Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's silly to refuse a C Section?

133 replies

sandradailey · 02/08/2022 12:38

I have been attending an NCT class didn't have one in my area with DA

I've made a good friend who has a friend who's joined us recently.

We were talking about birth plans (and how they probably won't go to plan), and her friend said 'the only thing I'm saying on there is 'NO Section'

I said what do you mean, she said 'I will refuse a section'. I said but what if it's an emergency for example baby is in distress? She said 'nope, I won't have one. Simple as that. No section means no section. I may consider it if I'm dying from something like dramatic blood loss but otherwise, no. What'll be will be with the pregnancy itself'

The conversation then moved on but AIBU to think it's a bit silly to say no section whatsoever? So many variables can happen at birth Confused

OP posts:
anonforthis87 · 02/08/2022 18:05

It does sound extreme but I think it is normal to be scared of major surgery. Also you keep hearing that in many countries / hospitals c-sections happen much more often than what would be strictly speaking medically necessarily, and the idea of being asked to consent to something like this while in labour without knowing for sure whether it is needed is pretty terrifying. Having said that I would still consent to it, but would likely keep wondering afterwards whether it was the right decision.

10HailMarys · 02/08/2022 18:02

To be honest, it sounds like your friend might have an actual phobia rather than just being generally anti-caesarian. I also suspect that if it came to it and she had to make the choice of either losing her baby or having the C-section, she would actually have the C-section rather than deliver a dead child.

I completely understand your feelings about what she said, and of course you are completely right that there are loads of situations where a section would clearly be the right choice - but I definitely think there is something more going on psychologically than just 'I don't want a C-section', so I think this is an issue that has to be between her and her delivery team to resolve and not one for friends to pitch in on - she will have heard all the rational arguments already and I think if you push the issue with her it will just increase her anxiety/distress.

YawnYawnYawn00 · 02/08/2022 17:57

Is this her first baby?
I think people say all sorts but don't know how they're really going to feel until they're actually in labour!

royly · 02/08/2022 17:51

A lot of women seem afraid of sections and I don't get it myself. I would be more frightened of having my vagina cut open with a knife than my abdomen.

I was petrified, it's the cut, the spinal, not being able to feel body, strapped down etc. I absolutely hated it but the anaesthetist was fantastic & really calmed me.

Jedsnewstar · 02/08/2022 17:50

LilacPoppy · 02/08/2022 12:40

Yes she should not have got pregnant if she was happy to let her baby die. Trying other options first absolutely, but not oh well baby can just die then but if I might die I will consider it!

What a stupid comment. Seriously over the top.

royly · 02/08/2022 17:48

@SmallSoupcon ouch

royly · 02/08/2022 17:48

I was offered a CS with dc3 due to position. I asked to be induced first as didn't want a CS ideally & the consultant agreed due to previous straightforward VBs. It was agreed that if induction failed it would be CS, which is what happened.

SmallSoupcon · 02/08/2022 17:46

Similar story here. 17 failed attempts at a spinal before they did the GA.

royly · 02/08/2022 17:45

Especially because during a section, you'll definitely be numb there- whereas if they cut your vagina, it's often done without any numbing

my sil felt it & had to be put under

2021mumma · 02/08/2022 17:43

If I hadn’t had csections both my babies would be dead. It’s a simple decision to make when you’re faced with those facts!

LadyLaSnack · 02/08/2022 17:39

Especially because during a section, you'll definitely be numb there- whereas if they cut your vagina, it's often done without any numbing.

This isn't always the case - section 1 I could feel pain as they'd perforated a membrane in my spine whilst doing the epidural and the drug was leaking out. \i had the option of bearing it, or been put under a general anaesthetic then and there (opted to bear it).

Section 3 I could also feel some pain. Didn't tell them as things seemed to be going well and didn't want to derail/distract the operation and I knew I could probably bear it after no. 1.

concernedguineapig · 02/08/2022 17:30

She's the type to end up having a cat 1 section under GA.

Do report back after her delivery and let us know!

SmallSoupcon · 02/08/2022 17:28

I have some sympathy with her, as I was pushed to have a c-section my second time around even though I was determined to have a vbac.

The reason behind my determination was because I'd ended up having an EMCS under GA the first time round, so completely missed the birth.

I should point out there was no medical reason for me having a c-section the second time, just the 'risk factor' of being 40.

However, even though the consultant was fully supportive of my wishes, as soon as I went into hospital the doctor on duty immediately tried to push me into a c-section. I got the impression they wanted to control everything medically.

In the end I got the birth I wanted because I stuck to my guns.

I should add I would have no problem with another c-section in a medical emergency.

LovinglifeAF · 02/08/2022 17:24

I am frightened of being cut open, so while I‘m sure in the throes of Labour it it came to it I’d have agreed to a section, I can kind of see a bit where she’s coming from. I hope it’s not a choice she has to exercise and then lives to regret.

