Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel angry at Tory voters?

740 replies

Dottodo · 02/08/2022 00:52

DF has always voted Tory. He’s very anti immigration and we will never see each other’s POV.
DHs friends are all Tory voters and hate being with them as they are all racist, xenophobic & misogynistic.
Other Tory voters I know through work or extended family members are also xenophobic and casually racist.
I’ve spoken to friends about this and they agree that the Tory voters they personally know are also racist and xenophobic.
Why is this?
Me and DH lived abroad and as we've lived as ‘foreigners’, we don’t share their views.

OP posts:
AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 08:45

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 08:21

And the greens / other are protesting against the new nuclear site at the same time people laud the French for having nuclear

We either want better trains that lower vehicle demand or energy security or not. If we do it takes time, interruption and money.

Its your locals in Suffolk who don't want a Nuclear power station and with good reason & they wont be lauding the french either.

I spent a lot of time at Hinkley, the disruption (lasting years) is immense.

I think the Tory idea, now dropped, of providing discounted rates to those effected would be a great idea, be that for on shore wind/solar or nuclear.

110 billlion would transform local services, esp if the railways were more state owned, instead of taking profits away, often to subsidise european networks.

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 08:22

There…

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 08:21

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 08:06

I see criticism of HS2 a lot but also of trains in U.K. not being as good as some EU countries (of course it’s mn everything in EU is paved with gold) but on this isn’t it better we improve trains here? Iirc it’s electric so on environmental levels a better way to travel

No one who has used EU railways can not be impressed with a: their cost or b their efficiency and coverage.
So not sure why you have to have a dig at this?
Some things are better, some are worse.

Having a very short length of HS in a relatively small country doesn't improve the lot of the many commuter lines that need urgent up grade or the astronomical fares.
Its 50% to drive to London (Cornwall, for 4 of us), park, pay for all the tube fares, have a meal than it is to take the train.

The environmental damage the building of this track is immense, not too mention the cost, £110 billion and rising.

And the greens / other are protesting against the new nuclear site at the same time people laud the French for having nuclear

We either want better trains that lower vehicle demand or energy security or not. If we do it takes time, interruption and money.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 08:20

See the moaning about GPs or the state of the NHS/social Care... They voted for the run down of these services but when they need them... it becomes "Labour ruined it all....."

I don't think Labour ruined the NHS but I think the NHS no longer works in its current state.

There's been some very interesting MN threads on this recently and the consensus was that the part state-private healthcare systems in France and Germany provided better patient care. I also have friends who are NHS consultants so I hear a fair amount about the issues they face.

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 08:19

pigeonstreet123 · 04/08/2022 07:53

@MeanderingGently

Yes, typical tory voter attitude. It's all about individual. Whats innit for me

But you should look at the broader picture. What's best for society? We cant all be entrepreneurs. We need teachers, nhs, refuse workers, public transport to keep civilised society functioning

We need policies to look after others not just our own needs

People don’t pay half income in tax without thinking about society, it’s fairly obvious a big chunk is going to the state.

There’s seems to be an idea people paying in are morally worse than those taking out. Yet we need people to pay the tax burden for all the services you list. It’s not out of thin air.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 08:10

Yes I am about individuals being rewarded. That's capitalism in essence. I went to state schools, worked my arse off to get the best grades I could, qualified as an accountant post university and that opened up a highly paid job in investment banking.

My parents didn't pull any strings or have any experience of that industry. It was down to me as an individual. I contributed to society as a whole through the tax I paid, and all the trickle-down effects of spending on local goods and services.

If the high earners paying 50% of their salary in income tax (plus more on other forms of tax) isn't enough, I think we need to ask why? One factor is an ageing population but it must be more than that. I'm not convinced that all public money is spent wisely. Honestly, when I see the amount we pay in tax, I'm not keen to pay more. I doubt most people would be in their heart of hearts.

In response to the post about needing minimum wage workers, I agree with what you say. That's a tough one. Not everyone can be a high earner.

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 08:10

pigeonstreet123 · 04/08/2022 07:53

@MeanderingGently

Yes, typical tory voter attitude. It's all about individual. Whats innit for me

But you should look at the broader picture. What's best for society? We cant all be entrepreneurs. We need teachers, nhs, refuse workers, public transport to keep civilised society functioning

We need policies to look after others not just our own needs

^100%

Your typical Tory only care about themselves until they don't and then they moan like xxxx because they can't get state help.

See the moaning about GPs or the state of the NHS/social Care... They voted for the run down of these services but when they need them... it becomes "Labour ruined it all....."

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 08:06

I see criticism of HS2 a lot but also of trains in U.K. not being as good as some EU countries (of course it’s mn everything in EU is paved with gold) but on this isn’t it better we improve trains here? Iirc it’s electric so on environmental levels a better way to travel

No one who has used EU railways can not be impressed with a: their cost or b their efficiency and coverage.
So not sure why you have to have a dig at this?
Some things are better, some are worse.

Having a very short length of HS in a relatively small country doesn't improve the lot of the many commuter lines that need urgent up grade or the astronomical fares.
Its 50% to drive to London (Cornwall, for 4 of us), park, pay for all the tube fares, have a meal than it is to take the train.

The environmental damage the building of this track is immense, not too mention the cost, £110 billion and rising.

pigeonstreet123 · 04/08/2022 07:53

@MeanderingGently

Yes, typical tory voter attitude. It's all about individual. Whats innit for me

But you should look at the broader picture. What's best for society? We cant all be entrepreneurs. We need teachers, nhs, refuse workers, public transport to keep civilised society functioning

We need policies to look after others not just our own needs

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 07:48

lot123 · 04/08/2022 07:20

Mangyinseam I also agree with your post. I doubt many Conservative voters object to the safety net of a benefits system for those unable to work or make ends meet.

But there also needs to be a financial reward for people who work hard and study to improve their career prospects. I understand that not all kids have the same opportunities to work at school and that wealth is a key factor in educational achievement. Equally we provide free education, albeit of a differing standard, and that provides opportunity.

see plenty of kids who can't be bothered to work at school and seem surprised when their only option is a minimum wage job. I also know lots of kids whose parents emigrated to the U.K. and education/aspiration is highly valued and they work their socks off.

I'm not heartless. We pay half of our household income in tax, which, put bluntly, is a decent sum of money. I think that's enough. I think the government could spend their money better at times, particularly when I see some of the procedures the NHS funds and schemes such as HS2. I'm also a firm believer in taking responsibility for your own career prospects and limiting government intervention and bureaucracy where possible.

And before the pile on comes my way, I know some people work very long hours for the minimum wage. My brother is in this category.

Imo half is a lot and psychologically where people feel that a limit has been met in terms of paying the state.

I see criticism of HS2 a lot but also of trains in U.K. not being as good as some EU countries (of course it’s mn everything in EU is paved with gold) but on this isn’t it better we improve trains here? Iirc it’s electric so on environmental levels a better way to travel.

I agree generally that dependency on state isn’t always a positive. And a huge state isn’t either - Covid was abnormal times but that level of state intervention created some dependency which we’re now moving away from. Although some sectors still do the we need help, when actually it is their problem to solve.

ToodlePipYouLongHairedGit · 04/08/2022 07:45

@MangyInseam @lot123 I agree with you both

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 07:41

@lot123 Apart from your first sentence, i agree with you.

I was that lazy kid who got a mw job but then realised i needed to educate myself and with completely free and in some cases, paid state support, i got O levels and then a HND, which then led to a well paid career.

That help has been totally removed, a younger me would have stayed working in that low paid job, as i just wouldn't have been able to afford to stop work & at that time, been unable to see the long term benefits of FE.

BUT & here is the rub, society will not function unless there are large numbers of people who do these MW jobs.... so how do we square that circle?

NHS confederation says we have 100k NHS staff shortages and an amazing 165k shortages of Care workers.

Up the pay of Care workers and they then will be on an hourly rate similar to a newly qualified nurse etc but without a substantial loan to pay back or staff parking to pay, let alone the responsibility levels.

I don't know how any Govt is going to sort this mess out, public pay freezes have caused a headache for us all.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 07:20

Mangyinseam I also agree with your post. I doubt many Conservative voters object to the safety net of a benefits system for those unable to work or make ends meet.

But there also needs to be a financial reward for people who work hard and study to improve their career prospects. I understand that not all kids have the same opportunities to work at school and that wealth is a key factor in educational achievement. Equally we provide free education, albeit of a differing standard, and that provides opportunity.

see plenty of kids who can't be bothered to work at school and seem surprised when their only option is a minimum wage job. I also know lots of kids whose parents emigrated to the U.K. and education/aspiration is highly valued and they work their socks off.

I'm not heartless. We pay half of our household income in tax, which, put bluntly, is a decent sum of money. I think that's enough. I think the government could spend their money better at times, particularly when I see some of the procedures the NHS funds and schemes such as HS2. I'm also a firm believer in taking responsibility for your own career prospects and limiting government intervention and bureaucracy where possible.

And before the pile on comes my way, I know some people work very long hours for the minimum wage. My brother is in this category.

Mississipi71 · 04/08/2022 05:58

MangyInseam · 04/08/2022 02:05

I'm not sure how many people really think that everyone starts from the same place or doesn't understand that there are people with disadvantages.

Even most conservatives in western countries believe there needs to be a health care system, an education system, that works for all. There are different ideas about what works best, and it's really not at all clear that the best systems are the ones that are the most completely socialized and government run. But the reason most people think that is because they see those are areas that make a huge difference to what those with disadvantages can achieve.

Most conservatives however also think that if you create systems of dependence on it, it ultimately disempowers people and undermines important forms of community resilience. So there is a balance to be struck and it is not always simple. And then at another level, when people are dependent on an entity like the state, or equally a corporation, they are at the mercy of that organization in a way that is ultimately politically dangerous and also dehumanizing.

I watched an interesting film the other day about black conservatibes in the US, and I was really struck by the way many of them percieved the approach of the Democratic party. They felt that the DP was happy to give black Americans a certain amount of state support, so long as they remained in some kind of underclass position and dependent (apart from a few token examples) so they would continue to vote Democrat and not contest other types of Democratic policies. And they say this as a continuation of earlier DP policies like Jim Crowe laws, which also looked to use the black community to gain votes in another way.

Which is to say, they saw the actions of the left, the DP, as purposefully maintaining policies that damaged their ability to better themselves.

Now whether or not you think that analysis is correct, I think it gives some window into how people can think quite differently about what kind of social policy creates opportunities for people to thrive,

Excellent post.

MangyInseam · 04/08/2022 02:05

Crikeyalmighty · 03/08/2022 19:43

I'm not going to post anymore as I can feel my blood pressure rising but just to say - I have no issue if people on here vote Tory , their choice- But i do have an issue with those on mumsnet in general who have zero empathy with those who may struggle in life far more than they do , speak to anyone renting like the shit on their shoe (their are many reasons people do, not all down to 'bad choices' - by a very long way) and seem to feel anyone left of Jacob Rees Mogg is some kind of hard left agitator. Then again on the other side of it I've not got a lot of time for those who struggle a bit and choose to make snarky jealous comments about anyone who has done ok through hard work and their own efforts .

I'm not sure how many people really think that everyone starts from the same place or doesn't understand that there are people with disadvantages.

Even most conservatives in western countries believe there needs to be a health care system, an education system, that works for all. There are different ideas about what works best, and it's really not at all clear that the best systems are the ones that are the most completely socialized and government run. But the reason most people think that is because they see those are areas that make a huge difference to what those with disadvantages can achieve.

Most conservatives however also think that if you create systems of dependence on it, it ultimately disempowers people and undermines important forms of community resilience. So there is a balance to be struck and it is not always simple. And then at another level, when people are dependent on an entity like the state, or equally a corporation, they are at the mercy of that organization in a way that is ultimately politically dangerous and also dehumanizing.

I watched an interesting film the other day about black conservatibes in the US, and I was really struck by the way many of them percieved the approach of the Democratic party. They felt that the DP was happy to give black Americans a certain amount of state support, so long as they remained in some kind of underclass position and dependent (apart from a few token examples) so they would continue to vote Democrat and not contest other types of Democratic policies. And they say this as a continuation of earlier DP policies like Jim Crowe laws, which also looked to use the black community to gain votes in another way.

Which is to say, they saw the actions of the left, the DP, as purposefully maintaining policies that damaged their ability to better themselves.

Now whether or not you think that analysis is correct, I think it gives some window into how people can think quite differently about what kind of social policy creates opportunities for people to thrive,

DdraigGoch · 04/08/2022 00:33

Blossomtoes · 03/08/2022 22:40

Which budgets were increased? Every single public service is worse now than those the Tories inherited. Improvements in health and education flushed away, millions more children living in poverty, Surestart swept away. It’s heartbreaking.

Take International Development. The civil servants in that department couldn't spend the money fast enough.

Healthcare spending (even before the pandemic) has also increased in real terms since 2010.

Gallante · 04/08/2022 00:10

However people vote, I think we need to look at the fact that the people of Britain has been struggling year on year since the Tories came to power in 2010.
Food banks served 40,000 people in 2009 and this jumped to 60,000 in 2010 then more than doubled to 128,000 in 2011.
Now over 2 million rely on food banks. Many of these people work but do not earn enough to pay their bills and buy food!
Furthermore, Tories raised tuition fees, cut benefits & disability benefits, introduced a bedroom tax, spent billions on unusable PPE during the pandemic and had a no deal brexit which has caused many manufacturers to fold or move to Eastern Europe due to the stringent new measures introduced for customs.
Under Labour, I was on a considerably much lower wage, yet had far more disposable income despite having a mortgage to pay.
Yet the rich get richer. How is this fair and why do people still vote Tory when our people are struggling more and more each year even those of us with two full time earners?

Blossomtoes · 03/08/2022 22:40

DdraigGoch · 03/08/2022 19:32

Some cuts were made, but the budget was balanced far slower than Darling planned to.

Some budgets were even increased.

Which budgets were increased? Every single public service is worse now than those the Tories inherited. Improvements in health and education flushed away, millions more children living in poverty, Surestart swept away. It’s heartbreaking.

XingMing · 03/08/2022 21:08

We all abhor the sort of countries where gay people are prosecuted and persecuted, let alone killed. But that topic was not germane to the general direction of the conversation. In my experience, Tories are actually rather more chilled on sexual preferences than most, because they tend to view them as private matters.

Crikeyalmighty · 03/08/2022 20:52

@Onlyhereforthebatshitneighbours Why thank you . I do find it frustrating- I always thought women were the softer sex , so I am always suprised at the amount of vitriol against those who are a bit more liberal or concerned about the amount of hard nosed Americanisation creeping in here (without the better aspects of the USA) I'm all for endeavour but not without safety nets .

Onlyhereforthebatshitneighbours · 03/08/2022 20:33

@Crikeyalmighty thank you for articulating your posts so well. My heads been a bit all over the place this week, but your posts are near summations of what I think and I've been to have you posting.

Anyone else notice how the further right the government leant, the more radical centrist ideas and maintenance of the long-established status quo were deemed??

Mississipi71 · 03/08/2022 20:31

AndreaC67 · 03/08/2022 20:25

I believe you ride a bike, you see the state of the roads.

I ve been cycling for many years, over the last 10 years or so, roads have become in many cases, little more than tracks.

Funding to Councils has fallen, in real terms by 40%, we all see the results of that.

Austerity was required for a 4 or 5 years, but not 10.

The Tories had to become big spenders because of CV and now Cost of Living but they hate it, hence, going fwd, Truss wants Austerity 2, tax and budget cuts, even seeking to cut the pay of public sector workers outside of London/SE....

I don't see these public sector cuts in Europe.

WE are in Europe.

AndreaC67 · 03/08/2022 20:25

DdraigGoch · 03/08/2022 19:32

Some cuts were made, but the budget was balanced far slower than Darling planned to.

Some budgets were even increased.

I believe you ride a bike, you see the state of the roads.

I ve been cycling for many years, over the last 10 years or so, roads have become in many cases, little more than tracks.

Funding to Councils has fallen, in real terms by 40%, we all see the results of that.

Austerity was required for a 4 or 5 years, but not 10.

The Tories had to become big spenders because of CV and now Cost of Living but they hate it, hence, going fwd, Truss wants Austerity 2, tax and budget cuts, even seeking to cut the pay of public sector workers outside of London/SE....

I don't see these public sector cuts in Europe.

AndreaC67 · 03/08/2022 20:18

Mississipi71 · 03/08/2022 19:26

Err, I believe this is yet another thread slagging off the Tories. If you don't want comeback, maybe don't pile on.

Ha ha another right winger telling those whose opinions they don't like to shut up.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 03/08/2022 19:53

I think that the thing that everyone forgets is, um, thingy, you know, what's he called? Well him, he did that with, no I mean he DIDN'T do that. But ignoring that for the moment.. Oh, I lost my train of thought now. TRAIN that was it ! STRIKES.