Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ever ok to start tidying someone else's house without being asked. I think it's bloody ride

139 replies

Hoorhhuudde · 02/08/2022 20:35

It's a MIL one.
We have two under fives and our house is in the process of being sorted out for our expected third baby. It's clean. I did the hoovering, mopped the floors etc before the in-laws came to visit. It's tidy in the way a toddler filled house can be. It's not minimalist retiree tidy.

MIL has never coped well with being a guest. Hovers round me asking to help. I tell her we have a small kitchen, I know where everything is and I don't need help. DH reinforces that we don't do too many cooks in the kitchen because it hinders, doesn't help and we have this rule even when it's just me and him.

Anyway, hovering commenced whilst I was trying to dish up family meal, with all the various meal preferences and extra faff that guests tend to bring. Politely sent MIL out of kitchen. DH putting out cutlery etc in living room.

Come in and she's 'tidying' the kids toys. I have SEN children so stations of things we use daily like mood boards etc. Swept into random places. It wasn't the type of thing where there was an obvious toy box and she was just putting them back. It was like she had deemed it not tidy enough and was implementing her own random system. And it was really random. It actually looked worse than when she started.
I've just spent ten minutes searching out things from random places. Am I being unreasonable here? Is this normal guest behaviour?
For context I wouldn't tidy up in someone's house unprompted but I'd get my kids and I to help when tidying was happening or offer if an appropriate time.

Yabu- yes it's normal to do impromptu tidying
Yanbu- that's a bit weird

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 02/08/2022 22:49

Hoorhhuudde · 02/08/2022 21:01

We don't iron things.
She's allowed to: play with the kids, chat, drink tea, read, watch telly.

I don't think it's unreasonable to expect guests to entertain themselves whilst I'm dishing up.
And yes, I have to dish up because we don't have the room or the props for a help yourself scenario. She dishes up when we go to hers. Probably for the same reason. My portions are plentiful, we allow people to leave food and ask for seconds.

Allowed?

As opposed to 'welcome to'?

HintofVintagePink · 02/08/2022 22:49

I love it when my mum comes to visit us for exactly this reason. She just cracks on and does what she can see needs doing. For the two/three days she’s here my life runs so much better!

justfiveminutes · 02/08/2022 22:44

Yikes I can see that suggesting you wouldn't mind if it was your own mum has already been done a lot and was not well received. Sorry!

justfiveminutes · 02/08/2022 22:42

I think lots of us do the little helpful jobs that we wish someone had done for us when we had a young family and were hosting.

I doubt she is trying to upset you, and I doubt you'd be this upset with your own mum. When you know she's coming, have a job ready. If it's a genuine help to you then it's worth ten seconds of thinking time.

godmum56 · 02/08/2022 22:40

Hoorhhuudde · 02/08/2022 20:44

I don't see why I should have to provide fake jobs for grown adults who should be able to read the situation and listen to what is being said.
It's enough faff getting the five year old to load the bloody dishwasher.

I also wouldn't mind if it was actually tidying. But she literally just moved stuff around and hid daily needed things.

well obvs what she is doing is annoying you...you can continue to be annoyed, or blow up and experience the consequences, or try something that might help.....your choice really.

Pallisers · 02/08/2022 22:38

Especially when historically I've cleaned the bathroom etc before they visit and then she asks to clean it on day one. Feels like a comment.

of course it is a comment.

All those saying MILs can't do right etc. are you ignoring the people on the thread who said their own mothers do this and it drives me crazy. I really do love my mil - call her more than dh does and have an independent relationship with her that is very loving. But this thing of insisting on being in the kitchen drove me up the walls. It is astonishing to me how women are expected to just put up with whatever someone else wants to impose on them and they are rude and ungrateful if they don't just give in. I was very unselfish and generous in many ways with mil and I'm sure OP is too. Just this one effing thing of not helping in the kitchen every dinner or cleaning your house. why is it so hard?

When my kids have places and partners of their own I will ask what I should do, I will read the room to see if it is a polite ah no need or a genuine one, will check in with my own child if I'm in doubt and then I will either help or sit and do whatever they'd prefer me to do because it isn't all about me.

Kona84 · 02/08/2022 22:34

I hate this, I have a friend who looked after our house for 2 days. I expected she would clean her dishes, maybe empty the bin.
but she had cleaned the house top to bottom.
i had to text her for weeks asking if she remembered where she had moved things to.
she had reorganised my kitchen so much that I didn’t want to cook in it as it didn’t flow how I liked

SummerDays2020 · 02/08/2022 22:31

Begoniasforever · 02/08/2022 21:05

Oh right, you missed that out from your op. Big thing to forget. How come you focused on tidying Toys?

No, she didn't. She mentioned mood boards etc. that they have in stations to use every day.

Hoorhhuudde · 02/08/2022 22:30

925XX · 02/08/2022 22:19

God lord she was trying to help as your have 2 kids and another one on the way. You would be writing a thread complaining that " she never offers to help" if she didn't tidy. Some people can not do right no matter what!

I really really wouldn't. In an ideal world. I'd like guests to relax and be guests, enjoy the break.

I'm also of the opinion that I'm a grown adult who has a husband that pulls.his weight and kids that are learning to tidy their own things. We manage fine without guests rescuing us. It's unnecessary. We're not living in piles of fag ash like the poster above. It's a normal household with children. No SOS required.

OP posts:
AngelinaFibres · 02/08/2022 22:23

Soontobe60 · 02/08/2022 20:45

I always tidy up when I go to my DDs houses 😂😂😂
I also often cook them dinner, do the laundry, a spot of gardening, pick up their food shop, look after their children.
When they come over to mine, they revert to teenage behaviour - empty the fridge, change the TV channel, argue and take the piss out of me and DH. It’s called ‘family life’.

Ah but you are the mother of DDs and therefore perfect in the eyes of MN. Mothers in law are not regarded in the same way.

D0lphine · 02/08/2022 22:19

Yes I have once cleaned a friends flat without her asking. I was staying over for a few days and she had popped out to a doctors appointment for a couple of hours so I was left chilling in the flat.

In my defence it was absolutely revolting. Every dish and pan was dirty, rubbish and recycling on the floor. Piles of fag ends in ash trays. It. Was. Vile.

She was going through a heavy depressive episode at the time. Didn't help that her flat was tiny.

I did the basics- I took the rubbish and recycling out, washed dried and put away the dishes and put all the dirty clothes into the laundry bin. I could have spent all weekend cleaning.

She didn't seem fussed either way that I had done it (depressed).

In your case, I don't think your MIL should have cleared up. Maybe give her a childcare activity to do- tell her to entertain the kids or read them a story.

925XX · 02/08/2022 22:19

God lord she was trying to help as your have 2 kids and another one on the way. You would be writing a thread complaining that " she never offers to help" if she didn't tidy. Some people can not do right no matter what!

PussInBin20 · 02/08/2022 22:10

My DMUM does this and to me it is a criticism. Like her way is right and mine isn’t. I said this to my DH today after she left. She wouldn’t do it in anyone else’s home, but mine she thinks this is ok. It really gets my goat.

Yesterday I was hanging my washing out and she was redoing it the other end! Then later she came rushing upstairs in a panic as she had turned off my DH’s computer by mistake after trying to turn off my coffee maker. I told her “that will teach you for tidying up”. She has no reason to do any “tidying” at all. I don’t expect (or want it) and never ask- she just feels she has the right to. But why? She would hate it if I did the same at hers.

