Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be a bit upset by my best friend..

89 replies

groovyychick · 02/08/2022 12:59

My best friends baby is getting christened soon and I am a godparent. I have 2 children and has been with my partner 10 years but we separated 6 months ago. We have recently decided to give it another go, spend time as a family etc. my children are 5 and 10 months respectively.
My eldest really wants to come to the christening, so I asked if their dad could come with us, meaning that all 4 of us could go and have a day as a family. Meaning I wouldn't have to leave DS sat with strangers if I have to go up to the front of the church.
She outright said no. Because she doesn't like how he treated me. Granted he was a shit to me but I was no Angel either. She said her partner thinks we are a joke. He didn't want me as godmother either as he said I wouldn't provide a stable home and had enough on my plate. I have more savings than my friend does, I've brought up 2 children, I'm working. He seems very judgemental.
It means either it's just me and DS who will be on his own at times or I go alone.
I'm keeping the peace and going regardless but am I unreasonable to be a bit upset secretly??

OP posts:
TeddybearBaby · 02/08/2022 17:23

Was you directing that at me @MacKenzieMcHale?

If so in answer to your question judging your friends won’t make them behave in the way you want, it will just make them not be able to confide in you.

I had it myself recently op so I totally get where your friend is coming from. I HATE my friends husband, I think he’s a massive narcissistic prick but I never want my friend to feel stupid or small. I’m always honest with her but me putting my opinions on her and her choices won’t make her suddenly do what I think she should. It’s none of my business anyway, I’m not in her relationship.

SmileyClare · 02/08/2022 17:13

It seems like an over reaction to your friend telling you she doesn't like how your partner treated you and doesn't want him at an event.

I guess your kids won't have God parents then?

Why not calm down and make a decision when you're feeling more rational.

There's a danger you may become very isolated if you cut off anyone who expresses disapproval of your dp's behaviour.

MacKenzieMcHale · 02/08/2022 17:12

How has she handled it badly? She doesn't want her friend's cheating sexting prick of an ex at a happy event. Sounds like a decent friend to me.

TeddybearBaby · 02/08/2022 17:07

What a shame! You must have been good friends to have chosen each other to be godparents.

Sounds like you were having a terrible time and your partner acted like an arse (as did you) but your friend probably saw you suffering and can’t stand the thought of you being back with this guy.

She hasn’t handled it well at all. It’s hard to know I guess but just feels sad really.

groovyychick · 02/08/2022 16:54

Thank you everyone. I think I'm probably not going to go at all, and we probably both need to find new friends.

OP posts:
RubyandPearl · 02/08/2022 16:01

Why is a five year old so keen to go to a christening anyway? They're boring enough for grown ups tbh. Your friend is not obliged to invite anyone to her child's christening. The whole point of being a god parent is to provide lifelong support anyway it shouldn't just be about the ceremony itself. If you can't commit to thar then maybe you should reconsider being god parent?

TeapotTitties · 02/08/2022 15:56

groovyychick · 02/08/2022 14:28

@Hoppinggreen because he barely knows me and judges me.

I'd be judging you too if there was a chance you were going to be Godmother to my child.

MacKenzieMcHale · 02/08/2022 15:56

Your friend's child's christening isn't an excuse for you to have 'a family day out'.

It doesn't sound to me like you're properly back together, so all this 'now I can't have a day with my family' stuff seems a bit dramatic. If you're not living as a family why should everyone else pretend that nothing has changed?

SmileyClare · 02/08/2022 15:50

Pinkdelight3 · 02/08/2022 15:14

*He isn't her husband and they didn't even live together when she got pregnant, so they aren't perfect either.

You think badly of them because they've not married and didn't move in before the pregnancy?🤨*

Well exactly! That might alarm a Victorian, but it's hardly up there with sending sexy pics and shagging another guy when your DC is 5mo. Live how you like, but don't complain about people judging you when you're in a v pot/kettle situation.

Honestly, if you want to stay friends, you've got to stop making this about your partners, at least one of whom is unlikely to last. If you get all tit for tat angry about how her DP is as bad as your DP (he doesn't sound like), you can't win - no one will win, you'll just blow the whole thing up. And then when you split again, she won't be there for you.

This is great advice.

Her opinion of your partner/ex is formed on the basis of what you've told her.

Sorry but you're being very petty and prepared to wreck the friendship over this, which of course leaves both your dc without godparents.

I mean how can you be a god parent if you're not speaking? Grin

Think about what's important here.

I get the impression the christening is just an excuse for a party and no one is taking the God parent thing very seriously. Most people don't these days unless very religious, God fearing Christians?
Your judgement of your friend's life choices, playing tit for tat is playground stuff and pretty hurtful if she has been there for you during your break up.

OnaBegonia · 02/08/2022 15:27

A 5 yr old ' really wants to go' to a christening? There's a word called NO, go yourself.

ManateeFair · 02/08/2022 15:22

He isn't her husband and they didn't even live together when she got pregnant, so they aren't perfect either.

Although they apparently do have a stable relationship that doesn’t involve sexting and sleeping with other people, so they seem to have a healthier relationship than you, perhaps.

ManateeFair · 02/08/2022 15:18

groovyychick · 02/08/2022 13:07

He was just an arsehole with me really. He was sexting someone behind my back. I was texting someone myself who I then started sleeping with well started a relationship with once we broke up. So we're as bad as each other in some respects.

You know the role of a godparent is to be there to give the kid spiritual and moral guidance, don’t you? I’m not a Christian but based on that I can see why your friend’s DH isn’t that keen on you being godmother. It isn’t about what job you have or how many children you’ve got.

Your relationship has been chaotic, you’ve been unfaithful to each other, all while your second child was barely more than a newborn, and your friend has listened to all your difficulties, and you’re now expecting her to support round two as if nothing’s happened.

With regards to your ex coming to the christening, they should absolutely not feel they have to have a man they detest present at their child’s special life event.

You say your 5-year-old wants to come - but if they can’t sit on a pew and watch on their own for the few minutes you’ll be standing at the font during the ceremony, they’re probably a bit young for it anyway. A christening is a full church service; it’s not a scintillating occasion for a 5-year-old to sit through so I don’t think they’re missing out by staying home with their dad.

KL29 · 02/08/2022 15:17

You don’t sound like someone who I’d want to be my child’s godmother.

MzHz · 02/08/2022 15:16

peaceandharmonyinalltheworlddd · 02/08/2022 13:21

I completely agree with her DH.

Me too tbh

Pinkdelight3 · 02/08/2022 15:14

*He isn't her husband and they didn't even live together when she got pregnant, so they aren't perfect either.

You think badly of them because they've not married and didn't move in before the pregnancy?🤨*

Well exactly! That might alarm a Victorian, but it's hardly up there with sending sexy pics and shagging another guy when your DC is 5mo. Live how you like, but don't complain about people judging you when you're in a v pot/kettle situation.

Honestly, if you want to stay friends, you've got to stop making this about your partners, at least one of whom is unlikely to last. If you get all tit for tat angry about how her DP is as bad as your DP (he doesn't sound like), you can't win - no one will win, you'll just blow the whole thing up. And then when you split again, she won't be there for you.

Summerslam · 02/08/2022 15:13

With all due respect, I wouldn't want you as a godparent to my child, either. You don't sound as if you have a moral compass and I wouldn't want you to have any influence over my child's life.

I would suggest to your friend that she finds someone more suitable to be godmother.

SmileyClare · 02/08/2022 15:13

He said I wouldn't provide a stable home (as a god parent)

This is a myth, a god parent doesn't become the child's guardian in the event of the parent's death.

To be blunt, this all sounds like unnecessary drama, just respect your friend's decision and don't spoil the day with bad feeling.

I doubt your ds would enjoy the day, particularly if he doesn't know anyone..you say he'll be sitting with strangers.

It's a mistake to involve friends in the details of a messy break up and essentially force them to take a (your) side. You've told them some dreadful things about your partner so of course they're not going to welcome him with open arms.

MichelleScarn · 02/08/2022 15:00

He isn't her husband and they didn't even live together when she got pregnant, so they aren't perfect either.

You think badly of them because they've not married and didn't move in before the pregnancy?🤨

user1471457751 · 02/08/2022 14:56

Have you posted about this recently? There was a poster who was upset about a christening and the same issue of 'stability' was there.

Either way, I can understand your friends reluctance. You can't tell her about all the shit things your partner has done to you and then expect her to play nice with him

groovyychick · 02/08/2022 14:54

easyday · 02/08/2022 14:46

You have behaved badly as has your partner. All they have done is had a child while not living together so you think they 'are not perfect either'. Of course no one is perfect but your ideas seem skewed.
It's their baby's christening and she obviously cares about you to ask you to be godmother - and do you know what that mean? It's not the same as guardian, it is someone who will help raise the child in the faith to which it is being christened in the strictest sense, and to be a special person in their life in a looser sense.
But you obviously do not hold her in the same esteem nor does it sound like you'd be a good godmother anyway.
Aside from that why can't your five year old remain seated? You are only going up a few yards from where he'll be. You can carry your baby.

She is my son's godmother so I do hold her in the same esteem. It was me who told her that godmother isn't the same as guardian, which is when he changed his mind about me being one.

OP posts:
Thatboymum · 02/08/2022 14:49

I think it sounds like you have a great honest friend who cares about you a lot and as others have said just because you are ready to forgive him doesn’t mean they are. It’s their child’s day and I wouldn’t want somebody I didn’t like at my event I think they are being honest and reasonable which is a rare quality. I’d rather have a friend be bluntly honest than humour me

easyday · 02/08/2022 14:46

You have behaved badly as has your partner. All they have done is had a child while not living together so you think they 'are not perfect either'. Of course no one is perfect but your ideas seem skewed.
It's their baby's christening and she obviously cares about you to ask you to be godmother - and do you know what that mean? It's not the same as guardian, it is someone who will help raise the child in the faith to which it is being christened in the strictest sense, and to be a special person in their life in a looser sense.
But you obviously do not hold her in the same esteem nor does it sound like you'd be a good godmother anyway.
Aside from that why can't your five year old remain seated? You are only going up a few yards from where he'll be. You can carry your baby.

SuperCamp · 02/08/2022 14:41

A godparent is there to help guide them through life and, strictly speaking, be a better Christian.

Generally gauged more on things like family values, faith, marriage vows etc than how big your savings account is?

With all this Christening going on, are you and your friend actual Christians?

I’m not, and so wouldn’t have my child Christened, or act as godparent in a religious service.

Ginnypotter44 · 02/08/2022 14:40

Her husband sounds like a bit of a dickhead but your friend has a point. The amount of times my friend got back with her abusive ex was so frustrating. I hated him and wouldn't have wanted him at any sort of event to do with my dc either.

However the comment about him not wanting you as godmother was unnecessary. She didn't have to tell you that and if it were me I would be inclined to say that I wouldn't do it, it's meant to be a joint decision and he clearly doesn't like you.

RedRec · 02/08/2022 14:29

You don't seem to get it. You can explain / make excuses here until you are blue in the face but they don't. want. you. there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread