Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the able bodied / mind/ non carer/ non low wage s worker on benefits, benefit population that claim benefits should contribute somehow to the community/ get the money for WORK .

495 replies

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 15:16

Yes this may be costly to set up such as enhanced dbs checks etc.

I feel that this would both give a purpose and a contribution. And lead to jobs possibly/ develop cv / show work ethic.

In addition , it may stop the resentment and the benefit bashing if the claimants are seen to be contributing to society.

This is not necessarily a tory notion.
Karl Marxs idea about each to ones own ability... encompasses this idea of people working together for the whole of society accordi ng to ability. A quick google implies this is actually a socilaist idea of all doing what they can . This is what i am suggesting.

And before anyone says they would be pushed into things.. maybe there could be a choice of ways to contribute ,like on a data base.

Also, I am a cleaner myself. I literally clean poo off loos. I do not feel less worthy than others . I do the job because I can no longer work in my profession , as I get older, ( burnt out nhs) and see nothing but value in my ( ? Seen as some,lowly work). It gives me structure, a decent wage, and I contribute. All good. No shame in doing a good job , whatever that job if it is in my ability.

How can this idea, properly managed be other than reasonable. ?

OP posts:
JustLyra · 02/08/2022 20:40

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 20:22

Litter picking
planting municipal flowers
park maintenance
graffiti removal
grass stemming and cutting
and a whole host at f community work should also be available
This would ensure tax payers would see a benefit and prosperity in return for their financial support. The bad feeling would end over night.

And what happens to the people currently doing those jobs?

wallpoppy · 02/08/2022 20:40

@Festoonlights who is paying half of their salary to prop up the benefits system? The answer is no one, high rate tax payers pay 40% of part of their salary, so no one is paying more than 40% total. And the wealthy use tax breaks to pay far less as a percentage of their total income than the working class or middle class. And are you also one of those people who don’t use roads, schools, or the NHS? And do you plan on refusing your pension when the time comes? I hope so, otherwise you would be a massive, massive hypocrite.

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 20:40

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 20:25

Some people are already paying half of their salary to prop up the benefits. You would see a mass exodus if it was increased. We are already considering a move to a more affluent tax friendly option. I am not here to sustain the bloated welfare system!

Some people are paying tax.

Tax goes in to a huge pot.
The same pot that vat, inheritance, property, bed etc tax all do.

Then it's paid out to various places.
Education, defense, pensions, MPs wage, health care. So on and so on.

The unemployed get less than 2% of the total welfare bill.

If you're going to talk nonsense, at least look up your nonsense to make it as least nonsensical as you can.

To think the able bodied / mind/ non carer/ non  low wage s worker on benefits, benefit population that claim benefits should contribute somehow to the community/ get the money for  WORK .
RaininSummer · 02/08/2022 20:39

There are quite a few fit and well people not working I see them every day in my job. They often do have other barriers to work though such as transport, housing issues, education, experience and sometimes the fact that when young benefits seem enough money if living with family.

I don't think it's the worst idea in the world but not for benefit money. It would need to be paid properly. For example maybe a coach could pick people up at the job centre and take them to pick fruit or veg each day in season. Would take a lot of organising though and probably doesn't make economic sense.

It isn't good for young people to lounge about on benefits for years so maybe something more organised for them would help build confidence and experience as well as improving society in some way.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 02/08/2022 20:38

FromerGerman · 02/08/2022 17:56

Because it's so much better to have people who are sound of mind waste away while - what - watching telly?

Not sure Hawkins would have been happy with that...

I'm disabled. On the days I have to stay in bed because the pain is so bad, I'm dosed up with morphine so wouldn't be capable of doing any work. I struggle to even work the remote for the tv. Should i work during my more lucid moments?

Livelovebehappy · 02/08/2022 20:37

Mousemat25 · 02/08/2022 15:26

With the staggering number of people who don’t work due to I’ll health, i wonder why we don’t have a whole area of the NHS specifically looking at addressing these health problems and getting people back into work. It would more than pay for itself. Hi

Agree. Lots of people with depression, anxiety, phobias who could get help to return to work. I’ve never known as many people not working due to MH issues as there are now. Clearly something to be focused on.

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 20:28

NewBootsAndRanty · 02/08/2022 20:26

What happens to the people currently employed to do all that?

They lose their jobs, go on UC, then are forced to do their old jobs for £77pw.

It's genius, when you think about it. Think how the wage bills will be slashed and how profits will shoot up. I can totally see why employers would go for it.

onthefencesitter · 02/08/2022 20:28

Everyone I know who doesn't work full time is not working due to mental health problems/disability so not exactly able bodied.I don't actually know a healthy person who doesn't work full time. Other than mothers with young kids (but those fall under people with caring responsibilities). Also know a young person who was not working after graduation and hence claiming but she has gone abroad now (and is working).

FictionalCharacter · 02/08/2022 20:27

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 15:21

In my post I had hoped to make it clear that i was only talking about
Claimants that do not work,and claim .
I was also only applying this to those who are fit in body.and mind and have no carer responsibilities.etc

If they are not working but could, and they are fit and able, what benefits are they eligible for?

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 20:26

You need to start with a flexible, gentle employer and start slowly and build up. I worked afternoons only at the start, as I found I could manage better

I love the idea that you can tell your work coach 'Well actually, I'm going to need a flexible, gentle employer and I'm only going to work afternoons'. You'd be sanctioned before you'd finished speaking.

It's ridiculous comments like this that show how out of touch some people are. I take it you weren't on UC when you found your lovely gentle employer, @Festoonlights ?

And I bet, too, that you were paid a fair wage for the work you did. Unlike the free labour you're advocating here.

TheSummerPalace · 02/08/2022 20:26

Working actually improves mental health. Having purpose, support, direction, autonomy and a future with achievement is incredibly beneficial to well being.

That’s not what I see, having had to advise DD to take her employer to the Employment Tribunal several times for disability discrimination - ie not tackling bullying, harassment, and belittling (and that’s just her manager) several times!

NewBootsAndRanty · 02/08/2022 20:26

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 20:22

Litter picking
planting municipal flowers
park maintenance
graffiti removal
grass stemming and cutting
and a whole host at f community work should also be available
This would ensure tax payers would see a benefit and prosperity in return for their financial support. The bad feeling would end over night.

What happens to the people currently employed to do all that?

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 20:25

Also, I have worked in the past and been a tax payer. I never looked at someone on benefits and wondered what they could be doing to pay me back or whatever. That is weird.

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 20:25

Jux · 02/08/2022 20:20

This

Some people are already paying half of their salary to prop up the benefits. You would see a mass exodus if it was increased. We are already considering a move to a more affluent tax friendly option. I am not here to sustain the bloated welfare system!

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 20:24

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 20:22

Litter picking
planting municipal flowers
park maintenance
graffiti removal
grass stemming and cutting
and a whole host at f community work should also be available
This would ensure tax payers would see a benefit and prosperity in return for their financial support. The bad feeling would end over night.

Most of those are carried out by people who paid an actual wage to do it... or people on Community Service or whatever it is called now. The latter have committed a crime, so do it for nothing.
People on benefits have not committed a crime, and should not be expected to work for free.

Jux · 02/08/2022 20:22

NewBootsAndRanty · 02/08/2022 15:21

Do you mean workfare? Been done already.

And this

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 20:22

Litter picking
planting municipal flowers
park maintenance
graffiti removal
grass stemming and cutting
and a whole host at f community work should also be available
This would ensure tax payers would see a benefit and prosperity in return for their financial support. The bad feeling would end over night.

TooManyPJs · 02/08/2022 20:21

They are already expected to "work". If you are on UC with no health issues or caring responsibilities, you are expected to be job searching full-time.

If they were doing other "work" when would they be job searching?

If they were doing the traditionally low paid jobs, you'll be taking work away from someone that could be earning National Minimum Wage.

Are you aware that a single person under 25 with no children or health conditions receives £265 PER MONTH to live on. If they are over 25 they get £334. It's below subsistence level but you want them to do presumably menial tasks for it, taking a job away from someone else, and stopping them focusing on looking for an actual job?

Jux · 02/08/2022 20:21

ManateeFair · 02/08/2022 15:31

If there is suitable work available, people should be paid a full wage for it. They shouldn’t be doing a job and just getting ‘benefits’ instead of a salary. It’s not prison.

And this

Jux · 02/08/2022 20:20

alibongo5 · 02/08/2022 15:31

What about the mega rich contributing to society by paying higher taxes - as you say Marx said "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs". Or do you think it should only apply to poor people, not rich?

This

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 20:18

Northernsouloldies · 02/08/2022 20:10

It was send them to the fields to pick fruit yesterday promoted by the angry mob with flaming torches and here we are back at square one. I'm in the process of starting a claim for benefit and to the haters, I would give anything to be able to get a job. I usually say hope you never experience what it's like but actually I hope some of posters that spew vitriol on this subject, I hope you do and experience the feelings of degradation that having to claim brings.

💐

I'm so sorry you have to read this crap. And I hope things look up for you soon.

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 20:17

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 20:16

Get other workshy layabouts to do it for their £77pw! Two birds with one stone and all that!

Why pet food?
Feed it back to the work shy via mince at the foodbanks. Would make a nice spag bol.

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 20:16

BullshitHunter · 02/08/2022 19:58

Grind them up into pet food I say. That'll teach them.

Get other workshy layabouts to do it for their £77pw! Two birds with one stone and all that!

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 20:13

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 19:52

i think many more than you imagine offer flexibility. I say this as someone that was very ill as a young adult. Working transformed my life and self esteem. It was literally a life saver.
You need to start with a flexible, gentle employer and start slowly and build up. I worked afternoons only at the start, as I found I could manage better. Or work for yourself so you can choose the hours or days when you are feeling stronger.

You think wrong.

Northernsouloldies · 02/08/2022 20:10

It was send them to the fields to pick fruit yesterday promoted by the angry mob with flaming torches and here we are back at square one. I'm in the process of starting a claim for benefit and to the haters, I would give anything to be able to get a job. I usually say hope you never experience what it's like but actually I hope some of posters that spew vitriol on this subject, I hope you do and experience the feelings of degradation that having to claim brings.