On Sunday throughout lunch I got several items out ready to use and she had put them all away before I had the chance! So annoying.

hiredandsqueak · 02/08/2022 22:10

I think she probably means well. I know for a fact my adult son and daughter leave stuff knowing I'm popping over because they know I will sort it. They are both always delighted when I go and clean at theirs whilst they are away with work or on holiday. I never do anything as a criticism of them, I do it so that it's one less thing for them to do. I'd harness the MIL, have a loaded basket of ironing (as dd does) or similar so that you have something for her to do when she asks.

youkiddingme · 02/08/2022 22:07

I'd swap her for my MIL who would sit and expect to be waited on (ham sandwiches on the right kind of bread and no crusts type of thing), and complain vocally if she wasn't, even when she turned up the day I came home from hospital with a newborn and a nether end full of stitches. I trained her eventually, but it took years.

Hoorhhuudde · 02/08/2022 22:01

Tasmanium · 02/08/2022 21:52

@Hoorhhuudde I completely get why this be so irritating for you, but if I had to take a wild guess what was going on with her- I’d guess she was quite a traditional mum when your husband was growing up and that cleaning, tidying and helping out was what women did for each other as a matter of course while at each other’s houses.

I grew up around what you might term traditional women, a lot of full time house wives and when a relative or a neighbour arrives with husband the women would buzz about together in the kitchen or wherever catching up, doing food/drink prep, tidying if needed - just anything housey. The men would probably catch up in the other room, and keep an eye on the children or play with them a bit or whatever. This was seen as one of the benefits of having a close friend or family member over, your domain was their domain and they usually knew what they doing, because that’s effectively their full time job and they are good at it!

Now I’m making a massive assumption that this applies to your MiL, but it does sound like she doesn’t know what to do with herself and is just anxiously going into this mode as a way of connecting with you.

I mean it’s sort of pretty retro and sexist, but from a socialising perspective it makes a lot of sense in a way. In days gone by, guests playing with and entertaining children certainly happened, but it wasn’t assumed to be a central role of guests really for any longer than a few minutes at a time, adults socialised with adults, and children just sort of slotted in with that. So socially, it made more sense for the women to be in kitchen together and men to be in the living room. That way husband and wives who see each other all time weren’t trying to make polite conversation in the living room with each other, or trying to get a sensible conversation out of 6 year olds for half an hour or more while the hosts were absent making the food or whatever.

What I’m getting at is there’s a good chance she’s not being at all rude as far as she’s concerned, and even your little protest that no help is needed would be a classic thing to do in the context where it would be absolutely expected.

Could you try it that way and maybe take control of the food prep, or drink prep and get her to be sous chef rather than your husband? It might help things flow better, even if it’s still slightly annoying. It can be a really nice way to catch up informally with someone too. I do this with my MiL and my DM, and even though they are from different cultures both of them sort of expect it. It’s one of the ways they get to share their expertise as well, which they maybe don’t get to do so much of when children are grown and very few people are SAHP.

There's probably a lot of truth to that, although I do think the pointed comments are meant as a comment on the way we run things too.

It's sadly not a sous chef situation. It's a tiny kitchen and DH doesn't go in it whilst I am cooking. She doesn't know where anything is so a quick job like setting the table becomes an absolute faff.
Id hope she'd just be proud DH pulls his weight and helps out by setting the table. She does it all at theirs and fil just sits there.
Will get DH to ask her to assist maybe, but I honestly don't think it will fill whatever need she has to do this.
But it does feel rude. Especially when historically I've cleaned the bathroom etc before they visit and then she asks to clean it on day one. Feels like a comment.

OP posts:
A580Hojas · 02/08/2022 22:00

"I agree MILs just can’t win."

Of course they can. Just open their ears to what their dc are asking of them as guests. It's not difficult.

My Mum is someone who can't sit still and was a random tidier and forever asking for a job to do "so I can help you darling". Quite sweet but ultimately more work than just occupying herself and the gc.

CookPassBabtridge · 02/08/2022 22:00

@Begoniasforever Um you know I was replying to another poster, right? 😂

Soontobe60 · 02/08/2022 21:56

Hoorhhuudde · 02/08/2022 20:48

Presumably they haven't asked you to stop?
I think this is quite a different situation. This in no way helped but added an extra, putting things back to their right places, job for me.
So I had to make dinner.
Serve dinner.
Retrieve the tidied items.
Actually tidy.

Not helpful.

The let her make dinner instead!

knackeredagain · 02/08/2022 21:56

My SIL used to do this and it made me feel really shit. She cleaned and tidied my cutlery drawer once, wiped inside my microwave, cleaned under DS bed. I just felt really inadequate, even though I’m sure she was trying to help.

Hoorhhuudde · 02/08/2022 21:55

The point is that finding a job will lead to more work or faff for me.
Ironing, I'd have to get it all out and then it'd take up all the space for the kids and fil(who manages to entertain himself)

Sewing, find stuff that needs sewing. Space.

Bedroom. Feels invasive and I'd have to make sure it was mil friendly.

Dusting. Doesn't need dusting. Had cleaned.

It's a fake job in that I'd be creating it for her to be busy. If there was something she could.do.to be helpful I'd give it, but the logistics of our house mean that there's not endless space for setting up jobs.

OP posts:
Tasmanium · 02/08/2022 21:52

Hoorhhuudde · 02/08/2022 21:12

Because the kids stuff is the stuff Sen will find difficult to cope with.
My stuff, annoying, baffling, but won't cause a meltdown.

@Hoorhhuudde I completely get why this be so irritating for you, but if I had to take a wild guess what was going on with her- I’d guess she was quite a traditional mum when your husband was growing up and that cleaning, tidying and helping out was what women did for each other as a matter of course while at each other’s houses.

I grew up around what you might term traditional women, a lot of full time house wives and when a relative or a neighbour arrives with husband the women would buzz about together in the kitchen or wherever catching up, doing food/drink prep, tidying if needed - just anything housey. The men would probably catch up in the other room, and keep an eye on the children or play with them a bit or whatever. This was seen as one of the benefits of having a close friend or family member over, your domain was their domain and they usually knew what they doing, because that’s effectively their full time job and they are good at it!

Now I’m making a massive assumption that this applies to your MiL, but it does sound like she doesn’t know what to do with herself and is just anxiously going into this mode as a way of connecting with you.

I mean it’s sort of pretty retro and sexist, but from a socialising perspective it makes a lot of sense in a way. In days gone by, guests playing with and entertaining children certainly happened, but it wasn’t assumed to be a central role of guests really for any longer than a few minutes at a time, adults socialised with adults, and children just sort of slotted in with that. So socially, it made more sense for the women to be in kitchen together and men to be in the living room. That way husband and wives who see each other all time weren’t trying to make polite conversation in the living room with each other, or trying to get a sensible conversation out of 6 year olds for half an hour or more while the hosts were absent making the food or whatever.

What I’m getting at is there’s a good chance she’s not being at all rude as far as she’s concerned, and even your little protest that no help is needed would be a classic thing to do in the context where it would be absolutely expected.

Could you try it that way and maybe take control of the food prep, or drink prep and get her to be sous chef rather than your husband? It might help things flow better, even if it’s still slightly annoying. It can be a really nice way to catch up informally with someone too. I do this with my MiL and my DM, and even though they are from different cultures both of them sort of expect it. It’s one of the ways they get to share their expertise as well, which they maybe don’t get to do so much of when children are grown and very few people are SAHP.

user1487194234 · 02/08/2022 21:51

My mum does this, I am positively grateful 😀
But obviously if you are not you /your DH should tell her

pinkstripeycat · 02/08/2022 21:48

Neither my DM or MIL would have done this when my DC were little. It’s rude.
They’d always ask if wanted help so washing up or feeding DC when I was tidying but if I said no they’d leave it.
They’d mostly just play with DC as that’s why they were visiting.

saraclara · 02/08/2022 21:48

With any other guest in your house, you'd do whatever makes them comfortable. So if you know that a parent or PIL is happiest when occupied with a job, why is it suddenly a pain in the neck to find them one? It's not a 'fake' job anyway.

I enjoyed seeing my in-laws involved in our family chores. And they enjoyed being involved. My mum of course never lifted a finger. She was either sitting in front of the TV or in my garden, smoking.