Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel angry at Tory voters?

740 replies

Dottodo · 02/08/2022 00:52

DF has always voted Tory. He’s very anti immigration and we will never see each other’s POV.
DHs friends are all Tory voters and hate being with them as they are all racist, xenophobic & misogynistic.
Other Tory voters I know through work or extended family members are also xenophobic and casually racist.
I’ve spoken to friends about this and they agree that the Tory voters they personally know are also racist and xenophobic.
Why is this?
Me and DH lived abroad and as we've lived as ‘foreigners’, we don’t share their views.

OP posts:
AndreaC74 · 05/08/2022 08:26

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 23:23

The simple fact is, that being in the EU did not benefit enough people in the UK. It benefitted the wealthy at the expense of the less wealthy, and the highly educated at the expense of the less educated. Which is why Brexit won.

Indeed

Yet when posters point out that Brexit was voted for by the poor and less well educated, they are lambasted.

Interesting that Truss was a keen remainer but is now a ardent leaver, highly unusually in RL.

Wonder if she'll change back.

apintortwo · 05/08/2022 08:18

i don’t buy the argument about how it’s not part of our DNA to belong. It worked pretty well for the best part of forty years until the EU wanted to clamp down on tax havens. The following week 100 Tory MPs wrote to Cameron to demand action and here we are

But that's the thing, isn't it. These imposed central rules by unelected representatives seem to work, until they no longer do.

See my example about Dutch farmers above. There's always a tipping point when a national government is forced to take a measure that will disadvantage its own for 'the grater good'. These measures are usually imposed by global lobby groups with their own financial motives -climate change, a move to full cashless, etc. It could be anything really.

lot123 · 05/08/2022 07:59

Sorry, just realised I've made an unfortunate misspelling of your username. Apologies.

lot123 · 05/08/2022 07:22

Dedraigcoch I thought my father's train knowledge was unbeatable. He wore his Navy uniform to blag his way into various train sheds in his 20s. Apparently Crewe was the mecca but Cricklewood sheds had some rare trains.

Anyway, you win. That's some detailed train expertise! I know capacity is for existing demand but I wonder if it's chicken and egg to the extent that expanding capacity reduces prices and is therefore utilised.

DdraigGoch · 05/08/2022 01:25

lot123 · 04/08/2022 21:02

You won't get double-deck trains on existing lines in the UK. They won't fit.

I was wondering that, is it track width or height? They don't seem that much higher, they have a kind of mezzanine structure.

Height mostly. There's not actually that much difference - only a foot between UK rolling stock and a TGV Duplex but if you're going to collide with a bridge, the result is the same whether it's a foot or a yard. Ceilings on TGV Duplexes are pretty tight so knock six inches off of each floor and I'll just be glad not to be 6 feet tall. They did try double decked trains in the UK but it was absurdly cramped.

UK railways were the first in the world and were built to fit the small steam locomotives of the day. Therefore Network Rail limits the height of rolling stock to 13'1". European loading gauges were agreed at a minimum of 14'1" in 1913 and France had to do a lot of work to improve its infrastructure to match the standards set by the Kaiserreich, but labour was cheap then. The UK wasn't party to the Berne Convention - it had no need to be as apart from a handful of vehicles that used the ferries, nothing from the continent would ever enter the UK until the Channel Tunnel was built in 1994.

Could we improve the loading gauge of our existing lines? In short it would cost a fortune. In order to install electric wires on the Great Western Main Line, Network Rail has spent a considerable sum of money raising bridges and lowering tunnels in order to fit electric wires in and maintain the 13'1" clearance (bear in mind that you have to keep the wires a safe distance from both structures and the roof of the train otherwise it'll arc). The UK is a very crowded country so you've got more bridges to do.

Any engineering work done has to fit around existing traffic. Everyone hates replacement buses, imagine having the things every weekend until further notice. In 1998 Railtrack started the West Coast Main Line Route Modernisation. After many overruns the project was finally finished (after being descoped) in 2009. The cost had gone from £2.5bn to £14.5bn in four years (2002 prices), driving Railtrack into liquidation as it went. That was for a project that yielded a fraction of the capacity that HS2 offers.

Adding extra lines to the existing route won't work either. The WCML wiggles it's way through the country, having to avoid the country estates of influential 1837 landowners. Development has been built right up to the route, so you'd still have to demolish loads of houses. You'd still have to rebuild Euston and demolish the same amount of Camden to accommodate it.

Just to illustrate how much capacity the project gains, there will be room for 13,300 commuters and 21,600 long-distance travellers out of Euston per hour. That compares with 5,500 commuters and 5,800 long-distance travellers now. It also releases some capacity out of St Pancras and King's Cross. You'd need to build two motorways to shift that number of people (just think what sort of land take that would be).

Midnightblack · 05/08/2022 00:39

I’ve read a few articles about it where Cameron claimed he’’d rather manage it himself which, of course, meant that the food banks didn’t get the money. It’s a bit like Cornwall being promised that Westminster would give them the same level of funding as there was from the EU until the gvnmt turned round and said ‘oh, sorry, no.’ It’s one of the poorest regions of Northern Europe let alone the UK.
i don’t buy the argumenypt about how it’s not part of our DNA to belong. It worked pretty well for the best part of forty years until the EU wanted to clamp down on tax havens. The following week 100 Tory MPs wrote to Cameron to demand action and here we are.
it would be much easier to move on and embrace the benefits if somebody could identify them.

apintortwo · 05/08/2022 00:17

It’s not so long since they turned down millions of pounds worth of aid for food banks from the EU.

Do you know the ins and outs of why funding could have been turned down? Same with roads and infrastructure, it's a bit naïve to believe that billions were up for grabs and we just said 'no thanks' (whilst being major contributors).

Anyway, the main concern for a lot of voters was FOM, and sovereignty. The drawbacks of being in the EU of those two elements were tangible for most people in one way or another. And people voted accordingly.

Maybe as a nation we culturally cannot function effectively as part of a wider union. It's not in our DNA. We need to be in control. Why not move on and build on the opportunities that this new era will bring along?

Midnightblack · 05/08/2022 00:06

Turning down EU help.

To feel angry at Tory voters?
Midnightblack · 05/08/2022 00:01

I don’t blame them for voting Brexit. I blame those who conned them.

Midnightblack · 05/08/2022 00:01

I fear we are going to see that being in the EU did help them, as they will be bearing the costs of leaving along with everyone else, but less able to do so. The government was told time and time again that leaving would hurt the poorest hardest and first.
The Tories have done a great job of deflecting their culpability onto the EU. It’s not so long since they turned down millions of pounds worth of aid for food banks from the EU.

Florenz · 04/08/2022 23:48

i don't know if Brexit will help the less well off at least educated. But being in the EU didn't help them either. So you can hardly blame them for rolling the dice and voting Brexit.

Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 23:39

This is the Tory government’s own report summary on how a hard Brexit would affect the nation. It’s simply not true that Brexit is helping the less well off and better educated. It suits the likes of Jacob Rees-Mogg that you should think so though - Brexit means he can continue not to pay full tax on his vast wealth. Tory party and its donors have done v v well. Ordinary people not so much.

To feel angry at Tory voters?
Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 23:30

Most people didn’t give much thought to the EU before 2015, which is a sign of it working reasonably well. There was some minor irritations, most of which was fake news generated by one B Johnson, but for the most part people just got on with their lives. But the Vote Leave lot ran an extremely slick and clever campaign persuading people that the country’s woes were the fault of the EU rather than the Tory government. You should see the video they produced showing the NHS treatment we’d all be getting if Leave won. It wasn’t showing the elderly on trolleys for three days and lines of ambulances backed up outside hospitals, that’s for sure.

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 23:26

Political analysits are already discussing how the 'left' has been overtaken by a typical right wing neoliberal ideology, the fact that MN was full on fan girling for Corbyn who was a life long Eurosceptic and think that a left wing position is to support the neolib ideal is people who are just tribal, you can see it with how the 'working class who's parents where down the mines' scoff at the red wall that went con.

There's certainly a lot of confusion nowadays from all sides.

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 23:23

The simple fact is, that being in the EU did not benefit enough people in the UK. It benefitted the wealthy at the expense of the less wealthy, and the highly educated at the expense of the less educated. Which is why Brexit won.

Indeed

Florenz · 04/08/2022 23:21

If there were clear and obvious benefits of being in the EU to all British people, the Vote Leave campaign wouldn't have worked.

Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 23:16

The simple fact is that the Vote Leave campaign persuaded people that being in the EU didn’t benefit them. It benefitted many far more than they realised and we are beginning to see the consequences now.
it isn’t just a year abroad that people are talking about. It’s the ability to live and travel freely and far more people took advantage of that. Loads of people did. Remember Auf Wiedersehen Pet? But even if that weren’t the case the year abroad would still be a significant loss to some people, so why shouldn’t they talk about it? Why should people ‘get a grip’ and just shut up if something they believe in has gone for no apparent good reason?
Things like Erasmus greatly enriched home universities as well. It is really beneficial to have the presence and perspective of Erasmus students associating with home students in classes.

Florenz · 04/08/2022 23:08

I think all the people going on about lack of students being able to study for a year abroad need to get a grip. Less than half of all UK kids even go to university in the first place, and only a small fraction of those that do have ever studied abroad for a year.

The simple fact is, that being in the EU did not benefit enough people in the UK. It benefitted the wealthy at the expense of the less wealthy, and the highly educated at the expense of the less educated. Which is why Brexit won.

Blossomtoes · 04/08/2022 22:58

MN was full on fan girling for Corbyn who was a life long Eurosceptic

You were on a different MN to me. It was - and to a degree still is - “Yeah but Corbyn”.

Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 22:44

I do think it’s worth remembering that the likes of Johnson and Farage have done their very best to stoke division, as has much of the media. I remember when Farage was roaring about ‘they said you don’t know what you were voting for. They think you’re all stupid’, when actually nobody had said anything about being stupid. Caroline Lucas was on QT explaining that even she, a politician, didn’t have all the ramifications of the EU at her fingertips and that it wasn’t a slur to say people couldn’t have known about all the consequences. She was shouted down. But it was ludicrous to expect that detailed knowledge from the public. Nobody knew. Not Leavers nor Remainers. The likes of Farage are desperate for division.

Justanotherlurker · 04/08/2022 22:05

The conservative voters I know are not racist in the slightest, they have been called racist slurs by those vocal social media types as being race traitors though, which is kind of ironic.

What has been lost in the age of social media is nuance grey area of politics/policies, people used to scoff at the idea of slippery slope argument but you can see it at play in many different arears, mn has been posting echoes of '1930's' germany for over 12 years.

I want Labour to win the next election so that they can deal with the last 'not true labour' gov PFI hitting it's peak and highlighting the simplistic solution of 'underfunding' the NHS argument.

Political analysits are already discussing how the 'left' has been overtaken by a typical right wing neoliberal ideology, the fact that MN was full on fan girling for Corbyn who was a life long Eurosceptic and think that a left wing position is to support the neolib ideal is people who are just tribal, you can see it with how the 'working class who's parents where down the mines' scoff at the red wall that went con.

GrowlingManchego · 04/08/2022 21:56

Cornwall had around £500 million from the EU for infrastructure if I’m remembering correctly, to give an example. And substantial amounts of EU money went into science and technical innovation projects that created good quality jobs. And there were smaller pots of money for all kinds of things. It was all there for the taking but aside from some specialised industries, little effort was made by the UK administration to signpost our businesses and institutions to these opportunities.

DdraigGoch · 04/08/2022 21:54

MarshaBradyo · 04/08/2022 15:49

EEA includes free movement of people doesn’t it?

I don’t think it would be much change or point if it’s largely the same

I don’t know why the points system isn’t used more to our advantage for skills. I admit we are used to it in Aus and it’s part of the national psyche by now as a way to benefit the country;

EFTA would have included the four freedoms, but would have kept us out of the ECJ, CAP, CFP etc. It would also hare allowed us to pick and choose which regulations we actually want to apply - Norway has only adopted a sixth of them into law.

XingMing · 04/08/2022 21:53

We all presume a brighter future for our kids, but seriously, I am not sure that this is anything we should presume. I think (my child is a young adult) that we should be telling them not to assume the future is better. It will be different for sure.

Midnightblack · 04/08/2022 21:47

lot123 · 04/08/2022 21:42

why should young people settle for something that's less good than what their parents had?

Speaking only from my university experience, it's far better than I had. There was hardly any opportunities for a year abroad when I did my degree.

In fact, I recall thinking about turning down my offer for one of the more competitive RG universities for a fairly mediocre university that offered a year in the US as part of their course.

But it’s a lot less good than it was three years ago and there’s no good reason for that.