Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all "naughty" children actually neurodivergent?

208 replies

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 11:11

As the subject asks. The children in my life (friends, family, DC school peers, colleagues' children) fall into two camps - the ones who can be stubborn at home, but tend to behave fabulously for anyone who isn't their parents including at school.

And those who are challenging in many settings, don't like to conform, oppositional. So many of these are being referred for ADHD/Autism after a year or two at school, mine included.

Does anyone have any actual experience of "naughty" children (by naughty I mean doesn't do what they're asked, refusal to comply, cheeky, rude, attitude) who did eventually grow out of it?

OP posts:
Mummiepig · 02/08/2022 12:10

I'm autistic and have adhd, I was the best behaved child, in fact too well behaved, shy, quiet, compliant, intelligent, top of the class, ND does not mean naughty, and some children are naughty due to poor parenting, putting the two things together is not right in any way

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 12:10

@starfishmummy I also have this too, and the teacher has commented how well behaved DS has been when other child isn't at school. However this is always the case - it's like my DS seeks out children who aren't great influences.

OP posts:
Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 12:09

@missbunnyrabbit by that definition my DS is naughty. He appears to know right from wrong, he is of normal intelligence and (with reminding a lot of the time) can follow instructions well. He doesn't hit, though.

In which case where the fuck am I going wrong with my parenting?!

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 02/08/2022 12:08

lifeturnsonadime · 02/08/2022 11:23

Well I can flip that and say that my neurodivergent children are not naughty.

They never behaved badly when at school.

I'm not saying my ND child was/is never naughty but he has always been generally well behaved. The short lived "phase" at school was due to another child leading him on - not just my biased opinion, but what we were told by his teachers.

SoverNow · 02/08/2022 12:07

All neurotypical children are also naughty.

Remember Matilda's song?

It's insane to expect children to not be naughty.

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 12:06

That's amazing @CallOnMe. We haven't had a great experience with my DS' school journey so far. The nursery teachers seemed most effective, but that year was 2019-20 so cut short. His reception teacher didn't communicate much to me, and his Year One teacher also didn't, but punished him a lot in class (I only found out from him, it was very much glossed over at parents' evenings. He's never violent so I've never been pulled aside at the end of the day). I've been the one to raise possible underlying needs, the teachers so far have been happy to label him as naughty. The Senco is more helpful, thankfully.

OP posts:
missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 12:04

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 11:29

I’ve also noticed that people say autistic children can’t be naughty and I say that as someone with an autistic child myself, there is a boy in my sons class who has asd who throws chairs around the class, throws books at children, threatens them, swears at the teacher, but apparently you can’t be autistic and naughty and he’s only doing it cos he is autistic.

This this this. I am a teacher and our Senco says "No child is ever naughty" and it is absolute rubbish.
For me, the distinction is whether the child knows what they're doing is wrong. If they have been asked to not hit other children, and they are both of normal intelligence and can understand instructions, then to continue hitting other children is pure naughtiness. It doesn't matter to me whether they have SEN or not. If your judgement of a child is that they DO understand that what they are doing in wrong, yet continue to do it anyway, that is disobedience and naughtiness.

CallOnMe · 02/08/2022 12:04

I think more people are neurodivergent than we think.

I agree.

I don’t think anyone is actually ‘normal’ but many of us play the role of what is expected because that’s what we’ve been taught and what our parents were taught.

But I can guarantee that we all have little quirks that are associated with some form of SEND.

CallOnMe · 02/08/2022 12:02

Usually naughty children are naughty for a reason - whether that’s an undiagnosed SEND or some form of trauma.
(It’s also surprising how many SEND is caused by trauma)

Even ones who are naughty to get attention are doing it for a reason if you look behind the scenes.

I have always worked in mainstream schools and then moved to working with children with SEND and SEMH and it is shocking that my students now are treated much more as individuals and are allowed movement, brain and sensory breaks throughout the lesson, yet in mainstream they’re expected to sit still and concentrate all day.

If a mainstream student misbehaves they are seen as naughty whereas an SEND student is given much more understanding.

Many of my mainstream students could easily be in my SEND class but they just don’t have an EHCP and likewise with my SEND students many of which are very mainstream and will do mainstream lessons with no issues.

I now treat every mainstream student like my SEND students as I know many are undiagnosed and the techniques used for SEND children are just as effective for mainstream students.

It’s just much harder as a teacher of 30+ when SEND classes are less than 10.
I believe class sizes in mainstream should be made much smaller.

EhatBow · 02/08/2022 12:01

TheSoapyFrog · 02/08/2022 11:55

I think more people are neurodivergent than we think.
Many ND children are not naughty (I wasn't and my sons aren't).
If a child behaves impeccably at school and/or with other people, and then explode when they come home, they were probably masking. (Look up the coke bottle effect as well). Masking for a long time causes burn out.
It sounds like you're talking about ODD and PDA rather than autism in general.

When does it stop being neurodivergent and start being just different, which after all we all are. If a large proportion of the population are neurodivergent, doesn't that just mean a different NT?

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 11:59

I am absolutely wondering if my DS is the way he is because of my parenting. I try very hard but feel I am either too soft, too strict, not enough boundaries, too nit picky. Or I just haven't earned his respect.

My reason for pushing on with a referral for him is because it's been consistent, "low level" behaviour since he was 3. He is 6, so that's half his life now. And he is like it at school too, he just doesn't seem to be like the other children (he will be the only child in his class making a fuss about something, or asking why he has to comply with a relatively straight forward request). He doesn't have obvious meltdowns, however I know it's not always clear cut and can show as shutting off or shutting down. In a group of children in a social setting, he's usually the one not listening to his parents/the person in charge. There are little things too which I pick up on because I'm hyper sensitive to it. He is naturally a reserved child, and the behaviour doesn't match up.

To clarify I don't think ND children are always naughty, a few friends have boys diagnosed with autism. It's the ones who are perhaps labelled as naughty, because their bad behaviour is low level, which are harder to spot.

OP posts:
TheSoapyFrog · 02/08/2022 11:55

I think more people are neurodivergent than we think.
Many ND children are not naughty (I wasn't and my sons aren't).
If a child behaves impeccably at school and/or with other people, and then explode when they come home, they were probably masking. (Look up the coke bottle effect as well). Masking for a long time causes burn out.
It sounds like you're talking about ODD and PDA rather than autism in general.

mynamesnotMa · 02/08/2022 11:55

Thankfully schools have a responsibility to look into why students might be struggling to engage. Often it's boredom sometimes it's difficulty being able to concentrate or the way they learn is different This doesn't make them naughty. Often sensory seeking behaviour is out of their control as is the need to move fiddle and even talk or stare out of a window. Luckily we are bit more enlightened and don't label them naughty. It's about helping the child understand their behaviour and adopt learning strategies.

Not just throw them on the scrap heap if they don't conform to "normal behavioural expectations".

Personally I think the whole way we expect students to learn is far too narrow which impacts the behaviour.

ArborealArmadillo · 02/08/2022 11:53

In my experience of being neurodivergent at school the naughty children were more likely to be NT because they knew the rules, knew how to bend them and when messing about would be seen as cool/funny by their peers. I was terrified of breaking a rule, I've never not done my homework or worn my uniform incorrectly. I had no idea what rules could be bent and why my behaviour within the rules was 'weird' when their behavior broke the rules but half the time even the teacher would end up laughing or letting them off. I find similar with my DD who is in the process of being assessed for ND. She is so good, she tries so hard to please the teachers, she can't read or write but she is so proud of winning the 'tidying up' award on a regular basis. Other kids run rings round her and their naughty behaviour is often social and goes under the radar of the teachers

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 11:53

I think we’ve come a long way in awareness of disorders that affect children (I’m a ND adult who went under the radar as a kid). The problem is that it may have tipped too far in the other direction.

Anecdotal obviously but I have friends who are teachers and over the last ten years, the number of kids with SEN in their classes has gone from 1 in 5 to nearly 4 in 5. That includes kids with a diagnosis (minority) and kids with parents who are pursuing one. I struggle to believe that in ten years we’ve gone to the majority of kids now having SEN, but this is apparently the experience of my friends in various schools in the area.

BogRollBOGOF · 02/08/2022 11:53

Some children are raised with poor boundaries/ ineffective parenting/ no respect.

Some children have trauma or poor role models.

Some children's personalities are more awkward but without falling into being neurodiverse.

Some children can have difficult behaviour due to unrecognised neurodiversity.

There are also many wonderful neurodiverse children whose behaviour is not problematic within society.

Some adults/ systems are poor at reading/ managing behaviour and aggravate it because it's not one size fits all.

DS is a masker. In 7 years of primary school, I've been contacted once, early in yR about behaviour. I get the overwhelm being unleashed at home. His actual level of "naughtiness" is pretty similar to his NT sibling. His behaviour in school is better than average.

Didiplanthis · 02/08/2022 11:49

My ND children are quite capable of being naughty.. this is not part of their neurodiversity.. this is part of them being kids.. they also show behaviours that might be perceived as naughty but are actually complete overwhelm from sensory overload and anxiety.... the key is working out which is which, this can be difficult and you feel really shit when you judge it wrong.

BeanieTeen · 02/08/2022 11:42

No. Many children struggle with behaviour due to ASD and ADHD, sure. Some have had traumatic experience which will impact behaviour too.
Many children with ASD and ADHD don’t display difficult behaviour at all. But they struggle inwardly.
But a lot of children are also simply spoilt little shits (not their fault). They don’t grow out of it if their parents don’t change because why should they, they rule the roost and they’ve been conditioned to feel they are more important than everyone else and then are massively lacking in empathy for others. Parents often mean well, but clueless parenting can cause a lot of behavioural problems.

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 11:40

x2boys · 02/08/2022 11:20

You realise it's a spectrum right?
My child has severe autism and learning disabilities, he has no concept of 'naughty behaviour " his behaviour is often very challenging but that is due to his disabilities.

Same, which makes it nigh on impossible to 'discipline' him.

Sprogonthetyne · 02/08/2022 11:40

I think there is always a reason for 'naughty' behaviour. That reason could be that they are young and haven't learned yet. In older children who don't 'grow out of it' it could be SEN, but could also be adverse experience or parenting issues.

For what it's worth my autistic DS is rule obsessed, so doesn't fit the stereotypical naughty child profile at all. I don't agree at all with the coupling of 'naughty' and SEN which seems to happen. The two groups often overlap, but are completely different.

Antigonesaunt · 02/08/2022 11:39

A lot of kids who were branded naughty before were actually neurodiverse, traumatised, child carers, or those living in poverty and destitution. I don't think it's a bad thing that now when a child behaves badly schools actually question whether there is a root cause, because all behaviour is communication, and if a child is behaving badly there often is an unmet need the child is trying to communicate. I remember kids branded naughty growing up who as adults found out they had a hearing issue or should have worn glasses or were abused at home and couldn't say, or had dyslexia or dyspraxia and nobody noticed. Then there are all the adult adhd and autism diagnoses and it makes me think that actually there are next to no kids who just chose to behave badly, just kids who didn't know how to show their distress or ask for help in any other way

I remember at my school lots of teachers would say kids were 'attention seeking' and that pisses me off because one of those kids I knew was being neglected and had an addict mum and abusive dad and would self harm, and another had been sexually abused (school did nothing) by another student and was bulimic. Lots of other attention seeking/ badly behaved troubled kids were actually being abused by a teacher at that school as well. So these were traumatised kids, not bad ones. They were desperately trying to express their distress and get some help, not so called attention seeking.

I'm glad we have taken a few small steps in the right direction.

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 11:38

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 11:36

Well some people do, I’m on a page on Facebook for parents with autistic children and often see posts like this, someone said the other day that no one will believe her child is autistic so she “just has to put up with getting hit and house being smashed up”
Like isn’t there a chance the child is just naughty and has no discipline? It always has to be that they are ND

Btw to clarify the child was not diagnosed as no professionals would believe her when she said she thought the child has autism.

10HailMarys · 02/08/2022 11:38

Not all naughty children are neurodivergent.

Not all neurodivergent children are naughty.

Some neurodivergent children are naughty in ways that aren't actually a result of their neurodivergence. An autistic child might have a tantrum because of sensory overload in a busy place, because of their autism. But the same autistic child might also sometimes be naughty in exactly the same way that an NT child might.

Mally100 · 02/08/2022 11:37

picklemewalnuts · 02/08/2022 11:27

Lots of children who were ND were labelled as naughty because they couldn't conform.

Some children behave badly because they haven't been taught better.

Some children behave badly because at some level it works for them- attention needing behaviour for example, for the child who would otherwise be ignored.

There are always reasons for a child's behaviour- sometimes reasons that can be addressed and the behaviour changed, other times it's the environment that needs to change.

Agree, sometime the label should be bad parenting and lack of attention and discipline.

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 11:37

x2boys · 02/08/2022 11:35

I hate this attitude ,just because your autistic child doesn't display the behaviours that this child does doesn't mean this child is being naughty
You have met onevperson with autism ,you have met one person with autism etc .

So you can’t be autistic and be naughty or a bully as well? My son is scared to go to school because of him and dropped out of football club because he was there

Swipe left for the next trending thread