Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think adoption is not a fix all answer to not having biological children?

263 replies

StopSayingIt · 02/08/2022 10:53

Just want to preface this by saying I in absolutely no way mean that adopted children are loved any less, I understand that you can certainly feel exactly the same way about adopted children and biological children. That's not the point of this thread.

I have suffered from fertility issues myself for a long time, I do have children but it was a long long road involving various consultants, late stage losses, IVF clinics, genetic counsellors and on and on... Because of this I know quite a few people in similar circumstances through the various clinics I attended, Facebook groups and the like, I also have some close friends going through similar issues.

One thing I cannot stand when discussing this subject is the amount of people who suggest adoption as a fix all answer. "Have you looked into adoption?" It absolutely infuriates me and I think anyone who does it is frankly, a bit of an idiot.

Firstly, everyone knows about adoption, we don't need reminding that it exists.

But secondly and most importantly, I don't think it's fair or correct to state it as if it's some easy answer to infertility. Adoption is wonderful, my best friends daughter is adopted and I know she absolutely loves her daughter no less than her biological children but it's not easy either, it's not just a simple "fix" for having biological children, there have been lots of tough times, lovely times and challenges in its own right. She also hates people suggesting it in response to infertility and has said simply wanting children is not the same as going through the adoption process.

AIBU or is it a reasonable suggestion that couples suffering fertility issues "could just adopt"?

OP posts:
Roady1 · 05/08/2022 16:49

Mama234567 · 05/08/2022 16:40

I think it depends on how it's said and how well you know the person asking. If I witnessed a close friend going through ivf and baby loss I might ask if they had ever thought about adoption. I would never make a flippant comment about how someone should 'just adopt' though.

I think a close friend asking would be easier to stomach than a randomer or someone on MN.

But still it does beg the question of why you'd need to ask. If this person is talking to you about their fertility struggles I would assume they'd also talk to you about adoption if that was something they wanted to discuss and look into. As has been said already, it's pretty accepted that most people do know about adoption and don't need telling. If they wanted to, they could bring it up with you.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 16:47

It does put the person being asked in a tricky situation as well. How are you supposed to answer it? 'no because I want a child that's biologically mine'. People have already expressed offense at that notion on here. Then you may have to get into justifying yourself as to why it matters to you and so on...

Mama234567 · 05/08/2022 16:40

I think it depends on how it's said and how well you know the person asking. If I witnessed a close friend going through ivf and baby loss I might ask if they had ever thought about adoption. I would never make a flippant comment about how someone should 'just adopt' though.

topcat2014 · 05/08/2022 16:32

DW and I were approved to adopt. Notice past tense.. an adorable 6 yo was placed with us. I loved this child from day one.

The placement broke down because DW couldn't cope.

This was two years ago now. I miss this child every day.

Adoption is not easy x

CounsellorTroi · 05/08/2022 16:27

@Roady1 thank you so much x

Endlesssummer2022 · 05/08/2022 16:23

Some people are quite weird about adoption. Also there’s a tendency for those who’ve had a negative experience to be the majority of those who share on the internet.

I have bio and adopted DC. Love them the same. Adopted DC removed at 4 weeks. Birth mother, not a drinker or drug user, but had a spell in care, so generational issues, had neglected other kids who were in foster care so was being watched as soon as she got pregnant. She made one error and SS were did not fuck around and wait for her to neglect latest kid so removed and placed with the best foster family ever (still friends with them).

Adopted DC is happy, healthy, popular, well adjusted, secure and so gorgeous they turn heads. Looks biologically related to the family too, the matching was that good. Social worker 100% got us and knew what would work. We lucked out with her.

We tell adopted DC they are adopted but we don’t bang about it every 5 minutes to virtual strangers like some adopted parents I know. I think the push to do a 180 from hiding adoption in the 60s to constantly telling them and everyone else about ‘their story’ will eventually be seen to be an error. I know a local kid who’s mum tells all and sundry ‘he’s adopted’ within 2 mins of meeting them and is setting up a cycle of low expectations by stating he can’t possibly be expected to do X and Y at school e.g turn up on time ‘because he’s adopted’. I think it’s not good for a young person’s psychology to be constantly told publicly and privately and have their parents constantly tell everyone this. Kids just want to feel like they belong and it kind of feels like the parent is trying to distance themselves from any issues.

Not every adoptive parent will agree with me but I find (in my personal experience) that adoptive parents who also have bio children can see adoptive kids a bit differently to those who don’t have adopted kids. For example if an adopted child is playing up, the adoptive parent may rationalise it as ‘it’s because he’s adopted’, has ‘issues’ and follows through with that. However, I have an older bio child so when the younger one plays up I just know it’s not because they are adopted, it’s because they are 11 and sometimes 11 year olds make dick moves. I know this because my older kid used to do shitty things which would make me fantasise about abandoning my family and starting a new life!

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 16:21

I'm sorry about your father x

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 16:21

CounsellorTroi · 05/08/2022 16:19

I know people don't like to hear it but when it was me and people used to just breezily mention adoption like it would solve everything I'd want to scream at them. I was very clearly grieving what I thought at the time was my inability to have a biological child. Not just because of pregnancy and birth (although that is a loss too), I can't even fully explain it myself, it's just a natural urge isn't it? Adoption wouldn't have fixed that problem for me at that time.

I lost my father young (17) and part of my reason for wanting my own child was to have a child related to him. Selfish perhaps…..

It's not at all selfish. You're entitled to have biology matter to you. I don't understand why that's offensive to anyone. It obviously doesn't matter to adoptive parents and that's great, it doesn't mean I have to believe the same thing in my own situation otherwise I'm offensive and calling adopted children lesser. I'm not. But to me it mattered. And that is fine.

CounsellorTroi · 05/08/2022 16:19

I know people don't like to hear it but when it was me and people used to just breezily mention adoption like it would solve everything I'd want to scream at them. I was very clearly grieving what I thought at the time was my inability to have a biological child. Not just because of pregnancy and birth (although that is a loss too), I can't even fully explain it myself, it's just a natural urge isn't it? Adoption wouldn't have fixed that problem for me at that time.

I lost my father young (17) and part of my reason for wanting my own child was to have a child related to him. Selfish perhaps…..

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 16:08

Are not at

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 16:07

And someone coming to you upset about infertility is very obviously not yet over it. So suggesting adoption to them at that point is also next to useless.

I know people don't like to hear it but when it was me and people used to just breezily mention adoption like it would solve everything I'd want to scream at them. I was very clearly grieving what I thought at the time was my inability to have a biological child. Not just because of pregnancy and birth (although that is a loss too), I can't even fully explain it myself, it's just a natural urge isn't it? Adoption wouldn't have fixed that problem for me at that time.

That is not to say I think adoptees at lesser children. Not at all. But I think there is a difference when someone is grieving the potential for a biological child. It's not a solution and neither is at easy 'just do this'.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 16:01

It’s surely realistic to think that most adopters end up there after infertility

Perhaps. But it shouldn't be the sole reason for you adopting, to fill some sort of void you feel in your life. You should be adopting because you want to adopt and feel you can deal with everything (as explained by PPs) that could potentially come with. Not just because you want a child.

Hence why you have to show you have come to terms with infertility prior to the adoption process. Because they are two separate things and you shouldn't be using one to solve the other.

miltonj · 05/08/2022 16:00

@Roady1 absolutely!
Also just because someone could be a good mum to a birth child, doesn't mean they would be a good mum to an adoptive child. A child adopted at birth can go through childhood with little to no extra issues and then the trauma can start to present itself in teenage or young adult years. People need to understand this.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 15:59

And anyway, if someone comes to you upset about infertility and wanting some support, they are very obviously grieving being unable to have a biological child. Adoption, even though it is not lesser, does not solve that and people know it exists they do not need reminding.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 15:57

miltonj · 05/08/2022 15:52

I am not being naive or simplistic. I have close experience of this and know that in order for adoption to work for the kids, you have to be someone who is willing to dedicate their life to raising kids with different issues to a birth child. Often doing much more than a birth parent would. I.e leaving work even in teenage years as the children need more stability than a birth child. It needs to be something that the parent really, really wants, otherwise children get hurt.

This is exactly why I was saying wanting a child does not automatically equal a good adoptive parent. There are (generally) differences, no not to the love or care you feel, but as laid out by PPs and just because you want a biological child but can't have one does not automatically mean adoption would be a good option for you.

It's separate, it's something you should want to do on its own merit not just as the last option so you can fix an issue in your life.

Belephant · 05/08/2022 15:56

@Cw122 couldn't have (and indeed didn't) put it better myself!

miltonj · 05/08/2022 15:52

TeenDivided · 05/08/2022 15:12

Words are failing me on this thread.

We aren't anything special. We adopted because we wanted to be parents and to raise a family, and we thought we would be up to the task of adopting. I think the people who say you should only adopt if you think you have a 'calling' are naive and simplistic.

Of course you can't 'just' adopt. But there is no getting away from the fact that adoption is a way to make a family and for infertile couples it is one of their few potential options. As is clear from posts on this thread it is also true there are still myths around who is eligible to adopt.

If you know someone well enough to be sharing your upset over infertility with them, maybe you should accept that if they ask about adoption maybe they are trying to help / give you space to explore that route / genuinely interested as to whether that might be an avenue you would explore? Obviously there is a time and a place, and 30s after a negative result would not be the time or the place.

Making adoption taboo to even mention it seems so negative.

I am not being naive or simplistic. I have close experience of this and know that in order for adoption to work for the kids, you have to be someone who is willing to dedicate their life to raising kids with different issues to a birth child. Often doing much more than a birth parent would. I.e leaving work even in teenage years as the children need more stability than a birth child. It needs to be something that the parent really, really wants, otherwise children get hurt.

PurpleDaisies · 05/08/2022 15:50

My last sentence doesn’t say what I wanted it to say! It’s surely realistic to think that most adopters end up there after infertility.

PurpleDaisies · 05/08/2022 15:49

adopting isn't a backup option though? It's not for people to say 'oh if I can't have biological kids I'll just adopt, problem solved' you either want to adopt or you don't in my opinion. An adopted child should go to a home who really really wants them, not as a back up option

I don’t think that someone who has made peace with not being able to have biological children but then decides to adopt is going to be a bad parent. Nobody comes to it with the “problem solved” attitude that you’ve implied here. It’s a serious and properly thought through decision. It has to be to survive the vetting process.

It isn’t realistic to think that many (probably most) adopters come to it after infertility.

Cw122 · 05/08/2022 15:45

jewishmum · 05/08/2022 14:51

  • that you birthed. Asking as we have a long family tree of adopted people and I myself find it hard to see a difference.

@jewishmum it's obviously dependent on the needs, background and experiences of the adopted child but there can be some differences. Firstly that child when adopted will have two families however they choose to engage with their first family. The adoptive family will have responsibilities around contact with bio parents- this could be life story work, letters or visits and playdates. There will also be check ins from social workers etc. A lot of children in care are older than 3 years old and are likely to have lived in a number of houses by that age which can make it difficult for them to trust and build attachments with adoptive parents. They will have other siblings they might really miss who they will need to have contact with. And as they grow older they may have a wide range of feelings about being adopted. Some young people I work with are happy as part of their adoptive family while others resent being adopted at all and feel it should have happened later when they had a choice in the matter and a fostering or guardianship role would have been closer to meeting their needs. If course some children may be affected by FAS or trauma, may even experience PTSD and have long term attachment disorders. If you treat an adopted child like they aren't adopted and have never been, in part you're almost denying a part of their identity and life experiences so that's why it's so crucial the adoptive parents are grounded emotionally so that they can hold space for whatever their child is feeling and experiencing and however they process their life journey. That's something that people with children they gave birth to don't have to consider in the same way.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 15:45

TeenDivided · 05/08/2022 15:35

Why do people have babies? Is it because they want to be pregnant (9 months) or because they want to be parents (18 years+)? We wanted to be parents. We tried the easy/free route, then the more difficult one, then the hardest one.

It's obviously more nuanced than that.

But yes missing the experience of pregnancy and birth can be a big thing and can be very upsetting and it's perfectly valid to grieve that.

However, it's not the only reason someone may struggle to come to terms with not having a biological child, lots of people want a biological child and it's not just because they want to be pregnant. It's not wrong or offensive to say you want a biological child.

Simply wanting a child does not automatically make adoption for you.

Vikinga · 05/08/2022 15:45

It is odd that people suggest it like it's something new that you may not have heard of!

I would definitely have tried to adopt had I not been able to have my own children. My best friend is adopted and I have friends who have adopted. The ones who have adopted due to infertility is the minority, most already have children and have adopted after having their own children.

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 15:41

what is wrong with wanting to have biological children?

Nothing is wrong with that. That's my point. Hence why just breezily suggesting adoption to someone grieving the loss of being able to have a biological child is not very sensitive. Because they are entitled to grieve and want that.

TeenDivided · 05/08/2022 15:35

Why do people have babies? Is it because they want to be pregnant (9 months) or because they want to be parents (18 years+)? We wanted to be parents. We tried the easy/free route, then the more difficult one, then the hardest one.

grey12 · 05/08/2022 15:34

Roady1 · 05/08/2022 10:47

But if I couldn't have children I would have done it

Can you not see though that comments like this do suggest that the majority of people do want to have biological children and it's not taboo to say that? If it didn't matter to you, you'd have adopted prior to having biological children but you didn't. You looked at it after and said IF you couldn't have bio DC, you would have.

And what is wrong with that?! 🤷🏻‍♀️ what is wrong with wanting to have biological children? If we were infertile (like someone in our family) we would still want to parent children (neither me or DH wanted to remain childless) and adoption is an option then (like that family member adopted 2 lovely boys)

Actually that's not even what I said: I did say we were still considering but I had 3 children and have been struggling a bit. If I wasn't struggling and we had a big house where we didn't have to stick the 3 in one room, yes we would be thinking about adopting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread