringing copyright in the work, and (b) either—
(i) intends to make a gain for P or another person, or
(ii) knows or has reason to believe that communicating the work to the public will cause loss to the owner of the copyright, or will expose the owner of the copyright to a risk of loss.

(2B)For the purposes of subsection (2A)— (a) “gain” and “loss”—
(i) extend only to gain or loss in money, and
(ii) include any such gain or loss whether temporary or permanent, and
(b) “loss” includes a loss by not getting what one might get.

IamnotSethRogan · 03/08/2022 09:04

I mean it sounds like she saw this painting of a place you loved and thought you would love a picture like that and put a lot of time and effort into recreating it

SurfBox · 03/08/2022 09:04

*I'd either give it back to her (on the grounds above) or destroy it.

I am very uncomfortable with blatant plagiarism*

oh ffs have you got any friends left? You aren't actually serious are you? Suppose you disown friends who eat LIDL versions of Cornflakes as it ain't the real thing?

BellePeppa · 03/08/2022 08:58

I do think she should have at least said she used the other artist’s work as inspiration rather than making no mention. A bit like sampling music from another artist and having the decency to acknowledge it.

UniBallEye · 03/08/2022 08:57

Op I understand why this has taken the shine off a bit.
While it's fairly normal for students or amateur artists to copy grand masters ro learn technique etc it's really not OK to take work by a living contemporary artists & make a direct copy without being upfront about it.
I have a family member who is a very well established artist & regularly has people making copies or using their artwork to make money & it's massively irritating. There's not a lot they can do about it but it certainly bothers them

There is a world of difference between someone making a copy of the Mona Lisa or a Monet and someone copying a local established artist who is currently selling work to make a living.

Beefcurtains79 · 03/08/2022 08:57

I’d be a bit embarrassed to have a blatant copy in my house, I’d also think she was a bit strange by not admitting it and pretending it was all her own work from her imagination.

pinkyredrose · 03/08/2022 08:57

yes I know she painted it, but it's a fake

It's not a fake, it's a copy.