Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the able bodied / mind/ non carer/ non low wage s worker on benefits, benefit population that claim benefits should contribute somehow to the community/ get the money for WORK .

495 replies

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 15:16

Yes this may be costly to set up such as enhanced dbs checks etc.

I feel that this would both give a purpose and a contribution. And lead to jobs possibly/ develop cv / show work ethic.

In addition , it may stop the resentment and the benefit bashing if the claimants are seen to be contributing to society.

This is not necessarily a tory notion.
Karl Marxs idea about each to ones own ability... encompasses this idea of people working together for the whole of society accordi ng to ability. A quick google implies this is actually a socilaist idea of all doing what they can . This is what i am suggesting.

And before anyone says they would be pushed into things.. maybe there could be a choice of ways to contribute ,like on a data base.

Also, I am a cleaner myself. I literally clean poo off loos. I do not feel less worthy than others . I do the job because I can no longer work in my profession , as I get older, ( burnt out nhs) and see nothing but value in my ( ? Seen as some,lowly work). It gives me structure, a decent wage, and I contribute. All good. No shame in doing a good job , whatever that job if it is in my ability.

How can this idea, properly managed be other than reasonable. ?

OP posts:
JemimaPuddlegoose · 03/08/2022 01:59

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 00:29

@JemimaPuddlegoose im reading it as a lot of overpayments too and reason self employment , assets and living together as top reasons
Also sometimes UC etc messes up
I have had tax credit overpayments before despite giving all correct info

Scroll down to "Appendix 1: Overpayment rates and monetary values by benefit"; it breaks everything down into three separate categories: Fraud, Claimant Error, and Official Error.

The 0.3% for PIP and 2.5% for pension credit are purely fraud, not overpayments. Figures for overpayment are listed in the last column. (On my screen I had to scroll to the right to see that column.)

Antigonesaunt · 03/08/2022 01:56

I think universal basic income would be fantastic. Would stop everyones bitching for a start. People would be able to improve themselves over time without the fear of hunger and destitution, and we could have a robust work force who actually wants to be at work and unify for decent contracts, because they are not too terrified of being made redundant.

Which is why it won't happen, because if the 99% stop infighting the 1% and their media lackeys will be in trouble

feistyoneyouare · 03/08/2022 01:50

alpenguin · 02/08/2022 18:48

And how long before employers stop paying employees and just sign up to workfare or whatever fancy name they try to give it next, to get cheap staff working for government money of what £80 a week (?) Instead of paying minimum wage or preferably more?

people must be paid a fair amount for doing work not forced into some kind of servitude when they are hard on their luck.

Exactly this.

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 01:39

@Frequency its a mix here
A lot work but there are families where no one works in the house incl adult children
Its often a little more complex than just not working in many cases
Zero hrs doesn't help at all or the hrs sometimes as childcare isn't always available around here
Only a couple schools offer before and after school clubs and childminders are like gold dust and both only cover say 8-6 so if shift work is all thats available ( and there is a lot of that around here ) they simply logistically can't do it

Frequency · 03/08/2022 01:29

@worriedatthistime to clarify, leaving out the people suffering from addiction who tend not to live in family units, all of the households I know have at least one member of the family who works at least part-time if not full time. It's more common to have 2 (mum and dad) working part time than one working fulltime but that is down to the local job market/lack of fulltime opportunities/zero hours contracts rather than a deliberate choice. I know a decent handful of people who have more than one job or do some kind of selling/crafting/cash in hand type thing on the side of their main job.

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 01:22

@Frequency long term unemployed doesn't have to be never employed though
But your considered long term if been many years
My own uncle hasn't worked for last 30 years
My 26 year old nephew has worked about 6 months in total if you added up all his jobs
I would consider them both long term unemployed

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 01:19

I guess also a universal payment means no filling in tons of forms and questions and for those claiming PIP endless appts
A fair system that helps all that need it
Long term disabled especially as you can't change your situation

Frequency · 03/08/2022 01:19

I live in one of the most deprived areas in the country. I don't know a single person who has never worked a day. Even the local heroin addicts do the odd days/weeks on the fishing boats, although admittedly, they do have long periods of unemployment. What they don't have is the correct support to get clean and stay clean. A family member of mine would deliberately get caught shoplifting in order to be arrested. He wanted to go to prison to get the help he needed to get clean.

I don't know any families with multiple generations of long term unemployment. I also don't know anyone who fraudently claims to be disabled.

I'm long term unemployed according to my neighbour. I overheard her musing with a shopkeeper at the local corner shop about how I could afford to drink "every weekend in the garden on benefits".

The reality is I work from home full time on a fairly healthy salary in a position with good career progression opportunities.

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 01:16

@Antigonesaunt helping people get bAck into secure work is the answer and there seems to be none of that
Zero hrs are find for sAy students etc but nor families
I know families who end up worse off working than benefits at times when you take transport into account , childcare issues etc
I mean how many jobs pay when your off sick with a child
Loosing a weeks pay cripples people
The system is broken but its going to be hard to fix all at once
Some families are stuck in a cycle as well
Its just frustrating when you see someone playing the system and then another struggling to put food on the table
I think maybe a universal payment is maybe a way to go ? But then anytime min wage goes up then so does food and costs so it never feels like when your at the lower end that it gets better

Antigonesaunt · 03/08/2022 01:03

I've lived on council estates and/or areas of deprivation most of my adult life, and most of the people I know work or if they don't somebody in their household does. That wasn't true a decade ago, but it is now. And they are mostly employed part time, insecurely self employed, on zero hours type contracts. That's who wants to employ people who have been out of work for a while, people who want cheap Labour and know that they can treat their workers whatever way they like because nobody can just 'sit on benefits.' Roles like cleaning, factory/warehouse, retail, hospitality, deliveroo, etc. Care work too because they always are desperate for care workers. Most of the time one full time job is being spread between many people on zero hours so that in reality there aren't more jobs, just more people working the same job just with not many hours (and contracted to not do anything else).

Otherwise people go on the sick after years because they have developed mental and physical health problems and addictions from the misery and inadequate life quality that is a life on the dole. I don't think forcing people to work for free is going to motivate those people who have lost all hope. The opposite, in fact.

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 00:47

How many of you who say this rarely happens live in a deprived area
If you haven't had a job for 15 years who do you think whats to employ you ? So when people do want work its not always easy
People get trapped in benefits as well as thats not good either

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 00:45

@JustLyra how would they find them ? They wouldn't be privvy to peoples personal data
I know multi generational families , are they a figment of my imagination

Ticksallboxes · 03/08/2022 00:45

Antigonesaunt · 03/08/2022 00:11

Everyone seems to know a family where "nobody has worked for multiple generations" but statistically that is unlikely, as other than a very small subset of families most families have somebody working. Yes there will be maybe granny, mum and daughter all on benefits and may all be single parents (still very small number statistically) there will be brothers, sisters, uncles, aunties, great aunts, great uncles, cousins, nieces, nephews and children who are working, or working and claiming (the new norm for a lot of working class families). Yes there are occasional cases of multiple generations not working but usually this is due to them working outside the law instead, and even then there will usually be some 'breakaway' members who follow the conventional path. Most people want to work or want the financial security that work brings, at least. It's a tired trope used to demonise benefit claimants, but it's not based in reality behind the occasional unicorn family

Absolutely this!!

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 00:42

@JustLyra yes a couple people on here have sAid nobody does it
If you live in an area surrounded by people you will know people who do
You will also know people who seem to get nothing barely and seem to get no help at all and really struggle

Bednobsbroomsticks · 03/08/2022 00:41

JemimaPuddlegoose · 03/08/2022 00:27

Okay but what do you want us to extrapolate from that: that you live in some kind of hyper-fraud hotspot where benefit fraud has 300% higher than anywhere else for 30 years without anyone noticing or doing anything about it?

It's reasonable to assume that someone fighting tooth and nail to get their "30 years experience" in handling PIP claims accepted as The Truth are speaking broadly.

Makes you wonder why they even employ fraud teams? Not needed are they lol.

Well considering nearly 90% of all disability benefit fraud claims are found to be baseless...

I work in a very deprived area up north. A lot of poverty high rates of depression sickness, mental health. Its dire.

Years ago under Tony Blair I was seeing claimants who were taking more income than me by claiming benefits. But people were okay, they had money in their pocket, kids were fed, people claimed what they were entitled to and no more, because they didn't need to.

Along comes the tories, they put in lha and bedroom tax, they give shared accommodation rates and benefit cap.
Suddenly a single person is on 250 a month with 250 rent and left to rot. That person has no choice but to try get extra income. If they can't get work it's easier to claim sick and pip. It's not rocket science.

Universal credit has increased the applications for pip. I rarely did them till uc came in do j blame people for trying to survive? No. Do I get angry when people tell me they lie to get it? Yes. But the system isn't working. Let's have a universal basic income for all. Soon to be trialled in uk leave the pip for those who need it. Workers shouldn't be worse off than those who don't want to work and along the way let's look after people. But able bodied people should be offered opportunities not some shit pound land slave labour job. Skilled work. They used to pay people extra benefits to start work. All that has gone. Also get rid of zero hour contracts. Benefits are at least reliable unlike that rubbish. It's just not black and white and to say I'm lying is just lazy because I see how broken it is and how people have to do what they can to survive.

JustLyra · 03/08/2022 00:41

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 00:37

@JustLyra but not in its current form it hasn't There was a lot less help years ago

There was enough for the multi generations of lazy work shy families that are allegedly around to have been around, yet a large charity couldn’t find them…

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 00:40

@JustLyra where is this evidence ? Give it 10 years and there will be a lot more generations claiming
When benefits were really high people actually couldn't work as they were worse off when taking into account getting to work etc
When tax credit system was in place And I was offered more hrs i had to say no as we would of been worse off , once I added childcare costs and extra petrol etc
Thats not a good place to be either

JustLyra · 03/08/2022 00:39

s unrealistic to think no one plays the system

nobody has said absolutely no one does it.

Its just that the rhetoric of the majority being on the fiddle is bollocks.

And it’s dangerous bollocks because it allows governments that don’t like the poor or disabled to attack benefits with impunity because they’re “aiming at the fraud”. Without giving a single shit that the majority of those suffering from the cuts are absolutely genuine.

AyeUpMeDuck · 03/08/2022 00:38

JustLyra · 03/08/2022 00:32

Unemployment benefits have been around in various forms for over 100 years.

Experimental and limited began in 1911, it was extended in 1920, decreased in 1930s, then increased and standardised in the mid 40’s.

There have been plenty opportunities for families to have multiple generations of lifestyle choice benefit claiming, but the evidence is that doesn’t happen.

The poor laws...

Fascinating stuff really.
No relevance on modern day, but interesting none the less.

Then the great evils of the 30s and 40s..

I think labour swore to rid society of the great evils.. yeah, that went well. 😁

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 00:37

@JustLyra but not in its current form it hasn't There was a lot less help years ago

worriedatthistime · 03/08/2022 00:36

@AyeUpMeDuck but its still a small percent as benefits were not the same as now by any strectch
Its unrealistic to think no one plays the system
I have family members even that do or have done
The whole thing is a mess there is no real help for those wanting to get into work
I found myself unemployed due to covid and went to what i thought was job centre and it was all about putting in a claim
They never helped me find work or anything like that, its used to be a lot more help in getting people into positions
I got zero help and it was a lot of hassle for the £70 quid a week
Luckily i found work quite quickly but there were other people there struggling who just needed help and wanted to work but maybe interview technique etc was a bit rusty
More effort should be put in getting people back into work in some capacity and that means helping people and working with employers to give people a chance and pay a fair wage

Davyjones · 03/08/2022 00:36

This was done
People were being fired, claiming benefits, then re”hired” at no pay

JustLyra · 03/08/2022 00:34

Bednobsbroomsticks · 03/08/2022 00:28

Ok. If it makes you feel better.

Makes no odds to me of someone feels the need to be goady and tell lies on the Internet.

I just hope you’re also bullshitting about your job as I’d pity anyone with the unfortunate luck to get landed with such a judgemental “expert”

JustLyra · 03/08/2022 00:32

Unemployment benefits have been around in various forms for over 100 years.

Experimental and limited began in 1911, it was extended in 1920, decreased in 1930s, then increased and standardised in the mid 40’s.

There have been plenty opportunities for families to have multiple generations of lifestyle choice benefit claiming, but the evidence is that doesn’t happen.

Discovereads · 03/08/2022 00:31

Bednobsbroomsticks · 03/08/2022 00:22

I have also fought tooth and nail to get decisions overturned (100% success rate) so as much as you want to paint me as a bad guy you won't.

Yeah for the paltry 1% you thought were deserving disabled, obviously not for the 99% you had decided were liars.