Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think adoption is not a fix all answer to not having biological children?

263 replies

StopSayingIt · 02/08/2022 10:53

Just want to preface this by saying I in absolutely no way mean that adopted children are loved any less, I understand that you can certainly feel exactly the same way about adopted children and biological children. That's not the point of this thread.

I have suffered from fertility issues myself for a long time, I do have children but it was a long long road involving various consultants, late stage losses, IVF clinics, genetic counsellors and on and on... Because of this I know quite a few people in similar circumstances through the various clinics I attended, Facebook groups and the like, I also have some close friends going through similar issues.

One thing I cannot stand when discussing this subject is the amount of people who suggest adoption as a fix all answer. "Have you looked into adoption?" It absolutely infuriates me and I think anyone who does it is frankly, a bit of an idiot.

Firstly, everyone knows about adoption, we don't need reminding that it exists.

But secondly and most importantly, I don't think it's fair or correct to state it as if it's some easy answer to infertility. Adoption is wonderful, my best friends daughter is adopted and I know she absolutely loves her daughter no less than her biological children but it's not easy either, it's not just a simple "fix" for having biological children, there have been lots of tough times, lovely times and challenges in its own right. She also hates people suggesting it in response to infertility and has said simply wanting children is not the same as going through the adoption process.

AIBU or is it a reasonable suggestion that couples suffering fertility issues "could just adopt"?

OP posts:
Roady1 · 05/08/2022 10:15

Relationships can break down with biological children too though.

Of course they do. But obviously adoption does come with its own unique set of potential challenges that not everyone wants or feels able to deal with.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 10:13

HappyHappyHermit · 05/08/2022 09:49

I don't think that analogy works at all and is, once again, rather offensive and suggestive that an adoptive child is lesser than a biological one. Simply suggesting the consideration of adoption is not a bad thing to do if done in the right way. It should not become a taboo subject.

This is where it breaks down isn't it. Because people can't accept without taking offense that for some people it isn't the same and they would rather not adopt if they can't have biological children.

Mourning being unable to have biological children is perfectly valid and no one has to say they'd be open to adoption in order to not offend anyone because of that.

I'm assuming the people who do go onto adopt are the ones who believe that biology isn't a big deal to them. To some people it is. And that is fine.

And I think most people who have suffered fertility issues obviously wanted biological children and therefore will have a period of mourning not having that. There will be some that go onto adopt and others that don't.

But again, there are a host of reasons, as already explained rather extensively on the thread, why it's not always an easy solution and it can be very misleading and dismissive to tell someone to 'just adopt'.

Besswess88 · 05/08/2022 10:11

When I was trying to be a surrogate for my friends the abound of times I heard “why don’t they just adopt” just made me want to scream.

I work in social care, I know the reality.

CounsellorTroi · 05/08/2022 10:06

HappyHappyHermit · 05/08/2022 09:49

I don't think that analogy works at all and is, once again, rather offensive and suggestive that an adoptive child is lesser than a biological one. Simply suggesting the consideration of adoption is not a bad thing to do if done in the right way. It should not become a taboo subject.

I’m not suggesting anything of the sort. I’m just saying adoption isn’t for everyone.

HappyHappyHermit · 05/08/2022 09:54

Of course it may not work for some and SS are known for being rather rubbish. Relationships can break down with biological children too though.

Not the same though? Again with the offensive language. Tell that to my own parents and those I now support through the process. They love, care for and treat their child in a way that is no different to anyone else.

mycatisannoying · 05/08/2022 09:49

It's not the same, and for all the many success stories, there are some that just aren't.
Lovely GP friends of mine adopted a brother and sister, when one was a very young child and the other was a toddler. They really, really put their non-bio parents through the wringer over the years, and now none of them are in touch. It's heartbreaking. All those years of love and effort for nothing.
In short, these particular siblings should never have been placed together (as later confirmed by SS), and too much damage had already been done by the biological parents.

HappyHappyHermit · 05/08/2022 09:49

I don't think that analogy works at all and is, once again, rather offensive and suggestive that an adoptive child is lesser than a biological one. Simply suggesting the consideration of adoption is not a bad thing to do if done in the right way. It should not become a taboo subject.

CounsellorTroi · 05/08/2022 09:43

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 09:35

Do you think it's acceptable for someone to just want to mourn being unable to have biological children?

I just can't see any need to bring adoption up in a conversation about infertility.

This is a good point.

I remember an agony aunt, can’t saying that saying to someone who has fertility problems “why don’t you adopt” is a bit like saying to someone who wanted to be an opera singer but lost their voice “why don’t you play the piano instead?” Now playing the piano is indeed an alternative way of making music, and for some it may be equally rewarding, but for others it is not the same as their own voice. And they need to mourn that.

HappyHappyHermit · 05/08/2022 09:35

@Roady1 I think everyone here agrees it isn't an easy option.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 09:35

Do you think it's acceptable for someone to just want to mourn being unable to have biological children?

I just can't see any need to bring adoption up in a conversation about infertility.

HappyHappyHermit · 05/08/2022 09:34

@CounsellorTroi There is a right thing to say to you. Many of those I come across have said how much of a difference it made to their lives and how glad they are that someone suggested it as even though they knew it was an option, they wouldn't have considered it at that time without someone saying it first and offering support.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 09:34

Because the criteria is strict and specific and I wouldn't have got past it

So you obviously agree it's not an easy/simple solution.

CounsellorTroi · 05/08/2022 09:28

HappyHappyHermit · 05/08/2022 08:58

I dont think it is about reminding someone, but if someone is in a dark place it can sometimes be helpful to offer some potential light. Sometimes in any situation it can feel so bad that you cannot see any possibilities so people that suggest something are most likely being kind rather than insensitive. I suspect in this type of situation there isn't really a right thing to say, a bit like when someone has lost a loved one, it will depend on the individual person and what they see as supportive.

If someone is iIn a dark place sometimes they just need you to sit in there with them and hold their hand (figuratively or literally) for a bit. They know there is no easy or quick fix way of getting out.

And yes there is a right thing to say in this situation. People on this thread who are in this situation have said it over and over again. “I’m so sorry you are going through this, it must be so hard.” And listen. But I suspect in this situation many say what will make them feel better and they think that will make the person they’re talking to feel better. But it doesn’t always.

georgarina · 05/08/2022 09:28

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 09:12

I think what people don't like to hear is a lot of the time people are mourning being unable to have a biological child, to be pregnant and to give birth to their child. They aren't stupid. They know adoption exists but in that moment it isn't what they want and that is okay. It's not wrong or offensive or a slight against anyone. It's not for you or anyone else to try and get them to change their outlook or to think that they shouldn't care about biology. They may come to that by themselves after a while or they may not. But mourning being unable to have biological child rather than a child is very real and perfectly normal and valid to feel.

That's how it was for me with using a donor to have a child

Why didn't you just adopt? (Said with sarcasm).

Because the criteria is strict and specific and I wouldn't have got past it.

Your sarcasm isn't clever.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 09:23

To speak about adoption in such general terms is misleading as it is a many layered and complex issue and to discuss it with stock phases is wrong

100%

empresstonkoko · 05/08/2022 09:21

Rightly or wrongly we don’t seem to have moved on much in society and, in general, people still expect women to have a family at some point in their lives. This pressure is real and can go alongside the biological urge to reproduce for some women.I know the pain of infertility and have found, in general, people have not suggested adoption as a ‘solution’, but if they have I have gently explained to them why this is not a panacea. People do find this topic generally uncomfortable and whilst I do not see it as my job to make people more comfortable I have tendered to try and be kind to them despite the pain I have been experiencing. To speak about adoption in such general terms is misleading as it is a many layered and complex issue and to discuss it with stock phases is wrong. However unless you have been part of the process in any way it is difficult to understand. Generally I have found that the system does not provide enough support for either adopters or birth parents.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 09:15

And I think all this 'theres just no right thing to say' is a cop out personally for just being there for a friend or whoever is talking to you. It doesn't take a genius to work it out that you don't need to offer solutions.

I think it's very different if you're coming at it as someone who's been there and chose X route (i.e. sperm donation) and then I think it's fine to say 'I did this and if you'd like to ask me any questions or discuss it let me know' but not to push any further. But Sandra who's got 3 kids and didn't struggle for any of them saying 'why don't you just adopt, there's loads of kids needing homes' is entirely different and inappropriate.

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 05/08/2022 09:14

Ps. Full disclosure- I’m still sitting on the fence regarding having kids. But I can see that, if me and my DH choose NOT to have them, our social circle will get significantly smaller. People just won’t leave us alone, and I don’t fancy dealing with “what’s wrong with you?” questions all the time. For now they assumed we’ll try soon/are trying already.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 09:12

I think what people don't like to hear is a lot of the time people are mourning being unable to have a biological child, to be pregnant and to give birth to their child. They aren't stupid. They know adoption exists but in that moment it isn't what they want and that is okay. It's not wrong or offensive or a slight against anyone. It's not for you or anyone else to try and get them to change their outlook or to think that they shouldn't care about biology. They may come to that by themselves after a while or they may not. But mourning being unable to have biological child rather than a child is very real and perfectly normal and valid to feel.

That's how it was for me with using a donor to have a child

Why didn't you just adopt? (Said with sarcasm).

georgarina · 05/08/2022 09:04

CurbsideProphet · 05/08/2022 08:38

@georgarina don't you think it's quite patronising to think that a woman would need "reminding" that adoption (or donor sperm) is an option?

Not if you're having a conversation and they're talking to you about being unable to have a child 🙄

FFS people are so touchy on this site.

Often there are things that feel strange/daunting/unfamiliar but with encouragement the person can change their outlook/feel brave enough to do it.

That's how it was for me with using a donor to have a child. At first it felt much too unfamiliar and scary but in talking about it with people, and in them bringing it up and making me consider it, I was brave enough to do it. And I'm extremely grateful and happy that I did.

HappyHappyHermit · 05/08/2022 08:58

I dont think it is about reminding someone, but if someone is in a dark place it can sometimes be helpful to offer some potential light. Sometimes in any situation it can feel so bad that you cannot see any possibilities so people that suggest something are most likely being kind rather than insensitive. I suspect in this type of situation there isn't really a right thing to say, a bit like when someone has lost a loved one, it will depend on the individual person and what they see as supportive.

Lovemypeaceandquiet · 05/08/2022 08:57

I think being childless, whether by choice or due to infertility, is still very much a taboo.

Some people with kids are having hard time understanding why would somebody choose or settle for opting out of parenthood - maybe they truly pity the childless ones, or maybe it makes them question their own choices?

I think becoming a parent is not something many people think as optional. It’s rarely reflected upon, as many pregnancies are accidental, it’s just becomes something you get on with.

So the people who try to convince you to adopt, they probably think having an adopted child is better than having none right? Because there’s no way in hell adults can live for the sole purpose of their own enjoyment and fulfilment. There’s no life beyond being a parent. Once you can’t/won’t have kids, you’re life is basically over.

😬

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 08:47

This is part of the problem. You don't have a magic wand you can wave and make the problem go away. If someone is coming to you upset about fertility issues, you don't need to remind them about adoption as if it will solve all their woes. I am pretty much 100% sure that person will have already thought about it at least once and knows that adoption exists. They don't need reminding as if they are going to go 'GOSH YOU'RE RIGHT, I HADN'T THOUGHT OF THAT, WOW EVERYTHING IS GREAT NOW'.

If they aren't bringing it up with you then just assume they have thought about it already and have decided against it for now.

And yes, it's perfectly fine to mourn the loss of being able to experience pregnancy and birth. It doesn't make anyone a bad person.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 08:44

(as someone who has a child now but spent many years struggling and went through IVF and the like).

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 08:43

Feeling the need to 'remind' someone going through fertility struggles is patronising as fuck. No one needs reminding about IVF or sperm donation or adoption or anything else. We aren't stupid.

In fact we probably have a better idea about things like IVF than you do considering most people will be under some sort of medical care/doctor.

It's just comes across so dismissive. 'why are you so upset? remember you can just do X Y or Z silly'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread