Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel angry at Tory voters?

740 replies

Dottodo · 02/08/2022 00:52

DF has always voted Tory. He’s very anti immigration and we will never see each other’s POV.
DHs friends are all Tory voters and hate being with them as they are all racist, xenophobic & misogynistic.
Other Tory voters I know through work or extended family members are also xenophobic and casually racist.
I’ve spoken to friends about this and they agree that the Tory voters they personally know are also racist and xenophobic.
Why is this?
Me and DH lived abroad and as we've lived as ‘foreigners’, we don’t share their views.

OP posts:
XingMing · 04/08/2022 21:46

That said, I still think the EU is too large and too disparate to reconcile all the tensions. North to south and east to west tensions/differences are going to be painful. I thought in 2016 and still think that northern and southern Europe are not going to reach close enough accommodations to satisfy the apolitical majorities.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 21:45

(I compromised and volunteered for a year in a school in Chicago for underprivileged children. Even Conservative voters can have a sense of public service...).

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 04/08/2022 21:44

YABU. I know plenty of Tory voters who aren’t racist and plenty of labour voters who are.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 21:42

why should young people settle for something that's less good than what their parents had?

Speaking only from my university experience, it's far better than I had. There was hardly any opportunities for a year abroad when I did my degree.

In fact, I recall thinking about turning down my offer for one of the more competitive RG universities for a fairly mediocre university that offered a year in the US as part of their course.

XingMing · 04/08/2022 21:38

No, I agree we definitely didn't need the hardest possible version. I voted leave, just, but it never occurred to me that it would be treated as a suicide note.

pointythings · 04/08/2022 21:29

@XingMing I do wonder how much of the UK's lack of benefit from EU membership has been about Conservative reluctance to accept anything with the EU branding on it. I still remember the winter floods when Cameron was in power - the EU offered flood relief money, the Tories turned it down. Toxic nationalism seems to be the bullet they have consistently used to shoot themselves in the foot.
We didn't need to have our current extreme hard Brexit. Westminster did that to us.

XingMing · 04/08/2022 21:22

I do own, and lament, what was thrown away. But I also feel that we dodged a bullet not joining the euro, and I still (instinctively) feel the EU is too big and divergent to operate effectively as a unit. As a slippy free trade zone, with freedom of labour and capital, and aligned (not necessarily exactly) trading standards (nothing dangerous, but upper and lower range limits) it should have been possible to provide a full conformance certification at a premium price, and a working towards certification accreditation.

I think it is interesting, hopefully informative, anecdata to say that the road network now in northern Spain, where we've holidayed recently, is fabulous (much improved since I last visited in 1992) and to say that a lot of EU funds have made this possible. I have not seen anything similar in the UK's infrastructure, despite the UK being the EU's second largest contributor while we were members.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 21:02

You won't get double-deck trains on existing lines in the UK. They won't fit.

I was wondering that, is it track width or height? They don't seem that much higher, they have a kind of mezzanine structure.

pointythings · 04/08/2022 21:01

@lot123 but why should young people settle for something that's less good than what their parents had? Why shouldn't they be angry that it was thrown away? It's pathetic to say 'well, you can have this, it'll have to be good enough because in the good old days we walked to school in all weathers, uphill both ways...'

Brexit has cost the UK many many good things and I just wish Brexiters would won that.

DdraigGoch · 04/08/2022 20:54

lot123 · 04/08/2022 09:05

I'm not particularly unbiased as the HS2 construction is through our local area. My goodness, it's brutal.

I think the money would have been better spent improving west to east services in the north (I say this as a southerner). There's already a decent service from Marylebone to Birmingham so I'm not sure the reduction in journey time justifies the cost. I'm also not convinced that the London to Birmingham service is a more popular/problematic route than the others.

I've travelled on some European trains this year. Swiss trains are great but not cheap either. Italian trains weren't great for punctuality but were really cheap. Other than one from the airport to the local shipping centre 5 minutes away which cost £10 per ticket.

I enjoy travelling by train but it's bloody expensive. It cost me over £200 for a day return from London to Manchester a few weeks ago. I wonder whether the double decker type trains they have in Europe might expand capacity and help to reduce prices?

You won't get double-deck trains on existing lines in the UK. They won't fit.

They'll fit on HS2 though...

Take a look on Google Street View at HS1. When that was under construction it would have been the same. Now though, everything has settled in and the cuttings/embankments have grassed over.

XingMing · 04/08/2022 20:53

The rail journey across the Pennines is tortuous. Thanks very much for your crisp debrief @DdraigGoch . That's the clearest explanation I've heard, and goes a long way to justifying the spend, and I have two friends (techies though) who have not explained the upsides so coherently.

XingMing · 04/08/2022 20:44

I've just wondered whether I needed to give myself a reality check in thinking that it ought to be normal for a young person to spend a period living, working, and studying overseas. Obviously DS is at an advantage in that the idea can even be contemplated without winning a major scholarship. (one child, ancient parents)

Rough and ready poll, if you are willing to say, how many of the people still on this thread have
a) moved abroad for longer than six months
b) moved more than 250 miles from home in the UK for work, or love, or education, or just a change
c) live within 20 miles of where they were born.

I bet everyone has taken the skid.

DdraigGoch · 04/08/2022 20:40

AndreaC67 · 04/08/2022 08:57

Who said otherwise?

Why not incentivise locals with cheaper travel/bills? (i can't win, i support a Tory policy or a former one)

But you ve (as a HS2 supporter) not answered the fundamental point i asked "How does a short section of track costing 110 billion, help congested and expensive commuter lines"

  1. London to Manchester might be shorter than Paris to Lyon but that's not an argument for not building the line, that's an argument for extending it north of Wigan. However it does shrink journey times between London and Scotland which is a long distance and the journey times between London and Edinburgh/Glasgow will drop below four hours which is considered to be a key threshold for modal shift from airlines. Look at the effect Eurostar had upon aviation. www.oag.com/blog/high-speed-rail-vs-air-eurostar-at-25-the-story-so-far

As for commuter lines, you realise that the WCML between London, Birmingham and Scotland is one? Moving the intercity services from the WCML to HS2 will provide plenty of extra paths for both stopping services and freight.

In any case, hasn't Transport for London just seen a massive investment in the form of Crossrail? Given that commuter markets haven't yet recovered from the pandemic (unlike long-distance and leisure travel which is booming) I think that the South East has had enough for the time being. The commuter lines aren't actually that congested at the moment, whereas the long-distance mainlines are full.

The government is also looking at improving connections across the North, using a new line crossing the Pennines. The main line nearest me is receiving investment, likewise the Cornish Main Line has had improvements to increase frequencies and resilience. The South Wales Valleys are getting electrified, as is much of Scotland. HS2 is not the only bit of the railway to get some capital investment.

As for the price tag, I'd like to know where you got your figure. The latest estimate is between £72bn and £98bn at 2019 prices (though construction projects are all inflating at the moment). Some people are claiming that the Oakervee review put a figure of £106bn but they have (wilfully) misread the report.

Not that it's a Tory project anyway, it was launched under the Brown government and has cross-party support.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 20:35

now you sound like an old codger whinging about why people need all those TV channels because back in the good old days they made do with BBC 1 and 2.

Thank you (I have a sense of humour). I'll stand by my point though, I used those two countries as examples, there were lots of different counties offering degree exchanges.

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 20:31

lot123 · 04/08/2022 18:58

If you apply to go to Australia for instance, that country should be enough, and the same happens for the UK. Why should it be essential to have access to 27 additional countries?

I agree. There's also some good international exchange programmes between the U.K. and overseas universities. I'd love to have spent a year of my degree in the US or Aus.

