Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the able bodied / mind/ non carer/ non low wage s worker on benefits, benefit population that claim benefits should contribute somehow to the community/ get the money for WORK .

495 replies

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 15:16

Yes this may be costly to set up such as enhanced dbs checks etc.

I feel that this would both give a purpose and a contribution. And lead to jobs possibly/ develop cv / show work ethic.

In addition , it may stop the resentment and the benefit bashing if the claimants are seen to be contributing to society.

This is not necessarily a tory notion.
Karl Marxs idea about each to ones own ability... encompasses this idea of people working together for the whole of society accordi ng to ability. A quick google implies this is actually a socilaist idea of all doing what they can . This is what i am suggesting.

And before anyone says they would be pushed into things.. maybe there could be a choice of ways to contribute ,like on a data base.

Also, I am a cleaner myself. I literally clean poo off loos. I do not feel less worthy than others . I do the job because I can no longer work in my profession , as I get older, ( burnt out nhs) and see nothing but value in my ( ? Seen as some,lowly work). It gives me structure, a decent wage, and I contribute. All good. No shame in doing a good job , whatever that job if it is in my ability.

How can this idea, properly managed be other than reasonable. ?

OP posts:
NellesVilla · 02/08/2022 19:33

And I’m fed up of people defending people on benefits (other than the disabled etc). I think these people must either be really comfortable- made money in property or inheritance etc- or actually be on benefits themselves.

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 19:33

I'm assuming that Mumsnet employees and moderators share the stance offered up by these benefit bashing posts, it is the only conceivable reason as to why they allow them to continue once they've been reported.

I'd like them to confirm one way to the other as, to be frank, of they continue to support and enable these threads, it shows MN is not the place for those claiming in work top up, disability, incapacity, child benefit, UC etc etc.
That'll be shop workers ,nurses, care staff, hospital porters, teaching assistants, janitors and more and more and more.

NellesVilla · 02/08/2022 19:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Terfydactyl · 02/08/2022 19:27

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:12

Most working people working increasingly hard and unable to pay their bills bring forced to
support healthy able people perfectly capable of with but choosing not to work is going to be increasingly unacceptable!

From the other thread about fruit picking, which didnt go so well for Op

There were around 803,000 people in the United Kingdom who had been unemployed for less than six months, compared with 129,000 unemployed for between 6 and 12 months, and 353,000 who were unemployed for more than a year

From
www.statista.com/statistics/284187/uk-unemployment-figures-by-length/

This is not many people. Take the 350k how many are disabled but have no support to claim? How many are near retirement and wont get a job anyway?
How many are carers? Etc. Etc.

If you are not happy supporting these few people I hope you never claim or claimed a penny in benefits. So no state pension for you eh.

QuestionableMouse · 02/08/2022 19:25

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 15:28

Lilithslove where i live there are many many unfilled positions. On my facebook each and every week employers are asking for staff. The current staff are exhausted .. covering too many shifts.

There's often a good reason why employers can't keep staff, and it had nothing to do with people claiming benefits.

More and more people are refusing to accept toxic workplaces and are rightfully leaving. Big staff turnover is a sign the place is either toxic to work, or that they're not paying enough to retain staff. Putting more people into that situation, who probably don't have the option to just leave, isn't the answer.

Frequency · 02/08/2022 19:23

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:16

It was great experience and worked! What’s not to love. No one should be paid to decline at home.

If there was 30 hours of work available at the doggy daycare then someone should have been paid NMW for it. If the slave labour hadn't been an option to the business they would haver had to pay someone a legal wage. The position wouldn't have dissapeared due to lack of free workers.

Hawkins001 · 02/08/2022 19:21

Due to £ being the main factor, in General most businesses want cheaper costs, and more profits, then if businesses were lean with how many employees were actually needed, that in it self means what to do with a large amount of society's population.

Overall it seems, society needs a whole new restructuring.

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 19:20

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:16

It was great experience and worked! What’s not to love. No one should be paid to decline at home.

What if someone wants paid employment in doggie day care?

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 19:20

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:16

It was great experience and worked! What’s not to love. No one should be paid to decline at home.

If there was work available, it should have been remunerated appropriately. Free labour is certainly not something 'to love', unless of course you're an unscrupulous employer who can avoid paying a wage for an honest day's work.

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 19:16

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:12

Most working people working increasingly hard and unable to pay their bills bring forced to
support healthy able people perfectly capable of with but choosing not to work is going to be increasingly unacceptable!

You can't 'choose not to work'.

(Cue you telling me about a family you know where nobody works but they can afford Sky TV/holidays to Florida/to have the Mona Lisa on their wall)

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:16

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 19:14

Who was the winner in this? The doggie day care... they got 6 months of free labour.
How is this even legal?

It was great experience and worked! What’s not to love. No one should be paid to decline at home.

VladmirsPoutine · 02/08/2022 19:16

You being a cleaner and holding this position is really a testament to how pervasive the myths surrounding benefits, unemployed people are. The constant shows decrying benefit cheats and poverty porn of the 90s really did a number on a lot of people. A friend wondered how the tories are still in power and things like this really explain why.

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:15

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 02/08/2022 19:11

There is already so many schemes like this in place after 6 months signing on they send you on placements for 30 hours a week or training courses the only extra they pay out is for travel my friend ended up at a doggie daycare for 6 months before getting a permanent job else where

It should be reduced to 12 weeks - so many jobs available atm

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 19:14

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 02/08/2022 19:11

There is already so many schemes like this in place after 6 months signing on they send you on placements for 30 hours a week or training courses the only extra they pay out is for travel my friend ended up at a doggie daycare for 6 months before getting a permanent job else where

Who was the winner in this? The doggie day care... they got 6 months of free labour.
How is this even legal?

Gotobloodysleep · 02/08/2022 19:14

I used to work with a charity in London that also had coop/reduced rent houses and flats (some right on the river Thames, amazing locations). One of their stipulations in the contracts was that the residents had to give back to the community. This might be in keeping the communal gardens neat, chairing resident meetings, helping with any repairs. It worked well and their was a great community identity.

TreacheryPepper · 02/08/2022 19:14
Biscuit
DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 19:13

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:09

I completely agree op.

You think that jobs should be taken away from people who currently have them, and given to people who are forced to do the same work for £77pw?

And those forced into unemployment by this will likely end up doing the same work they were doing for a proper wage, for £77pw?

Why do you think this? Are you perhaps an employer who stands to benefit from a drastically reduced wage bill?

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:12

Most working people working increasingly hard and unable to pay their bills bring forced to
support healthy able people perfectly capable of with but choosing not to work is going to be increasingly unacceptable!

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 02/08/2022 19:11

There is already so many schemes like this in place after 6 months signing on they send you on placements for 30 hours a week or training courses the only extra they pay out is for travel my friend ended up at a doggie daycare for 6 months before getting a permanent job else where

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:09

I completely agree op.

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 19:07

FromerGerman · 02/08/2022 18:30

"People like me"?

There is a huge difference between could/ should/ must. My point was that we currently don't have the infrastructure to cater for many otherwise fine disabled people.

I'd leave the decision as to realistic (not ambitious, no - realistic)working hours to doctors, not random people infantilising a lot of disabled people.

I'm disabled. I have experience of how difficult it is to find work when you're disabled - particularly when you need several days off a month for hospital appointments, when your medication makes you vomit for 48 hours after you inject it, when your pain and fatigue means you can't get out of bed (and certainly couldn't do a day's work while you're there). Unsurprisingly, employers don't want employees like me, who never know from one day - even one hour - to the next whether they'll be well enough to work. And that's even before we get to the costs of adaptations that may need to be made to workplaces to accommodate us.

I'm not infantilising disabled people. Just pointing out how absolutely ridiculous it is to expect bedbound people to work.

Klippetyklip · 02/08/2022 19:07

NopainNoGain65 · 02/08/2022 18:44

My friend lost his job because of this kind of scheme. He worked full time stacking shelves and earned minimum wage. Then the company took part in this scheme and had lots of people on benefits in working, who they did not have to pay a wage to. After a couple of months he was down to 4 hours a week, and then not on the rota at all due to lack of hours available. He had to claim benefits, where he was then given the opportunity to work in the same shop for his benefit money....which was 40 pound per week. It happened to all the full time employees in that particular branch who were not supervisor or managers.

I Imagine this happened a lot

merryhouse · 02/08/2022 19:03

Surely that's just "a job"?

Which - contrary to what many people may tell you - can be quite hard to get. You'd be better off persuading employers to employ people who've been out of the workplace for a while, or who have the wrong sort of accent, or who can't answer the competency and skills questions, or who appear over-qualified and under-trained, or who panic at the mere idea of phoning someone or trying to Make A Sale...

DrCoconut · 02/08/2022 19:01

YABVVVVVVU. Very. If work needs to be done then someone should be paid a fair wage to do it. Not forced to work for unemployment benefits because if you are working you are not unemployed. Not humiliated by the kind of community service usually reserved for criminals. That is gross exploitation of the poorest and most vulnerable and should be banned. I am not talking about genuine volunteering opportunities here which are great for building skills, experience etc. I mean companies taking on people forced into workfare on the cheap then getting rid of them for the next batch of victims rather than giving them a permanent job. Or government/council jobs being axed then filled by workfare. Anyone who is OK with this needs to have a think because with the level of instability in the country at the moment it could be them or their DC picking up dog turds in the park for £80 a week.

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 19:00

This thread again?

It didn't go so well for the op.last time..

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4602049-why-arent-people-on-benefits-be-asked-to-pick-fruit-why-bring-in-immigrants?latest=1