Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all "naughty" children actually neurodivergent?

208 replies

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 11:11

As the subject asks. The children in my life (friends, family, DC school peers, colleagues' children) fall into two camps - the ones who can be stubborn at home, but tend to behave fabulously for anyone who isn't their parents including at school.

And those who are challenging in many settings, don't like to conform, oppositional. So many of these are being referred for ADHD/Autism after a year or two at school, mine included.

Does anyone have any actual experience of "naughty" children (by naughty I mean doesn't do what they're asked, refusal to comply, cheeky, rude, attitude) who did eventually grow out of it?

OP posts:
HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 19:58

Imagine trying to tell people there is no difference between children with SEN and those without. Lol.

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 19:57

Ignorant comment, please educate yourself. :)
If you actually think human beings can be sorted into two boxes then ...wow. The fact that you have sorted your children is bizarre. Your NT children might have secret difficulties that they hide, you have no idea what they might be thinking or masking, just because they are compliant and well behaved or whatever.

You don't have any experience of SEN do you? 😆

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 19:55

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 19:51

*Why on earth do you think that someone being labelled 'neurotypical' means they will have an easy life?!
It's not NT = easy life and ND = hard life.

I find it extremely offensive. It's just plain dumb to try to put human beings into two perfect boxes.*

Wow imagine taking a person's account of the way their child's additional needs impacts their life and making it all about you. I have nt children and one with SEN and I can assure you, life is harder since the latter.

Ignorant comment, please educate yourself. :)
If you actually think human beings can be sorted into two boxes then ...wow. The fact that you have sorted your children is bizarre. Your NT children might have secret difficulties that they hide, you have no idea what they might be thinking or masking, just because they are compliant and well behaved or whatever.

You cannot just sort people into neat boxes.

Trying2310 · 02/08/2022 19:53

Some of the comments on here are absolutely shocking and show a lack of awareness of autism and the way it can present across the spectrum. For those children who have been diagnosed by a clinican, their parents could tell you that it is a long drawn out process with lots of assessments from school and at home. For those saying that if it presents only at home and not a school, quite frankly don't have a clue what they are talking about and should educate themselves before making such inflammatory statements that can cause offence. My ASD and ADHD (11) is good as gold in school and is actually very frightened of getting things wrong or in trouble. As he has got older, he is also actuely aware that he is 'different' to his classmates and he tries his best to fit in and follow the social norms. He spends each day trying to read situations and emotions that he doesn't fully understand, keep friendships going and try to navigate through changing and developing relationships. He also has to work out the NT memebers of his class calling him autistic boy. ' kick the ball properly autistic boy' should he have to put up with that?! He tries to work out expectations of each of his different teachers and classrooms. By the time he gets home he has masked all day and like a PP explained its the coke bottle effect. Someone observing our family home could claim he is just naughty and disrespectful (and sometimes he is) but a lot of the time he is in a meltdown and cannot help his reactions. Whenever he comes out of the meltdown he is deeply sorry and ashamed but can often not remember the content of the meltdown. Now try having that level of anxiety every day and in every situation!

No-one is saying that any other child should be on the receiving end of any violence and this should be managed by the school and the correct support given to all students. The level of support and provision for SEN students is so poor and that it can be a contributing factor in a disregulated child presenting like they are naughty.

As a teacher I have witnessed many vulnerable and SEN students being wound up, provoked and bullied by students who are aware of how that child will react and they sit by and watch their reactions and punishment with glee.

Other PP are quite rightly said that some NT children are naughty (could be for a variety of different reasons) and some not. In the same way some ND children can be naughty and take advantage of a situation. However, when a ND child is in a meltdown they are not being naughty and these meltdowns can present in many different ways.

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 19:51

*Why on earth do you think that someone being labelled 'neurotypical' means they will have an easy life?!
It's not NT = easy life and ND = hard life.

I find it extremely offensive. It's just plain dumb to try to put human beings into two perfect boxes.*

Wow imagine taking a person's account of the way their child's additional needs impacts their life and making it all about you. I have nt children and one with SEN and I can assure you, life is harder since the latter.

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 19:49

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 02/08/2022 15:58

I try not to label any child as 'naughty', NT or ND...

So what's the definition then of doing something you've been told not to do, and you make an active choice to do it anyway?

missbunnyrabbit · 02/08/2022 19:46

Deguster · 02/08/2022 15:47

@Goldbar Yes, it is heartbreaking. I absolutely understand and I hate all this "super power" schtick. I would do anything to make DS' life easier and to ease his anxiety, but the only thing that would do that is to make him NT - which we are told is somehow "denying his true identity". I sometimes feel stuck between a rock, a hard place and another rock - i.e. the parents who just want DS to disappear from their naice school and their children (who never get the blame for anything in which DS is also involved because scapegoating), the ill-informed twats who think autism a superpower (but can't cope with DS for more than a few minutes) and the typically very "high functioning" advocates for autistic people who think the reason DS gets destabilised is because I am not managing his sensory needs adequately.

DS has no friends. He cannot understand why other people don't want to spend breaks memorising things or walking in a circle a set number of times. The school saw some "improvement" when he started hanging out with a group of girls. It turned out they were plaiting his hair, putting him in dressing up clothes, basically treating him like a pet - and he has basically been taught that he needs to be more accommodating of NT children, so just accepts them dragging him around because he thinks that's what friendship is.

Why on earth do you think that someone being labelled 'neurotypical' means they will have an easy life?!
It's not NT = easy life and ND = hard life.

I find it extremely offensive. It's just plain dumb to try to put human beings into two perfect boxes.

Willyoujustbequiet · 02/08/2022 17:05

There are lots of neurodiverse kids who are perfectly well behaved.

The op seems to imply that ASD/ADHD is trotted out as an excuse for bad behaviour/not a real diagnosis which is incredibly offensive and ableist

Goldbar · 02/08/2022 16:57

@Deguster . Yes, I guessed it was another post you meant to tag but didn't want to not reply... I can imagine how difficult it is to deal with all that "superpower" rubbish when you have a real, distressed child to care for. I absolutely agree that tolerance and education are needed both ways. It helps because we've known my DC's friend since he was a baby, but DC is aware that there are certain games his friend likes to play and certain things he doesn't like (and also that taking his sweets, toys or other treats just because he says ok is absolutely not on...). ND children should absolutely be encouraged and helped to have appropriate personal boundaries and imo schools should be on the ball to make sure that other children don't infringe these boundaries just because some ND children may not be able to speak up for themselves effectively.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 16:41

Exactly @Goldbar - instead of supporting the autistic children to adjust, what they often infer is that any NT behaviour is "normal" and has to be accepted. DS has waist-length, very beautiful hair because he cannot tolerate the hairdresser (noise, people, physical contact - ugh!) He feels that he "has" to let the girls play with his hair - and he comes home with ornate french plaits and space buns - because his place is to accommodate other people's strange (to him) expectations while ignoring his own needs. Tolerance really should go both ways, especially with young children, all of whom need a bit of domestication!

And he's also been biffed at school - the response I get from teachers is pretty much "they're at primary school - it's not uncommon and they'll learn". Until its my DS doing the biffing when suddenly it's a Massive Deal because autistic.

I also apologise because I meant to tag @PollyEsther in my reply to her post.

Goldbar · 02/08/2022 16:30

@Deguster . I know the mother of my DC's little friend worries about that too and my heart goes out to you and everyone else who has to help their children navigate this. It is so tricky. I can already see the issues ahead for this little boy in terms of socal interaction and his lovely sweet nature being taken advantage of. He is just so accommodating to other children, especially when he finds them overwhelming, that it is hard for him to understand that he is entitled to have personal boundaries in the way that my NT 4yo already does (for example, in not immediately handing over a treat like a biscuit or sweet to my DC when he does actually want it just because my DC asks for it).

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 02/08/2022 15:58

I try not to label any child as 'naughty', NT or ND...

Deguster · 02/08/2022 15:55

PS - your DS sounds lovely. One of the cruellest things about the lack of specialist provision is that autistic children don't necessarily meet anyone "like" them with whom they might click. Cheesy but profoundly autistic children instinctively seem to "get" each other when they meet.

Deguster · 02/08/2022 15:47

@Goldbar Yes, it is heartbreaking. I absolutely understand and I hate all this "super power" schtick. I would do anything to make DS' life easier and to ease his anxiety, but the only thing that would do that is to make him NT - which we are told is somehow "denying his true identity". I sometimes feel stuck between a rock, a hard place and another rock - i.e. the parents who just want DS to disappear from their naice school and their children (who never get the blame for anything in which DS is also involved because scapegoating), the ill-informed twats who think autism a superpower (but can't cope with DS for more than a few minutes) and the typically very "high functioning" advocates for autistic people who think the reason DS gets destabilised is because I am not managing his sensory needs adequately.

DS has no friends. He cannot understand why other people don't want to spend breaks memorising things or walking in a circle a set number of times. The school saw some "improvement" when he started hanging out with a group of girls. It turned out they were plaiting his hair, putting him in dressing up clothes, basically treating him like a pet - and he has basically been taught that he needs to be more accommodating of NT children, so just accepts them dragging him around because he thinks that's what friendship is.

goldfinchonthelawn · 02/08/2022 15:43

Loads of NT kids are naughty for loads of reasons:
bad parenting - violence, neglect, over-indulgence etc
traumatic incidents (parents splitting up or fighting; severe illness at home etc)
sudden hormone surges

When life improves, their behaviour improves.

DS2 is ND and afaik, no more difficult than most kids. He had his moments and he never got great school reports until he was diagnosed and given supposrt. But i was never called up to school or told he caused problems.

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 15:42

@Lindasllama your job sounds fascinating, congratulations on finding something so well suited to you. I'm still on the hunt for that!

OP posts:
Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 15:41

@Goldbar it's interesting, however my DS at only just turned 3 was the least compliant at his pre-school - the manager was sure to tell me this when I asked outright: "The other children get in line/wash their hands/sit down for stories when I ask". So already he was less "typical", at that tiny age. He's not as bad, and he has apparently improved in terms of obedience since the beginning of Year One to the end, but I suppose not at the rate of the other children.

OP posts:
Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 02/08/2022 15:38

@Moonface123 I do tend to agree with your post; however it feels very much like the majority of children are able to conform and comply with little resistance.

I hope my DS is able to reach his potential as an adult, whatever that potential might be.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 02/08/2022 15:28

I can only comment on younger children (under-5s) and don't have sufficient experience of neurodiversity and how it manifests and is diagnosed in older children to judge whether most 'naughtiness' is in fact neurodiversity, though it sounds unlikely to me. This is all anecdotal as well.

The sweetest child I know of my DC's age (4yo) is ND (autism). He is a very kind, considerate, caring little boy who would happily give up a toy or a biscuit to another child who wanted them because he loves to make people happy. He also finds a lot of things overwhelming or triggering, and can have extreme meltdowns and throw things, bite and hit with this happens. I would not describe him as 'naughty' in the very least. Like all children, he has his moments but on the whole I would say he is a much 'better-behaved' child than his NT brother and my NT DC.

That said, most 'naughtiness' which I have seen in under-5s is a combination of poor impulse control, high energy levels, a strong will and confidence rather than anything else. An energetic, strong-willed, confident preschooler who is into anything and everything is much more likely to be labelled 'naughty' than a shy compliant child because, for example, they find it hard to sit still in circle time (while the more compliant child finds it easy) and fall easily into mischief while quieter children often hang back and observe rather than jumping in head first. Our early education system is a better fit for some children than other children. However, as children grow up, they generally become better able to channel their energy and control their impulses so I suppose many do grow out what may have been termed 'naughtiness' early on and it may be evidence of other issues being in play if they do not (hence the general reluctance to diagnose very young children).

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/08/2022 15:26

@BiscoffSundae
it is not you who needs to educate themselves.

PollyEsther · 02/08/2022 15:22

Deguster · 02/08/2022 14:56

It's not a competition, and my child isn't any less worthy of humanity than yours

Absolutely, this. It is utterly depressing to come on a MN thread and see mothers and caregivers talking about disabled children in such a contemptuous way. Any of us (including all the PP's who want autistic children to magically disappear from their own children's space) might find ourselves in the position of fighting for appropriate support for our child, there isn't a special "queue" for the SN/SEN/ND/whatever parents. None of us signed up for this, and most of us are only doing our best for our children, as any decent parent would.

Some PP's should re-read their posts and reflect on what they are teaching their own children about inclusivity. And FAOD nobody has or would suggest that children just accept being harmed at school.

Quite.

And then we're told how 'grateful' we should be for our child's disability, because it's a 'super power,' and that we 'wouldn't change them for the world.' Well fuck right off, I would take away this pain from him in an instant.

DD has a friend over today, DS is struggling to cope with this and just had a screaming fit at me. Yes, this is 'bad' behaviour, yes he has been reprimanded and told it's unacceptable. Then he sobbed all over me that 'I'm just angry because I never have a friend over like she does,' which is true. Because he doesn't have friends the way she does. It's devastating for him, devastating for me as his Mum, and yet the kids who wind him up are 'victims' when he retaliates and we should feel sorry for them. I don't. They're snide little fuckers whose behaviour is far more damaging to the world than his will ever be.

Nevermind though, he's just a 'naughty' kid who deserves to be excluded at all times, obviously.

(DS is actually soft as anything, extremely sensitive and empathetic, fiercely loyal and defensive of those few who are kind to him. But because he shouts and swears when he can't cope in a disabling environment he's considered awful. It's extremely upsetting.)

x2boys · 02/08/2022 15:11

ThePumpkinPatch · 02/08/2022 14:31

So you're saying that you think children with Autism cannot be naughty?!?! My child has Autism and very much IS naughty in ways that have absolutely ZERO association to her ASD! She's a little sh*t when she wants to be....🙈
Yes she can also behave in ways that may appear to others as naughty, but actually it's a manifestation of her ASD. 90% of the time though, she's just plain naughty...!

I didn't say that all ,I was pointing out that's children like my son have no concept of "naughty " because of how their autism impacts then 🙄

Lindasllama · 02/08/2022 15:07

I was diagnosed with ADD when I was 42. It came about because my DS (then 8) was referred and I recognised similar traits in myself.

My DS struggled with formal education but has nevertheless become a very respected chef. Academia just didn't suit him. However this has only happened in the last three years. In between he has also been a complete arse.

I think it needs to be remembered that MH differences and being an arsehole are not mutually exclusive.

People can be badly behaved regardless of their MH status. The trick is to distinguish between the two and to try and embrace the benefits of such a diagnosis. In my case it's hyper focus. (As my DS) if they find something they love then it will be the making of them.

I'm a criminal investigator. There is an 'up side'. ! I am like a dog with a bone and will not stop until I have my wo(men) ..

It's hard but try and embrace e the positives as they are !

MoodyTwo · 02/08/2022 14:56

Mine is a little shit to be honest! And no diagnosis of anything, just a brat sometimes (but absolutely lovely the rest of the time)

Deguster · 02/08/2022 14:56

It's not a competition, and my child isn't any less worthy of humanity than yours

Absolutely, this. It is utterly depressing to come on a MN thread and see mothers and caregivers talking about disabled children in such a contemptuous way. Any of us (including all the PP's who want autistic children to magically disappear from their own children's space) might find ourselves in the position of fighting for appropriate support for our child, there isn't a special "queue" for the SN/SEN/ND/whatever parents. None of us signed up for this, and most of us are only doing our best for our children, as any decent parent would.

Some PP's should re-read their posts and reflect on what they are teaching their own children about inclusivity. And FAOD nobody has or would suggest that children just accept being harmed at school.