Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think adoption is not a fix all answer to not having biological children?

263 replies

StopSayingIt · 02/08/2022 10:53

Just want to preface this by saying I in absolutely no way mean that adopted children are loved any less, I understand that you can certainly feel exactly the same way about adopted children and biological children. That's not the point of this thread.

I have suffered from fertility issues myself for a long time, I do have children but it was a long long road involving various consultants, late stage losses, IVF clinics, genetic counsellors and on and on... Because of this I know quite a few people in similar circumstances through the various clinics I attended, Facebook groups and the like, I also have some close friends going through similar issues.

One thing I cannot stand when discussing this subject is the amount of people who suggest adoption as a fix all answer. "Have you looked into adoption?" It absolutely infuriates me and I think anyone who does it is frankly, a bit of an idiot.

Firstly, everyone knows about adoption, we don't need reminding that it exists.

But secondly and most importantly, I don't think it's fair or correct to state it as if it's some easy answer to infertility. Adoption is wonderful, my best friends daughter is adopted and I know she absolutely loves her daughter no less than her biological children but it's not easy either, it's not just a simple "fix" for having biological children, there have been lots of tough times, lovely times and challenges in its own right. She also hates people suggesting it in response to infertility and has said simply wanting children is not the same as going through the adoption process.

AIBU or is it a reasonable suggestion that couples suffering fertility issues "could just adopt"?

OP posts:
secular39 · 03/08/2022 21:30

In all this though. Having children is a privilege not a right.

Halstead · 03/08/2022 21:18

DifficultBloodyWoman · 02/08/2022 23:57

@bringon2020 - that had never occurred to me but it does make sense.

@Halstead - very interesting - thank you

You’re welcome 😊

Littleoakhorn · 03/08/2022 13:18

@EL8888 , that’s also absolutely true.

EL8888 · 03/08/2022 11:31

@Littleoakhorn but lm sure lots of people like me are burned out by the IVF process and can’t face the adoption process -even if l did want to adopt. I just don’t have the stomach for more hoop jumping, endless appointments and stupid requests e.g. having to use contraception, taking extended periods of time off work etc

CounsellorTroi · 03/08/2022 11:10

WhatNoRaisins · 03/08/2022 06:48

I wonder if you did a survey of the UK population how many would have a realistic idea of what's involved in modern adoption. My suspicion is that most people's concepts are based on how it was 50+ years ago or adoption in fiction, typically set in different time periods or cultures.

And yes being able to listen sympathetically without trying to fix is a great skill that should be valued more.

Yes - like children in care are all like Annie in the film.

WhatNoRaisins · 03/08/2022 06:48

I wonder if you did a survey of the UK population how many would have a realistic idea of what's involved in modern adoption. My suspicion is that most people's concepts are based on how it was 50+ years ago or adoption in fiction, typically set in different time periods or cultures.

And yes being able to listen sympathetically without trying to fix is a great skill that should be valued more.

Littleoakhorn · 03/08/2022 03:16

people say ridiculously insensitive things to couples with infertility. However, looking at it a different way, if you have the emotional strength to get through ivf and to pick yourself up after losses, and you have the space in your heart and life for a child, then you might make a good adoptive parent. It’s never a case of ‘just’ adopting though.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 02/08/2022 23:57

@bringon2020 - that had never occurred to me but it does make sense.

@Halstead - very interesting - thank you

Halstead · 02/08/2022 21:42

CbaThinkingOfAUsername · 02/08/2022 11:38

Would you mind sharing why parenting adopted children is nothing like parenting birth children? Does it stem from trauma that the children may have faced in their birth families? Does it depend on the age that the children were adopted?

There is a lot of research on this which I will attempt to summarise (poorly, no doubt). It also doesn’t fit every child - there will be exceptions.

Child development is broadly linear. It goes…

  1. Attachment
  2. Understanding Reward/Punishment -aka cause and effect
  3. Social interaction (eg reading non verbal cues)
  4. Reflecting/reasoning
  5. Executive function/problem solving/complex thinking - impulse control and empathy.
if the first step isn’t completed properly the next steps will be interrupted/won’t develop properly. Executive function is still being developed until mid 20s.

The fundamental underpinning (attachment) of Children’s secure development occurs in their first 18-24 months. (Postnatally*), it starts with the ‘serve/return’ that takes place between child and primary caregiver (not necessarily parent). Baby has a wet nappy, parent goes to them, soothes them, changes their nappy, settles them.

Baby learns they are important enough to have their needs met. They develop a secure attachment. They learn… at a sub conscious level… they are important and have a ‘place in the world’. As a result of this, they go on to be able to develop things like resilience and emotional regulation properly … everything else fundamental to being a functional adult (I.e. the following steps of child development)

Adopted babies are overwhelmingly from a background of abuse and or neglect (in the UK). When they cry they don’t have a primary caregiver soothing them. They are (often) ignored… or punished.. for crying.

These babies often - not always - develop disordered attachment. The rest of their development is interrupted as a result. Neglect is often worse than abuse… that is certainly the case with my two children where DD (neglected) is more severely impacted than DS (abused).

DS (16) cannot - and I mean cannot - link cause and effect. He cannot understand why if he watches his laptop all night after smuggling it to his room (no impulse control) he has screen time restrictions imposed. In his world, it’s grossly unfair, the parental controls I installed weren’t strong enough, it was his sisters fault for leaving the laptop in his room, if he had no restrictions he’d regulate himself (reader, he wouldn’t!)… it really is toddler logic. This logic extends into every area of his life, no matter how much we spend time helping him work out ‘what happens next’. I imagine he will get into debt as an adult, but won’t learn/take responsibility and will repeat the cycle multiple times.

DD is 14 but operates at the level of a 6 year old. No stranger danger. No road safety. Sensory processing issues. Question mark over whether she’ll ever work or live independently.

*it is possible for there to be ill effects from in utero experiences too. Alcohol, obviously, can cause FASD, but what is less known is that high stress levels during pregnancy can create elevated cortisol levels in a baby that can also have some significant effects.

That’s all to say no… it often doesn’t matter what age children are removed. The biggest impact on a child’s life is had in pregnancy/the first 18-24 months. Quite often, social services/the courts haven’t removed children before that age. Then, it’s over to the adopted parents to try to manage the arising difficulties, often with little support.

Lastly - and anecdotally - it’s said (and, knowing a lot of adopted families I would say this bears true)… around 20% or adopted children will have few to no ‘issues’… 60% medium to moderate (both my children would fall into this bracket) and 20% severe… including violence. Those thresholds, one would expect/hope, are not the same as for birth children.

Hope that helps.

bringon2020 · 02/08/2022 21:32

I don't know if anyone said this already, but I think this kind of comment comes from the time when babies were put for adoption simply because they were born from single women (which was a very sad thing, there are horrible stories about that).

In this situation, adopting a baby was relatively straightforward, you go home with a newborn baby, the main difference is that the baby is not genetically yours.

Today it's a completely different thing. Children are usually older, frequently coming from complicated homes, SS involved, etc.

Adopting children in UK today is completely different from adopting children in the UK in the 1960s. And the people who make this kind of comments are, I think, still in the 60s.

TheOGCCL · 02/08/2022 18:15

Some people seem to think to adopt you can rock up somewhere (not sure where exactly, a home?) and pick out one you like the look of. Like a rescue cat.

They may think babies are easy to come by, not imagining quite challenging four year olds. And they do not seem to appreciate that their backgrounds are likely to be difficult ( or else why are they in need of a new home) and behavioural problems common.

Just not the same as having your own child.

JubileeTrifle · 02/08/2022 18:06

I imagine there is a massive difference from having a newborn baby to taking home a toddler/child with issues.

I knew someone who adopted 3 children (she always knew she was infertile from being very young) and gave up working as she knew she needed to give them lots of time.

I did have a friend going for IVF who said the adoption thing. She now has 2 children (second was a surprise) who spent most of their time with GPs. I don’t imagine she would have stuck with the process.

gannett · 02/08/2022 17:34

This isn't something I say, nor even believe - I was adopted and am now NC with my evangelist Christian parents so it didn't work out too well for me (though not especially worse than for people who are NC with birth parents, so I don't think adoption itself was to "blame").

However I still feel the words come to my lips when people are talking about infertility. I always stop it but it's fundamentally because I have no idea what to say. I'm child-free and so I have no idea what the urge to have a biological child even feels like, can't relate to it at all, so the nearest feeling I can imagine is a general need to nurture.

Like I said I know that assumption is bollocks and so I don't say anything. But that might be where people are coming from.

StopSayingIt · 02/08/2022 17:22

People are doing their best not to stick the knife in. Realistically what would you like to hear?

Just that they are there if you need to talk. That's all anyone needs to say.

Its like a friend phoning you upset you would do your best to console... but you don't have a magic wand to solve whatever is going on.

No one is expecting a magic wand, you can't fix the situation, no one is expecting you to. Not strictly comparable obviously but if a friend phoned me to talk about her husband dying I wouldn't suggest 'have you thought about online dating?' and yet when my baby died people seem to think it's appropriate to ask me about adoption as if it would solve everything. It doesn't, I didn't want people to solve it, they couldn't have.

OP posts:
BiscuitLover3678 · 02/08/2022 17:22

ChagSameachDoreen · 02/08/2022 14:23

Totally agree.

I'm adopted myself, but if I hadn't been able to conceive, there is no way in the world I would have adopted. I would have remained childless.

I’m curious as to why you say this?

StopSayingIt · 02/08/2022 17:18

It might not be right for you but there's a running theme through this thread that biology is everything

I don't personally see it. I don't think there is anything wrong with saying that wanting children but not being able to have them doesn't automatically mean you'd be open to adoption and I don't think "biology is everything" but I also won't be guilted for wanting biological children either or feeling like adoption if that couldn't happen, wouldn't have been for me.

That's not to say that adoptive parents don't feel the same way about their children as biological parents, I'm not saying that in the slightest. But I do think simply wanting children isn't the same as being prepared to adopt a child and the potential challenges which could come with that. You could want one but not feel able to do the other and the latter is not simply a solution to being unable to have biological children.

OP posts:
Gingerbeer81 · 02/08/2022 15:52

@gogohmm I get what you are saying. For us, we did not want to pursue IVF according to our beliefs. Separately - we also felt that adoption could be a way we serve a vulnerable child (a conclusion option to fertile people too!! ) and, more importantly, we were excited about being parents.

But even if biology isn't everything for us as parents - it is still VERY significant to the child. Both in terms of their right to their biological heritage, identity and family (a loss that as a parent you have to support them through, and be prepared for them to remake bonds with their bio family) and also in terms of the impact their biology and prenatal environment has on the challenges they will face (e.g. and commonly - substance abuse before/during pregnancy).

There is a balance that maybe you feel is missing in this thread but it's a counterweight to the frankly naive way adoption is often portrayed.

MRSAHILL · 02/08/2022 15:51

@gogohmm Well said

Gingerbeer81 · 02/08/2022 15:43

People also don't comprehend the level of intrusion and scrutiny, and uncertainty, that is involved in the early adoption process.

gogohmm · 02/08/2022 15:42

Children in the care system deserve loving families. It may be different to having birth children but it's not inferior which some of these posts imply.

Plenty of people disagree with assisted conception in particular use of surrogates. I personally haven't adopted but very close friends did without trying ivf because they had a strong belief in giving children a home. It might not be right for you but there's a running theme through this thread that biology is everything

Gingerbeer81 · 02/08/2022 15:38

OP I understand what you mean. Personally, when children didn't come naturally we pursued adoption and did not do IVF. I would STILL never suggest it lightly as a simple fix. I believe that is a disservice to people suffering infertility and also, more importantly, to adoptees.

In fairness, it's a comment borne out of ignorance and awkwardness. People honestly have trouble believing that bad things can happen to people that don't have easy fixes. It's a self-protection mechanism.

We have adopted and love our son, who I think is genuinely the best ever. But it is a different journey. Even though he doesn't have a very challenging background (by UK adoption standards) as his parent I have to be prepared to guide and support him through the complex emotional and identity issues he will may navigate as he grows older as an adoptee. I have to be emotionally ok myself with the fact others have been his mummy before me and that he may seek out and form attachments to his first mum. I am not complaining - I love being his parent and it's worth it 100%. But it's something not to go into lightly, for the sake of the child, and I don't like it being suggested lightly.

StopSayingIt · 02/08/2022 15:28

But I still DO think, not don't!

OP posts:
StopSayingIt · 02/08/2022 15:28

I have no doubt there probably is a proportion of adopters that are infertile and have perhaps only gone on to adopt for this reason. But I still don't think the two are separate things and one doesn't automatically equal the other. You can desperately want to be a parent but feel adoption isn't for you because, as PPs have said, it does often come with its own unique challenges. It's not as simple as 'oh you want to be a parent? Just adopt then'.

And, as per my first point in the OP, do people think those suffering with fertility issues don't know about adoption? We do. But it's not a magic wand.

I think if someone is talking to you about fertility issues, they aren't looking for you to provide them with a solution. You likely couldn't even if you tried. The only time I think this could possibly be relevant is discussing medical conditions with those who've gone through the same thing and discussing different treatments that have worked for them. But no one discussing fertility issues with someone who's never experienced them is looking for a magic solution. Just listen and sympathise. It is a hard conversation, I get that.

OP posts:
InChocolateWeTrust · 02/08/2022 15:18

In the UK adoption generally involves children from terrible situations eg trauma, neglect, substance abuse, emotional damage etc.

A significant proportion of adoptions fail. Another noticeable proportion will have foetal alcohol syndrome or other disabilities associated with drug use in pregnancy. Lots will have deep seated attachment disorders.

It's completely incomparable with raising biological children.

Belephant · 02/08/2022 14:39

More than anything, I think adopted children deserve parents who actively want to adopt, and parents who are in a place to offer the unique support that an adopted child may need.

Adopted children aren't just a consolation prize you get if you couldn't have children of your own. They're human beings with needs and issues of their own.

Infertility can be traumatic, and being adopted can be traumatic too. A traumatised couple should not use a traumatised child as a plaster to stick over their wound.

I know two adopted people. One is a close friend, and for her her adopted family are 100% her real family, and she has no desire to find out anything about her biological family at all.

The other, despite loving her adopted mum deeply, does not regard her as her real mum. She yearns for her biological mother. She has gotten in touch with her biological family and regularly sees them. Thankfully, her mother (who is the person I am actually friends with in this scenario) did not adopt her as a replacement for a biological child - she adores her equally to her biological children, but she knows the relationship is different and she is actually over the moon that her adopted daughter is finding comfort and healing in being able to connect with her biological family. She wants what is best for her daughter and does all she can to support her in every way. She's an amazing parent, to be honest. They're very close and they always will be, I'm sure.

I think everyone who adopts a child needs to be prepared for such a scenario.