Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bohemian, "lefty" free range middle class parenting really just lazy neglectful parenting jazzed up?

579 replies

Naturelover5 · 02/08/2022 16:12

In my three dc's classes we have some of these bohemian, creative lefty parents.. The children are unkempt, scruffy, hair undone & dressed without fail in mismatched clothes... Some of the children have very questionable manners & are either running amock or with their heads glued to screens constantly (as seen on holiday recently, loud obnoxious parents quaffing seccy while the kids were largely ignored).. If council estate kids were dirty, scruffy & looked uncared for social services would be called.. For this particular group (& they are everywhere) the barefoot, scruffy kids are seen as badges of honour..
The lefty parent types are also very anti homework & organised activities outside school as they think kids should be kids however aibu to think they are just lazy & couldn't be arsed putting the effort in?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Lndnmummy · 03/08/2022 17:48

Naturelover5 · 03/08/2022 15:53

The funny thing is the self proclaimed "eco warrior" mum has 4 kids & would love a 5th (obviously no problems with overpopulation) 🤔 drives a 4x4, the family are always jet setting (the American fly drive was this years big holibobs😉) yet has the neck to scold a mum for plastic use cutlery...
I think the main thing with this type is there complete & utter lack of self awareness... They think they're alternative & different because they let the kids run around dirty in badly fitting clothes & think they're saving the planet by only buying organic or vegan produce..
Don't get me started on the anti vax stance...
A man my DH knows is really into saving the environment & is constantly jetting around the world to see the effects of climate change 😅 he doesn't see the irony & he is part of the problem...it's OK for him to do it but no one else seemingly!

Couldn't agree more. We live in area like this and my dh (who is black) always says "imagine if we let pur kids go to school with dirty uniform, hair a mess and holes in their shoes". We'd have "welfare concerns" and ss called on us. But its all fine for little Boden clad Esmeralda/Ruben to turn up like that. What annoys me to the core is things like "hair policy" where black hair is seen as "unprofessional" or "untidy" but little Elliot can turn up with long uncombed and filthy hair (with nits)....

Legrandsophie · 03/08/2022 17:45

I think you are confusing the crunchy set with all MC people.

The crunchy set are annoying and probably mostly MC but I know people who you would probably consider WC who are very crunchy eco warriors and only ever ride bikes and go camping but also have four kids.

What people find annoying is being preached to and criticised. So it cuts both ways. I personally find preachy wannabe Hyacinth Buckets incredibly rude and irritating.

Dogscanbefallguysforallmannerofthings · 03/08/2022 17:44

BishFish · 03/08/2022 09:42

I think the PP have covered it when talking about fear of judgment. My DM and her family grew up in a working class area that was seen as “really rough” even within an already “rough” town.

My GM was absolutely impeccable in every way. Her home was spotless and always decorated perfectly, her clothes were kept on hangers with protective bags over them, shoes in the shoe boxes, hairdressers for rollers every week etc.

She was really strict about appearance and my DM was definitely a “dress and plaits and bows” child. My GM herself had grown up in such absolute poverty that she couldn’t stay on at school because her own parents couldn’t afford school shoes and uniform. That has to have an ongoing effect in terms of worrying about how other people see you and the way you are dressed.

My DM moved away from there and married someone from a different background. But the hangover from her own childhood is still there and comes out when she says things like “You can’t let a child out in odd socks, what will people think?!”.

The “What will people THINK” is a real theme. I remember her once faffing and tidying around before I had a visit from a health visitor , after one of my DC were born.

I was saying to her “the health visitor really doesn’t care if my house is messy” (normal level of “just had a baby” clutter, nothing alarming). But it was clearly something that mattered to her, and she is was concerned about what the health visitor would think.

I wouldn’t care about someone judging my parenting due to an odd sock (or, god forbid, double denim 😂) or worry about what any visiting professional might think if my house is a bit untidy, as I’m quite secure in myself and my parenting. Then again, I have grown up always having the things I needed, maybe I’d feel differently if I hadn’t.

Yes I think a certain lady who set up a children’s party supplies business was on about tier 2 or 3 of the layer-cake you describe.

Her off-spring made it to the top layer quickly .. I bet they surprised themselves!

Btw I meant to say earlier that the “leftie” business is just ridiculous. As if they would vote labour 🙄

Naturelover5 · 03/08/2022 15:53

bluekostree · 03/08/2022 14:45

Op I know what you mean. I used to live in a very middle class/ leftie city. Like any city there were pockets of deprivation. A couple of dc's friends parents were how you described. The kids were dressed in hand me downs that were either too big or two small (they all had at least 4 kids). Clothes were often dirty with holes but it didn't matter as the were Boden or JoJo. The kids hairs were rarely brushed and the boys had long scruffy hair (I don't know how they were able to see). They rode bikes (no cars), took their kids out of school to go to extinction rebellion protests and the kids didn't seem to do homework (the same 3 sets of parents didn't have a clue when sports day was, SATs were, end of school etc). They often talked and sniggered about the 'other kids' whose parents sent them in to school impeccably (e.g. why would you put bows in hair like that it looks ridiculous). They did not see the irony. Their houses were also so run down (though they'd lived there years and never spoke of doing them up) and quite frankly dirty- but they often spoke about their 1m pound house.....

The kids manners seemed fine but at the park they appeared feral and never came back when their parent called them.

I've since moved away .....

The funny thing is the self proclaimed "eco warrior" mum has 4 kids & would love a 5th (obviously no problems with overpopulation) 🤔 drives a 4x4, the family are always jet setting (the American fly drive was this years big holibobs😉) yet has the neck to scold a mum for plastic use cutlery...
I think the main thing with this type is there complete & utter lack of self awareness... They think they're alternative & different because they let the kids run around dirty in badly fitting clothes & think they're saving the planet by only buying organic or vegan produce..
Don't get me started on the anti vax stance...
A man my DH knows is really into saving the environment & is constantly jetting around the world to see the effects of climate change 😅 he doesn't see the irony & he is part of the problem...it's OK for him to do it but no one else seemingly!

OP posts:
Naturelover5 · 03/08/2022 15:37

Puffalicious · 03/08/2022 13:26

Because when MC parents don't bother with homework or proper school uniform it's considered a lifestyle...when WC parents don't bother, it's because the home is chaotic or there are social issues...and the kids will be on the radar and watched closely by professionals

Exactly this. My bf works in a very MC area- lots of privilege and money- and kids regularly come to school in uniform 2 sizes too small/ stained/ same sweatshirt all week/ unbrushed hair/ too small shoes/ homework never done. I work in a very deprived area in the same city, and these very same things would have pastoral care teachers concerned and on the phone to home/ social work.

It's actually true.

This is my point, the same parents are more than able to provide clean clothes that fit.. The said parents are very well turned out, latest runners with floaty dresses.. Expensive haircuts & colours.. Spend some on your kids or at least ensure the clothes are clean.

OP posts:
Legrandsophie · 03/08/2022 15:17

allfurcoatnoknickers · 03/08/2022 14:37

@Legrandsophie If I weren't an only child, I'd think we had the same mother. I remember being at more than one party as a child and not being allowed to play with the other children in case I got my outfit dirty. It makes me so sad to think about now.

As a reaction, I definitely let DS run to feral when it comes to dress. He's not allowed to be a dick though.

I think this was sadly common if you are of a certain age and had parents who had made good. Both of mine are from very deprived working class backgrounds and had been lucky/ worked hard to make it to a standard of life they considered middle class.

But it sadly did not seem to make either of them happy, which is a shame. Mum still spends a lot of her time talking with her friends about things they find ‘common’ or ‘uncouth’. The weight of judgement is constant with them. It took me decades not to care what they think.

I’m not sure why people think this is a good thing to pass on to children.

OriginalUsername2 · 03/08/2022 15:12

Johnnysgirl · 02/08/2022 20:32

You seriously thought that's what middle class meant? You are confused.

Well thanks for helping me out with some education.. ?!

bluekostree · 03/08/2022 14:45

Op I know what you mean. I used to live in a very middle class/ leftie city. Like any city there were pockets of deprivation. A couple of dc's friends parents were how you described. The kids were dressed in hand me downs that were either too big or two small (they all had at least 4 kids). Clothes were often dirty with holes but it didn't matter as the were Boden or JoJo. The kids hairs were rarely brushed and the boys had long scruffy hair (I don't know how they were able to see). They rode bikes (no cars), took their kids out of school to go to extinction rebellion protests and the kids didn't seem to do homework (the same 3 sets of parents didn't have a clue when sports day was, SATs were, end of school etc). They often talked and sniggered about the 'other kids' whose parents sent them in to school impeccably (e.g. why would you put bows in hair like that it looks ridiculous). They did not see the irony. Their houses were also so run down (though they'd lived there years and never spoke of doing them up) and quite frankly dirty- but they often spoke about their 1m pound house.....

The kids manners seemed fine but at the park they appeared feral and never came back when their parent called them.

I've since moved away .....

allfurcoatnoknickers · 03/08/2022 14:37

@Legrandsophie If I weren't an only child, I'd think we had the same mother. I remember being at more than one party as a child and not being allowed to play with the other children in case I got my outfit dirty. It makes me so sad to think about now.

As a reaction, I definitely let DS run to feral when it comes to dress. He's not allowed to be a dick though.

TheKeatingFive · 03/08/2022 14:20

I work in a very deprived area in the same city, and these very same things would have pastoral care teachers concerned and on the phone to home/ social work.

But the difference isn't difficult to comprehend. Scruffy clothes aren't problematic in and of themselves.

It's what they signify and what they signify is determined by context. So the family that sends kids in looking scruffy, but also has tennis lessons, skiing holidays, lives in a nice part of town, those children aren't likely to be struggling due to lack of funds. The clothing is clearly a choice.

For less privileged children, the clothing may be more indicative that there isn't sufficient cash to meet their wider needs. Of course that might not be the case, but it's a harder call to make.

Of course the system isn't perfect but Social workers will work on the balance of probabilities and these signifiers don't exist in isolation.

Johnnysgirl · 03/08/2022 14:16

You'd hate me!
This is such a smug thing to say, really. Invariably trotted out by people who assume their perfectly normal behaviour is so avant garde that other people are stunned and amazed at their going's on.

bloodyplanes · 03/08/2022 14:14

When my dc were at primary school there was a mother who's children always looked like they had been dressed in the dark, unbrushed hair, the toddler always had snot trails down her face and a sagging nappy. The mother spoke with a very posh accent and they lived in what is known as " the golden triangle" of roads with extremely expensive houses. The class teacher even once had to politely ask her if it was possible could she put coats on her children for playtimes ( it was January). Even back then i knew that had i a very young working class mum who lived in a council house taken my kids into school every day in that state I would have been getting a visit from social services!

Pruella · 03/08/2022 14:12

Comedycook · 03/08/2022 14:09

although drinking in the garden while the kids are on a screen isn’t the end of the world either

That's generous of you to those who can't afford a holiday

Sorry I thought you had a problem
with drinking in charge of children? I don’t care what people do really.

Comedycook · 03/08/2022 14:09

although drinking in the garden while the kids are on a screen isn’t the end of the world either

That's generous of you to those who can't afford a holiday

Pruella · 03/08/2022 14:07

Comedycook · 03/08/2022 13:59

I were on holiday, and I wanted to have a few glasses of wine with dinner, I'd absolutely let my children watch a movie on the iPad!

Sounds better than..

If I were sitting in the front garden of my council house on an abandoned sofa and wanted to have a few cans of extra strong lager, I'd absolutely leave my kids watching any old crap on my phone....

Well it sounds more fun - I’d rather have the wine on holiday than the extra strong lager on an abandoned sofa. It also sounds safer for the kids to be watching a movie than to have unfettered internet access. So I guess to me yes it sounds better although drinking in the garden while the kids are on a screen isn’t the end of the world either.

Is your point that the two scenarios are equivalent and if so are both unacceptable or both fine?

bloodyplanes · 03/08/2022 14:03

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 02/08/2022 16:19

i have known some parents like that - not a lot, but I don't live in a very MC area any more, but when I lived in Brighton this was common and I can't bear it. Their houses are usually grim as well. Everyone is far too creative and free spirited to do laundry and vacuum the crumbs from the floor 🙄

I was just going to say Brighton is full of these types

Comedycook · 03/08/2022 13:59

I were on holiday, and I wanted to have a few glasses of wine with dinner, I'd absolutely let my children watch a movie on the iPad!

Sounds better than..

If I were sitting in the front garden of my council house on an abandoned sofa and wanted to have a few cans of extra strong lager, I'd absolutely leave my kids watching any old crap on my phone....

livinchina · 03/08/2022 13:42

(Saying that, after seeing your previous comment, my daughters love pink, and we don't 'do' gender neutral in my house because my kids just aren't into it and choose their own clothes, and I don't care about it either. So I guess I don't fit in with the cool boho mums either! And my kids love their extracurriculars, but I just let them choose the ones they want to attend? So maybe I'm just in a category by myself, unapproved of by everyone 😂

livinchina · 03/08/2022 13:39

I'm anti homework and I'm a teacher.

I let my children choose their own outfits each day because it brings them so much joy, they're really into their clothes even though they're so small! Sometimes my children go out wearing 'mismatched outfits' because I want to give them some freedom to express themselves. I think that's excellent parenting personally.

If I were on holiday, and I wanted to have a few glasses of wine with dinner, I'd absolutely let my children watch a movie on the iPad! And I'd not force them to go to bed at bedtime either. It's a holiday, a treat! For all of us, not only parents!

Also I'd be more than happy to let my children go barefoot in a number of situations - at a picnic, in the garden, on holiday, etc. I'd be barefoot too! I think this is lovely and freeing and fun.

You'd hate me! But people are different. Children are humans too, who can express themselves and have treats and enjoy themselves and who don't always need to be perfect. Just like adults.

My mum was the opposite of me (you'd probably approve of her!) which is why I'm so keen to raise my children with freedom of expression and creativity and more relaxed rules, because my mum's parenting did me untold harm.

Guess people are just different.

Puffalicious · 03/08/2022 13:26

Because when MC parents don't bother with homework or proper school uniform it's considered a lifestyle...when WC parents don't bother, it's because the home is chaotic or there are social issues...and the kids will be on the radar and watched closely by professionals

Exactly this. My bf works in a very MC area- lots of privilege and money- and kids regularly come to school in uniform 2 sizes too small/ stained/ same sweatshirt all week/ unbrushed hair/ too small shoes/ homework never done. I work in a very deprived area in the same city, and these very same things would have pastoral care teachers concerned and on the phone to home/ social work.

It's actually true.

Naturelover5 · 03/08/2022 12:54

Comedycook · 03/08/2022 12:37

At my dcs school we have a new breed of eco warrior middle class hypocrites parents. Often to be found on cargo bikes and waxing lyrical about the wonders of second hand clothes. One of them has a husband who collects classic cars (5 at the last count) not to mention a holiday home. But that's all offset by sticking their kids in holey t-shirts.

Exactly like said mum belittled a mum for single use cutlery then boasted on about their holiday plans to fly drive across the USA.. The irony!

OP posts:
Naturelover5 · 03/08/2022 12:52

apintortwo · 03/08/2022 12:34

What on earth are you talking about? You’re making a massive judgement here.

The main purpose in life of these extreme boho types is to be judged. They are desperate to be praised and perceived as superior. So people judge. Except that, instead of provoking admiration, others can see right through them and they are becoming a bit of a laughing stock.

And it's not that they can't afford or don't know how to clothe their kids properly. They simply don't want to.

The only thing that perplexes me is bohos in campsites, as I imagine these would be the kind of places they wouldn't want to be seen dead going to. Maybe their standards are dropping.

You've certainly ruffled a few feathers OP

You explained this so much better than me!
They judge girls wearing pink (yes it happened me with dd3, I was ridiculed & called old-fashioned, hers only wore gender neutral, however her boy could wear whatever colour he wanted but she loved him in pink!)
Judge the parents who bring kids to extracurricular, usual excuse is their kids love to be free & extracurriculars are too restrictive & parents should go children free time after school..
Another mum on the class whatsapp group wanted an anti-homework petition, funnily only her own crew backed her up, the rest of the parents/guardians on the whatsapp group blatantly ignored the message to avoid being drawn into an argument..

OP posts:
Comedycook · 03/08/2022 12:52

BaileySharp · 03/08/2022 12:47

Why do you love homework? Kids hate it and teachers do too! Especially in primary school kids should be having fun in their spare time

Because when MC parents don't bother with homework or proper school uniform it's considered a lifestyle...when WC parents don't bother, it's because the home is chaotic or there are social issues...and the kids will be on the radar and watched closely by professionals

Hallamus · 03/08/2022 12:51

The main purpose in life of these extreme boho types is to be judged. They are desperate to be praised and perceived as superior. So people judge. Except that, instead of provoking admiration, others can see right through them and they are becoming a bit of a laughing stock

But the thread hasn't just talked about those, but has included some groups who do quite normal stuff that some posters just happen to think is weird, and lump in with this amount of privilege and obliviousness. See the checklist upthread for instance.

Hallamus · 03/08/2022 12:48

There is no "this group" but you're clearly enjoying yourself, so carry on if you've nothing better to do. You're not engaging seriously with any counter-arguments, just repeating yourself. This thread has been educational for me because I now understand why I am judged by shitty, ignorant people who associate veganism, long hair, extended bf, with traits with which they have nothing to do, like poorly behaved kids, filthy houses, and even class. All the better to dismiss their ill-thought out views.