IsThisNormal123 · 02/08/2022 17:24

She sounds delusional.

napplieee · 02/08/2022 17:21

FizzyLizt · 02/08/2022 17:20

A lot of women seem afraid of sections and I don't get it myself. I would be more frightened of having my vagina cut open with a knife than my abdomen. I gladly had my baby exit via the sun roof.

Especially because during a section, you'll definitely be numb there- whereas if they cut your vagina, it's often done without any numbing.

Happy to be corrected, if I'm wrong in my assumptions. I only had c sections. All elective, because I wanted them.

FizzyLizt · 02/08/2022 17:20

A lot of women seem afraid of sections and I don't get it myself. I would be more frightened of having my vagina cut open with a knife than my abdomen. I gladly had my baby exit via the sun roof.

napplieee · 02/08/2022 17:16

Why is she so against a section ? Is she scared ?

whumpthereitis · 02/08/2022 17:13

eurochick · 02/08/2022 16:50

She seems a bit hard of thinking. It's one thing to be very anti c section and to have a high bar for having one (I was in this category myself) but for that bar to be set between baby dying and a threat to her own life just suggests she hasn't fully considered the implications. I pushed my consultant really hard on trying an induction but he convinced me the baby was likely too weak to survive the process so I reluctantly consented to a section. It seems like this woman hasn't thought through how she would feel having refused consent for a procedure that would have saved her baby's life, delivering a stillborn child and living with the implications of that.

Or she’s thought it through and has still decided to take that risk and is prepared to live with the possible consequences. Not a decision most would make, but still her right to make it.

Dixiechickonhols · 02/08/2022 17:04

Thread reminded me if this case that occurred when I was studying Law & Medicine.
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/law-report-vital-surgery-on-mother-ordered-re-s-family-division-sir-stephen-brown-president-12-october-1992-1557350.html?amp
A born again Christian was refusing a c section and both her and baby were about to die. It’s the shortest judgment - literally woman was in labour and Drs needed a decision. Legally it’s not good law she should have been able to refuse consent but the court ordered the c section. I wonder if with hindsight she was glad court took decision out of her hands.

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 02/08/2022 17:02

itssquidstella · 02/08/2022 13:56

@Teaandcakeordeath83 my section wasn't awful. Yeah okay, it was major surgery and that's never a walk in the park, but I was pain free from about a week after birth, exercising again after six weeks and now at ten weeks postpartum I feel almost totally back to normal and my body is well on its way to being back to normal too - I’m looking forward to starting running again in a week or two.

Everyone's experience is different and its unfair scaremongering to state baldly that EVERY c section is awful. It's statements like that which put women at risk by making them frightened to have one even when it's needed.

In my experience every section I've had was bloody awful for a variety of reasons so on an opinion based post I am "baldly" allowed to say that. Plenty of women on here can "scaremonger" about vaginal birth. That's the thing about opinions- everyone has them, based on their own experiences and they tend to be all different. I wouldn't wish my section experiences on my worst enemy but I'm very thankful that my two sisters in law had smooth sailing elective/emergency sections in the past three months. I did say that sections absolutely had their place when women chose them or they were medically required but you clearly didn't pick up on that sentence. 🤷🏼‍♀️

I'm glad you have recovered well and wish you a smooth return to running. 8 years on from my first section I still have flash back nightmares and still get recurrent nerve pain from complications after my second. Clearly I wasn't as lucky.

Willyoujustbequiet · 02/08/2022 16:58

I think some responses are too harsh.

Yes we can think it's a ridiculous attitude but her body her choice and that needs to be respected or it's a slippery slope.

eurochick · 02/08/2022 16:50

She seems a bit hard of thinking. It's one thing to be very anti c section and to have a high bar for having one (I was in this category myself) but for that bar to be set between baby dying and a threat to her own life just suggests she hasn't fully considered the implications. I pushed my consultant really hard on trying an induction but he convinced me the baby was likely too weak to survive the process so I reluctantly consented to a section. It seems like this woman hasn't thought through how she would feel having refused consent for a procedure that would have saved her baby's life, delivering a stillborn child and living with the implications of that.

MercurialMonday · 02/08/2022 16:32

I don't think anyone really knows how they'll react until they are in that position and if she ends up there there will be a room full of trained professionals to talk to her about her options and the associated risks.

I did turn one down weeks before due date as it wasn't about mine and babies safety but fucking internal politics around HB.

The consultant who was trying to insist on C-section argued with us about age of our then youngest and my own pg and medical history apparently because he'd read the notes wrong and dismissed our practical reasoning. It did not inspire confidence and he couldn't in end provide a good medical reason why it was needed.

If there had been a good reason to have a c-section I'd have had one but there wasn't and there were good reasons to avoid it for us.

Lindasllama · 02/08/2022 15:34

Hmmm

Wait till she is in that position..

Swipe left for the next trending thread