Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all "naughty" children actually neurodivergent?

208 replies

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 11:11

As the subject asks. The children in my life (friends, family, DC school peers, colleagues' children) fall into two camps - the ones who can be stubborn at home, but tend to behave fabulously for anyone who isn't their parents including at school.

And those who are challenging in many settings, don't like to conform, oppositional. So many of these are being referred for ADHD/Autism after a year or two at school, mine included.

Does anyone have any actual experience of "naughty" children (by naughty I mean doesn't do what they're asked, refusal to comply, cheeky, rude, attitude) who did eventually grow out of it?

OP posts:
gogohmm · 02/08/2022 14:55

No, there are naughty neurotypical children and angelically behaved neurodiverse kids, just like with most of life, it varies

Also whilst some neurodiverse children do not understand right and wrong - others are very aware and can be naughty!

OliviaBond · 02/08/2022 14:46

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 13:31

I would suggest that the child who is physically harming other children is home educated (there being no legal requirement to send them to that specific school) until proper provision can be made. No parent in that situation will do that, and I understand that to a point, but in lieu of that they are expecting young children to somehow be able to rationalise and cope with being attacked at school.

You are not going to be able to insist that your child’s employees put up with this on the basis of the importance of tolerance, and I really struggle that some think it’s ok to insist that young children put up with it because there’s just no other choice.

The LA aren't under any legal obligation to provide any provision once a child is home educated.

Underhisi · 02/08/2022 14:44

"So you're saying that you think children with Autism cannot be naughty?!?!"

She is saying that it is unlikely that her child is being "naughty".
The same with my own. His behaviour however challenging it may be, is focused on getting his needs met so he doesn't feel hungry, thirsty, in pain or feel sensory distress. He has no interest in winding up or annoying anyone else or having things for material reasons.

OliviaBond · 02/08/2022 14:39

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 13:50

It is on the parent of a violent child to make alternative provision. I’m not lacking in sympathy, it’s very sad, but the status quo of children (some of whom will also be disabled) being exposed to, or actually subjected to, physical violence at school is totally unacceptable and the shrugging justifications for this, much less insistence that the victims be kind, are abhorrent to me.

I’m not going to be responding further as it’s quite clear that nobody is going to change their view on this as it’d involve not putting their child first.

No, it's on the LA of a 'violent' child to ensure alternative provision is in place. Parents discharge their legal duty to provide education when they enroll a child in school. It is then up to the school and LA to ensure that child's needs are met and if they are met appropriately, you won't have a violent child on your hands.

OliviaBond · 02/08/2022 14:32

'The children in my life (friends, family, DC school peers, colleagues' children) fall into two camps - the ones who can be stubborn at home, but tend to behave fabulously for anyone who isn't their parents including at school.'

You just described my ND child...it's called masking.

PollyEsther · 02/08/2022 14:32

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 13:50

It is on the parent of a violent child to make alternative provision. I’m not lacking in sympathy, it’s very sad, but the status quo of children (some of whom will also be disabled) being exposed to, or actually subjected to, physical violence at school is totally unacceptable and the shrugging justifications for this, much less insistence that the victims be kind, are abhorrent to me.

I’m not going to be responding further as it’s quite clear that nobody is going to change their view on this as it’d involve not putting their child first.

No. It isn't. Education is a human right that, at primary age, the government is legally responsible to provide. Additionally, any child with 1:1 has an EHCP, which legally prescribes their education needs and rights. Not surprised you're refusing to engage, people usually do when they know deep down that they are wrong.

ThePumpkinPatch · 02/08/2022 14:31

x2boys · 02/08/2022 11:20

You realise it's a spectrum right?
My child has severe autism and learning disabilities, he has no concept of 'naughty behaviour " his behaviour is often very challenging but that is due to his disabilities.

So you're saying that you think children with Autism cannot be naughty?!?! My child has Autism and very much IS naughty in ways that have absolutely ZERO association to her ASD! She's a little sh*t when she wants to be....🙈
Yes she can also behave in ways that may appear to others as naughty, but actually it's a manifestation of her ASD. 90% of the time though, she's just plain naughty...!

PollyEsther · 02/08/2022 14:20

BiscoffSundae · 02/08/2022 12:44

Where did I say horrible little shit? Your words not mine, I just think he’s naughty and autistic, because you can be both, he’s not profoundly autistic either he is in a mainstream school with no 1:1, he also threatened to punch my son in the face and called him stupid, is that because he is autistic too?

More than likely.

My son is 10, and also a thrower/shouter, swearer/threatener. It is never without provokation or trigger. Ever. What did your son do that led to the child feeling that way about him? Or is yours a perfect angel who would never, ever whisper some nasty little quip to the other disabled kid but then get away with it because they're 'so well behaved?' All children misbehave wilfully at times. All ND children struggle to regulate their behaviour to some extent. It's not a competition, and my child isn't any less worthy of humanity than yours.

To be clear, my son is 1:1 full time in mainstream AND profoundly autistic. You can be both. So, as the PP said: please educate yourself. Properly.

Friendship101 · 02/08/2022 14:17

My friend has 2 children who she and her husband don’t discipline. The eldest is in year 3 at school now and starting to behave much better. The youngest is going into year 1 and is still a challenge. They’re waiting for school to teach them how to behave.

Moonface123 · 02/08/2022 14:15

Children are now expected to behave like little robots, it makes life easier for teachers and parents but crushes the spirit out of them. Everything these days is so organised including leisure time, we used to come home from school and play out over the fields unsupervised for hours,to let off steam after being couped up all day. l remember a teacher saying my youngest has no fear of authority, after she told him to stop running around in the playground when he was approx 8 years old and he didn' t.
Smug parents who have children with complient temperants think its all down to their way of parenting, until they go on to have another child who isn 't so eager to please and they have to resort to using other stratergies. Temperant is key, if you have an assertive child who isn't a natural people pleaser as a parent you will have your work cut out, but these are usually the children who become very succesful as adults further on down the line.

CuteGroot · 02/08/2022 14:10

That should have read

With an EHCP, and a LOT of fight (often at the expense of their parents’ livelihoods, mental health, other children) they MIGHT (very unlikely) get a place

CuteGroot · 02/08/2022 14:09

There is no provision.

I’m a leader in education.

Children with SEMH (what used to be referred to as behavioural issues) but no severe developmental / cognitive issues can’t get a place in special schools (and these are like hen’s teeth anyway).

Without an EHCP they end up in Pupil Referral Units.

With an EHCP, and a LOT of fight (often at the expense of their parents’ livelihoods, mental health, other children) get a place at a privately run specialist school, the vast majority of which in my experience are not fit for purpose when you dig beyond their shiny brochures. They are also almost all profiteering outfits, taking huge amounts of local authority money to invest in property and various markets.

Pleaee don’t blame parents and carers for the failings of successive governments to get education for children with SEND or SEMH right.

fatlazycow · 02/08/2022 14:05

Gobsmacked someone is saying it is on the parents if there is no funding or school places their child desperately needs

wtf

Beechview · 02/08/2022 14:02

Some children are dealing with a lot at home and can act out. They can be neglected, bullied and sometimes left playing fortnite for hours on end.
I've also seen very bright children bored at school who end up being labelled naughty because they're quite independent in their thinking and don't want to do things that they see no point in doing, from their point of view.

UWhatNow · 02/08/2022 14:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

fatlazycow · 02/08/2022 14:00

Yes what alternative provision??

what exactly are parents supposed to do?

crwnhgow · 02/08/2022 13:57

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 13:50

It is on the parent of a violent child to make alternative provision. I’m not lacking in sympathy, it’s very sad, but the status quo of children (some of whom will also be disabled) being exposed to, or actually subjected to, physical violence at school is totally unacceptable and the shrugging justifications for this, much less insistence that the victims be kind, are abhorrent to me.

I’m not going to be responding further as it’s quite clear that nobody is going to change their view on this as it’d involve not putting their child first.

Great, and if there's no alternative provision available?

crwnhgow · 02/08/2022 13:55

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 13:42

@crwnhgow I don't know if that was directed at me, but if it was I don't think anywhere on this thread have I suggested that autistic people don't have it bad. If you read my comments you'll see that I've explained that my DS has been referred for an assessment, and that it was me, not his school initially (although thankfully the helpful Senco agrees with me) that there might be an underlying reason for his "naughty" behaviour. I've also made it clear that I don't think all ND children are naughty.

Apologies, I'm still getting used to the new quoting system. I was responding to @missbunnyrabbit's post at 13:02 minimizing the difficulty autistic people have with masking.

Underhisi · 02/08/2022 13:54

"It is on the parent of a violent child to make alternative provision."

The LA has a duty to provide a suitable full time education. That is the law that overrides any opinions.

x2boys · 02/08/2022 13:53

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 13:31

I would suggest that the child who is physically harming other children is home educated (there being no legal requirement to send them to that specific school) until proper provision can be made. No parent in that situation will do that, and I understand that to a point, but in lieu of that they are expecting young children to somehow be able to rationalise and cope with being attacked at school.

You are not going to be able to insist that your child’s employees put up with this on the basis of the importance of tolerance, and I really struggle that some think it’s ok to insist that young children put up with it because there’s just no other choice.

All children are entitled to a school place ,my son is in a special school as his needs are very complex and cam be met in the LEA,s special school unfortunately is not a one size fits all and my sons school cares primarily for children with severe learning disabilities and autism ,there are special schools that cater for children who don't have additional learning disabilities, but they xost ££££££,s and LEA ,s are often reluctant to pay for then however it is the LEA,s responsibility to fund suitable education in or out of Borough.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:53

It is on the parent of a violent child to make alternative provision

There.
Is.
No.
Provision.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 13:51

There's an often used analogy in Sen education of a shaken pop bottle which finally explodes when the lid is taken off. I this case the kids being taken off is when the child finally gets somewhere they can relax

Absolutely true of DS. Not just different environments, but different people. Both my DM and my DH can take DS to a restaurant and he behaves impeccably. I’m his “safe space” so he lets all his autistic bits go wild when we’re alone, meaning that I’m more limited in what I can do alone with him.

DS was diagnosed age 3 at the Lorna Wing centre, and is followed up there every year. All completely normal for an autistic kiddo.

Confrontayshunme · 02/08/2022 13:51

We have four naughty children in our class. The most difficult has attachment disorder (and a lot of resulting behaviours) from being in care, one is definitely on the spectrum, one has been abused and cannot form relationships or self-soothe without tantrums, and the fourth is just a jerk raised by other jerks. So for the most part, yes.

rainbowmilk · 02/08/2022 13:50

It is on the parent of a violent child to make alternative provision. I’m not lacking in sympathy, it’s very sad, but the status quo of children (some of whom will also be disabled) being exposed to, or actually subjected to, physical violence at school is totally unacceptable and the shrugging justifications for this, much less insistence that the victims be kind, are abhorrent to me.

I’m not going to be responding further as it’s quite clear that nobody is going to change their view on this as it’d involve not putting their child first.

Underhisi · 02/08/2022 13:49

"A place in a special school costs between £30k and £60kpa."

It's a minimum of £60k at ds's school. Ds's place is probably about £150k with transport. There is not enough suitable maintained special provision ( no Asd special schools) so the LA are being forced to use independent specialist schools.