Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's silly to refuse a C Section?

133 replies

sandradailey · 02/08/2022 12:38

I have been attending an NCT class didn't have one in my area with DA

I've made a good friend who has a friend who's joined us recently.

We were talking about birth plans (and how they probably won't go to plan), and her friend said 'the only thing I'm saying on there is 'NO Section'

I said what do you mean, she said 'I will refuse a section'. I said but what if it's an emergency for example baby is in distress? She said 'nope, I won't have one. Simple as that. No section means no section. I may consider it if I'm dying from something like dramatic blood loss but otherwise, no. What'll be will be with the pregnancy itself'

The conversation then moved on but AIBU to think it's a bit silly to say no section whatsoever? So many variables can happen at birth Confused

OP posts:
CoalCraft · 02/08/2022 14:13

cestlavielife · 02/08/2022 12:40

She will chsnge her mind
When it s c section or yourbaby dies
Do not argue
Just smile and nod

I'd have assumed the same, but I read a case report recently about locked twin syndrome, where twins get locked at the neck/chin so that their heads are entangled and neither can enter the birth canal. It's extremely rare and when it does happen it's easily resolved with a section, but without a section it's ALWAYS fatal for at least one of the babies, usually both, and often the mother too.

And yet the mother in this report flat out refused a section, even as the babies' stats dipped and sadly finally showed that both had died. Ultimately she delivered the first baby breech and that one then had to be physically separated through horrible means from their twin so that the twin could also be delivered.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 02/08/2022 14:12

In my experience obstetrics and midwifery are so overly medicalised

I had the opposite issue. Took me 81 hours of broken waters, in agony as dc1 smashed his head into my sciatic nerve to convince them he was stuck. I had to get to full dilation and then push for 4 hours before they'd accept my diagnosis was correct. Turns out my suboptimal pelvis (flatter than normal) plus his giant head weren't a great match.

5 hours later, I got out of bed and got dressed. Never seen a midwife move so fast. Apparently you aren't meant to get out of bed without support.

NamelessBaby1 · 02/08/2022 14:05

Hugasauras · 02/08/2022 13:22

Also I listened to my baby's heart rate slow so much it basically stopped, and I saw the staff in theatre exchange some very panicked looks in those agonising seconds before it started up again. If anyone can listen to that and watch that and not agree to whatever the doctors said ASAP then they are an odd type of human. I've never felt fear like it.

Had this experience just last Monday, after a fairly rapid labour. It was awful hearing hear heart rate drop every time a contraction happened. I managed to get away with a forceps delivery, but a section was next and as much as I'd wanted to avoid it I would have done absolutely anything to make sure my wee one was safe and well!

FarmerRefuted · 02/08/2022 14:01

I've had a great section, textbook, recovered well.

I've also had a section where I haemorrhaged, developed sepsis, had a further haemorrhage, and was unwell for quite some time after.

No one with capacity to consent should be forced to have medical procedures they don't want (and even those who do not have mental capacity should only undergo procedures that are in their own best interests).

itssquidstella · 02/08/2022 13:57

*it's

itssquidstella · 02/08/2022 13:56

@Teaandcakeordeath83 my section wasn't awful. Yeah okay, it was major surgery and that's never a walk in the park, but I was pain free from about a week after birth, exercising again after six weeks and now at ten weeks postpartum I feel almost totally back to normal and my body is well on its way to being back to normal too - I’m looking forward to starting running again in a week or two.

Everyone's experience is different and its unfair scaremongering to state baldly that EVERY c section is awful. It's statements like that which put women at risk by making them frightened to have one even when it's needed.

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 02/08/2022 13:53

I had two "emergency" sections which where both horrific for entirely different reasons and turns out neither where actually an emergency. My third was a home birth. Like your NCT friend I had said that for my third the only time I would consider even stepping foot in the hospital, let alone the theatre would be in the case of immediate threat to life.

Sections have their place, either for women who choose them or situations that require them, but too often the criteria for them are set on really shitty research. You only have to look at the Cochrane database systemic reviews to see how poor the quality of research in women's health and pregnancy is.

In my experience obstetrics and midwifery are so overly medicalised. I don't blame her for not wanting a section. They're bloody awful.

To those posters suggesting that doctors would just perform a section anyway. Seriously, you're advocating that a fully competent and informed woman has medical treatment that she does not want forced on her?! Wow. This is exactly the mentality that is wrong with maternity care. That women are vessels to have care done to them and be told (and comply) with what to do.

itssquidstella · 02/08/2022 13:53

@Fluffygreenslippers I’m sorry you had that experience. That was one of the situations I wanted to avoid when I requested my c-section (that, and DS's heart rate was going a bit skew whiff and I wasn't going to hang around to watch it get worse). I’m so grateful that the medical team were supportive. Did you get a debrief afterwards where you were able to discuss the rationale for their refusal?

Felixsmama · 02/08/2022 13:51

I had a natural textbook delivery. I was left with urge incontinence and repeated bladder irritation. I think my labour damaged my bladder as I laboured mostly at home arrived at 10cm . Issues post natural delivery aren't talked about I'd have a c section next time as I wouldn't want to be left in nappies.

FarmerRefuted · 02/08/2022 13:51

someone I know was telling me recently that hospital staff had this discussion with the partner of a friend of hers when things were looking very serious. It’s possible he exaggerated slightly when he told the story though, I guess

They would never ask a partner to choose which one to save. Could you imagine the guilt and emotional trauma? The medical team would make such decisions based on clinical presentations, that's what they're trained for. The life of the woman would always be prioritised as she is the patient, the baby doesn't become a patient until it is born at which point it would be handed off to its own medical team and the initial medical team would carry on their work with the woman (at emergency sections there will be staff there specifically for the baby once it is born). If the woman was too far gone (e.g., already past the point of survival/already dead) then focus would switch to getting the baby out.

Fluffygreenslippers · 02/08/2022 13:49

I wish I had has a section rather than a theatre delivery with forceps and a bloody 4 inch long episiotomy. I asked them and was shut down. I lost so much blood (saw it all over the floor when I was wheeled out, had to have 2 transfusions) and the stirrups I was put in made my spd worse and i’m now half crippled. Would have loved a lovely calm fucking section.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 02/08/2022 13:49

I don’t think anyone LIKES the idea of major abdominal surgery. But the fear that takes hold when you hear your baby’s heart beat weakening during labour is like no fear I’ve ever felt before.

I’m usually very analytical and like to make fact-based and data-driven decisions. But at the moment in my first labour, when the obstetrical resident came up to me and said “I’d like to discuss the idea of a C-Section. There are a few risks you need to know before giving consent.” I pretty much shouted “no discussion needed, I consent, let’s go, let’s go, let’s go”.

Thankfully my mum calmed me (and the poor resident!) down and my DD was born vaginally about 10 minutes later. My DD was completely fine, but I’m painfully aware that things might not have ended so well had my contractions not sped up considerably towards the end. I was ready to pounce on that C-section if that’s what the baby needed.

glamourousindierockandroll · 02/08/2022 13:49

Very immature outlook.

I didn't want a C section (simply due to the longer recovery time, not for ideological reasons) and thankfully didn't need one, but I would not have hesitated for a moment if there was a risk to either me or the baby.

Wouldloveanother · 02/08/2022 13:48

Of course it’s silly but I doubt she will see it through. It sounds like she’s been on those Mother Earth type websites. She’ll see sense if she’s actually in that position.

Felixsmama · 02/08/2022 13:45

Is she a FTM? Many have a fixed idea of what their labour will be like when in fact we have little control. It's a roll of a dice if it turns out well. I'm sure she will change her mind while actually in labour.

iolaus · 02/08/2022 13:44

I remember once seeing a CTG where you could see the baby dying - it was horrendous (and it was being reviewed as a learning objective - all anonymised - and being asked when you would have intervened - I think every single person was saying they'd have intervened about 6 hours before the birth (which was about 20 minutes after the heart rate vanished for the last time) we were told by someone who had been there on the actual day - all the staff had been pleading with her (some in tears) because they all knew they were watching that baby die but couldn't convince her to change her mind, and in the UK the fetus has no rights until birth

itssquidstella · 02/08/2022 13:42

Bloody hell. My only non-negotiable was 'no high forceps'; I really wanted a natural birth but when things started to go a bit wrong I actually requested a c-section rather than risk putting DS in danger.

It was fine, and if I have another baby I'll have to think quite carefully about whether I even want to try a VBAC or just go straight for an ELCS.

I can't believe she'd be willing to risk her own baby's life rather than have medically necessary caesarean. Does she have significant body image issues and is worried about the impact of surgery on the appearance of her stomach? I'll be honest and say this was (and still is) a big concern for me - but not more of a concern than my baby's safety!

bangersandsmashhh · 02/08/2022 13:40

People say lots of things until they are physically in labour they won’t know what they’ll do
I didn’t want pain relief 😂 oh how I changed my mind pretty bloody quick

NeedMoreMilk · 02/08/2022 13:39

checking123456 · 02/08/2022 12:52

Hopefully this is one of those situations she is never in.

Similar to those people who tell their husbands and birthing partners to save the baby over themselves if that's the choice. Those choices would never really crop up so hopefully no need to test that!

I always thought this was the case (the woman is the patient until the baby is born, so their priority is to her) but someone I know was telling me recently that hospital staff had this discussion with the partner of a friend of hers when things were looking very serious. It’s possible he exaggerated slightly when he told the story though, I guess.

I’m fairly certain she’d change her mind if it actually came to it OP, but to be honest I find it quite disturbing that she’s even thinking it. I’d avoid as much as possible!

Youdoyoutoday · 02/08/2022 13:39

To be honest, I was scared of having a c-section when pregnant but a friend of mine had a selective one and said it all went well. I think I was more scared of the recovery than the actual procedure itself, I think I read some horror stories and it put me right off so didn't really research it properly! Bit like googling symptoms and coming to the realisation that it must be cancer! 🤦‍♀️

I didn't need one for either of my births but I would have to save my babies.

It's very strange to go through a pregnancy with her attitude though, no vaginal birth = equals no baby!! That's very extreme

neshtastic · 02/08/2022 13:36

sandradailey · 02/08/2022 12:42

Yes that's exactly what she's saying, she wants to refuse a section at all costs unless her own life is at risk. Is baby can pass away and she's still able to go for a vaginal delivery of baby, she will

I very much doubt that what's she saying

neshtastic · 02/08/2022 13:36

cestlavielife · 02/08/2022 12:40

She will chsnge her mind
When it s c section or yourbaby dies
Do not argue
Just smile and nod

100% this

undecided112 · 02/08/2022 13:35

That's ridiculous. I understand a lot of people prefer a natural birth but I simply can't understand why you'd decline a section if the baby was in distress. Did she give a reason?

Wishyfishy · 02/08/2022 13:35

When I was giving birth there was an emergency and I was wheeled to Theatre for an emergency c section. I would have had it if it had come to it but in Theatre they agreed to give me an extra 5 minutes to see if we could get the baby out vaginally, which I did manage with seconds to go.

A straight refusal of a c section I don’t understand but trying to avoid one if you possibly can, I do understand.

Parsnips88 · 02/08/2022 13:34

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 02/08/2022 13:23

Surely if the chance of the baby dying is high, the doctors will do a c section regardless of her demands?

If that's not the case and she's that uncaring about her baby before it's born, that child has no hope.

In the UK the foetus has no rights until it is born, so the doctors and midwives cannot perform a c-section without the woman’s consent, as long as she is found to have capacity. As a midwife I have begged a woman to consent to a c-section as we could hear her baby slipping away. Thankfully she eventually consented and the baby survived but it’s an awful situation for everyone involved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread