Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all "naughty" children actually neurodivergent?

208 replies

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 11:11

As the subject asks. The children in my life (friends, family, DC school peers, colleagues' children) fall into two camps - the ones who can be stubborn at home, but tend to behave fabulously for anyone who isn't their parents including at school.

And those who are challenging in many settings, don't like to conform, oppositional. So many of these are being referred for ADHD/Autism after a year or two at school, mine included.

Does anyone have any actual experience of "naughty" children (by naughty I mean doesn't do what they're asked, refusal to comply, cheeky, rude, attitude) who did eventually grow out of it?

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 02/08/2022 13:08

I get what you're asking and it's a very interesting discussion.

I'm an absolute believer that all behaviour is communication.

But it's not always neuro divergence in the sense of a diagnosis or condition or neuro difference like adhd and asd. But often the route cause is a difference in functioning that's not being met.

Dyslexia is a huge one which causes behavioural difficulties within education and it's accepted now any specific learning difficulty can have an affect on self esteem and therefore behaviour. Many class clowns are covering from what they see as a deficit in themselves and causes low self esteem which is actually just a learning difference .

Lots of these children will have difficult home lives - which include being spoilt. I include being spoilt and having no boundaries because if you get inconsistent messages continually from lots of care givers then you can develop MH difficulties such as anxiety and can also have behaviours very similar to those found in attachment disorder because secure attachments can't be firmed when you don't know what adults will accept what behaviours.

I've seen children who are entirely NT in the literature sense of the term behave appealing at school (in the behavioural policy sense of the term) and then become very difficult at home too.

"Out of control" teens who we often see parents seek help for on here are also communicating something. Be it a need for more autonomy feeling in their lives or not feeling a sense of belonging which often in a precursor for befriending people who are a bad influence (and these groups are experts at seeking people with this low self confidence)

So yes, some children will deliberately set out to disrupt and disturb others through their behaviour. But if we consider that always having punishments and people alienating you is against human nature and doesn't actually mean they gain something positive from the behaviour you have to consider the child isn't functioning well at the time.

I knew a girl who would always play up and deliberately push the boundaries set by other adults. She wasn't pleasant to be around. But her mum had no boundaries for her and even when she drew on others walls at their houses her mum would always excuse it. And of course - everything became about her behaviour and she was centre of attention for her actions so what incentive was there for her to stop?
She eventually had 2 failed secondary placements when her mum wouldn't allow schools to deal with the behaviour but wanted them to excuse it for a variety of reasons and did her GCSEs online learning through a PRU.

Her and her do not speak now. She blames her mum for not showing her cares by putting in boundaries. Sad

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 13:07

Ylvamoon · 02/08/2022 12:50

... stick a label on and suddenly it's fine!

Honestly, I think children need to learn to "behave" so that they can negotiate the complexity of our world/ society.

You can say, that they can't help themselves ect. But in the end they need to be able to live life as an adult.

It's hard and it's difficult because schools and many workplaces don't cater for different types of people. They have a one size fits all approach ... I really think that the increasing in the number of children with a ND diagnosis is a direct result of this.
plus children are starting school far to early!

This. I feel so strongly about all of this and it is so nice to people with this viewpoint for once.

As I said before, I have never been identified and diagnosed with anything because I'm very quiet and just got on with it. I definitely have autism and add traits that make it hard for me to fit in to society. I had an awful life at school with no friends. Finally, at 18, I decided I didn't want to be like this anymore so over the last ten years I have been copying everyone around me to the extent that I now pass as a 'normal' person! We all have to learn how to behave in society. Some of us find that harder than others. You have to try.

Jolinar · 02/08/2022 13:06

I reckon if my brother had been born 10 years later he'd have been diagnosed with ADHD. He was a nightmare child, really very difficult, no sense of danger etc. Puberty came and he turned in to a dream. Definitely NT.

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 02/08/2022 13:04

My ND children are terrified of being told off and are frankly the best 'behaved' kids that I've ever come across. They are absolute sticklers for following the rules.
So, no - of course not all 'naughty' children are ND just as not all ND children are 'naughty'.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:04

he didn’t “get in his face” we was walking past him when he said it

I didn’t suggest he did, I was talking about my DS. You implied that violence =/= autism and I was explaining that it can look like violence.

A more sensible way to deal with your concerns might be to explain to your DS that the little boy has a special type of brain, that it sometimes makes it hard for him to cope with noise or crowds, and that can make him
lash out. DS should be extra kind to him because he isn’t doing it on purpose. I believe that’s called “parenting” and reading posts like your unhinged ranting about disabled people, I find it hilarious that ASC parents are the ones accused of not doing it properly.

You should also speak to the teacher or SENCo about additional TA support to help manage the behaviour of the other kid.

Of course your DS should not be harmed st school, but this is a failure of the school
and LA rather than the overwhelmed child who you so desperately want to blame.

custardbear · 02/08/2022 13:03

With that concept then My children, who are both exceptionally well behaved, should be NT, but they're not unfortunately

Bad behaviour has various factors, sone SEN, some trauma and some just bad parenting or nature/nurture bad behaviours

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 13:02

Purplepatsy · 02/08/2022 12:48

If your child is being referred for adhd or autism the process of assessment is rigorous and a diagnosis won't be made unless the behaviour exists in more than one setting for a prolonged period of time.

I get very irritated by parents who insist that their child is badly behaved at home, but when that bad behaviour does not happen at school, it's because they are 'masking.'

In my view, if they can behave in school, they can also behave at home. I have read a lot of articles purporting to demonstrate how masking works, and how terribly exhausting it is for anyone who does it, but I don't agree.

We all 'mask' to a certain extent. For instance, when we are at a wedding, or in church, we subtly change our behaviour to match the event. We don't behave the same way at a football match as we do when we're out shopping.

That is why a diagnosis of autism or ADHD is based on the same behaviour being shown in more than one setting.

I do believe that children can be naughty without necessarily being neurodivergent.

This. Completely agree that most humans mask. If a child can behave at home then of course they can behave at school. It is a choice not to. We all adapt our behaviour to suit the situation. Yes, this is very easy for some and more difficult for others, but we all have to learn how to do it, otherwise you'd have inappropriate behaviour everywhere by everybody.

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 13:02

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 12:57

Please don't be so rude as to assume people aren't educated.

Clearly, your child shouldn't be in a mainstream school, that behaviour is shocking and unfair on everybody. Secondly, no one on here knows your son, so no one can say whether he knows what he is doing or not.
If he has a normal IQ and no learning difficulties, and understands his own actions, then autistic or not, his behaviour is naughty if he continues to do something he has been asked not to.

Thank you, honestly this is what we have to deal with being told our child is obviously provoking them to act that way, my son doesn’t engage with him or speak to him, he throws chairs around and books at children swears at the teacher, he doesn’t just target my son so not it’s not something my son is doing to cause it, how rude to suggest that! My younger son says he is the same in the playground and everyone is scared of him, He has no friends as they are scared to go near him, why should children be scared to go to school then the parents say well it’s obviously your child is provoking them. So if he is doing it to everyone are they all provoking him them? I agree the child shouldn’t be in mainstream. My son left football club because of this boy and I lost out on my money as I paid it upfront, very insulting to blame to victim.

Gruffling · 02/08/2022 13:01

Yabu. My child is neurodiverse and is the kindest, most 'well behaved' around other children. She has to be like that to mask her autism and try and fit in in a neurotypical world.

Many neurotypical children are badly behaved little shites.

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 12:59

Random789 · 02/08/2022 12:45

In addition to all the other problems with overstating the correlation of naughtiness with neurodivergence, there is the fact that it contributes to the underdiagnosis of various difficulties in girls, whose neurodivergence is often less likely to result in behaviour that is judged to be disruptive.

A side point: This catch-all term 'neurodivergent, and its catch-all antonym 'neurotypical' strikes me as horrible and unhelpful. I'm sure we don't know enough about the brain (and about the very many ways in which individual brains can vary) to be able to authorititively deem one set of neurological features to be 'typical'. And even if we could, everyone's brains would diverge from it to a greater or lesser extent.

There are as many ways of being what is called 'neurotypical' as there are ways of being neurodiverse, and the fiction of a monolithic 'typicality' that only unwell/challenged people 'diverge' from seems to stigmatise both groups.