I did this US for a year. Brilliant as I didn’t pay US fees at all, just a swap

You can still have great schemes

XingMing · 04/08/2022 20:29

DS is currently intermitting a break from university but is investigating doing the final year of his degree overseas, provided everything else works. Probably in NZ, if his academic points can be transferred. Not a linguist, so it needs to be Anglophone. A good school in the US costs eye-watering amounts if it's funded by UK earned income. All these broadening experiences should be encouraged.

The loss of Erasmus and the close down in scientific exchanges is much lamented. It impoverishes the whole eco-system.

pointythings · 04/08/2022 20:19

@lot123 now you sound like an old codger whinging about why people need all those TV channels because back in the good old days they made do with BBC 1 and 2. It isn't the point that Australia or the US ought to be 'enough' - it's that something good that offered opportunities has been thrown away and that many of today's young people who are affected didn't get a say in that.

Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 20:18

I value the freedom of movement across the EU, not least because it offers people the opportunity to learn new languages while working at the same time. Just going to the US or Aus is less diverse, I think. But the two options needn’t be mutually exclusive. They never used to be.

pointythings · 04/08/2022 20:17

@AndreaC67 FOM always was FOL!

@apintortwo the Dutch farming industry is one of the highest producers of pollutants in the EU. There needs to be drastic change. I'm Dutch (living in the UK), but I refuse to buy Dutch meat because of the low (EU minimum) welfare standards applied - the intensive farming methods used are incredibly bad for the environment. We can argue about the methods, but those farmers need to make changes for the sake of the planet and so far they have been completely recalcitrant. I'm with the EU on this one. We need to rear higher welfare meat and eat a hell of a lot less of it.

And give over with the 'Unelected' bullshit. That's Brexiter nonsense - you know full well that the people who design the policies are civil servants - and UK civil servants are also not elected - and that the politicians who decide which policies to implement are elected - by PR no less, which is arguably more democratic than the UK's FPTP system.

lot123 · 04/08/2022 18:58

If you apply to go to Australia for instance, that country should be enough, and the same happens for the UK. Why should it be essential to have access to 27 additional countries?

I agree. There's also some good international exchange programmes between the U.K. and overseas universities. I'd love to have spent a year of my degree in the US or Aus.

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 18:44

pointythings

Would you care to share your views on the recent Dutch farmers' protests?

A national government being forced to disadvantage and impoverish their own people in order to appease and comply with a requirement from an unelected central body is exactly what many Brexit voters wanted to avoid. I'm sure the issue is complex over there but it can give you some perspective

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-62335287

In May 2019, the Council of State ruled the government's strategy for reducing excess nitrogen breached EU directives on preserving vulnerable habitats

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 18:23

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 18:16

i mean why pay a fortune to come here but then not be allowed to move/study/travel/work freely in 27 other countries?

If you apply to go to Australia for instance, that country should be enough, and the same happens for the UK. Why should it be essential to have access to 27 additional countries?

Agree. The U.K. is attractive enough and you can still holiday in EU. People move to big cities like London or elsewhere due to a variety of reasons.

I know people are really down on U.K. but as someone who did it I know it’s not as much an issue people think. So many of my peers moved too. We didn’t choose France or wherever but thought London better. Then again Aus aren’t great at languages generally

We are meant to have visas coming in for top university graduates which would be excellent. Nothing like the excitement of trying to make it in a big city when young.

Points system can be really useful for skills but I’m not sure where that’s at.

Plus I see a lot of criticism re productivity so presumably same people would like higher automation and skilled economy

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 18:16

i mean why pay a fortune to come here but then not be allowed to move/study/travel/work freely in 27 other countries?

If you apply to go to Australia for instance, that country should be enough, and the same happens for the UK. Why should it be essential to have access to 27 additional countries?

XingMing · 04/08/2022 17:56

Sorry but there are two Andrea's here. Confuses me, as I'm a bear with a small brain!

XingMing · 04/08/2022 17:54

And I completely agree with @AndreaC74 (?) about the appalling treatment of the sciences right now too. Another shot in our foot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread