Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the able bodied / mind/ non carer/ non low wage s worker on benefits, benefit population that claim benefits should contribute somehow to the community/ get the money for WORK .

495 replies

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 15:16

Yes this may be costly to set up such as enhanced dbs checks etc.

I feel that this would both give a purpose and a contribution. And lead to jobs possibly/ develop cv / show work ethic.

In addition , it may stop the resentment and the benefit bashing if the claimants are seen to be contributing to society.

This is not necessarily a tory notion.
Karl Marxs idea about each to ones own ability... encompasses this idea of people working together for the whole of society accordi ng to ability. A quick google implies this is actually a socilaist idea of all doing what they can . This is what i am suggesting.

And before anyone says they would be pushed into things.. maybe there could be a choice of ways to contribute ,like on a data base.

Also, I am a cleaner myself. I literally clean poo off loos. I do not feel less worthy than others . I do the job because I can no longer work in my profession , as I get older, ( burnt out nhs) and see nothing but value in my ( ? Seen as some,lowly work). It gives me structure, a decent wage, and I contribute. All good. No shame in doing a good job , whatever that job if it is in my ability.

How can this idea, properly managed be other than reasonable. ?

OP posts:
Dotjones · 03/08/2022 09:43

I'd adopt a multi-faceted approach as there is no "one size fits all" solution. People should be grouped into those who are able and willing to work, those who are able but unwilling, and those who are unable/unfit.

  1. People who are able and willing to work should be given jobs that need doing - be it picking litter or fruit picking, any honest task available. They should have course get their skills matched to jobs that require them wherever possible, but this group would be obliged to take the work offered to them. If it meant travel or staying away from home, their expenses would be paid. Crucially this group would be paid an acceptable minimum wage, say £20,000 per year. They would still be paid if no work could be found for them but would have to take it when offered.
  2. Those who are unwilling to work would no longer receive financial assistance but be offered free lodging in a controlled environment, a kind of secure hospital type of place. They'd get basic accommodation and food, they'd have access to a communal TV with Freeview, that type of thing. Family units wouldn't have to be split up like in the old workhouse days but they would be prevented from having more children as far as is possible. They'd be free to leave once they could satisfy the authorities that they had somewhere to live and were able to support themselves, e.g. have a job offer. They could have the opportunity to earn "pocket money" by doing menial tasks in order to earn privileges like tobacco, strong lager or Sky Sports.
  3. Those who were unable to work but had someone willing to support them would be allowed to stay in the community. A degree of benefits would still be available to this group to enable them to live with friends or relatives.
  4. Those who were unable to work but not able to live in the community would be housed in a similar environment to those in (2) above, but with greater freedom and privileges such as days out or being able to receive visitors.
This system would be beneficial to the whole of society and have lots of positive knock on effects. There would be a lot more social housing available as people got cleared into the housing institutions, this could be given to those who are working or be sold off privately. There would of course need to be a big building programme to construct the housing centres so would help that industry. A side benefit would be that these structures could easily be converted to prisons (and vice versa) as demand for one service grows. It would cut down on a lot of "petty" crime because people would no longer steal to feed their families now they have a legal option. Crucially those who wanted to work would be able to have an acceptable standard of living.
DizzyWhoreI804 · 03/08/2022 09:33

Crikeymaccrikey · 03/08/2022 09:20

Bednobsbroomsticks i have had a long career in something that meant i was in contact with many people and many institutions.
I too like you want benefits to go to people.who need them.
I totally agree with you that some people are very able fraudsters who are very skilled at.working the system.
I had a stint in the benefits fraud dept for a good while prior to nhs. I absolutely agree with you. It is so hard to witness what they do but one gets called a tory for speaking the truth. You will never convince those who just dont want to see it. They will call you.brainwashed , went they actually have no experince of what you are talking about.many many on bemefits are not like this , but to deny a group that are , based on not knowing what you know, is as blinkered as they are accusing you as being.There is a group of people who dont want to.work and use the system based on your experience and others . How do.they know that you are wrong when you see it day in day out ? They dont .

They will call you.brainwashed , went they actually have no experince of what you are talking about

Many people on this thread do have experience of what you're talking about. Both personal and professional experience. And they have repeatedly said that you cannot claim disability benefits without reams of evidence from consultants/other HCPs. Interesting that you choose to disregard what they say, and instead focus on the one poster whose (dubious) claims of working with benefit claimants suit your narrative.

Also interesting is that you 'did a stint in the benefits fraud dept' prior to your work in the NHS. Very odd that you haven't mentioned this already on this thread, given it's utterly relevant. Also odd is that despite this work, you have no idea how the benefit system works.

Rather like @Bednobsbroomsticks telling us that she encountered no claims for PIP before UC came in, but after it was introduced there were numerous claims (99% of which were fraudulent, let's not forget).

The reason why she didn't encounter claims for PIP prior to UC being introduced is that PIP was introduced at the same time as PIP. Doesn't matter how fraudulent a claimant is, they can't claim a benefit which doesn't exist.

You really would think that a person who worked in the benefits field would know this, wouldn't you? You really, really would.

It's almost as if neither of you have worked with benefit claimants at all, isn't it?

Festoonlights · 03/08/2022 09:29

Business barons?! I have never met a business ‘baron’ but I have met lots of intelligent, ambitious people taking responsibility for themselves.
Worked to an early death? Are you referring to Victorian times? Literally centuries.
We NEED money makers, inventors and big business to pay for all of these benefits. Where exactly do you think all of the money to prop up the bloated system comes from?
Take a long hard look at Sri Lanka and tell me this how you want to end up?
And what exactly are YOU contributing?

The stupidity and absurdity of some pp is eye opening.

Crikeymaccrikey · 03/08/2022 09:20

Bednobsbroomsticks i have had a long career in something that meant i was in contact with many people and many institutions.
I too like you want benefits to go to people.who need them.
I totally agree with you that some people are very able fraudsters who are very skilled at.working the system.
I had a stint in the benefits fraud dept for a good while prior to nhs. I absolutely agree with you. It is so hard to witness what they do but one gets called a tory for speaking the truth. You will never convince those who just dont want to see it. They will call you.brainwashed , went they actually have no experince of what you are talking about.many many on bemefits are not like this , but to deny a group that are , based on not knowing what you know, is as blinkered as they are accusing you as being.There is a group of people who dont want to.work and use the system based on your experience and others . How do.they know that you are wrong when you see it day in day out ? They dont .

OP posts:
Discovereads · 03/08/2022 09:20

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 03/08/2022 08:51

betterexplained.com/articles/understanding-the-pareto-principle-the-8020-rule/

It's common knowledge. It's harsh but a truism from a quantified business perspective.
This is the issue with apprenticeships, the company has to stand the initial 12-24 months cost. Then once trained they leave.😂

Universal income is a terrible idea, look at the after-effects of the free money given away by the governments. It's seen millions disappear from the labour forces across the globe.😆

It isn’t true. It’s what the unethical business barons argue to increase profit.

The whole genesis of the minimum wage was to set a basement whereby a single working person earns enough for the most basic, bare bones, frugal lifestyle. Prior to there being a minimum wage, these business barons exploited and abused workers to the point of early deaths due to over-work, starvation, and so on. The working class lived in overcrowded slums with one family to a room and often no furniture- no bed to sleep on. No more than one set of clothes to wear. Often despite working 16-20hr days they couldn’t afford enough food to survive.

The minimum wage was to reform the above and prevent such abuse of workers from continuing. So everyone is worth the minimum wage because it’s the minimum earnings it takes for one human being to live above the absolute poverty line. Now, not saying the current minimum wage achieves that, but that is its purpose. It was never meant to be a reflection of the worth of the labour, but the minimum a person should be paid to live as frugally as society considers possible to live.

pointythings · 03/08/2022 09:11

@Hrpuffnstuff1 the theory may be economically sound, but implementing it would be immoral and unethical. Your suggestion leads back to the workhouse. Disgusting.

Tillsforthrills · 03/08/2022 09:08

DizzyWhoreI804 · 03/08/2022 08:45

Most people know this, but let's not let facts get in the way of a good old benefits bashing thread eh!

Quite.

Most offensive of all is the ‘but it’ll be sooo good for them!’

Not sure why MN is allowing these threads.

Tillsforthrills · 03/08/2022 09:06

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 15:26

I feel there can be a huge loss of confidence and social skills when not working.
In addition it may help break generational claimants , encorage the idea that work is good / normal not benefits and no work , no structure.

Yes! Forced jobs for below minimum wage will do absolute wonders for social opportunities and confidence.

JustLyra · 03/08/2022 09:02

*their

JustLyra · 03/08/2022 09:01

Terfydactyl · 03/08/2022 08:39

Generations of families who don't want to work
This is not true. The rowntree foundation did the research and never found three generations of benefit claimants.

I’ve been saying this the whole way through the thread, but as always people think they’re anecdata of one proves everyone else - including the governments own figures wrong.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 03/08/2022 08:51

DizzyWhoreI804 · 03/08/2022 08:38

some people aren't worth the min wage

Incredible.

betterexplained.com/articles/understanding-the-pareto-principle-the-8020-rule/

It's common knowledge. It's harsh but a truism from a quantified business perspective.
This is the issue with apprenticeships, the company has to stand the initial 12-24 months cost. Then once trained they leave.😂

Universal income is a terrible idea, look at the after-effects of the free money given away by the governments. It's seen millions disappear from the labour forces across the globe.😆

DizzyWhoreI804 · 03/08/2022 08:45

Terfydactyl · 03/08/2022 08:39

Generations of families who don't want to work
This is not true. The rowntree foundation did the research and never found three generations of benefit claimants.

Most people know this, but let's not let facts get in the way of a good old benefits bashing thread eh!

DizzyWhoreI804 · 03/08/2022 08:44

Discovereads · 03/08/2022 08:01

You’re talking about the creation of a slave class. Forcing people to work for survival level income. People do get trapped on benefits, but how much more will they be trapped if they are picking fruit all day every day for £74 a week?

Precisely.

How are people supposed to look for work if they're already doing a full time job? I assume they'll be expected to pay their own fares to their 'work'place - how will they be able to afford fares to job interviews too?

If there's a job to be done, it is a 'real job' and should be remunerated as such. And these jobs do exist, anyway, and the roles have been filled - every council cleans graffiti and takes care of its green spaces.

And even if these 'jobs' did exist, of course it wouldn't be cost-free to implement the ridiculous scenario being proposed.

Terfydactyl · 03/08/2022 08:39

Generations of families who don't want to work
This is not true. The rowntree foundation did the research and never found three generations of benefit claimants.

DizzyWhoreI804 · 03/08/2022 08:38

some people aren't worth the min wage

Incredible.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 03/08/2022 08:25

Bednobsbroomsticks · 03/08/2022 00:41

I work in a very deprived area up north. A lot of poverty high rates of depression sickness, mental health. Its dire.

Years ago under Tony Blair I was seeing claimants who were taking more income than me by claiming benefits. But people were okay, they had money in their pocket, kids were fed, people claimed what they were entitled to and no more, because they didn't need to.

Along comes the tories, they put in lha and bedroom tax, they give shared accommodation rates and benefit cap.
Suddenly a single person is on 250 a month with 250 rent and left to rot. That person has no choice but to try get extra income. If they can't get work it's easier to claim sick and pip. It's not rocket science.

Universal credit has increased the applications for pip. I rarely did them till uc came in do j blame people for trying to survive? No. Do I get angry when people tell me they lie to get it? Yes. But the system isn't working. Let's have a universal basic income for all. Soon to be trialled in uk leave the pip for those who need it. Workers shouldn't be worse off than those who don't want to work and along the way let's look after people. But able bodied people should be offered opportunities not some shit pound land slave labour job. Skilled work. They used to pay people extra benefits to start work. All that has gone. Also get rid of zero hour contracts. Benefits are at least reliable unlike that rubbish. It's just not black and white and to say I'm lying is just lazy because I see how broken it is and how people have to do what they can to survive.

Zero hrs contracts are going now where.
They give the employer flexibility over the workforce.
They're an antidote to the min wage which is an imposed artificial price on the cost of labour. Basically, some people aren't worth the min wage.
Pareto proves this.

Society has huge problems a fragmented family unit isn't economically sound. It's not productive and is complex to manage. The monogamous family and the industrial age rose in tandem. This is now broken, asking others to share this burden is counterintuitive, rewarding anti-social behavior.

Most people have enough income to pay for their own children only.
The current model is not sustainable and people resent it.

Discovereads · 03/08/2022 08:01

Getoff · 03/08/2022 07:56

I think a simple way to implement this is to create as many useful jobs as necessary that nearly anyone can do. For example, beautifying public places. (Could be litter-picking, weeding, cleaning graffiti.) These are jobs that benefit everyone, but society currently thinks it can't afford. (The criterion should be they are jobs that would not exist if there were no unemployed to do then, they must not compete with "real" public sector employment.) If the salary is just the benefits that would have been claimed anyway, there is no cost. These special jobs might have to be exempt from minimum wage. (It's actually important that they pay less, because we don't want people to do them in preference to "real" jobs.)

You’re talking about the creation of a slave class. Forcing people to work for survival level income. People do get trapped on benefits, but how much more will they be trapped if they are picking fruit all day every day for £74 a week?

Getoff · 03/08/2022 07:56

I think a simple way to implement this is to create as many useful jobs as necessary that nearly anyone can do. For example, beautifying public places. (Could be litter-picking, weeding, cleaning graffiti.) These are jobs that benefit everyone, but society currently thinks it can't afford. (The criterion should be they are jobs that would not exist if there were no unemployed to do then, they must not compete with "real" public sector employment.) If the salary is just the benefits that would have been claimed anyway, there is no cost. These special jobs might have to be exempt from minimum wage. (It's actually important that they pay less, because we don't want people to do them in preference to "real" jobs.)

Sockwomble · 03/08/2022 07:41

"It's quite clear I meant 99 per cent of the applicants I have encountered. Otherwise I'd be stating 99 per cent of all pip applicants which is an impossibility."

Why mention 99% at all when you knew it wasn't anything like a true representation of the actual percentage of claimants - unless the intention is to mislead.

pointythings · 03/08/2022 07:41

Dear Therese, you have now put out two threads on this in two days and you have been told why it's a stupid idea. Kindly desist and come up with some sensible proposals.

Oh wait, you're a Tory. As you were then.

TigerRag · 03/08/2022 07:35

"if they can't get work its easier to claim sick and pip"

As you've clearly been through "assessments" for "sick and pip" you'd know this isn't the case. Even with years of medical evidence from a qualified medical person, I was told there's nothing wrong, there's no medical reason why I can't drive. My parents were told when I was 4 I'd never drive. I'm now in my mid 30s. Nothing's changed.

DizzyWhoreI804 · 03/08/2022 07:27

Bednobsbroomsticks · 03/08/2022 00:41

I work in a very deprived area up north. A lot of poverty high rates of depression sickness, mental health. Its dire.

Years ago under Tony Blair I was seeing claimants who were taking more income than me by claiming benefits. But people were okay, they had money in their pocket, kids were fed, people claimed what they were entitled to and no more, because they didn't need to.

Along comes the tories, they put in lha and bedroom tax, they give shared accommodation rates and benefit cap.
Suddenly a single person is on 250 a month with 250 rent and left to rot. That person has no choice but to try get extra income. If they can't get work it's easier to claim sick and pip. It's not rocket science.

Universal credit has increased the applications for pip. I rarely did them till uc came in do j blame people for trying to survive? No. Do I get angry when people tell me they lie to get it? Yes. But the system isn't working. Let's have a universal basic income for all. Soon to be trialled in uk leave the pip for those who need it. Workers shouldn't be worse off than those who don't want to work and along the way let's look after people. But able bodied people should be offered opportunities not some shit pound land slave labour job. Skilled work. They used to pay people extra benefits to start work. All that has gone. Also get rid of zero hour contracts. Benefits are at least reliable unlike that rubbish. It's just not black and white and to say I'm lying is just lazy because I see how broken it is and how people have to do what they can to survive.

DH works in benefits in a 'very deprived area up north'. In the top 5% of deprived areas in the UK, in fact. We've just been chatting about this thread and he actually laughed at your assertion that 99% of PIP claimants are fraudulent. He might encounter a couple a year who seem not quite on the level, and that's out of literally thousands.

He pointed out (again, as you've already been told many times, and you'd know if you genuinely worked in the field) that you need reams of evidence from consultants and so on before you can apply. People who are 'faking' won't have any of this, so they don't generally tend to bother. And no, a letter from a GP is not enough evidence on its own to claim disability benefits.

He also wonders how you know people who have claimed via your place of work are out clubbing - do you keep their details then stalk them on Facebook, for example? Because that's incredibly worrying, and you could lose your job if you do.

I'm sure you wouldn't want to end up on benefits and face the stigma you yourself have placed on others, would you?

Nat6999 · 03/08/2022 03:11

Forcing people to work for benefits will cause more unemployment because employers will hire cheap labour in benefit claimants & dump their more expensive staff. Remember the old Youth Opportunities scheme in the 80's? Employers took kids on for a bit more than their dole money & then when their time was up got rid of them & got new ones, nothing more than cheap labour.

Nat6999 · 03/08/2022 03:04

Then make jobs pay a living wage no matter what age the employee is. Ds turned down a job this week when he was offered it. The ad said wage was £10.30 an hour but when he got the offer they only want to pay him £6.83 an hour because he is 18. Ds is a carer for me & his dad & by taking a job he would have been worse off & lost his carers allowance even though he would still have been caring over 35 hours a week.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 03/08/2022 02:30

Universal credit has increased the applications for pip. I rarely did them till uc came in

You didn't do a single PIP application until UC came in. Because PIP did not exist until UC came in. They were introduced at the same time.

Universal Credit and PIP were both introduced in the Welfare Reform Act 2012, and both launched with the same regional pilot/gradual rollout in April 2013, and with the same proposed schedule for full rollout, which was the intention for both to be fullly rolled out by 2017. In both cases the full rollout was substantially delayed by technical problems. (UC won't be fully rolled out until 2024.)

gov.uk has comprehensive statistics on exactly how many people have applied for PIP every year since 2013 and they make clear the increase in applications between 2013-2021 is due to the fact the rollout where people have been moved from DLA to PIP has taken such a long time.

to say I'm lying is just lazy because I see how broken it is and how people have to do what they can to survive.

The reason everyone's saying you're lying when you claim 99% of disabled benefits claimants are faking (or some weird claim that 99% of disabled benefit claimants in your area are faking but only in your area) is because there's not a single shred of evidence to support your claims, and every single official source and statistic disproves it, not to mention many of us have personal experience and know that what you're saying is total bollocks.