Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the able bodied / mind/ non carer/ non low wage s worker on benefits, benefit population that claim benefits should contribute somehow to the community/ get the money for WORK .

495 replies

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 15:16

Yes this may be costly to set up such as enhanced dbs checks etc.

I feel that this would both give a purpose and a contribution. And lead to jobs possibly/ develop cv / show work ethic.

In addition , it may stop the resentment and the benefit bashing if the claimants are seen to be contributing to society.

This is not necessarily a tory notion.
Karl Marxs idea about each to ones own ability... encompasses this idea of people working together for the whole of society accordi ng to ability. A quick google implies this is actually a socilaist idea of all doing what they can . This is what i am suggesting.

And before anyone says they would be pushed into things.. maybe there could be a choice of ways to contribute ,like on a data base.

Also, I am a cleaner myself. I literally clean poo off loos. I do not feel less worthy than others . I do the job because I can no longer work in my profession , as I get older, ( burnt out nhs) and see nothing but value in my ( ? Seen as some,lowly work). It gives me structure, a decent wage, and I contribute. All good. No shame in doing a good job , whatever that job if it is in my ability.

How can this idea, properly managed be other than reasonable. ?

OP posts:
JustLyra · 02/08/2022 21:55

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 21:52

Ugh, PIP is SO hard to claim. You need a shit ton of evidence. No one, ever, has just said they are a bit sad so they never have to work again.

FFS, exactly where is it that people are getting this shit from?

Political rhetoric…

It’s crazy how people still think it’s so easy.
ny DD’s friend is going through appeal again for her uncontrolled narcolepsy. Apparently hitting the deck 20/30 times a day is “predictably unpredictable” 🙄
DD is fully expecting to have the same battle when her award is renewed (and she relies on the PIP to access transport to Uni).

Dalaidramailama · 02/08/2022 21:55

Well she’s a MH nurse by trade but works on the side too as a pip assessor I.e devil incarnate according to some.

Dalaidramailama · 02/08/2022 21:54

@JustLyra

Yes but some people will not work if they do manage to get PIP. It is difficult but not impossible. My sisters a MH nurse and regularly gives out the full amount for those with MH problems. With more income coming in there’s not an incentive to work when in actual fact work can be an integral factor in recovery enhancing self worth and social cohesion etc, even for those with severe and enduring MH diagnosis.

It is not the right thing for all people with MH problems mind but many people do fall into the helplessness trap.

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 21:52

The numbers of people just idley on benefits whilst able to work, especially long-term, are shockingly low yet seem to represent publically the face of all claimants. Its abhorrent how grossly misrepresented it all is. The vast majority are disabled or caring for the disabled.

The myth of the idle is how they’re going to slash benefits more and more.

Its exactly what happened to disability benefits. The myth of people with fake bad backs raking in £65822973 a month meant it was politically acceptable to attack them.

Same with the decimation of Widowed parents allowance. The whole “we want to make it easier for them to move in with new partners” giving them illusions that there was a fucktonne of widows and widowers pretending to stay single because of the dosh they were raking in meant (along with the over confidence that it would never happen to them) people said absolutely nothing about it.

Its always “Oh but we don’t mean genuine people” with absolutely not a single care for the genuine people who will absolutely bear the brunt of the cuts when they come.

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 21:52

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 21:48

Most just applied for PIP instead essentially using their MH diagnosis to not ever work.

PIP isn’t an out of work benefit.

Its also not something you can claim simply on the basis of a diagnosis. It’s also notoriously difficult to claim for mental health issues.

Ugh, PIP is SO hard to claim. You need a shit ton of evidence. No one, ever, has just said they are a bit sad so they never have to work again.

FFS, exactly where is it that people are getting this shit from?

GuyMontag · 02/08/2022 21:50

Is English your second language, OP?

PeekAtYou · 02/08/2022 21:50

There are people who do these jobs funded out of council tax. Are you suggesting that these people are made unemployed because the council can hire people at £77pw instead of NMW?

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 21:48

Most just applied for PIP instead essentially using their MH diagnosis to not ever work.

PIP isn’t an out of work benefit.

Its also not something you can claim simply on the basis of a diagnosis. It’s also notoriously difficult to claim for mental health issues.

Mumofsend · 02/08/2022 21:44

I would love to see more barriers reduced.

Get rid of zero hour contracts. They benefit employers, not those who need to provide for their family. Contracts should be clear on working hours and days. Overtime is optional. A person can plan childcare then. How does one plan childcare when expected to be free 7 days a week but may only get 6 hours work?

As a carer of a disabled child who is slowly falling into my own MH trap because I hate that I had to give up work and resent the system that makes it so difficult. Make it easier for carers to work. Ensure disabled children can actually access childcare. Ensure they aren't charged quadruple non-disabled children. Ensure the childcare can meet the child's needs.

If you want to push employers to employ more disabled people through wild initiatives, make sure they are properly funded, resourced and maintained. Some of the projects in theory sound brilliant, but aren't in anyway actually set up to succeed for employers or employees.

The numbers of people just idley on benefits whilst able to work, especially long-term, are shockingly low yet seem to represent publically the face of all claimants. Its abhorrent how grossly misrepresented it all is. The vast majority are disabled or caring for the disabled.

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 21:42

womaninatightspot · 02/08/2022 21:35

I do wonder given that pensioners are also such a big drain if we shouldn’t be sending them off to do park maintenance. Ffs

Sharpen up all four legs of their walking frames and they can litter pick 4 times faster than a man with just one spike.. 👍

Dalaidramailama · 02/08/2022 21:38

@womaninatightspot

I don’t resonate with this. My husband applied for a bin man job “on paper” with an agency but then when he turned up they got him street cleaning. There was definitely no 3 days worth of training that’s for sure. He was straight out picking up litter and god knows what else.

womaninatightspot · 02/08/2022 21:35

I do wonder given that pensioners are also such a big drain if we shouldn’t be sending them off to do park maintenance. Ffs

womaninatightspot · 02/08/2022 21:31

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 20:22

Litter picking
planting municipal flowers
park maintenance
graffiti removal
grass stemming and cutting
and a whole host at f community work should also be available
This would ensure tax payers would see a benefit and prosperity in return for their financial support. The bad feeling would end over night.

I work for the council and people are employed at These jobs. They actually work quite hard mainly for the real living wage of 9.90 an hour as the council subcontracts out to an agency. You need to be trained and equipped. For example a street sweeper does 3 days of training, mainly health and safety everything from how to move in order to protect your spine to sharps disposal. Then it costs a further 600 quid to give them safety clothing as per the councils risk assessment. You can’t just send people out the insurance will go nuts.

WisherWood · 02/08/2022 21:29

who is paying half of their salary to prop up the benefits system? The answer is no one, high rate tax payers pay 40% of part of their salary, so no one is paying more than 40% total.

Yes. These are the tax bands:

Personal Allowance Up to £12,570 0%
Basic rate £12,571 to £50,270 20%
Higher rate £50,271 to £150,000 40%
Additional rate over £150,000 45%

So only once you are earning over £50k a year do you start paying 40% tax and then only on that part of your salary. No-one pays 50% tax on their salary in the UK.

Namechange303333311 · 02/08/2022 21:17

No, I don’t think people getting £75 a week should have to work full time for it. Great way for companies to employee less staff and save on wages though.

suzyscat · 02/08/2022 21:15

Honestly I didn't care about benefits and claimants. The pension bill is normally significantly larger, MPs don't need their massive salary and such generous expenses + subsidies, tax avoidance bill is towering.

I was always proud to live in a country that supported those in need, although the system is far from adequate now.

Very few people want to live off so little and it's rare that happy, we'll adjusted people do long term anyway.

Why waste your time worrying about those living hand to mouth on benefits, I promise you they're not the reason the economy is in the mess it is in, or why many are feeling the pinch.

Festoonlights · 02/08/2022 21:10

Its not even started lakie - I genuinely worry about the winter and what is coming.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 02/08/2022 21:09

Most people on benefits work.

Even a lot of disabled benefits-claimants work.

Able-bodied benefits claimants who don't work have to spend a certain number of hours a week job-hunting and have to attend regular appointments at the job centre.

The idea that there are millions of fit healthy people lolling in front of the telly all day and living it large off benefits is a myth created and pushed by the right wing tabloids working on government orders in order to demonise and scapegoat poor people so that the general public won't blame those who are actually responsible for austerity and cost of living crisis, and cuts to services: corrupt wealthy Tories who give £££££££ deals to their mates and let huge companies get away with paying no tax.

It's exactly the same weaponised hatred they've aimed at immigrants, that they've aimed at disabled people. The people in power want you to hate those who are poorer and more vulnerable so you won't look at their own fuck ups and utter lies and corruption.

LakieLady · 02/08/2022 21:05

WhatdoImean · 02/08/2022 15:44

So..... the unemployed account for about 2% of the welfare bill. Let's target those instead of the pensioners who account for about 40-odd percent.

Might it not be better to target the rich, and get them to pay more money?

But of course.... how stupid of me... the national press do not tend to point out about how rich people can minimise their tax bills by (for example) leaving the EU.... So much easier to kick people who are down and target them.

If there is a job that needs doing, then it should be paid for, at the appropriate rate. If it does NOT need doing, then the work is being done as punishment for someone who is not in a job.

Beautifully put, @WhatdoImean .

There've been a few threads like this this week. I was beginning to think it was National Benefit-bashing Week or something.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/08/2022 20:56

I remember the work programme.

Many employers stopped hiring or giving appropriate payrises to their existing staff because they made money from having people sent by the jobcentre to do it instead - and they got to work fulltime for the employer but not receive a fulltime wage.

It also put a stop to a lot of volunteer opportunities for people who wanted to get experience in different areas - because a self motivated, interested volunteer didn't come with funding attached. And for those who did make the effort to volunteer began to find their volunteering was no longer looked upon as a good thing by prospective employers because it was assumed they only did it because the job centre said they had to.

In short, it didn't exactly help anybody except the companies who made money from it.

Dalaidramailama · 02/08/2022 20:45

@Mousemat25

There is a job for that and they’re called IPS employment specialists for people with MH conditions. It’s a terribly tough job as you often don’t hit your targets as you can lead the horse to water and all that jazz but you can’t make it drink?

That is despite a LOT of one to one help ans liaising with employers to find meaningful work for the individual and not just any old work programme.

Hawkins001 · 02/08/2022 20:45

One of the Karl Marx, quoted with context is as follows,

"From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs" (German: Jeder nach seinen Fähigkeiten, jedem nach seinen Bedürfnissen) is a slogan popularised by Karl Marx in his 1875 Critique of the Gotha Programme.[1][2] The principle refers to free access to and distribution of goods, capital and services.[3] In the Marxist view, such an arrangement will be made possible by the abundance of goods and services that a developed communist system will be capable to produce; the idea is that, with the full development of socialism and unfettered productive forces, there will be enough to satisfy everyone's needs"

Source Wikipedia

DizzyWhoreI804 · 02/08/2022 20:41

Livelovebehappy · 02/08/2022 20:37

Agree. Lots of people with depression, anxiety, phobias who could get help to return to work. I’ve never known as many people not working due to MH issues as there are now. Clearly something to be focused on.

If you mean MH provision needs urgent reform and investment, then yes.

The waiting list for CBT and other therapies where I am is two years. Imagine how people deteriorate in two years.

Also, it's worth remembering that you don't get sickness benefits simply for being a bit depressed. Only those who are profoundly mentally unwell will be getting any form of sickness benefit.

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 20:41

Livelovebehappy · 02/08/2022 20:37

Agree. Lots of people with depression, anxiety, phobias who could get help to return to work. I’ve never known as many people not working due to MH issues as there are now. Clearly something to be focused on.

I am unable to work due to MH issues. The only help I have had is to keep me out of hospital/A&E/police cells.
Being able to cope at home and stay out of the above environments does not mean I can walk into a full time job.
My job now is making sure I stay well.

Dalaidramailama · 02/08/2022 20:41

@Livelovebehappy

They usually can’t be helped. I used to work as an IPS employment specialist within secondary mental health and despite having quite a large caseload to help back into work, they never wanted to return due to their MH.

If you don’t want to help yourself the likelihood is no one else can help you. I lost count of the amount of times I helped people with their CVs, arranged interviews for work that would be meaningful for them etc and they simply didn’t want to turn up.
Most just applied for PIP instead essentially using their MH diagnosis to not ever work.