Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all "naughty" children actually neurodivergent?

208 replies

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 11:11

As the subject asks. The children in my life (friends, family, DC school peers, colleagues' children) fall into two camps - the ones who can be stubborn at home, but tend to behave fabulously for anyone who isn't their parents including at school.

And those who are challenging in many settings, don't like to conform, oppositional. So many of these are being referred for ADHD/Autism after a year or two at school, mine included.

Does anyone have any actual experience of "naughty" children (by naughty I mean doesn't do what they're asked, refusal to comply, cheeky, rude, attitude) who did eventually grow out of it?

OP posts:
GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 02/08/2022 13:48

lifeturnsonadime · 02/08/2022 11:23

Well I can flip that and say that my neurodivergent children are not naughty.

They never behaved badly when at school.

Yep, my autistic DD has always been impeccably behaved, and her teachers and school reports corroborate this.

Conversely, there are lots of NT kids in her class who are little horrors.

ohfook · 02/08/2022 13:47

In my experience it looks to people outside the situation that ND (and indeed a lot of NT) children act worse for their parents. In reality I'd say they feel safest with their parents and spend a lot of the day in school or childcare masking rather than behaving the problem with that is it has to come out somewhere. There's an often used analogy in Sen education of a shaken pop bottle which finally explodes when the lid is taken off. I this case the kids being taken off is when the child finally gets somewhere they can relax.

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 13:42

@crwnhgow I don't know if that was directed at me, but if it was I don't think anywhere on this thread have I suggested that autistic people don't have it bad. If you read my comments you'll see that I've explained that my DS has been referred for an assessment, and that it was me, not his school initially (although thankfully the helpful Senco agrees with me) that there might be an underlying reason for his "naughty" behaviour. I've also made it clear that I don't think all ND children are naughty.

OP posts:
germsandcoffee · 02/08/2022 13:41

I've got autistic children who have no concept of how to be naughty 🤷‍♀️it's just who they are.
I was an absolute brat growing up but I've mostly grown out of it,I'm still cheeky but in a funny way and always nicely push boundaries but I'm socially normal for a better word!
So yes I was a kid who just was naughty 🤣

MrsG010814 · 02/08/2022 13:41

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 13:31

I would suggest that the child who is physically harming other children is home educated (there being no legal requirement to send them to that specific school) until proper provision can be made. No parent in that situation will do that, and I understand that to a point, but in lieu of that they are expecting young children to somehow be able to rationalise and cope with being attacked at school.

You are not going to be able to insist that your child’s employees put up with this on the basis of the importance of tolerance, and I really struggle that some think it’s ok to insist that young children put up with it because there’s just no other choice.

And how do you suggest the parent pays their bills if they have to give up work to home educate? Children with SEN are entitled to an education at school, the issue is support is not adequate in a lot of cases and that is no fault of the child or parents. Alternative provision may take years to be available if at all.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:39

@rainbowmilk speaking from bitter experience, if a child is removed from school then the LA will wash its hands of said child. I have a job and other caring responsibilities that mean home school is totally impossible for us.

I really don’t like the thinking behind these “out of sight, out of mind” comments. No child should be harmed at school, but ND people are not going anywhere. They are most likely to learn to manage any traits of their autism that are troublesome if they are included and allowed to participate in normal communities, in just the same way as ND children learn to rub along and lose their rough edges.

And yes, the LA/school/whatever should be making that happen. Blaming the child will increase their distress and anxiety. These are disabled children, FGS.

EhatBow · 02/08/2022 13:38

A place in a special school costs between £30k and £60kpa.

Obviously in a perfect world there'd be a place for everyone who needs one, but if we're really talking 1 in 5 children, who's paying for that? How high are you prepared to see taxes go?

crwnhgow · 02/08/2022 13:36

Are you the same poster who came on a thread on the neurodiversity mumsnetters board to talk about how autistic people don't have it that bad actually and ended up swearing at everyone?

An autistic person masking is not the same as a neurotypical person acting a little but more polite for a while.

howshouldibehave · 02/08/2022 13:31

The failure is the school’s

I disagree. Usually the failure is down to a lack of funding from the LEA, due to government policy.

We had a child a few years back who repeatedly lashed out at staff and children-causing significant distress and some permanent scarring. There is no diagnosis, but in all likelihood they have ASD with a PDA profile-the parents don’t wish to seek a diagnosis and school cannot refer. They have an EHCP and professionals recommend alternative provision but there are no spaces anywhere locally. They really need 2:1 to keep staff and peers safe in a mainstream environment, but the funding allocated only actually covers 1:1 for about 80% of the day (including the £6000 the school has to provide). The parents believe the funding will pay for a specialist autism teacher, in reality it allows the school to hire someone totally untrained on just above minimum wage.

This is not the school’s fault.

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 13:31

I would suggest that the child who is physically harming other children is home educated (there being no legal requirement to send them to that specific school) until proper provision can be made. No parent in that situation will do that, and I understand that to a point, but in lieu of that they are expecting young children to somehow be able to rationalise and cope with being attacked at school.

You are not going to be able to insist that your child’s employees put up with this on the basis of the importance of tolerance, and I really struggle that some think it’s ok to insist that young children put up with it because there’s just no other choice.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:28

"What's the alternative?" Are you for real? You actually think it's ok for children in mainstream to be abused?

Quite obviously I was talking about alternatives to mainstream. My options with DS are:

  • remove him from school. LA under no further obligation to help. I get prosecuted and probably a SS referral.
  • keep sending him to mainstream school. Maintain vague hope that the LA will find a suitable place for him. Hope the school manages his behaviour.
saying “he shouldn’t be in mainstream” is about as helpful as saying”Father Christmas should exist”. Yes, it would be great. No, it’s not realistic because these places either don’t exist or are not funded.

Every child deserves an education, including those with disabilities.

Underhisi · 02/08/2022 13:27

"Another rude person. I'm very educated thanks. I don't think you are, though?"

If you are a teacher in a mainstream school you probably won't have much understanding of autism.

MrsG010814 · 02/08/2022 13:25

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 13:20

"What's the alternative?" Are you for real? You actually think it's ok for children in mainstream to be abused?
This is extremely upsetting and disturbing.

Nobody is saying that it's OK but what would you suggest? It is the school and local authority's failure to provide adequate support to children in mainstream schools who struggle for a variety of reasons relating to their SEN.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:23

True meltdowns are different and rare, they are out of control. Some people get confused between what is an autistic meltdown and what is a temper tantrum, however

My son was hospitalized and needed stitches after headbutting a wall repeatedly, after I bought milk with a blue lid instead of a green lid. He couldn’t remember anything after seeing me with the milk. Is that “autistic meltdown” enough for you or would you like more examples that he’s not just a little shit having a tantrum?

Out of interest, would you insist a child in a wheelchair played football? Because it’s kind of the same.

You may well be correct about specialist schools. But until then, mainstream is the only game in town and legally we have to keep sending them in. If you want to do something constructive (and complaining about disabled children on MN clearly isn’t that) please help us support our children by pressuring the schools to put proper support in place. Because no LA can pull hundreds of special school places out if their arsehole.

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 13:20

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:14

We absolutely need to encourage kids to be tolerant of differences, but not in circumstances where they’re being physically or mentally harmed, FFS

But what’s the alternative? Go back to the days of asylums and lock autistic children away from the world? Or finish Asperger’s work for him?

The failure is the school’s. In all likelihood, the child cannot control the behaviour. My DS is exceptionally distressed when he finds out he’s hurt us during a meltdown.

"What's the alternative?" Are you for real? You actually think it's ok for children in mainstream to be abused?
This is extremely upsetting and disturbing.

Underhisi · 02/08/2022 13:20

Their are some clueless people on this thread. People will patiently explain things to them but they won't get it because they don't want to get it.

Triffid1 · 02/08/2022 13:19

I am not sure it's as simple as that. I do think that "naughtiness" at age 3 or 4 or 5 is pretty common and has nothing to do with whether a child is NT or ND. As they get older, I'd say that a relatively high percentage of children who display "naughty" behaviour are ND, but certainly not all. Some may simply be badly parented. Some may be responding to trauma. Some may not have the emotional or intellectual skills to manage their behaviour. It's certainly not a given that the child is ND.

Also, as a parent with a child who is ND - I agree with others that the trick is helping those children to navigate the world. I want him to be accepted and I am appreciative of accommodations that are made for him, but, assuming he lives a long and healthy life, he is going to have to navigate a lot of situations and people and places where accommodations are not going to be made. So he is going to have to learn how to do figure out solutions for himself.

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 13:17

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:12

Clearly, your child shouldn't be in a mainstream school, that behaviour is shocking and unfair on everybody. Secondly, no one on here knows your son, so no one can say whether he knows what he is doing or not

Great, I’ll get on to the LA and tell them that a poster on MN who has never met my son thinks he needs a specialist place shall I? Im
sure that will help. In the meantime, I’ll be breaking the law if I don’t send him to mainstream school where he will behave exactly as I described. Any more great suggestions?

In fairness to the LA, there are not many places that can cater to profoundly autistic people with IQ’s in the very upper ranges. So it’s really not as simple, on any level, as you seem to think.

If he has a normal IQ and no learning difficulties, and understands his own actions, then autistic or not, his behaviour is naughty if he continues to do something he has been asked not to

Another person who knows jack about how autistic children can present. Again, please educate yourself - there are hundreds of publications explaining the links between ASC and sensory challenges, ADHD, and overwhelm/meltdown. Behaviour is often compulsive and the child is not in control.

Another rude person. I'm very educated thanks. I don't think you are, though?

True meltdowns are different and rare, they are out of control. Some people get confused between what is an autistic meltdown and what is a temper tantrum, however. Parents will claim their child is out of control, except they stop when they get what they want. To me, that is very in control.

Mumsnet shows time and time again that Autism is a topic with huge disagreements and misunderstandings on all sides.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:14

We absolutely need to encourage kids to be tolerant of differences, but not in circumstances where they’re being physically or mentally harmed, FFS

But what’s the alternative? Go back to the days of asylums and lock autistic children away from the world? Or finish Asperger’s work for him?

The failure is the school’s. In all likelihood, the child cannot control the behaviour. My DS is exceptionally distressed when he finds out he’s hurt us during a meltdown.

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 13:13

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 13:02

Thank you, honestly this is what we have to deal with being told our child is obviously provoking them to act that way, my son doesn’t engage with him or speak to him, he throws chairs around and books at children swears at the teacher, he doesn’t just target my son so not it’s not something my son is doing to cause it, how rude to suggest that! My younger son says he is the same in the playground and everyone is scared of him, He has no friends as they are scared to go near him, why should children be scared to go to school then the parents say well it’s obviously your child is provoking them. So if he is doing it to everyone are they all provoking him them? I agree the child shouldn’t be in mainstream. My son left football club because of this boy and I lost out on my money as I paid it upfront, very insulting to blame to victim.

I completely understand. This is actually making me a bit emotional because I've had to deal with similar behaviour this year in my class from a variety of children with SEN needs. There's a few issues going on here, but if these children with SEN are intelligent enough, that is they don't have learning difficulties, then a lot of them do understand what they are doing. And in that case, it is completely unacceptable and plain naughty and horrible.
Some children with autism also have learning difficulties which means they don't understand. That's not naughtiness,, of course. They don't know what they're doing!
But either way, whether a child understands or not, if they continue to act like that they should NOT be in mainstream. I feel so so strongly about this. I have had little children in my class hit, smacked, kicked, screamed at, sworn at etc this year. It is unbearable. As a teacher, I felt utterly helpless. You're not allowed to give consequences to children with SEN in my school, despite them knowing what they're doing!!!

Underhisi · 02/08/2022 13:13

"there is a boy in my sons class who has asd who throws chairs around the class, throws books at children, threatens them, swears at the teacher, but apparently you can’t be autistic and naughty and he’s only doing it cos he is autistic"

My friends daughter ( diagnosed age 3) did most of that when in mainstream school without proper support. She is now in mainstream classrooms in a different school with proper support and she doesn't do it. She is fortunate that her parents were able to fight for the support she needed including going to Tribunal to get it as rarely do disabled children get the support they need without parents fighting for it.

MugginsOverEre · 02/08/2022 13:12

Nope. Nurture plays a part too. There are plenty of feral children running around from troubled families, shouting abuse to passers by, harassing whole neighbourhoods, littering, vandalising and one ten year old had a knife against a small child's throat a few years ago. Then there's the spoiled brats of more well off families who are allowed to be generally unpleasant all the time. Encouraged from birth to be awful, selfish, grabby and even violent.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:12

Clearly, your child shouldn't be in a mainstream school, that behaviour is shocking and unfair on everybody. Secondly, no one on here knows your son, so no one can say whether he knows what he is doing or not

Great, I’ll get on to the LA and tell them that a poster on MN who has never met my son thinks he needs a specialist place shall I? Im
sure that will help. In the meantime, I’ll be breaking the law if I don’t send him to mainstream school where he will behave exactly as I described. Any more great suggestions?

In fairness to the LA, there are not many places that can cater to profoundly autistic people with IQ’s in the very upper ranges. So it’s really not as simple, on any level, as you seem to think.

If he has a normal IQ and no learning difficulties, and understands his own actions, then autistic or not, his behaviour is naughty if he continues to do something he has been asked not to

Another person who knows jack about how autistic children can present. Again, please educate yourself - there are hundreds of publications explaining the links between ASC and sensory challenges, ADHD, and overwhelm/meltdown. Behaviour is often compulsive and the child is not in control.

InChocolateWeTrust · 02/08/2022 13:10

Lots of NT children are naughty.

Usually due to poor parenting, so no boundaries, inconsistent consequences or no consequences, lack of modelling of good behaviour etc.

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 13:10

DS should be extra kind to him because he isn’t doing it on purpose

This was the attitude of the staff at my school. The boy physically assaulted pupils and teachers and his victims were told to #bekind. It’s a hideous life lesson. In what adult world would we ask adults to be extra kind to people who are physically assaulting or verbally abusing them?

We absolutely need to encourage kids to be tolerant of differences, but not in circumstances where they’re being physically or mentally harmed, FFS.