Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder what life in Germany is like?

145 replies

prepared101 · 02/08/2022 09:48

lighthearted and somewhat stereotypical

I'm on holiday at in popular European summer holiday destination. The resort is made up of mostly German and English tourists.

The Germans are almost universally in excellent shape- not thin but lean and 'strong' looking. Their hair is in good condition- mostly natural looking. Their skin is great and their tans are superb.

So. as I sit on my sun lounger with dodgy tan (if you can call it that) lines, a bit of extra podge on my belly and hair that breaks at the sight of chlorine I ask... how do I live like a German?!

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 02/08/2022 15:48

BeanieTeen · 02/08/2022 15:31

If you've had severe stress or an operation or a serious illness you can apply for a three-week 'cure' in a residential clinic in a seaside/mountain/lakeside area - your contribution is 10 euro/day, which can be covered for you if you can't afford it.

Yes, I remember a German friend mentioning this. She seemed quite disgusted by the fact that my FIL, a few days after having major heart surgery, was just sent home. I’m Germany you would apparently spend 2 weeks or so in a ‘Reha-Kinik’. Like rehab, but not for drugs and alcohol abuse - rehabilitation from as you say an operation or illness.

Going to a convalescent type place would have made a huge difference to me after my mastectomy - instead of being sent home the day after with a leaflet of exercises, and expected to just get on with it!

Crikeyalmighty · 02/08/2022 15:34

I love Germany- vastly underrated place. We have been a lot with work stuff.

On the looking good front- I've yet to see many German women rocking the pantomime Dame look of huge thick eyebrows or constant false eyelashes and clothes tend to be 'sensible' and good quality rather than out and out fashionable.

As others have said ready meals aren't a big thing, nor is getting your shopping all from one place - the supermarkets are actually not great and people will go to fishmongers, butchers, markets stalls etc , greengrocers.

Definitely more outdoorsy and lots of woods/lakes/saunas etc- they have good summers too- particularly from Düsseldorf and going south- Bavaria can be very hot in summer and cold and skiing in winter- hence the tans.

A big thing though I think is the stress factor- a lot of Germans rent big family flats (nice ones) and pay what we would call social rents for very many years regardless of income - if they buy ,they often buy holiday homes instead in places like Majorca, Turkey.

If you are ill it's common to be sent to these rather nice post convalescent centres with pools, lakes, gyms etc

A lot of this applies to Denmark too - we noticed it when we lived there. A lot of the men too kept their good looks till far older than men seem too here- all that walking, cycling and swimming probably!!

BeanieTeen · 02/08/2022 15:31

If you've had severe stress or an operation or a serious illness you can apply for a three-week 'cure' in a residential clinic in a seaside/mountain/lakeside area - your contribution is 10 euro/day, which can be covered for you if you can't afford it.

Yes, I remember a German friend mentioning this. She seemed quite disgusted by the fact that my FIL, a few days after having major heart surgery, was just sent home. I’m Germany you would apparently spend 2 weeks or so in a ‘Reha-Kinik’. Like rehab, but not for drugs and alcohol abuse - rehabilitation from as you say an operation or illness.

BigFatLiar · 02/08/2022 15:28

If you tried to lower the prices for pools and transport here people would be complaining about subsidising services.

dreamingbohemian · 02/08/2022 15:17

That's a great point about how much more accessible facilities are.

In Berlin I paid 3.50 to use the local pool, here in London it's 10 quid, lots of people can't afford that at all.

bunsnroses1 · 02/08/2022 15:11

I’m in Germany at the moment touring round in our camper for the summer holidays. The public facilities here are so much better- a lot of towns have their own municipal pools which are clean and cheap to use (2 euro each the last one we went to which had diving boards, a kids pool and a ‘proper’ swimming area). Most towns also seem to have their own football pitches and tennis courts (also free to use). There are cycle lanes everywhere and easily accessible walking and bike trails in the forests with free parking.
The playgrounds we’ve seen are exciting and well maintained- the one we were at yesterday in Kehl has an brilliant river/fountain/water play area and the kids were in it all day.
At home you take your life in your hands going anywhere on your bike, nature (beaches and forests) cost a bomb to park at, public transport is woeful (I live in Cornwall) and our local pool is dirty, cold and £7 each to swim.
Our government are pissing on our backs and telling us it’s raining.

TheGraceFace · 02/08/2022 14:56

I’ve met some lovely German people both in Germany & whilst traveling around. However, I always think they look quite stern, which doesn’t go particularly well with his Speedos or her going topless.

onthefencesitter · 02/08/2022 14:54

BitOutOfPractice · 02/08/2022 14:39

No problem since we agree anyway @onthefencesitter 😀

It always strikes me when I'm in a lovely historic city in Italy or Spain for example, how many people still live in the city centre. Yet in historic towns across the UK there seems to be very little of it or it's so expensive that average families can't afford it.

Another factor that I think could be a contributor- in Germany, vier zimmer wohnung (3 bedroom and living room) is quite standard. I am looking for a similar apartment in London as my next home and it is much less common than 2 bed apartments! Most families would want 3 bedrooms, i think, even if you have 1 child, the third bedroom is useful as a study or playroom or for pets. And if you have 2 children, you would really want 2 bedrooms esp if mixed gender. in london, a lot of families live in 2 bedroom apartments, no wonder they are dying to move into suburbia.

onthefencesitter · 02/08/2022 14:48

BitOutOfPractice · 02/08/2022 14:39

No problem since we agree anyway @onthefencesitter 😀

It always strikes me when I'm in a lovely historic city in Italy or Spain for example, how many people still live in the city centre. Yet in historic towns across the UK there seems to be very little of it or it's so expensive that average families can't afford it.

DH grew up in zone 3 London and his mum never had a car even though she had 4 kids. It is technically the suburbs but you can reach central london in 20 mins via the tube. DH and I bought an apartment also in zone 3 london and we also don't have a car. DH cycles to work, we use public transport, we all have wheeley trolleys for the supermarket. DH refuses to live anything further out than zone 3 and he rejects all houses in our budget range; he says he would rather a more central apartment or a larger apartment where we live. This sentiment is quite unusual in the UK, I think it may be because he is quite European in mindset!

BitOutOfPractice · 02/08/2022 14:39

No problem since we agree anyway @onthefencesitter 😀

It always strikes me when I'm in a lovely historic city in Italy or Spain for example, how many people still live in the city centre. Yet in historic towns across the UK there seems to be very little of it or it's so expensive that average families can't afford it.

balalake · 02/08/2022 14:39

I have to say that whilst there are some overweight Germans, they seem fewer in number.

Maybe having competent governments and things such as adequate public transport helps. I wonder if the use of saunas also helps.

onthefencesitter · 02/08/2022 14:36

BitOutOfPractice · 02/08/2022 14:34

@onthefencesitter I didn't reference home ownership, just the greater propensity to live in the centre of cities / towns.

Sorry quoted wrong post!

BitOutOfPractice · 02/08/2022 14:34

@onthefencesitter I didn't reference home ownership, just the greater propensity to live in the centre of cities / towns.

onthefencesitter · 02/08/2022 14:30

BitOutOfPractice · 02/08/2022 14:25

I think that is so true. I think, across Europe as a whole (certainly the Netherlands that I have most experience of outside the UK), city / town centre living is the norm and it is easier to walk and cycle to amenities that are closer without having to rely on a car.

I've just moved to a city centre apartment and my car hasn't moved for 10 days. I walk / cycle / take public transport MUCH more than when I lived in suburbia before.

Netherlands has a higher home ownership rate than uk- 69% vs 63%.

Spain has 76% home ownership rate too. What I think is different is that people in the UK want to buy houses rather than apartments and so have to move to suburbia where land is cheaper.

BitOutOfPractice · 02/08/2022 14:25

dreamingbohemian · 02/08/2022 11:36

There are also more subtle things, like Germans in general are happier to live in rented flats all their lives (better tenants rights and pensions) so live more centrally and can walk and cycle everywhere, there is not the same flight to the suburbs that gives so many Brits longer commutes and needing cars etc.

I think that is so true. I think, across Europe as a whole (certainly the Netherlands that I have most experience of outside the UK), city / town centre living is the norm and it is easier to walk and cycle to amenities that are closer without having to rely on a car.

I've just moved to a city centre apartment and my car hasn't moved for 10 days. I walk / cycle / take public transport MUCH more than when I lived in suburbia before.

BigFatLiar · 02/08/2022 14:24

We were frequent visitors to Munich.

Definitely a lot of not slim people. Beer kellers popular, our friends could get beer delivered in the same way we get milk. First time there I thought there were a lot of coffins but it seems it was so the drunks could be taken somewhere out of the way to sleep it off.

Public transport was good and cheap.

onthefencesitter · 02/08/2022 14:12

YouSoundLovely · 02/08/2022 13:34

Oh yes, the museums and restaurants will definitely be open on Sunday, certainly in Munich.

By no means everyone builds/buys a house. People do, especially in some areas of the country (and it's much more usual to either inherit a house from parents, often after living in part of it for decades, or build - there's nothing like the UK housing market really), but, as a PP said, renting is a perfectly good option and many do it for life, esp (but not only) in cities. Tenants are properly protected. A landlord has to demonstrably have one of a very limited number of good reasons to end a rental contract (which are almost always permanent/time-unlimited), whereas a tenant can leave without giving a reason, just three months' notice. You'd never have a phrase like 'in rented accommodation' - with all its connotations of impermanency - in German.

No tuition fees! And a very generous system of state support for students - means-tested on parental income but fairly liberally so, so plenty of students from middle-income families get it - and it takes into account the number of children a family has to support. It's half a grant and half a loan.

It really depends. DH's German grandfather got a house as part of his employment, he still lives in it today. He helped both his children buy houses. However, DH's cousins don't own though one of them told me he would like to (as he is worried about whether his pension would support renting in old age) though he is happy renting too. He gets a lovely apartment and the rent hardly goes up. Equally, we also know people who have rented all their lives and are happy too.

I would say that people are not as obsessed about property as they are here. If circumstances allow them, they would buy eventually (and they tend to buy only 1 house and stay there until death) but its a bonus rather than an essential. I feel like DH's mother still has that mentality even though she has lived in UK for years so she couldnt understand my drive to buy our flat asap.

user1473878824 · 02/08/2022 14:07

RejectedFleece · 02/08/2022 12:19

My experience of years of life in Germany. Apologies if you don't like it.

I understood what you were saying just the comment wasn’t really anything to do with what the OP was asking.

Softplayhooray · 02/08/2022 14:06

YouSoundLovely · 02/08/2022 10:29

Pretty much all this. There are lots of bike stands outside pretty much every public building and a lot of private businesses. Trains have (relatively) large amounts of dedicated bike space. I also think there's more use of public parks/woods/green spaces (which are walked or cycled to) because it's much more normal to live in flats so people can't just go into gardens and need to get out. Much more outdoor swimming, too - lakes (either wild or with specially created swimming areas) and outdoor pools. Our very small and not very wealthy town has an indoor and and outdoor pool.

Healthcare is better. Mandatory health and social care insurance is 18%ish of your gross income, but if you are an employee, your employer covers half of that (and the rest comes straight out of your pay), and it's generally much easier to access care. If you've had severe stress or an operation or a serious illness you can apply for a three-week 'cure' in a residential clinic in a seaside/mountain/lakeside area - your contribution is 10 euro/day, which can be covered for you if you can't afford it.

That's literally incredible. A 3 weeks wellness holiday to recuperate? That's beyond what we could dream of. To think if Brexit hadn't happened I could've gone and worked there and got that 3 week stay one day!!!

Hoppinggreen · 02/08/2022 14:03

YouSoundLovely · 02/08/2022 13:34

Oh yes, the museums and restaurants will definitely be open on Sunday, certainly in Munich.

By no means everyone builds/buys a house. People do, especially in some areas of the country (and it's much more usual to either inherit a house from parents, often after living in part of it for decades, or build - there's nothing like the UK housing market really), but, as a PP said, renting is a perfectly good option and many do it for life, esp (but not only) in cities. Tenants are properly protected. A landlord has to demonstrably have one of a very limited number of good reasons to end a rental contract (which are almost always permanent/time-unlimited), whereas a tenant can leave without giving a reason, just three months' notice. You'd never have a phrase like 'in rented accommodation' - with all its connotations of impermanency - in German.

No tuition fees! And a very generous system of state support for students - means-tested on parental income but fairly liberally so, so plenty of students from middle-income families get it - and it takes into account the number of children a family has to support. It's half a grant and half a loan.

I was there last Sunday and the museums and restaurant were open.
Museums were pretty cheap too, 4e for a family of 4 in the one we visited

QueSyrahSyrah · 02/08/2022 14:03

Hoppinggreen · 02/08/2022 10:25

I’m in Germany on holiday and DH is German. The majority of them do look very healthy. Few things I have observed
Very outdoorsy
Lots of swimming
many more electric cars
excellent public transport but also lots of walking
lots of Doctors
mild hypochondria

GrinGrin You've basically described my German friends there Grin

FelicityFlops · 02/08/2022 13:59

@tara66 I wouldn't say that Germans are superior, there are good and bad as in every country. I would say that things are more organised and more formal with distinct processes. These tend to work 90+% of the time.
Again, as with everywhere, it depends on your demographic and where you live.
One thing I have noticed, which is quite interesting, is that compared to 15 or 20 years ago people are now prepared to move around a little more for work and are prepared to commute more, if it means they can buy or build a house in a less expensive area. This never used to be the case.

dreamingbohemian · 02/08/2022 13:55

tara66 · 02/08/2022 13:45

So - are Germans actually superior then?

Not at all, but I would say that in general in Germany there is a better quality of life for most people. Better healthcare, far more financial support for families, lots of outdoor activities, etc.

Though as PP said, there are still very stark differences between east and west, parts of the former east are very deprived with a lot of people suffering. It's not all roses in Germany.

And yet with all that, we still moved back to the UK and I am much happier here : )

Ammonites · 02/08/2022 13:53

Thanks for the Munich tips. I’m more familiar with the Düsseldorf area.

Think I’ll start a university degree in Germany thread nearer the time.

tara66 · 02/08/2022 13:45

So - are Germans actually superior then?