Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the able bodied / mind/ non carer/ non low wage s worker on benefits, benefit population that claim benefits should contribute somehow to the community/ get the money for WORK .

495 replies

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 15:16

Yes this may be costly to set up such as enhanced dbs checks etc.

I feel that this would both give a purpose and a contribution. And lead to jobs possibly/ develop cv / show work ethic.

In addition , it may stop the resentment and the benefit bashing if the claimants are seen to be contributing to society.

This is not necessarily a tory notion.
Karl Marxs idea about each to ones own ability... encompasses this idea of people working together for the whole of society accordi ng to ability. A quick google implies this is actually a socilaist idea of all doing what they can . This is what i am suggesting.

And before anyone says they would be pushed into things.. maybe there could be a choice of ways to contribute ,like on a data base.

Also, I am a cleaner myself. I literally clean poo off loos. I do not feel less worthy than others . I do the job because I can no longer work in my profession , as I get older, ( burnt out nhs) and see nothing but value in my ( ? Seen as some,lowly work). It gives me structure, a decent wage, and I contribute. All good. No shame in doing a good job , whatever that job if it is in my ability.

How can this idea, properly managed be other than reasonable. ?

OP posts:
Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/08/2022 22:58

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:56

And your experience is more in depth and prolific than the entirety of the DWP and the government?

I think not

They are clueless mostly.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/08/2022 22:57

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 22:51

Can you think of any other groups that would be so incessantly attacked, mocked and insulted?

If someone started a thread and called all back people lazy and feckless..
Or one calling all trans people lazy liars..

Poor, unemployed, disabled.. fair targets it seems.

No one is calling disabled people liars. Simply saying that people do lie stating they are disabled to increase their benefits.

This has been a trend since UC. Because its so low people have fallen to pip to increase their income. Can you always blame them ? No. But can they work often? Yes. Are they always disabled? No

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:57

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 22:51

Can you think of any other groups that would be so incessantly attacked, mocked and insulted?

If someone started a thread and called all back people lazy and feckless..
Or one calling all trans people lazy liars..

Poor, unemployed, disabled.. fair targets it seems.

Yep.

and always by people who have experiences that go completely against the facts found by charities, the DWP etc,

it’s remarkable…

Itdoesntreallymatter · 02/08/2022 22:56

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:48

The 4.5 billion was covid loan abuse - by businesses mostly.

Not by the unemployed claiming jobseekers.

Yup, businessmen and women are seemingly scroungers that lie too. Don't hear them getting slated though.

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:56

Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/08/2022 22:51

Not in my experience

And your experience is more in depth and prolific than the entirety of the DWP and the government?

I think not

Itdoesntreallymatter · 02/08/2022 22:52

I'm guessing this is a Tory idea being floated on MN to see the response. Possibles bots out today. Been a few of these threads today rummaging for people's opinions about people on benefits and the general consensus is the OP is over simplifying a complicated problem and needs to do more research, so maybe you could tell Truss and Sunak that they are oversimplified their policies and are lazy minded.

Don't even hide the above very well. Glaringly obvious.

MissMaple82 · 02/08/2022 22:52

What's with the massive, inconsistant paragraph breaks?

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 22:51

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:49

Bugger cut off my post too soon

Yet it’s the unemployed and disabled that are under attack. Again.

Can you think of any other groups that would be so incessantly attacked, mocked and insulted?

If someone started a thread and called all back people lazy and feckless..
Or one calling all trans people lazy liars..

Poor, unemployed, disabled.. fair targets it seems.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/08/2022 22:51

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:45

The governments own figures state that only 0.5% of disability claims are affected by error and fraud.

There are simply not a fuck tonne of false Pip or ESA claims. It’s a myth pushed along by those that want the public go ahead to slash benefits for all.

Not in my experience

Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/08/2022 22:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:49

Bugger cut off my post too soon

Yet it’s the unemployed and disabled that are under attack. Again.

WisherWood · 02/08/2022 22:48

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 22:33

WisherWood you say it is the fact that people have to show they have applied for jobs etc. ..that is true , but are you are aware that some people dont want to work and when they have applied for jobs to get the benefit folk off theirback they intentionally mess up the interview as they dont want to work.
? It happens ,it really does .

So what are you going to do? Are you going to design the welfare state around a very small minority of people, who will work around any system you put in place anyway? Bearing in mind that by doing so, you put the majority who actually need the help in a nearly impossible situation. You punish them for what they are not doing. You push them to the edge, and sometimes right the way over.

Or are you going to design a system that assumes that most people actually do want to work. That helps people to find work. That treats them with basic humanity and decency, and helps lift them out of poverty? And yes, there will still be a few who take advantage. But A. they will do that whatever system is in place and B. none of what they get up to is half as fucking corrupt or costs anywhere near as much money as is siphoned off by the kleptocracy we currently live in.

I mean, you can spew all this hate filled nonsense all you like, but I will always be of the belief that a society should be judged by how it treats its supposedly weakest members. And if it decides to throw them to the wolves, on the off chance that someone somewhere diddles the system, then I will always fight to have it changed.

We need a welfare state that helps people. We are all entitled to this. It is not scrounging. It is basic care and decency.

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:48

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 22:45

Ot might happen.. but it's not a common occurrence because the Job Coaches will contact employers and ask why the prospective employee failed the interview.

My job coach has called several of the employer's I've I reviewed for and asked for.feedback on my.behalf.

And even if some do fall through the cracks, out of the tiny percentage of long term u employed and even small percentage will be falling through the cracks. A tiny percentage of a tiny percentage.. it would amount to a hill of piss to punish these people.
The government literally waste and wipe off billions of pounds every year.. or, lets put it this way.

I January the government wrote off 4.9billion lost to fraud..

4.9Billion
343 a month x 12 = yearly cost of 1 unemployed person.
4.9 billion divided by that yearly cost..
1190476.19048 years of paying an unemployed person..

The 4.5 billion was covid loan abuse - by businesses mostly.

Not by the unemployed claiming jobseekers.

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:45

Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/08/2022 22:18

Disabled people are not lazy grifters.

Those people who PRETEND to be disabled are. There's a difference.

Plenty of disabled people work.

Plenty of liars don't.

The governments own figures state that only 0.5% of disability claims are affected by error and fraud.

There are simply not a fuck tonne of false Pip or ESA claims. It’s a myth pushed along by those that want the public go ahead to slash benefits for all.

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 22:45

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 22:33

WisherWood you say it is the fact that people have to show they have applied for jobs etc. ..that is true , but are you are aware that some people dont want to work and when they have applied for jobs to get the benefit folk off theirback they intentionally mess up the interview as they dont want to work.
? It happens ,it really does .

Ot might happen.. but it's not a common occurrence because the Job Coaches will contact employers and ask why the prospective employee failed the interview.

My job coach has called several of the employer's I've I reviewed for and asked for.feedback on my.behalf.

And even if some do fall through the cracks, out of the tiny percentage of long term u employed and even small percentage will be falling through the cracks. A tiny percentage of a tiny percentage.. it would amount to a hill of piss to punish these people.
The government literally waste and wipe off billions of pounds every year.. or, lets put it this way.

I January the government wrote off 4.9billion lost to fraud..

4.9Billion
343 a month x 12 = yearly cost of 1 unemployed person.
4.9 billion divided by that yearly cost..
1190476.19048 years of paying an unemployed person..

JustLyra · 02/08/2022 22:42

Dalaidramailama · 02/08/2022 22:02

@JustLyra

Depends on how long you’ve been doing the job and if your manager respects your opinion enough not to go against your recommendations. Takes a very strong character plus a LONG time in the role to challenge those from above mind.

The decision makers are not the managers of the assessors. They don’t even work in the same places.

Meadowland · 02/08/2022 22:41

YANBU

Dalaidramailama · 02/08/2022 22:41

@JemimaPuddlegoose

What usually happens is the care coordinator refers to the IPS specialist within the community MH team what they believe to be a good candidate. Except sometimes they don’t have the “belief” that certain service users have the capacity to work. This is when the IPS specialist has to put their foot down and make it known that even those with incredibly severe MH issues can (and do work). The IPS model has to be embedded into every MH team now so it might be worth actually mentioning it to your care coordinator. For some service users it’s been revolutionary and reduced hospital admissions.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/08/2022 22:40

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 22:33

WisherWood you say it is the fact that people have to show they have applied for jobs etc. ..that is true , but are you are aware that some people dont want to work and when they have applied for jobs to get the benefit folk off theirback they intentionally mess up the interview as they dont want to work.
? It happens ,it really does .

Yes my husband will get tons of applicants. Set up 2 days of interviews. Sometimes 1 person might show up.
People in this country are lazy. The pay is crap but people are still lazy. I'd work for crap pay because sitting at home is enough to make you go mad anyway.

I've supported people with cancer trying and failing to get pip while others with absolutely nothing wrong with them get back paid thousands.

If you think that's right you need a good shake

XenoBitch · 02/08/2022 22:39

Dalaidramailama · 02/08/2022 22:23

@JemimaPuddlegoose

Well they certainly do want people with mental health conditions in the workplace even those with severe and enduring psychotic conditions. It’s in the NHS long term plan and it is why employment specialists are now embedded into secondary MH teams so that they have access to personalised support that could help them with their recovery. For some employment has totally transformed their MH and kept them out of hospital. There’s a lot of research now on how effective the IPS model is at assisting those with poor MH back into the workplace.

I have MH conditions and
got managed out from the NHS (and it is HARD to get sacked from the NHS).
And when I tried to retrain and get back in, I got regarded as unfit for my HCP placement, and then kicked from uni. Mental health reasons again.
I did absolutely fucking try.
I was under CMHT for years... it was all about keeping me out of hospital and A&E. When I was stable enough for that, I was discharged.
There is no funding or staff now to get people back into work.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 02/08/2022 22:37

Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/08/2022 22:30

Then you should be outraged that people lie in order to claim benefits for people who really are affected by disability

I simply don't believe you are telling the truth. I know from personal experience that what you are saying is lies.

Please answer my question: where are all the actual disabled people????

According to you only 1% of all PIP claimants are actually disabled. So where are all the actual disabled people?

Are you claiming that all disabled people are actually in work??

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/08/2022 22:35

If there's a job that needs doing then pay a living wage.

Why should people work for under the nmw and take jobs from other people?

This!

why no just give someone the job if it needs doing, for a living wage?

Why have a benefits middleman whereby the person doing the work wouldn’t have a proper contract, pay, rights etc?

Crikeymaccrikey · 02/08/2022 22:33

WisherWood you say it is the fact that people have to show they have applied for jobs etc. ..that is true , but are you are aware that some people dont want to work and when they have applied for jobs to get the benefit folk off theirback they intentionally mess up the interview as they dont want to work.
? It happens ,it really does .

OP posts:
JemimaPuddlegoose · 02/08/2022 22:33

Dalaidramailama · 02/08/2022 22:23

@JemimaPuddlegoose

Well they certainly do want people with mental health conditions in the workplace even those with severe and enduring psychotic conditions. It’s in the NHS long term plan and it is why employment specialists are now embedded into secondary MH teams so that they have access to personalised support that could help them with their recovery. For some employment has totally transformed their MH and kept them out of hospital. There’s a lot of research now on how effective the IPS model is at assisting those with poor MH back into the workplace.

I have psychosis and bipolar disorder in addition to being mobility impaired and I have never, ever even heard of this in my many years of engagement with NHS mental health services.

Where I live you get an antidepressant prescription chucked at you, maybe six sessions of talk therapy, and then you're on your own unless you have an episode of acute psychosis when you get locked up and sedated then chucked out.

I attempted suicide last year and was officially a missing person, had my door kicked in by police and was taken to A&E only to be then dumped in the waiting room for several hours, and they finally told me to go home without seeing any MH specialist because there was no duty psychiatrist available. It took something like 8 months to get my first assessment with a psychiatrist after that, and all I've been offered is drugs and some kind of online course about the importance of going to bed at the same time every night!

Not one word has ever been said about my job or career, they seem to want me to stop working and go on benefits!

Bednobsbroomsticks · 02/08/2022 22:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.