Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think adoption is not a fix all answer to not having biological children?

263 replies

StopSayingIt · 02/08/2022 10:53

Just want to preface this by saying I in absolutely no way mean that adopted children are loved any less, I understand that you can certainly feel exactly the same way about adopted children and biological children. That's not the point of this thread.

I have suffered from fertility issues myself for a long time, I do have children but it was a long long road involving various consultants, late stage losses, IVF clinics, genetic counsellors and on and on... Because of this I know quite a few people in similar circumstances through the various clinics I attended, Facebook groups and the like, I also have some close friends going through similar issues.

One thing I cannot stand when discussing this subject is the amount of people who suggest adoption as a fix all answer. "Have you looked into adoption?" It absolutely infuriates me and I think anyone who does it is frankly, a bit of an idiot.

Firstly, everyone knows about adoption, we don't need reminding that it exists.

But secondly and most importantly, I don't think it's fair or correct to state it as if it's some easy answer to infertility. Adoption is wonderful, my best friends daughter is adopted and I know she absolutely loves her daughter no less than her biological children but it's not easy either, it's not just a simple "fix" for having biological children, there have been lots of tough times, lovely times and challenges in its own right. She also hates people suggesting it in response to infertility and has said simply wanting children is not the same as going through the adoption process.

AIBU or is it a reasonable suggestion that couples suffering fertility issues "could just adopt"?

OP posts:
CurbsideProphet · 05/08/2022 08:38

@georgarina don't you think it's quite patronising to think that a woman would need "reminding" that adoption (or donor sperm) is an option?

CounsellorTroi · 05/08/2022 08:23

BUT I think it is another way of having a family and people are just reminding you that there are other ways. Like reminding a single friend who wants a child that she could use donor sperm.

But most people in this situation don’t need “reminding”. They will have considered all their options exhaustively. As has been said over and over again on this thread, if someone talks to you about their infertility they don’t need solutions or advice. They just need to be listened to and supported. It’s possible to be supportive without going into problem solving mode.

namechanged4it · 05/08/2022 08:07

I think you're being harsh. It's am option like other posters have suggested. I think you're looking at it way too negatively. Would you feel the same if someone suggested IVF?
I have fertility issues and am more than happy to adopt/Foster and really don't kind when people open up the subject.

Lockheart · 05/08/2022 07:59

I think it can be AN answer for some people, but it is not THE answer for everyone.

I have friends who have adopted children and I have seen how hard the process is. But they could not have children and this was the answer for them.

HappyHappyHermit · 05/08/2022 07:54

@Josette77 and @Watermelonsugarhighlove I completely agree.

@Whynow2021 Interesting, I work with a lot of adoption support bodies and there is a strong feeling amongst adult adopters and adoptees that there is too much emphasis on protecting the biological link now. Too often that is put ahead of the needs of the child in the middle of the process and the biological parents are prioritised over the need of the child to have a stable home and a proper loving family. Too often the biological parents are just trying to get revenge on the system and are not bothered by what is best for the child or baby.

Watermelonsugarhighlove · 05/08/2022 07:40

Josette77 · 05/08/2022 06:56

Talking about children of "your own" and "unwanted babies" is shitty.

I'm adopted and an adoptive mom. Language matters. I was not unwanted.

Again this 100% some of these comments make us that are adopted a second prize.

Josette77 · 05/08/2022 06:56

Talking about children of "your own" and "unwanted babies" is shitty.

I'm adopted and an adoptive mom. Language matters. I was not unwanted.

georgarina · 05/08/2022 06:09

The process is definitely not easy and people would need to be prepared for invasive checks, expense, and potentially handling severe emotional trauma.

BUT I think it is another way of having a family and people are just reminding you that there are other ways. Like reminding a single friend who wants a child that she could use donor sperm.

I have a few friends who were adopted and have an adopted uncle and they are just completely part of the family.

Whynow2021 · 05/08/2022 05:54

I think the most important thing to remember is the child did not chose to go into the adopted family, but rather, the family chose to have them in their family. So the onus really is to make sure that all the child's needs are met. Including cultural, if appropriate.

Far too many times, in the past, adopted parents were treated like Saints and, very often, the adopted children were treated at sinners.

It is not a slight on you if the adopted child wants to know about their background. Why shouldn't a child know where they belong. Or if a child wants to meet their birth family.

It is not for everyone. In fact, in my opinion, only a select few that actually adopt successfully..

CounsellorTroi · 05/08/2022 00:07

I also think it's important to recognise that some people want to have the experience of giving birth, being pregnant and all that goes with that and allowed to grieve that when it isn't happening without having to fend off well intentioned solutions.

This. Most people want to procreate. That is the biological urge. That’s why most people, fertile or infertile, set out to conceive a child rather than adopt one when they decide they want a family.

Cw122 · 05/08/2022 00:00

The adoption and care system in the UK need dramatically overhauled. I work within this sector and while in some instances adoption is the best outcome for the child, it's super nuanced and there are a lot of adoptees who feel very strongly that adoption isn't the best way to support a child in care as opposed to guardianship for example where the child can still maintain their identity as part of their first or birth family. It also means that if that bio parents circumstances change or their mental health improves its too late, they've lost their child regardless and due to the demand for children under 3 as opposed to over 3 years old things move much more quickly with babies and toddlers which to me is ethically icky. I think the op actually is showing good insight in recognising that adoption isn't a way to fill a family. If that's the sole intention, then that focuses the adoption on the needs of the adoptive parents rather than the child which should be the focus because for them adoption will always be borne out of trauma grief and loss even if it appears to be a better environment for them at the time. They need their adoptive parents to be able to recognise and hold that space for them and also to recognise that there will be things they need from their bio families that they cannot get from adoptive families which can be really difficult emotionally. I also think it's important to recognise that some people want to have the experience of giving birth, being pregnant and all that goes with that and allowed to grieve that when it isn't happening without having to fend off well intentioned solutions.

Watermelonsugarhighlove · 04/08/2022 08:39

HappyHappyHermit · 03/08/2022 22:41

@BlahBl4h Please don't twist my words, I am not offended if people do not want to adopt at all, I am offended and hurt at the way some people on this thread are talking about adoptees and their families. You may not be saying that but several on this thread have.

This 100%

Ted27 · 03/08/2022 23:53

@AIBAnxious

I don’t think talking about babies as being ‘unwanted’ is helpful. The children to whom you were referring were mostly born to young, unmarried girls and women who were forced to give up their children.

on other points
I’m a single adoptive mum, I couldnt give a toss about biology, I never considered any other option than adoption to have a child. My son is my son. He is an amazing young man who has worked hard to overcome his early years.

But biology does matter to some people and that should be respected.
In the same way, biology matters to some adoptees and not to others, and in different ways.
My son’s connections to his birth siblings is incredibly important to him. He would be devastated if he could not see them. He is not that interested in his birth mum, but grieves for his dad. He is only 18, his feelings may change, they may not. But our relationship is very strong and I will support him in whatever he wants to do.

HappyHappyHermit · 03/08/2022 22:41

@BlahBl4h Please don't twist my words, I am not offended if people do not want to adopt at all, I am offended and hurt at the way some people on this thread are talking about adoptees and their families. You may not be saying that but several on this thread have.

BlahBl4h · 03/08/2022 22:35

But people are entitled not by.

BlahBl4h · 03/08/2022 22:34

I also don't think anyone should be telling someone what they should be offended about

No but being offended by something doesn't invalidate whatever it is you're offended by or mean that it's wrong.

I am sorry you're offended by people are entitled to not wish to adopt. No one is saying biology is the be all and end all but it's okay for someone to say they want a biological child but wouldn't be open to adoption if that couldn't happen. You yourself just said it isn't for everyone. PPs have given very good examples of why this may be.

No one is saying children who are adopted aren't 'as good as' biological children. Not one. Just that adoption is not an easy solution to infertility. You can say the latter without it meaning the former.

HappyHappyHermit · 03/08/2022 22:27

I also don't think anyone should be telling someone what they should be offended about. Imagine reading over and over again that you are clearly viewed as not as good an option.

I've been very clear I also believe it isn't for everyone, but biology is not the be all and end all and it may be important to be reminded not to cut off your nose to spite your face. Many on this thread would perhaps prefer we go back to the days where only biological children can inherit etc!

BlahBl4h · 03/08/2022 22:20

What people are saying is its not a quick and easy solve all solution to infertility and nor should it be.

BlahBl4h · 03/08/2022 22:18

HappyHappyHermit · 03/08/2022 22:11

Several people have very clearly stated they believe it is not an alternative.

I don't think people are saying its never an alternative or 'as good as'.

But I do think it's fair to say that just because you want a biological child and can't have one, doesn't mean you'd be suited for adoption and the potential challenges that could come with that. It's not always (in some cases it may be but there is no guarantee) going to be like for like in that sense for the very valid reasons PPs have given.

I don't think people should automatically rule it out just because it won't biologically be theirs

You can't tell people what they should and shouldn't rule out though. It may be hurtful but there is nothing wrong with someone wanting a biological child, there is no 'dont think they should' about it. That is their choice and it's not offensive or invalid. Some people don't care so much about biology, others will and that's okay.

HappyHappyHermit · 03/08/2022 22:11

Several people have very clearly stated they believe it is not an alternative.

CounsellorTroi · 03/08/2022 22:08

No one has said that it’s not an alternative. Only that it is not the answer for everyone who can’t have a child.

HappyHappyHermit · 03/08/2022 22:05

The idea that it is not an alternative is incredibly offensive to me as an adoptee. Of course it is. You don't have to want to do it but please some people here need to stop talking about all adoptees as if they are no more than pets or hobbies. My family is my family, biological or not. This thread has made me really sad.

AIBAnxious · 03/08/2022 21:58

YANBU. I suffered infertility and did look into adopting. Just getting through the process looked like it would require huge amounts of time, effort and dedication.

I saw it explained like this somewhere: years ago, before contraception and abortions were widely available, there were lots of babies who were unwanted and adoption was more straightforward than it is today. Now there are very few unwanted babies, so children needing adoption are ones who have been taken by SS. So a lot of them have been affected by abuse, drugs or alcohol. They don't just need a standard parent - they need a really special person to look after them and turn their lives around. Which is why you have to jump through so many hoops and prove yourself before you are allowed to adopt.

So it is 100% not an alternative to having your own children, it is almost a calling i would say. I have huge admiration for those who do it though!

Algbu6 · 03/08/2022 21:54

secular39 · 03/08/2022 21:30

In all this though. Having children is a privilege not a right.

That's a really shitty thing to say totally inappropriate. What consulation is that to anybody struggling to conceieve or had several miscarriages?

HappyHappyHermit · 03/08/2022 21:48

Unbelievably glad and grateful that my parents did consider and go through with adoption having been unable to have a child otherwise. I actually do believe more people ought to consider it as a potential option, as however painful it may be to admit you cannot create your own child, life with one who becomes yours could be amazing. I'm not saying it's for all and definitely not a dream solution but I don't think people should automatically rule it out just because it won't biologically be theirs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread