Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Immunocompromised people should receive treatment that would prevent them from being infected with COVID-19.

119 replies

dianthus101 · 02/08/2022 11:34

Many people including cancer patients, people on immunosuppressive medications, transplant recipients, people with primary and secondary remain extremely vulnerable to Covid, even after vaccination. For them lockdown has not ended and if anything, it is even worse than 2020 as COVID-19 infections are very high in the community. Some immunosuppressed people have barely been outside since 2020 and the psychological distress is enormous.

I'm not sure if people realise but an antibody treatment (Evusheld) that would prevent them from being infected was authorised by the UK regulator authority (MHRA) in March this year. Despite the fact that the evidence for this treatment is greater than it was for the COVID-19 vaccines (when they were rolled out) it is still not available in the UK (privately or via the NHs) even though it is available in 32 other countries including the US and many European countries. This is because the UK government have not bought any. There doesn't seem to be much publicity about it and I know many immunocompromised people feel very forgotten.

bloodcancer.org.uk/news/leading-charities-and-clinicians-urge-government-to-secure-evusheld/

OP posts:
dianthus101 · 02/08/2022 17:14

Hont1986 · 02/08/2022 17:06

Thank you, that's a helpful post. I'm not against it, I just want to understand the cost and the benefit because the information is pretty light in OP's link.

So the cost of the rollout for Evusheld for those 500,000 people at £800 per dose would be £400 million? And could potentially save in the region of 1000 deaths per year from that clinically vulnerable group?

Given the potential savings from not having to treat immunocompromised people with covid, the net cost could be lower than that.

OP posts:
Hont1986 · 02/08/2022 17:06

Thank you, that's a helpful post. I'm not against it, I just want to understand the cost and the benefit because the information is pretty light in OP's link.

So the cost of the rollout for Evusheld for those 500,000 people at £800 per dose would be £400 million? And could potentially save in the region of 1000 deaths per year from that clinically vulnerable group?

Dammitthisisshit · 02/08/2022 16:49

Thanks @nether - This is much better than the response I was starting to write! This ^^

nether · 02/08/2022 16:40

The chance of dying from covid is already very low (14.0 deaths per 100,000 people according to ONS) and the increased risk for disabled people is between 1.3 and 1.6x, so maybe 22.4 deaths per 100,000 people, aka 0.024%

This doesn't work as a comparison.

It's not being rolled out to the general population. Or even the 'disabled' population.

It's the severely immune supressed group (about 500,000 people). There have been about 750 covid deaths this year. Around 500 of them from that group.

It has been studied - MHRA has approved it. It's in use in about 40 countries now, so the monitoring is in place and ongoing

I've read OP's link but it doesn't say how much more effective this treatment is compared to the existing vaccines

People who respond to the vaccines would not be offered Evusheld. It's needed for those who do no produce antibodies. So the answer is 'vastly more effective' as it's taking protection from zero to about 77%

dianthus101 · 02/08/2022 15:48

For those that keep asking about the cost, can I point out that even if you want to argue that it isn't worth the cost (I strongly disagree), people can't even buy it privately in the UK.

OP posts:
dianthus101 · 02/08/2022 15:31

Wingedharpy · 02/08/2022 15:07

From what I've read OP, I don't think Evusheld is quite the magic treatment you purport it to be.
There have been cases, albeit v few, where folk have had this treatment but still contracted Covid.
As new variants are emerging all the time, in the way that viruses tend to do, some studies have shown that it isn't quite as effective as was hoped, against some of these.
My understanding is that it is still being studied and monitored which is a positive.

I speak as an immunosuppressed person who is not shielding but remains a cautious mask wearing copious handwasher.

I haven't said that it is a “magic treatment”. The fact that some people still catch it doesn't mean that it is of no benefit though, particularly if those people get less severe disease than they would have done. The risk of catching COVID is significantly lower in immunocompromised people who've been treated with it.

Regarding “studying and monitoring it” before buying it, do you not think that it's just an excuse for delaying buying it? There is more evidence for Evusheld then there was for covid vaccines (at the time they were rolled out) but they didn't have much problem buying those. No one seems to know what evidence they are waiting for and why the UK seems require more evidence than the 32 other countries that are using it including the US. This letter from leading clinicians and charities states:

“There is strong clinical support for Evusheld across a range of medical specialties. Nonetheless, we are concerned that Evusheld is being held to an impossible standard of evolving evidence. It is unclear what information and concerns the Government hold in relation to Evusheld’s effectiveness, and how these relate to the delays in its procurement. Despite real-world studies showing strong performance against Omicron BA1 and BA2 and subsequent data for BA4 and BA5, there has been a lack of transparency relating to Government testing and how this will influence procurement and rollout.”

media.bloodcancer.org.uk/documents/Evusheld_open_charity_letter_28.07.22.pdf

OP posts:
0pheIiaBalls · 02/08/2022 15:12

Hont1986 · 02/08/2022 15:01

£800 per dose seems quite high, the current vaccines cost around £20.

Unfortunately in a public healthcare model they need to balance cost and benefit. I've read OP's link but it doesn't say how much more effective this treatment is compared to the existing vaccines.

The chance of dying from covid is already very low (14.0 deaths per 100,000 people according to ONS) and the increased risk for disabled people is between 1.3 and 1.6x, so maybe 22.4 deaths per 100,000 people, aka 0.024%.

We're not talking about 'disabled people', though.

We're talking about people of all ages who led normal, full lives prior to March 2020 who have been in something akin to perpetual lockdown for two and a half years. Yes, there will be some disabled people who are immunosuppressed/vulnerable, but there will also be tens of thousands of people living with autoimmune diseases, for example, whose lives have been put on hold for years.

It's not just about risk of death. It's also about quality of life, the ability to earn a living, to not worry about sending DC to school, or use public transport.

Vaccines have been brilliant at preventing serious illness and death but if you're immunosuppressed, you won't have the same benefits from them as someone who isn't. A preventative drug would make all the difference to those who would be eligible for it, and would ultimately cost less than hospital stays/days lost to sickness (immunosuppressed people tend to be sicker for longer) and likely reduce strain on MH services, too.

LarchFairy · 02/08/2022 15:10

I think the numbers of people who would need this are pretty small so the cost wouldn't be the same as a national rollout.
I am immunosuppressed. Caught covid after two vaccines and was pretty ill. Hospital 8 days but not ICU, so that probably cost quite a lot.
I'm not still shielding though. I figure the odds are in my favour, I survived covid once, it's less deadly now and I have had 3 more vaccine doses.

Wingedharpy · 02/08/2022 15:07

From what I've read OP, I don't think Evusheld is quite the magic treatment you purport it to be.
There have been cases, albeit v few, where folk have had this treatment but still contracted Covid.
As new variants are emerging all the time, in the way that viruses tend to do, some studies have shown that it isn't quite as effective as was hoped, against some of these.
My understanding is that it is still being studied and monitored which is a positive.

I speak as an immunosuppressed person who is not shielding but remains a cautious mask wearing copious handwasher.

Hont1986 · 02/08/2022 15:01

£800 per dose seems quite high, the current vaccines cost around £20.

Unfortunately in a public healthcare model they need to balance cost and benefit. I've read OP's link but it doesn't say how much more effective this treatment is compared to the existing vaccines.

The chance of dying from covid is already very low (14.0 deaths per 100,000 people according to ONS) and the increased risk for disabled people is between 1.3 and 1.6x, so maybe 22.4 deaths per 100,000 people, aka 0.024%.

Dammitthisisshit · 02/08/2022 14:52

RoseAndRose · 02/08/2022 14:36

Cost should be no more than £800

That's roughly the equivalent of 2 nights in hospital (not including the actual treatments the patient receives for whatever lands then in there)

which is a huge amount less than it cost for someone to come round to my house and give me the antibody drip which is what happened when I caught Covid.

Dammitthisisshit · 02/08/2022 14:50

I agree OP. I don’t understand why it’s not rolled out.

nether · 02/08/2022 14:39

Hont1986 · 02/08/2022 14:25

How effective is it, and how much does it cost?

Is this going to be another thing like the vaccines that appear increasingly ineffective?

Oh it's going to stop the pandemic > it won't stop the pandemic but it'll make you less likely to get it > ok it doesn't make you less likely to get it but it reduces the chance you'll pass it on > ok it doesn't reduce the chance you'll pass it on but it reduces the symptoms > ok it doesn't reduce symptoms but it makes you less likely to die. Well, better than nothing I guess.

The target group for this treatment is precisely those who currently have "nothing"

Those who are still shielding because they do not make antibodies. This gives them antibodies, and the protection lasts about 6 months.

If you had been in lockdown continuously since March 2020, would you like to be able to rejoin ordinary life?

RoseAndRose · 02/08/2022 14:36

Cost should be no more than £800

That's roughly the equivalent of 2 nights in hospital (not including the actual treatments the patient receives for whatever lands then in there)

Hont1986 · 02/08/2022 14:25

How effective is it, and how much does it cost?

Is this going to be another thing like the vaccines that appear increasingly ineffective?

Oh it's going to stop the pandemic > it won't stop the pandemic but it'll make you less likely to get it > ok it doesn't make you less likely to get it but it reduces the chance you'll pass it on > ok it doesn't reduce the chance you'll pass it on but it reduces the symptoms > ok it doesn't reduce symptoms but it makes you less likely to die. Well, better than nothing I guess.

lOPAS · 02/08/2022 14:09

My immune system is sitting at 0.2 currently but I can get access to antivirals within a day of getting Covid via my nurse.

JustSmallFry · 02/08/2022 14:05

I wish this had been offered to my friend who is currently in a coma after catching Covid :-(

RoseAndRose · 02/08/2022 14:03

Good explanation of Evusheld here

bloodcancer.org.uk/news/evusheld-does-it-work-against-omicron/#:~:text=Evusheld%20is%20already%20available%20in%20countries%20like%20the,in%20the%20UK%20are%20unable%20to%20get%20it.

It's not a vaccine, it's pre-exposure prophylaxis.

If you are allergic to all forms of vaccine, or have a condition which means you do not produce antibodies, then this is the only way to mitigate risk

nether · 02/08/2022 13:58

Topgub · 02/08/2022 11:51

I dont really know enough about the cost benefit analysis.

Are immunocompromised people at as much risk from this variant?

Risk of death?

Yes

ICNARC data showing how the immune suppressed are by far the largest group admitted to ICU

class="underline">COVID-19Report_2022-07-08.pdf.pdf

Discussion of 77% reduction in severity (NB: effectiveness against omicron has now been established)

britishlivertrust.org.uk/evusheld-approved-to-prevent-covid-19-in-people-whose-immune-response-is-poor/#:~:text=In%20a%20clinical%20trial%20in%20adults%2C%20Evusheld%20was,at%20least%206%20months%20following%20a%20single%20dose.

Those who form no antibodies in response to vaccine will gain about 6 months protection.

NICE agreed that back in March

nether · 02/08/2022 13:49

And what are the costs of giving the evushield every 6 months?

Drop in the ocean compared to costs of the pandemic. And less by far than an ICU admission.

Right now there are about half a million people who still need to follow shielding-type advice. That's the equivalent of a city like Glasgow, or Sheffield, or Bristol still being under lockdown.

And as those affected are not an age group, it is like a city - young and old.

And 500 have died since NICE approved the drug.

It's British developed and made, and in use in about 40 other countries.

I think it's a national disgrace that the government has been prepared to throw so many people under the bus.

And it's also bad from a self-interest pov. When the immune-suppressed fall ill, they stay ill for a long time. But it's not just taking up NHs resources. It's that by staying ill for a long time, they act as a perfect incubator for new variants.

We need a procurement decision now. And a roll out plan in the autumn - one that actually works (not like the utter balls up of third primaries).

It's a crying shame, and a mark of an 'I'm all right Jack' government that they leave people in this plight when there is a good and effective way to give that 'city' their lives back

dianthus101 · 02/08/2022 13:44

Capturetotalelotion · 02/08/2022 13:33

I‘ m immunosuppressed, have had x 3 jabs, refused the 4th. Have had covid once that I know of. I was fine. I’d prefer not to take any more medication that what I already do thanks. I’m happy for others to have it if they want it though.

Nobody would be forcing you to take it. Not everyone who is immunosuppressed would be eligible anyway ( it would depend on whether the vaccines are likely to be effective).

OP posts:
Topgub · 02/08/2022 13:40

@dianthus101

Tell that to the people questioning me

dianthus101 · 02/08/2022 13:39

@Topgub This is not a thread about vaccines. It is a thread about pre exposure prophylaxis in immunocompromised people. If you want people to give you data on vaccines in healthy people start another thread.

OP posts:
Capturetotalelotion · 02/08/2022 13:33

I‘ m immunosuppressed, have had x 3 jabs, refused the 4th. Have had covid once that I know of. I was fine. I’d prefer not to take any more medication that what I already do thanks. I’m happy for others to have it if they want it though.

Topgub · 02/08/2022 13:28

@SuperPets

So they are of interest?

OK. Challenge them then.

Show me the data that disproves what I've said

Swipe left for the next trending thread