Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel angry at Tory voters?

740 replies

Dottodo · 02/08/2022 00:52

DF has always voted Tory. He’s very anti immigration and we will never see each other’s POV.
DHs friends are all Tory voters and hate being with them as they are all racist, xenophobic & misogynistic.
Other Tory voters I know through work or extended family members are also xenophobic and casually racist.
I’ve spoken to friends about this and they agree that the Tory voters they personally know are also racist and xenophobic.
Why is this?
Me and DH lived abroad and as we've lived as ‘foreigners’, we don’t share their views.

OP posts:
lot123 · 04/08/2022 13:48

I've chatted to a lot of different people from Europe and North America over the last few months. They don't see the U.K. as a crap hole and a joke.

Perhaps we should also celebrate the good parts of living in the U.K, particularly in terms of the opportunities and freedom for women.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 13:46

We need to lose the self-abnegation and loathing,

We really do. It's good to be encouraging a tolerant and diverse society but I think some of the navel gazing and self-hatred has gone too far at times.

We have a lot to offer, both individually and as a society, and I think some positivity might help us pull together to get out of the recession and address some of the wider public issues.

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 13:46

Self loathing? don't see that all

I know some people won’t see it but maybe they’re part of it.

I find it infuriating and I’m not looking at it from U.K. perspective but more from o/s one. I moved here due to attraction of London. Other big cities would have been good too but London has worked out well,

The U.K. has loads going for it - culture, science, arts, development, sports. Admittedly the pandemic shut a lot of what is good down tg it’s back now.

It doesn’t have to be best or world beating all the time just not the level of moaning and U.K. is ‘laughing stock’ rubbish that you generally see on SM

It is possible to enjoy and acknowledge the good stuff without always mooning over EU

Blossomtoes · 04/08/2022 13:39

You forgot “world beating” @AndreaC67 😂

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 13:37

I ve just listened to Ken Clarks assessment on the economy and what needs to be done.
Targeted help, reduce/limit those going into poverty, no tax cuts until inflation dealt with.
Absolutely spot on and what i ve been saying for an age, these views from Clark doesn't make him from the hard left or even left but apparently those who have been saying this on here are "Lefties"

Self loathing? don't see that all but if you want to improve then going around saying "We are the best at X Y or Z" will not improve anything.

This is what we hear far too much off, best football league, best justice system, world leading NHS.... etc etc

One thing we are world leading on is Life Sciences (in conjunction with Europe) but what are we intent on doing? wrecking this sector, silence from most Conservative supporters.

We are not the worst by any means but to improve, one needs to have an element of self awareness and self critic, most importantly, learning from the very best.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 13:37

Lot I appreciate your answer but I recall a post re electric being cheaper which HS2 will be - there’s a poster who knows more Draig I think, apologies if I got this wrong

That's very interesting, I hadn't appreciated the existing Birmingham route wasn't electric. Am I right in thinking the east coast line is?

Is therefore the premise of HS2 that it wouldn't be practical to introduce an electric line while still running it? In other words, too disruptive on current track?

I think the pandemic has caused a fairly fundamental shift in remote working. But there's definite environmental benefits in encouraging train travel.

I really hope they return the Chilterns to something that resembles its previous state. Particularly the town-like complex they've built near Denham. The tree protesters have gone recently so I guess it's full steam ahead.

pointythings · 04/08/2022 13:28

@XingMing I agree. It's going to take a big cultural shift though, starting with our press which seems to thrive financially on stoking division. And that is across the entire political spectrum.

XingMing · 04/08/2022 12:34

MarshaBradyo's comment that we need to lose the self-abnegation and loathing, and simultaneously eschew exceptionalism and jingoism is spot on.

XingMing · 04/08/2022 12:30

Latin America tends to flip-flop. Brazil alternates between Bolsonaro and Lula da Silva, and neither has delivered clean effective government. Venezuela has created a refugee wave all its very own thanks to Chavez squandering oil revenues like the Perons. Mexico is violent and corrupt; ditto Bolivia. Chile and Ecuador are fairly competently run, currently. Argentina should function better than it does given its innate resources. Costa Rica is developing its eco-tourism very thoughtfully with an eye on the long term. Panama is cultivating an image as a good base for retirement, with tax advantages. Dominica functions reasonably; Haiti doesn't. Uruguay and Paraguay I know little about, except that a friend enjoyed Montevideo as a city. Same of the remaining NE Atlantic countries.

The US Latino population is hard to pigeonhole because of its diversity, but a lot of Latin Americans immigrants (especially Cubans in Florida) have been there since the 60s, and are established as the rising forces in politics, business and the law, so far mostly at State level. But as the Latino population dwarfs the African-American, both Republicans and Democrats are courting their votes. I read somewhere that the USA is forecast to be 50:50 by language come 2050.

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 12:01

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 11:28

Although not entirely of course with the war and PFI figures on here seem sky high, but he managed to take the country with him, initially anyway, build it up and not talk it down. The U.K. has a lot going for it and it benefits from that positivity

Blair had the advantage of taking over at a time when the UK was a low ebb, he increased spending and had the world economic cycle on his side, so low inflation, decent growth, high pay rises, relatively low bills (for the majority)
We also saw the end of the IRA (mostly) inward investment, boom in tourism, low cost flights, huge boost in life sciences... We felt good about the future.

Thats not the case now.

Whoever wins the Tory party battle (which is really about who can convince us they ve not been in for the last 12 years) and/or the next GE, has a huge task in front of them, not one i envy.

Blair very much had the global cycle on his side, I did suggest this on another thread and it didn’t go down well. I think the US was benefitting similarly and then of course suffered the crash built in the back if it, as did we.

However we need a way to feel better about the U.K., imo it has suffered from this self loathing narrative over last few years

The party who wins the next GE will be facing a much worse global outlook than Blair did, especially if the war is still going, but taking people with you is still key. And not creating pockets of dislike - eg against tax payers whom we need.

I think Blair did this well - looking at his landslide - he didn’t demonise payers into the tax system but at same time lower earners felt he offered opportunity

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 11:45

most South & Central American countries are far right

That's incorrect, a lot have gone Left now

Presumably migrants who can now vote came to the US long ago?
Wonder why there pop. rejected the far right?

if the US hadn't sanctioned Cuba for decades, they'd be better than they are

It's interesting how some manage to find a way to blame conservative views for every world ailment, but there you go...

Lol so that fact that both Democrat and Republican Govts sanctioned Cuba has zero effect..... best tell that one to the World and sanctions on Russia then.

Its only you that mentions Left Right on this, the reality is it isn't, both parties in the US are right of centre.

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 11:28

Although not entirely of course with the war and PFI figures on here seem sky high, but he managed to take the country with him, initially anyway, build it up and not talk it down. The U.K. has a lot going for it and it benefits from that positivity

Blair had the advantage of taking over at a time when the UK was a low ebb, he increased spending and had the world economic cycle on his side, so low inflation, decent growth, high pay rises, relatively low bills (for the majority)
We also saw the end of the IRA (mostly) inward investment, boom in tourism, low cost flights, huge boost in life sciences... We felt good about the future.

Thats not the case now.

Whoever wins the Tory party battle (which is really about who can convince us they ve not been in for the last 12 years) and/or the next GE, has a huge task in front of them, not one i envy.

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 11:21

most South & Central American countries are far right

That's incorrect, a lot have gone Left now

if the US hadn't sanctioned Cuba for decades, they'd be better than they are

It's interesting how some manage to find a way to blame conservative views for every world ailment, but there you go...

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 10:47

Voters generally are pragmatic hence the parties in the middle doing well at GE

Ideology usually loses voters - eg Corbyn

At this point a party who deals with bread and butter stuff rather than provoking emotional reactions could be good

I think Blair did well with the education, education line - something that appealed to me personally but since then Labour has lost that ability . As seen in last GE.

I don’t know who will win the next one but I’m pretty sure Starmer will go to the centre again. I find his policies head line rather than sensible (charity status for schools for example is going to increase state sector when it’s already strained) and need reassurance in taxing wealth that it will work and isn’t just a way to appeal on same grounds

Blair was good as he did the optimism thing well without the penury to high earners

Although not entirely of course with the war and PFI figures on here seem sky high, but he managed to take the country with him, initially anyway, build it up and not talk it down. The U.K. has a lot going for it and it benefits from that positivity

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 10:44

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 09:38

Which is to say, they saw the actions of the left, the DP, as purposefully maintaining policies that damaged their ability to better themselves

Similar to what happens with some Hispanic communities in the US (e.g. in Florida). They are leaning far(ish) Right as they don't want to see a repeat of the regimes they are escaping from to take over in the US.

Cuba aside, most South & Central American countries are far right & if the US hadn't sanctioned Cuba for decades, they'd be better than they are.

So what your saying simply isn't true.

Plus they (US immigrants) as a bloc vote democrat.

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 10:38

See @XingMing Its as someone said up thread, we are, mostly, reasonable people and want the best for society.... we can come together.

To me, it appears that its our political parties that act on ideology.

The voters, perhaps are are little more pragmatic.

Crikeyalmighty · 04/08/2022 10:31

I'm anti high speed 2 - it's being built for a lifestyle that has now changed for money. There is nothing wrong with the current route and times and far less commuting going on and far more zooms etc than meetings - the money would be better spent on west to east line, Liverpool, Manchester, Leeds, York, Newcastle etc - which at the moment is slow and expensive

Crikeyalmighty · 04/08/2022 10:28

@XingMing I agree with all your post (I'm very much in the centre politically) that's why having lived there I like the Scandinavian way. High wages, high tax but Denmark was remarkably capitalist , however it had great social underpinning for the 'necessities' including childcare, utilities, social rent , transport. How you spent the rest of it was up to you but it was 'non necessities to survive' If you put more effort in , worked longer hours or were a successful entrepreneur, you were still far wealthier than others. Germany is similar as is Netherlands

I personally agree with Germanys policy on health , you do pay in to a scheme (unless unable to do so and that is allowed for and protected) but that is ringfenced money and allows for much better care. We aren't talking US levels of payment, it's at reality level. The problem with funding via NI and general taxation is that tax levels are not high here relative to elsewhere and NI is not ringfenced , money can be used for all sorts and is- so if the country is short of cash it shows and is reflected in healthcare, services, roads etc

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 09:38

Which is to say, they saw the actions of the left, the DP, as purposefully maintaining policies that damaged their ability to better themselves

Similar to what happens with some Hispanic communities in the US (e.g. in Florida). They are leaning far(ish) Right as they don't want to see a repeat of the regimes they are escaping from to take over in the US.

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 09:29

Society needs all kinds of people driving it, including people who take risks and get financial reward. That incentive means we get new developments all the time. It helps employment and generates profits to tax.

Some see that as individualism and inherently bad but I think that would be foolish.

Lot I appreciate your answer but I recall a post re electric being cheaper which HS2 will be - there’s a poster who knows more Draig I think, apologies if I got this wrong

XingMing · 04/08/2022 09:21

@pigeonstreet123 You ask an important question: what IS best for society?

And answers will vary based on the respondee's perspective.

I take @AndreaC67's point that the post-school route to a better life via further education has largely been dismantled, or requires the student to quit work and/or pay fees. Education needs better resources and more money without question, but the massive long-term investment involved has to be treated as a capital expense in the national long-term interest. There must be a better funded route for students to return to education or to learn necessary trade skills. As a SME, we see the dearth of such skills in people under 40, and those who have paid fees / served apprenticeships quite sensibly want to earn and keep the rewards, without sharing them upward.

It's egregious that London schools receive so much more per capita than rural schools, where the issues are different but equally damaging to individual prospects. Leafy suburban comprehensives in the Southeast perform well; nobody in their right mind would turn down a place at Peter Symonds. This is in large part because of more affluent catchments and earnings are closely related to intellect, which is highly heritable. See all the twin studies.

On health, it's starting to dawn on the public that the NHS may not be the correct model for delivering absolutely everything desirable and recognition that the shared public/insurance route used in France, Germany and Australia delivers better outcomes WITHOUT leaving older, poorer, less-healthy people unable to get the care they need. As someone said above, there have been several reasoned threads on the NHS recently.

You can be conservative (small c) and believe that these two in particular are the building blocks of a stable, prosperous democracy. Such views are perfectly compatible with being a decent human being. But it's a delicate and moveable edge between societal and individual responsibility.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 09:06

*shopping

lot123 · 04/08/2022 09:05

I'm not particularly unbiased as the HS2 construction is through our local area. My goodness, it's brutal.

I think the money would have been better spent improving west to east services in the north (I say this as a southerner). There's already a decent service from Marylebone to Birmingham so I'm not sure the reduction in journey time justifies the cost. I'm also not convinced that the London to Birmingham service is a more popular/problematic route than the others.

I've travelled on some European trains this year. Swiss trains are great but not cheap either. Italian trains weren't great for punctuality but were really cheap. Other than one from the airport to the local shipping centre 5 minutes away which cost £10 per ticket.

I enjoy travelling by train but it's bloody expensive. It cost me over £200 for a day return from London to Manchester a few weeks ago. I wonder whether the double decker type trains they have in Europe might expand capacity and help to reduce prices?

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 08:57

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 08:51

Of course it’s going to disrupt the location in which it’s built. But if people keep demanding we have better trains like EU and nuclear like the French it’s not going to magically appear. Time, disruption and money.

Who said otherwise?

Why not incentivise locals with cheaper travel/bills? (i can't win, i support a Tory policy or a former one)

But you ve (as a HS2 supporter) not answered the fundamental point i asked "How does a short section of track costing 110 billion, help congested and expensive commuter lines"

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 08:51

Of course it’s going to disrupt the location in which it’s built. But if people keep demanding we have better trains like EU and nuclear like the French it’s not going to magically appear. Time, disruption and money.