Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's silly to refuse a C Section?

133 replies

sandradailey · 02/08/2022 12:38

I have been attending an NCT class didn't have one in my area with DA

I've made a good friend who has a friend who's joined us recently.

We were talking about birth plans (and how they probably won't go to plan), and her friend said 'the only thing I'm saying on there is 'NO Section'

I said what do you mean, she said 'I will refuse a section'. I said but what if it's an emergency for example baby is in distress? She said 'nope, I won't have one. Simple as that. No section means no section. I may consider it if I'm dying from something like dramatic blood loss but otherwise, no. What'll be will be with the pregnancy itself'

The conversation then moved on but AIBU to think it's a bit silly to say no section whatsoever? So many variables can happen at birth Confused

OP posts:
AngelinaFibres · 02/08/2022 15:24

Gruffling · 02/08/2022 12:48

If only it was that easy :(

This natural birth bullshit sets women up to fail. You watch your baby almost die and be rushed off to NICU because she won't breathe and then, on top of all of that trauma, you get judgemental comments because your birth was not 'natural'.

I had my first baby by cesarean. He was breech and fully engaged wrong way up. I was happy he was born alive and not massively brain damaged. My NCT leader phoned to check on me. When I explained I had had had a section she said "Oh dear, never mind. Still you can do it properly next time". That baby is 30 this year. Her comment pops into my head now and again. Silly cunt.

Philandbill · 02/08/2022 15:19

@ChagSameachDoreen it's the woman saying it, not the NCT teacher. NCT classes all cover caesarean birth now, it's part of the course content that teachers have to follow.

Phos · 02/08/2022 15:19

When my daughter's blood oxygen levels were headed in the wrong direction because the hospital had effed things up so royally, I refused forceps/ventouse and told them to go straight for the caesarean and get her out.

I genuinely believe if I'd let them mess about much longer, I would not be sitting here as the mother of a healthy/able-bodied child.

Marmunia1066 · 02/08/2022 15:13

I was like this as I have a phobia of surgery - being cut open etc - as it makes me faint. If someone starts talking about surgery, I feel faint. Actually I feel myself fading now at the thought of it. Injuries are fine - it's the thought of surgery and stitches.

LadyLaSnack · 02/08/2022 15:10

I’ve had 3 sections. 2 ‘unplanned’ (ie technically emergency but without an emergency) after long unsuccessful inductions, and one elective when baby showed no signs of dropping or getting ready to come out.

I do feel sad. Breastfeeding has been difficult at first with all three partly due to the surgery, and recovery was incrementally painful with each (the third being extremely hard/bad). I can also empathise with the fear women fear going into the section - it’s hard and very very scary.

I wish I’d been able to get them out the traditional way, and periodically feel a bit down knowing that that ship has now sailed. However I’d never vocalise that as I know I’m I’m incredibly lucky - all 3 are safe and healthy and I’d never have considered refusing treatment to help them arrive in a safe, healthy condition. In fact I think I’d probably have accepted any degree of detriment to my own body to make sure that happened.

i do experience digs re. the ‘natural birth’ narrative from women friends who should know better (or who at least should realise that their own natural birth is down to luck and only luck - and that C-sections don’t happen through lack of effort/lack of strength/lack of womanliness.

i actually had this recently with a friend. I was empathising with her re. how hard she had found first time BFing and the guilt she’d felt when switching to formula.

In the next breath she said ‘still - at least I had a natural birth’.

So - yes, your friend is misguided, but there’s a lot of factors leading her that way (pressure/fear etc).

FarmerRefuted · 02/08/2022 15:06

It would be a very odd thing for the dad to make up about the birth of his child, but perhaps he misunderstood what they were asking him.

Easily done in a stressful situation and a lot of people will mutter something like "save our baby" or "don't let my wife die" and will think that's them telling the medical team which one to focus on. Thankfully the majority of the time everyone survives but it's an awful situation to be in.

ChampagneLassie · 02/08/2022 15:04

Not your circus, not your monkeys. I wouldn't bother expending any energy on this. Hopefully she won't need one, and if she does 8d be suprised if she doesn't agree. My emergency c section they weren't able to numb me enough after 4 attempts and asked permission to crack on as babys heart rate dropping. I was more worried about the baby than potential pain. In those moments before I heard the baby screen you've come so far you'd agree to anything I think to have nest chance of getting a healthy baby. I'm crying now remembering it

rickandmorts · 02/08/2022 14:57

sandradailey · 02/08/2022 12:42

Yes that's exactly what she's saying, she wants to refuse a section at all costs unless her own life is at risk. Is baby can pass away and she's still able to go for a vaginal delivery of baby, she will

She honestly said she'd rather give birth to a deceased baby rather than have a c section? If she said that then she clearly has massive issues/ phobias around surgery and I'm not sure what posting this thread is going to achieve? Poor woman.

ChagSameachDoreen · 02/08/2022 14:54

Madness.

I didn't want a section, but when it became clear that DD needed to come out, I went ahead. The alternative doesn't bear thinking about.

NCT seems to be a breeding ground for this sort of nonsense.

LadyLaSnack · 02/08/2022 14:50

I remember with no. 1 I wrote ‘no forceps unless completely necessary’ on my birth plan. 😆

Essentially ‘birthsplaining’ to the medical team 🤣.

But yes - your friend is misguided I think.

Starlight86 · 02/08/2022 14:50

BellePeppa · 02/08/2022 14:38

So does a natural birth, I know two people whose children suffered brain damage because of difficult births, if they’d had elective c sections it wouldn’t have happened. At least with an elective c section there’s no emergency involved, all that labour and pain and you end up having a c section anyway. I can only speak from my own experiences and my elective c sections were stress free, pain free and relaxed. There can be a bit of pain after because of the stitches but once they’re out it’s fine. I never wanted natural births but that’s just me.

Yes it absolutely does however trained medical staff should be able to assess these situations and advise strongly accordingly.

easyday · 02/08/2022 14:49

Well exactly the point @ElegantlyTouched. They didn't insist but for medical reasons (which you may not have been aware of) they offered. Sections are more expensive they don't offer them on a whim.

RamblingEclectic · 02/08/2022 14:44

I won't call refusal in a birth plan silly. It's based in fear, a normal feeling when looking at birth and why these plans are as they are. I dislike how birth plans are often put out like a menu, it gives an illusion of more control than we have, but they're basically a tool of fear management and communication. If they were treated like that, they might work better. My latter birth plans included my fears and how I generally managed them. I found that far more helpful than going through all the possible outcomes.

My birth plans also included refusals - my disabilities put me at significantly higher risk when it comes to spinal anesthetic, so it said that in the event of a C-section or manual placental removal or similar, I need general anesthetic and I don't consent to any spinal anesthetics. That ended up happening for a manual placental removal, which was great as I'd lost the ability to talk while being prepped for that even when I was scared from hearing one midwife keep talking about my needing an epidural for it.

I also in my last labour refused active management of third stage until after the placenta had passed. I got some push back for that, even had a midwife try to hug me into changing my mind (literally hugging me while encouraging me for active management while still in first stage, it was weird), she didn't think my previous situations had anything to do with it, but I got a physiological management with the injection after the placenta had passed & it worked great for me, no extreme pain like I had with active management (having happened right after labour, I can say it was somehow a lot worse than labour), faster, and no retention issues. It might have to do with my conditions - I'm not suitable for a lot of 'normal' medication and/or that my placentas tended to be quite enlarged (last one got a lot of comments, it was too big for the bag they usually use so it had to sit on the table of tools taking over the whole thing for a bit), but while statistically riskier and I imagine some thought it was silly / reckless / fearful, it ended up being the right path for me.

balalake · 02/08/2022 14:41

A C section is not a minor thing. I don't blame any woman who would not want one unless a life threatening situation (to mum or the baby).

Fluffygreenslippers · 02/08/2022 14:41

itssquidstella · 02/08/2022 13:53

@Fluffygreenslippers I’m sorry you had that experience. That was one of the situations I wanted to avoid when I requested my c-section (that, and DS's heart rate was going a bit skew whiff and I wasn't going to hang around to watch it get worse). I’m so grateful that the medical team were supportive. Did you get a debrief afterwards where you were able to discuss the rationale for their refusal?

No :/
I requested one but I never heard back. I asked for a c section when I was repeatedly told baby was measuring large (99th centile) and was outright refused. I asked again during my awful, induced, was turned out to be 60 hour labour. I suppose I’m ‘lucky’ as my pelvic floor seems to be okay, but my actual pelvis is fecked.

AllyCatTown · 02/08/2022 14:39

Starlight86 · 02/08/2022 14:31

I would always refuse a section.......unless there was a risk to baby or me, which is the only reason imo sections should be offered.

And thats not because im some sort of hero or think a vaginal/natural birth means your a cut above the rest, its because its major surgery that poses its own risk of very real complications.

Vaginal birth pose some risks that are lower in c sections such as incontinence.

BellePeppa · 02/08/2022 14:38

Starlight86 · 02/08/2022 14:31

I would always refuse a section.......unless there was a risk to baby or me, which is the only reason imo sections should be offered.

And thats not because im some sort of hero or think a vaginal/natural birth means your a cut above the rest, its because its major surgery that poses its own risk of very real complications.

So does a natural birth, I know two people whose children suffered brain damage because of difficult births, if they’d had elective c sections it wouldn’t have happened. At least with an elective c section there’s no emergency involved, all that labour and pain and you end up having a c section anyway. I can only speak from my own experiences and my elective c sections were stress free, pain free and relaxed. There can be a bit of pain after because of the stitches but once they’re out it’s fine. I never wanted natural births but that’s just me.

Lovelystuff · 02/08/2022 14:36

Is there a possible phobia of surgery? I can’t think why someone would have such strong views against it otherwise.

NeedMoreMilk · 02/08/2022 14:31

FarmerRefuted · 02/08/2022 13:51

someone I know was telling me recently that hospital staff had this discussion with the partner of a friend of hers when things were looking very serious. It’s possible he exaggerated slightly when he told the story though, I guess

They would never ask a partner to choose which one to save. Could you imagine the guilt and emotional trauma? The medical team would make such decisions based on clinical presentations, that's what they're trained for. The life of the woman would always be prioritised as she is the patient, the baby doesn't become a patient until it is born at which point it would be handed off to its own medical team and the initial medical team would carry on their work with the woman (at emergency sections there will be staff there specifically for the baby once it is born). If the woman was too far gone (e.g., already past the point of survival/already dead) then focus would switch to getting the baby out.

Well that is what I thought (and what I said, in the first part of my post) but that’s definitely what she said.

It would be a very odd thing for the dad to make up about the birth of his child, but perhaps he misunderstood what they were asking him.

Starlight86 · 02/08/2022 14:31

I would always refuse a section.......unless there was a risk to baby or me, which is the only reason imo sections should be offered.

And thats not because im some sort of hero or think a vaginal/natural birth means your a cut above the rest, its because its major surgery that poses its own risk of very real complications.

BellePeppa · 02/08/2022 14:29

Is it her first? First timers can sometimes be a bit precious - saying no c section, no pain relief etc as if medals are getting handed out after. I had two elective c sections and they were a dream. I don’t understand women who want to do it the hard way 🤷‍♀️

Saggytrousers · 02/08/2022 14:21

I think you should mind your own business and concern yourself with your own birth.

eastegg · 02/08/2022 14:18

FarmerRefuted · 02/08/2022 13:03

In the event she needs a section it'll be explained to her and she'll be asked to consent, she has the right to not consent because its her body and therefore her choice. If she's in a dire enough situation that she's not able to consent then the medical staff would act in what they consider to be her best interests.

It's not for anyone else to say whether her decision is wrong, she gets to choose the same as everyone else.

It is for people to say though, it’s an opinion forum and people can give their opinions on whether they think she’s stupid/selfish/right/wrong or whatever. What we can’t do is physically stop her from making the choice ie force a CS on her.

I have an opinion on a person who would rather their baby die than have a CS, and I’m entitled to voice it. They’re making a terrible choice, they are wrong (MH conditions aside).

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/08/2022 14:15

It’s absolutely nuts but I’m sure if she needed one she would get one.

This sort of birthing zealotry is normally quite quickly forgotten once the baby arrives and normal life resumes.

whumpthereitis · 02/08/2022 14:15

I recall at least one case where a woman refused a C section and the baby died as a result.

Ultimately it’s her body and her choice. Medical staff can’t override her unless she’s not of sound mind, and making a decision most would consider to be foolish doesn’t necessarily mean that someone isn’t of sound mind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread