Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel angry at Tory voters?

740 replies

Dottodo · 02/08/2022 00:52

DF has always voted Tory. He’s very anti immigration and we will never see each other’s POV.
DHs friends are all Tory voters and hate being with them as they are all racist, xenophobic & misogynistic.
Other Tory voters I know through work or extended family members are also xenophobic and casually racist.
I’ve spoken to friends about this and they agree that the Tory voters they personally know are also racist and xenophobic.
Why is this?
Me and DH lived abroad and as we've lived as ‘foreigners’, we don’t share their views.

OP posts:
AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 17:46

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 17:03

The government opting for such a hard Brexit when 48% of those who voted wanted to remain is very unfair

But if it had been the other way round I doubt Remainers would have made any concessions to accommodate the concerns Brexiteers have. So maybe think of it that way.

Then that would have been equally wrong, with such a divisive referendum (which should never have happened in the way it did) compromise should have been sought whoever "won" dismissing concerns of millions was unwise.... but remember the saying "Divided and conquer......

I would have liked to see FOM become FOL (Freedom of Labour) with some self funding rules put in for retirees wishing to go abroad

Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 17:46

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 17:09

It’s not going to work to have FOM and EEA as a kind of fudge. It’s that issue that’s the sticking point.

There we’re other moments that I think are more a shame, Cameron for one, not having a higher number for change, and not taking it as advisory - but once all those things were accepted Brexit happened and FOM a key part of it.

I don't know how Cameron sleeps at night. Alec Salmond asked David Lidington as Leader of the House about ensuring safeguards such as a supermajority. 'No, no' bleated Lidington - 'it's not as if anyone is going to act on the result. It's just advisory.' And then bloody, bloody Cameron takes it upon himself to promise the nation to implement the result and not a single MP from any party points out the problem.
And then we discover that if the referendum had been binding, it would have been declared null and void under the Vienna Convention because of the evidence of so much illegality, but because it was advisory there was nothing there that could be done.
I can't just move on from all that, when I think it's done so much harm, and I can't imagine how difficult it must be for people who've lost businesses in consequence.

XingMing · 04/08/2022 17:39

Well the last folk standing around here now are definitely reasonable... why can't the politicians see it? At times like this, while we despair about polarisation, I hope fervently that someone at party HQ is reading along and brings it to all the leaders' attention.

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 17:38

With EEA, FOM is different to the EU's FOM in that they can apply an emergency brake, only once done and it might mean losses in other areas but it was talked about after 2016 "Norway+" ... this is what i understand the position to be with EEA.
Norway seems happy with this arrangement but as the French pointed out, its our labour market i.e very easy to work in the black economy, that makes the UK so attractive.

With around 400k long term unemployed (mostly unskilled) but many more vacancies to be filled, we need something or our economy will never grow.

Pts based system might work but so far hasn't, i mean why pay a fortune to come here but then not be allowed to move/study/travel/work freely in 27 other countries?

Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 17:29

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 17:03

The government opting for such a hard Brexit when 48% of those who voted wanted to remain is very unfair

But if it had been the other way round I doubt Remainers would have made any concessions to accommodate the concerns Brexiteers have. So maybe think of it that way.

Well Farage said that a 52/48 result would definitely be unfinished business and I don't know that there wouldn't have been any concessions if Remain had won. It would have taken someone very diplomatic and gifted to handle it and May certainly wasn't that person. The whole discourse descended so quickly into vitriol and slagging the other side off that positions became far more polarised than they needed to be.
I haven't got the answers about the fudge being unsatisfactory - I can see that if I were a Leaver I probably would think it was BRINO and might feel cheated.
I accept that professions that were undercut by EU workers might now feel that they are better off - that is a good thing, though the same outcome could have been achieved without all the damage.
I can't see how anyone could point to anything that there is for Remainers except for loss and damage. To be berated for minding about those losses and that damage, effectively told to shut up and to emigrate for minding really just rubs salt into the wound.
I agree that some dreadful things have been said to some Leavers and that these have not been deserved.
I have never seen the country so divided and don't know how we move forward. Being able to have reasonable debate here and seeing that we do actually agree on quite a lot helps.

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 17:09

It’s not going to work to have FOM and EEA as a kind of fudge. It’s that issue that’s the sticking point.

There we’re other moments that I think are more a shame, Cameron for one, not having a higher number for change, and not taking it as advisory - but once all those things were accepted Brexit happened and FOM a key part of it.

pointythings · 04/08/2022 17:08

@apintortwo it was pointed out very many times to Brexiters that the issues around not knowing who was in the country/being unable to deport EU nationals who were not working could have been resolved if the UK had bothered. Many EU countries have ID cards and demand local registration in order for someone to receive services from their local council - the systems exist.

But the UK chose to do nothing. I'd have been perfectly happy with the introduction of a simple ID card system (though not the bloated data gobbling monstrosity Labour were proposing!)

I also suspect most Remainers would have been perfectly happy to see a clamp down on companies and organisations who were failing to pay NMW. Workers' rights and all that good stuff.

Which things do you think there would have been no concessions on?

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 17:03

The government opting for such a hard Brexit when 48% of those who voted wanted to remain is very unfair

But if it had been the other way round I doubt Remainers would have made any concessions to accommodate the concerns Brexiteers have. So maybe think of it that way.

Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 16:54

Yes - EEA does include freedom of movement. I agree there wouldn't be much point, but since I struggle to see much of the point anyway, to me that would be so much better. I also think that that would have been the most democratic option for a vote that was so close. The government opting for such a hard Brexit when 48% of those who voted wanted to remain is very unfair. 17.4 million out of 66 million should not have been enough to warrant what we've ended up with.
The points system is all very well, except that actually we need people to come in and take up jobs in roles that might not score well under such a system, but are still hugely valuable.

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 16:47

Labor went in stronger on renewables iirc and moving away from coal etc

Interesting. I wonder how farmers will fare there over these green policies. I've seen they are being very negatively impacted in Canada and the Netherlands

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 16:34

Apin the Labor states had very long lockdowns so I think not related to that

imo it was green policy. Aus has extreme weather events and those fires which highlight the real impact. Labor went in stronger on renewables iirc and moving away from coal etc. People are likely worried about impact on next generation

We are a bit different here, apart from 40 degree day recently it’s not so much on agenda and both parties seem to have similar approach. Cons re-routing through tax breaks and incentives for large companies and building nuclear, it’s not so stark

Mississipi71 · 04/08/2022 16:32

Great to see some reasoned debate in the last few pages of this goady thread. How many times has the OP been back? Imagine starting a thread entitled to be Angry at Labour Voters. No wonder she has not been back.

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 16:19

the way Australia has shifted to left whilst keeping border policy has made me think a bit more

Why do you think Australia has swung to the left? Was it extreme lockdown fatigue?

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 15:49

EEA includes free movement of people doesn’t it?

I don’t think it would be much change or point if it’s largely the same

I don’t know why the points system isn’t used more to our advantage for skills. I admit we are used to it in Aus and it’s part of the national psyche by now as a way to benefit the country;

Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 15:47

I think most people would have accepted an EEA membership, even if it would have seemed a bit pointless. I don't think I'd be thinking about Brexit very much now, if that had been the case.
But Brexit has precisely taken away from us citizenship and passport. Since we are no longer EU citizens we lose all the working/ residence rights that had been ours automatically. My work brings me into contact with people who are often looking for jobs in the EU - and it is so, so much harder for them if they are competing with people who have EU passports, which is often one of the criteria. Why would an EU business want to bother with the extra admin and hassle of employing a Brit who doesn't have an EU passport, when they've got people from 27 other countries without those issues? They don't. The availability of work is much, much smaller.

Crikeyalmighty · 04/08/2022 15:21

To be honest Marsha- I could live perfectly well with EEA type membership, all a bit pointless but hey ho- but I don't think what is effectively a 'no deal at all' relationship is actually benefitting anyone apart from seriously rich and maybe certain low paid in shortage occupation areas and I think that will be short term as I genuinely believe this gvt will bring in 'work for benefits' -

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 14:40

Crikey I do have sympathy for your position, I’m not sure if you mentioned what type of business it is but it is natural that if your income has been impacted you won’t have wanted that.

Inflation is mostly global energy prices and staff shortages are in many other countries. It’s a post pandemic issue whereby lower earners moved on, even Aus has this too.

Denmark is interesting, I don’t know much about it but had gathered it was quite strict on borders too

Lastly I don’t see those as equivalent. I voted remain, was annoyed when we lost but it’s no where near equivalent to anyone stripping me of a citizenship and passport.

But I appreciate impacting someone’s business is tough, I felt the same during pandemic about livelihoods. Where it’ll go in the next couple of decades is up for change, and has made me think beyond fixed remain view (and I was probably the most remain person you could meet, or one of them)

Crikeyalmighty · 04/08/2022 14:23

It's the equivalent @MarshaBradyo to
Me saying- well you can keep the Oz passport--- but your UK one doesn't apply anymore, so next time you come here we will treat you as a 3rd country national and you will need visas to live and work and fit our specific rules on living and working here . We had in effect a European passport pre Brexit -

Crikeyalmighty · 04/08/2022 14:19

@MarshaBradyo it's easier to think good things here if you are ok for money , can eat well and live somewhere nice with a lot going on - I think there are lots of good things about the UK- it's culture and sport and varied scenery for a start- but from a business angle in particular it's really not good. It's causing logistical problems, staff shortages and high inflation(although Ukraine is mixed in with that too)

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 14:13

Most people don't have access to sports facilities, culture & arts, they meaningless to them.

You don’t need to go to the stadium. I watched Wimbledon at home, Euros and World Cup, enjoyed it a lot and posted with others who felt the same.It was a nice break from the mn gloom

Many galleries are free, even outside London. If people have zero interest in arts that’s up to them but people get enjoyment from other things - watching football as a ticket holder or not. I’d say calling that group of things you listed as meaningless is missing a huge amount of what people enjoy.

I do see some posters who only say good things about EU but zero re U.K. it must be exhausting to see little that is good about where you live. Or maybe there are things people like but just don’t post about it - I hope so.

Crikeyalmighty · 04/08/2022 14:08

@MarshaBradyo Just so you know I'm with you on border control- the UK has handled it very badly over the years, there were far more controls available to us that were never used, including within the EU, and it's come back to bite the UK on the arse. we've just come back from living in Denmark and even for EU citizens it's quite strict. You can't just remain indefinitely without registering

The thing is by being in the EU these issues would have become clear to many of the countries, not just the UK , France and Germany , Scandinavia etc and I think certain things and rules would have changed anyway if climate change/resources were becoming an issue.

The thing is you have an option to return to Oz if you wished- many people here now have zero option to go anywhere else - Oz also has 'enhanced preferred country ' within EU, much easier to stay and look for a job -- the UK doesn't have this because we haven't offered it to EU citizens

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 14:04

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 13:46

Self loathing? don't see that all

I know some people won’t see it but maybe they’re part of it.

I find it infuriating and I’m not looking at it from U.K. perspective but more from o/s one. I moved here due to attraction of London. Other big cities would have been good too but London has worked out well,

The U.K. has loads going for it - culture, science, arts, development, sports. Admittedly the pandemic shut a lot of what is good down tg it’s back now.

It doesn’t have to be best or world beating all the time just not the level of moaning and U.K. is ‘laughing stock’ rubbish that you generally see on SM

It is possible to enjoy and acknowledge the good stuff without always mooning over EU

Yet another little dig? You can't help yourself can you.

You are well off, M/C with great access to the many things you mention, you re in London for starters and can afford to attend, where they are not subsidised.

Most people don't have access to sports facilities, culture & arts, they meaningless to them.

As for the UK being an international laughing stock? Not overall by any means but Johnson and Brexit most definitely.

Which is why the Tories have got rid of him and why it won't be long before we will reverse many aspects of Brexit, we will be forced too.

Still no criticism for the lack of Horizon co-op.

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 13:56

Crikeyalmighty · 04/08/2022 13:51

@MarshaBradyo - what nationality are you Marsha? It makes a difference because it's easy to be here as say an American or an Australian and not see what so many Brits have lost in this situation- because those options were not there for you . businesses, business issues, family issues, retiring elsewhere, short term contracts in EU .

If you are from the EU- well you haven't really lost anything at all

Crikey I’m dual Aus / UK

I voted remain and at the time I felt so strongly about staying in, I was that London type remainer whose sector is diverse (so I’d say most were remain) and I was so wedded to that view

But I’ve started to think about climate issues, mass migration and the way Aus deals with its border. I’m wondering what changes we’ll see in the next couple of decades as resources become scarcer, places become more uninhabitable and citizens demand security.

I was so sure re remain but the way Aus has shifted to left whilst keeping border policy has made me think a bit more

Blossomtoes · 04/08/2022 13:53

Have those people actually been here recently? One of my friends recently returned from Germany having lived there for about seven years. She’s absolutely appalled at how down at heel and shabby the UK is now by comparison. My SiL who’s lived in Germany her entire adult life said the same when she was in N Ireland a few weeks ago.

Anecdote is pointless as evidence because everyone’s anecdata is different.

Crikeyalmighty · 04/08/2022 13:51

@MarshaBradyo - what nationality are you Marsha? It makes a difference because it's easy to be here as say an American or an Australian and not see what so many Brits have lost in this situation- because those options were not there for you . businesses, business issues, family issues, retiring elsewhere, short term contracts in EU .

If you are from the EU- well you haven't really lost anything at all