Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think adoption is not a fix all answer to not having biological children?

263 replies

StopSayingIt · 02/08/2022 10:53

Just want to preface this by saying I in absolutely no way mean that adopted children are loved any less, I understand that you can certainly feel exactly the same way about adopted children and biological children. That's not the point of this thread.

I have suffered from fertility issues myself for a long time, I do have children but it was a long long road involving various consultants, late stage losses, IVF clinics, genetic counsellors and on and on... Because of this I know quite a few people in similar circumstances through the various clinics I attended, Facebook groups and the like, I also have some close friends going through similar issues.

One thing I cannot stand when discussing this subject is the amount of people who suggest adoption as a fix all answer. "Have you looked into adoption?" It absolutely infuriates me and I think anyone who does it is frankly, a bit of an idiot.

Firstly, everyone knows about adoption, we don't need reminding that it exists.

But secondly and most importantly, I don't think it's fair or correct to state it as if it's some easy answer to infertility. Adoption is wonderful, my best friends daughter is adopted and I know she absolutely loves her daughter no less than her biological children but it's not easy either, it's not just a simple "fix" for having biological children, there have been lots of tough times, lovely times and challenges in its own right. She also hates people suggesting it in response to infertility and has said simply wanting children is not the same as going through the adoption process.

AIBU or is it a reasonable suggestion that couples suffering fertility issues "could just adopt"?

OP posts:
empresstonkoko · 02/08/2022 14:38

I think that often people find infertility an uncomfortable subject as reveals a lot about a person and can indicate that they have experienced a loss. In this situation often, well meaning, people try to suggest a solution to make themselves more comfortable and adoption feels like an ‘easy solution’. I speak as someone who has experienced infertility and has adopted.

ChagSameachDoreen · 02/08/2022 14:32

Watermelonsugarhighlove · 02/08/2022 13:27

Great these type of threads make people who are adopted (like me) feel fantastic Hmm

Hard disagree.

I'm adopted but I completely understand why some people don't want to do it.

It's a hard pill to swallow but there we go. That's life.

I personally wouldn't want to bring up children who are not biologically related to me. I know my adoptive parents would have rather had biological children, but life isn't fair.

I don't even bristle at terminology like "my own children" and "real parents". That's just the reality of how a lot of people see it.

Algbu6 · 02/08/2022 14:30

I can see you point OP but it's a bleak situation if you can't have kids.

People are doing their best not to stick the knife in. Realistically what would you like to hear?

Its like a friend phoning you upset you would do your best to console... but you don't have a magic wand to solve whatever is going on.

CurbsideProphet · 02/08/2022 14:27

D0lphine · 02/08/2022 12:13

I just never know what to say and I'm constantly worried about saying the wrong thing.

I get some people might mansplain to you but surely most people are trying to be nice and supportive.

If you don't want to receive such comments could you just not discuss infertility? Except with people you know are supportive?

@D0lphine you say "that sounds really hard. I'm so sorry you're going through this. I'm sorry I don't have a solution for you, but I can always listen if you need someone to talk to, or go for a walk if you want to get out of the house and don't want to be alone."

If a friend told me they had cancer or other health diagnosis I would say something like the above. A friend doesn't need you to give empty suggestions, they really just need to know that you're there for them and acknowledge their sadness / anger / frustration / fear.

One of my friends used to message me every week "just checking in so you know I'm thinking of you" for months. I didn't have to reply, I just knew she was there is I needed her.

ChagSameachDoreen · 02/08/2022 14:23

Totally agree.

I'm adopted myself, but if I hadn't been able to conceive, there is no way in the world I would have adopted. I would have remained childless.

GooglyEyeballs · 02/08/2022 14:22

I agree OP and I often feel like infertile couples are almost vilified for going through IVF trying to have their own biological children instead of adopting. As if all the children who don't have families are somehow the responsibility of the infertile instead of society as a whole. Plus I think it's unfair on those children needing adoption to be considered the solution to an infertile couple. It's a very different route to building a family, equally important and valid but one should not be considered automatic plan B if you find you're infertile.

wallpoppy · 02/08/2022 14:11

Children adopted internationally are often, for all intents and purposes, sold. They are trafficked children. I have some family members who adopted children from China and from a couple of different countries in Africa and they and their "adoption community" are fundamentalist christian, entitled, awful people. They collect children like trophies. There are exceptions to the ethical issues with international adoption - the orphans left behind by Ceaușescu's regime of forced birth in Romania come to mind - but in general, international adoption is a criminal enterprise.

So that leaves domestic adoption, which is ethical in only two very specific situations:

-a voluntary surrender by parents and extended family including grandparents/aunts/uncles, and only after every conceivable charitable and governmental assistance option to the birth parents and their immediate family to raise the baby themselves has been offered and rejected. This would cut out 99% of voluntary surrender adoptions, but for those that still happen, every effort should still be made to keep the baby in her original community with the ability to know and spend time with as many members of her birth family as she can and wants to see as she grows up.

-involuntary surrender, when a parent or parents have their parental rights severed by the courts. And again, the first option should always be adoption within the child's own family and community, with any required charitable or financial support, and every opportunity to know and spend time with her community and biological family as far as it is safe to do so.

I think the UK, most adoptions are due to involuntary surrender. Still sad, and even then sometimes preventable with early intervention, but I understand that it is needed in many cases. In the US, however, it's a very different story. Many young women are bullied, manipulated, and browbeaten by religious institutions and desperate potential adoptive parents into giving up children they would love to raise themselves, and who they COULD raise themselves, if they were only given support. Giving up a baby is a horrific trauma and birth mothers almost always regret it.

So no, adoption is not a solution for infertility. It should be a last resort in very specific situations, and it should be the FIRST choice of adoptive parents - not a consolation prize for the infertile. No one is owed a child.

whattheactualfck · 02/08/2022 14:03

I completely hear you OP.

I have had this said to me numerous times.

Yes I understand if I adopted I would have a child that I long for. However - I long for my biological child which is a very different longing than for any child. This is absolutely not meant to cause any offence whatsoever.

I would potentially consider adoption in the future but not as a replacement for my own biological child. Adopting a child will not cure my infertility or my longing for a child that is biologically mine and my husbands. Adoption is not the solution to the medical diagnosis of infertility.

Sending you love x

CounsellorTroi · 02/08/2022 13:58

I think people will suggest adoption as an option to you as you state trying to have kids has involved "long long road involving various consultants, late stage losses, IVF clinics, genetic counsellors and on and on..."
People dont want to see you suffer id say. Like why put your body and mind and relationship through all of that when your body is clearly not agreeing. It is almost like self torture in a way.

If people don’t want to see you suffer, then if they k ew anything at all about the adoption process they wouldn’t suggest that either. It can be brutal. That’s why often people don’t’want to do it when they’ve already been through many years of unsuccessful fertility treatments.

Legomania · 02/08/2022 13:58

CounsellorTroi · 02/08/2022 13:45

But it does seem to be a potential solution for infertility so i can understand people suggesting it.

Adoption is a potential solution for children in care. It is not a solution to infertility. Adoption agencies do not see their role as supplying children to would-be parents, but to find homes for children in care. That’s how it should be.

Although it's absolutely how it should be for adoption agencies, presumably adopters without biological children/the ability to conceive naturally vastly outweigh those with?

Marvellousmadness · 02/08/2022 13:53

I think people will suggest adoption as an option to you as you state trying to have kids has involved "long long road involving various consultants, late stage losses, IVF clinics, genetic counsellors and on and on..."
People dont want to see you suffer id say. Like why put your body and mind and relationship through all of that when your body is clearly not agreeing. It is almost like self torture in a way.

I know biológica kids are not the same as adopting one. But if having a kid would be the only goal: then adoption would be a very good alternative.

But most people wouldnt consider adopting as they want a mini me /genetic offspring where they can see their own features and characteristics in. And thats why they continue on the long and harsh road of ivf /treatments etc.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 02/08/2022 13:49

If I hadn't managed to be successful with IVF I wouldn't have adopted as I wanted to experience pregnancy etc and have one that I was genetically related to. I would have settled with lots of cats instead.

MRSAHILL · 02/08/2022 13:49

I never think of myself as a "saviour" and none of the other adoptive parents I know think of themselves like that either. I didn't even bother going down the fertility treatment route, as soon as I knew for definite we couldn't conceive the usual way, we started the adoption process. In fact, I actually had it from the opposite angle, "well meaning" people asked me why I wasn't trying IVF or IUI first. My cousin tried to explain in great detail to me what happened during these procedures and kept saying "you might not have to adopt" as if it was something to avoid if at all possible. I found myself having to justify why I wanted to go straight to adoption, why I wasn't going to do everything possible to have my "own" child. Well, I got my "own" child. A gorgeous little 3 year old boy who was desperate for loving parents. I've sat at a playgroup with him and had to listen to another mother tell me of her struggle to conceive her son and how they too had "thought about adoption if everything else failed" but thankfully she'd conceived naturally in the end and hadn't had to "resort" to adoption. Infertility hurts across the board, whether you are trying to adopt or trying to conceive through fertility treatment and, similar to a bereavement, lots of people just don't know what to say to you and through their own ignorance, come out with stupid and upsetting comments.