This so much, I HATE that we are dividing society into NT and ND, with the assumption that no one with NT has any problems and their lives are dandy. Humans are complex. It drives me nuts when people try to fit us into two neat little boxes.

NCHammer2022 · 02/08/2022 12:58

Yes, my brother. He’s still a bit of a prick, tbh, but settled down, grew out of it, did well at secondary school and is a doctor.

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 12:57

Deguster · 02/08/2022 12:40

there is a boy in my sons class who has asd who throws chairs around the class, throws books at children, threatens them, swears at the teacher, but apparently you can’t be autistic and naughty and he’s only doing it cos he is autistic

Thats exactly how my profoundly autistic son behaves in the classroom. He finds school overwhelming and fears demands being made of him. His behaviour is compulsive and a symptom of an overloaded mind, rather than because he’s a horrible little shit (as your post implies). So yeah, it’s totally because he’s autistic.

Please educate yourself.

Please don't be so rude as to assume people aren't educated.

Clearly, your child shouldn't be in a mainstream school, that behaviour is shocking and unfair on everybody. Secondly, no one on here knows your son, so no one can say whether he knows what he is doing or not.
If he has a normal IQ and no learning difficulties, and understands his own actions, then autistic or not, his behaviour is naughty if he continues to do something he has been asked not to.

FarmerRefuted · 02/08/2022 12:55

GreenWheat · 02/08/2022 12:46

Some children are just poorly disciplined with parents who have inconsistent boundaries.

But this does not get a diagnosis. To be diagnosed with a condition you actually need to have the condition and there are thresholds for that diagnosis.

Poor parenting does not cause autism, adhd, pda, etc.

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 12:55

Deguster · 02/08/2022 12:52

Where did I say horrible little shit?

I wrote that you implied it. Reading comprehension not the best, then?

no he’s not profoundly autistic either he is in a mainstream school with no 1:1

My profoundly autistic son attends mainstream school and has an IQ of >160. You clearly know jack shit about autism.

he also threatened to punch my son in the face and called him stupid, is that because he is autistic too?

Possibly. My DS would do that of another child got in his face at a time when he was struggling with sensory overload. It’s impulsive and he can’t control it. He knows hitting is wrong, but pre-meltdown he quite literally has zero impulse control. Of course the LA are literally falling over themselves to offer DS a funded place in a specialist school…said nobody ever.

Do you expect all NT people to behave in exactly the same way? If not, why do you expect it of autistic people?

Again, please educate yourself (especially if you really do have an autistic DS).

oh god here we go, he didn’t “get in his face” we was walking past him when he said it, my son didn’t even look in his direction, and there we have it blaming someone for being bullied or implying they provoked it in some way 🤦🏻

Sweatinglikeabitch · 02/08/2022 12:54

Some are just like that. Some have shit parents. Some have been though traumatic stuff. Some are ND.
Bad behaviour is not autistic behaviour and I wish people would stop connecting the two.

FarmerRefuted · 02/08/2022 12:52

Worth noting too that the term SEN refers to Special Education Need, specifically that a child is not progressing as expected in one or more areas and needs additional support in order to access/progress in those areas.

SN refers to Special Needs, such as a long term condition and/or disability.

Not all children with SN will have SEN and visa versa, although there is often an overlap.

I have a NT child who was on the SEN register at school for a time as they were behind in one specific area of learning (SAL). They had support to help bring them on, targets to work towards, and their progress was monitored. By the end of the school term they were back in line with age related expectations, did not need further support, and so came off the SEN register.

I also have two disabled children who are on the SEN register as their disabilities impact on their ability to access education without the correct support, they can do the work but they need scaffolding in order to do so. Both have an EHCP.

Having multiple children with SEN in a class doesn't mean that they all have disabilities, medical conditions, or neurodevelopment issues.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 12:52

Where did I say horrible little shit?

I wrote that you implied it. Reading comprehension not the best, then?

no he’s not profoundly autistic either he is in a mainstream school with no 1:1

My profoundly autistic son attends mainstream school and has an IQ of >160. You clearly know jack shit about autism.

he also threatened to punch my son in the face and called him stupid, is that because he is autistic too?

Possibly. My DS would do that of another child got in his face at a time when he was struggling with sensory overload. It’s impulsive and he can’t control it. He knows hitting is wrong, but pre-meltdown he quite literally has zero impulse control. Of course the LA are literally falling over themselves to offer DS a funded place in a specialist school…said nobody ever.

Do you expect all NT people to behave in exactly the same way? If not, why do you expect it of autistic people?

Again, please educate yourself (especially if you really do have an autistic DS).

Ylvamoon · 02/08/2022 12:50

... stick a label on and suddenly it's fine!

Honestly, I think children need to learn to "behave" so that they can negotiate the complexity of our world/ society.

You can say, that they can't help themselves ect. But in the end they need to be able to live life as an adult.

It's hard and it's difficult because schools and many workplaces don't cater for different types of people. They have a one size fits all approach ... I really think that the increasing in the number of children with a ND diagnosis is a direct result of this.
plus children are starting school far to early!

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 12:50

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 12:49

@BiscoffSundae without butting in, just because the boy doesn't have a 1-1 and is in mainstream doesn't mean he's not profoundly autistic. The waiting lists are very, very long for school age children. It's "lucky" if your child is referred and seen whilst of preschool age, and also if it was pre-covid. The waiting list in my area is now minimum two years just for the first appointment with a paediatrician.

Either way my point still stands I should accept my son being bullied because the child bullying him has autism? Hmm...

sandradailey · 02/08/2022 12:49

x2boys · 02/08/2022 11:20

You realise it's a spectrum right?
My child has severe autism and learning disabilities, he has no concept of 'naughty behaviour " his behaviour is often very challenging but that is due to his disabilities.

Snap. My son runs around and is constantly jumping around and hyperactive. He also can't use a toilet or respond to his name being called. And he can't even communicate a basic need of needing a drink

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 12:49

@BiscoffSundae without butting in, just because the boy doesn't have a 1-1 and is in mainstream doesn't mean he's not profoundly autistic. The waiting lists are very, very long for school age children. It's "lucky" if your child is referred and seen whilst of preschool age, and also if it was pre-covid. The waiting list in my area is now minimum two years just for the first appointment with a paediatrician.

OP posts:
Purplepatsy · 02/08/2022 12:48

If your child is being referred for adhd or autism the process of assessment is rigorous and a diagnosis won't be made unless the behaviour exists in more than one setting for a prolonged period of time.

I get very irritated by parents who insist that their child is badly behaved at home, but when that bad behaviour does not happen at school, it's because they are 'masking.'

In my view, if they can behave in school, they can also behave at home. I have read a lot of articles purporting to demonstrate how masking works, and how terribly exhausting it is for anyone who does it, but I don't agree.

We all 'mask' to a certain extent. For instance, when we are at a wedding, or in church, we subtly change our behaviour to match the event. We don't behave the same way at a football match as we do when we're out shopping.

That is why a diagnosis of autism or ADHD is based on the same behaviour being shown in more than one setting.

I do believe that children can be naughty without necessarily being neurodivergent.

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 12:47

Deguster · 02/08/2022 12:40

there is a boy in my sons class who has asd who throws chairs around the class, throws books at children, threatens them, swears at the teacher, but apparently you can’t be autistic and naughty and he’s only doing it cos he is autistic

Thats exactly how my profoundly autistic son behaves in the classroom. He finds school overwhelming and fears demands being made of him. His behaviour is compulsive and a symptom of an overloaded mind, rather than because he’s a horrible little shit (as your post implies). So yeah, it’s totally because he’s autistic.

Please educate yourself.

Because he is autistic I should allow him to threaten my son and call him names 🤔 my son doesn’t want to go to school because he is scared of him and I should go and “educate myself” you can bully people and be autistic, it’s not impossible to be a bully because you have autism.

easyday · 02/08/2022 12:47

Kids test boundaries, it's called growing up. Much of this behaviour will be considered naughty. They eventually mature and develop and push boundaries in other ways.
Id be a bit concerned if a child is always compliant and is never 'naughty'.

Guiltycat · 02/08/2022 12:46

No.

The same as all neurodivergent children are not naughty.