CounsellorTroi · 02/08/2022 13:48

Also and I don’t know if anyone has said this up thread but having biological children after an infertility journey doesn’t make all of those years of struggle just disappear either.

Neither does adopting a child. Someone I know who adopted told me they still feel sad about missing out on pregnancy, breastfeeding etc.

crowsfeet57 · 02/08/2022 13:47

In my experience over last 30 years, all the parents I knew who adopted were taking on children with special needs. Some adopted babies and others toddlers

This is definitely not always the case, although it isn't uncommon. I adopted three unrelated babies. Two were perfect healthy babies with no issues at all in the background, the other had a family history which may have caused inherited problems as an adult . The local authority couldn't have been more open with us, they subpoenaed the medical records of the parents for that child and sent them to an expert who analysed all the information and gave us the probabilities and any information we wanted.

CounsellorTroi · 02/08/2022 13:45

But it does seem to be a potential solution for infertility so i can understand people suggesting it.

Adoption is a potential solution for children in care. It is not a solution to infertility. Adoption agencies do not see their role as supplying children to would-be parents, but to find homes for children in care. That’s how it should be.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 02/08/2022 13:41

D0lphine · 02/08/2022 12:13

I just never know what to say and I'm constantly worried about saying the wrong thing.

I get some people might mansplain to you but surely most people are trying to be nice and supportive.

If you don't want to receive such comments could you just not discuss infertility? Except with people you know are supportive?

Just say nothing really.

MumChats · 02/08/2022 13:38

I get that saying "just" adopt is insulting, as though it's an easy thing to do. But it does seem to be a potential solution for infertility so i can understand people suggesting it. I know three couples who have adopted of whom two tried unsuccessfully to have a biological child first. A fourth friend made a comment during her second IVF cycle that if it was not successful they'd try adoption instead. For many couples it is the next step in the journey if things don't work out the way they'd planned.

123ROLO · 02/08/2022 13:36

My friend (male) who is married to a man recently adopted. Process took two years, the first stage they said there were in training courses with 5 other couples, by the end (about a year later) they had heard most of those couples had withdrawn.

They heard from another couple that its hard for heterosexual couples struggling to conceive to adopt, they alluded this was due to worries they at a later point would conceive which would change their minds on adoption, apparently they had far more barriers to adoption than the others.

NotMeNoNo · 02/08/2022 13:32

Infertile people/couples will always be a proportion of adopters, because it is a way to have a family despite the complications, and it's usually better for the children to have a stable home and family. But it's very far from being either a default or a simple solution. Nobody with personal experience of adoption is likely to say anything so unthinking.

I think in these situations you are well to have a polite (or otherwise) brush off prepared. "I prefer not to talk about it" etc. Unfortunately it's obvious whether or not you have children and nosy questions soon follow if you don't.

Legomania · 02/08/2022 13:28

Obviously 'just adopt' is crass as it's not a simple process.
But all the adopters I know did so because they were unable to have biological children - I think some posters are being a bit disingenuous about the link.

SweatyChamoisPad · 02/08/2022 13:27

Spot on @Headbandheart . In the past six years I’ve had to watch (and support) a friend who was dealing with all kinds of behavioural problems after adopting a child as a single woman. She is kind, solvent, confident and works with children - she couldn’t be more perfect. But thanks to social services handing over a child who was seriously disturbed and telling her that the child had just been removed due to “neglect” she is a shadow of who she was. Despite the support of her friends, family, medical and educational professionals the adoption failed and she feels such a failure that she’s had to take time off work and gone on anti depressants.

Most kids who are taken into care these days need help. Gone are the days when you could just get a newborn from an unwed mother. Adoption is not the last option, as a previous poster put it, but from what I’ve seen it’s absolutely the hardest.

Watermelonsugarhighlove · 02/08/2022 13:27

Great these type of threads make people who are adopted (like me) feel fantastic Hmm

Thatswhyimacat · 02/08/2022 13:23

I think most people don't realise how difficult adoption is.

Greenginghamdress · 02/08/2022 13:20

I have always spoken about adoption a lot as I have two close people in my life who were adopted; my mother and my best friend. I remember speaking to my friends parents a few years ago who said it was hard to do in the 80s. Now I think it's extremely difficult to adopt a child. It's sad that people bandy around 'just adopt' as if it is really simple and viable for everyone.

If I had not been able to have DD, I would have wanted to adopt, possibly because it's always been around my life. DP said he wouldn't have wanted to. Not everyone who is unable to have children will want to adopt. Adoption and fertility are different issues, not different sides of the same coin.