Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think PTS is not the worse thing that can happen to an animal.

37 replies

Arashi · 01/08/2022 19:20

I breed dogs and have done for 20 years. In that time I've had 8 litters (including one now). I always keep a puppy, I am licenced, extensively health test, vet the homes, offer life time back up including offer free puppy training classes for my pups and lifetime "issue" support (I'm a qualified behaviourist). I have a waiting list and most people are on it an average of 18 months. I keep mine until they die of old age not replace them when their breeding days are done. They are part of the family and I love them all dearly.

I also am loosely involved in the breed specific rescue in that I offer my behaviour assessments free, have fostered on occasion, and provide transport around the country.

There is a woman, let's call her Susan, who I know vaguely from the agility circuit. She has a tendency to buy herself a large breed working dog, clearly not train it or invest time in it and then by the time it's 2/3 years old and large and unruly (and occasionally aggressive) she gets rid and gets another puppy and the circle starts again. Each time she swears she's train it better. She currently has an imported German Shepherd. The pup is 13 months and is extremely fear reactive. She is unpredictable, reacts to both dogs and people and honestly is a serious accident waiting to happen. She has bitten Susan (stiches required) who now wants to rehome her

I have been asked by the organiser of the agility group - Jane - if I could take the dog. As I have pups on the ground I said I could but not for another 6 weeks when they have gone as I just won't have the time right now. I provided a couple of rescues I thought might be able to help quicker but there is some concern about her worsening in a kennel environment and finding a suitable Foster home isn't easy. Susan doesn't want to wait and is proposing to PTS. Jane has rung me in a panic saying that if the dog is due to be PTS on Friday and I need to help. I've explained I can't and the reasons and as part of the conversation I said the exact words "PTS is not the worse thing that could happen to that dog"

Jane has gone ballistic and I mean ballistic. She has "reported" me to the charities I work with as unsuitable to work in rescue as I believe it's OK to kill animals. Is saying I clearly just want to kill them to make way for people to buy my puppies. And has banned me from the agility group.

It all seems a bit overdramatic but surely it is not that "controversial" of an opinion?

OP posts:
Whitney168 · 01/08/2022 20:23

I’m another who thinks that if Jane is so upset at the prospect, she should put her own money where her mouth is and take the dog on herself. I also wouldn’t be bringing a dog like that into a household with my own dogs.

The sad truth is that there are many Susans out there, and many rescues passing real problem dogs on to owners. I am a firm believer that dog ownership should actually be a pleasure once you’ve put an appropriate amount of work in, and some of these dogs would be far better PTS and let people re-home dogs they have a decent chance of actually enjoying - very sad, and I am glad I’m not the one having to make the decisions.

GuyFawkesDay · 01/08/2022 20:22

Jane needs to take the dog.

I agree entirely, it's our responsibility as decent owners to do what's right for the dog. Having to make those PTS calls is the last thing we can do for beloved pets, and one of the hardest for us.

I've seen it with horses too, horses bought by owners who aren't experienced enough, then passed on because owner can't/won't work with the horse and then buying a new one that's equally not suited to them.

MarsupiIami · 01/08/2022 20:17

This says more about Jane than you. Why can’t she take the dog? Her plan seems incredibly reckless. At least you know where you stand with her now.

Ludo19 · 01/08/2022 20:04

I don't think you're a callous bitch, I think you're a realist and a fab breeder....wish there were more like you.
Regardless if Susan donates generously to a given cause she obviously is clueless about what it takes to have a dog of say a particular breed!
Jane well Jane is a complete tool. I work in the veterinary field, I agree with you entirely. Some animals that are put into shelters meet the same fate for less issues than what Susan's dog has at present so Jane needs to get her head out of her arse. If she's so concerned she should take the dog!

Arashi · 01/08/2022 19:43

Ahh well Susan is independently wealthy and contributes generously to all things group related. To be fair she is a lovely person excluding the animal thing and I think that's more that she just views them as possessions like a bag and when it's not great she moves on. Words have been had with her but she's quite urmmm ..rigid (?) confident (?) in her opinions and eont be swayed. This is the 5th dog I've seen her with and I think it's around 8/9 years I've known her. I've told her she'd be better buying an older dog that's been trained and pay for some lessons but she loves the puppy phase.

Jane is not usually this reactive (lol) but she is strongly rescue focused and there have been small digs about breeding in the past but I just didn't expect this level of well anger at what I think is a perfectly reasonable opinion.

I've been lucky in that the rescues I've worked with haven't been particularly neglected physically but that's not to say I haven't seen or heard the stories and I know a dog like this in the wrong hands or wrong environment is a disaster. Shes about 35kg now so she's not a small fluffy pile of cuteness. She's a ball of angry scared muscle.

Tbf I suppose its not a AIBU because even if you were all yes you are I'd be no I'm not (the worse kind of poster) but I just genuinely don't get where this idea of alive at all costs comes from. I don't get it with people either. Maybe I am just a callous bitch Grin

OP posts:
Sapphirensteel · 01/08/2022 19:42

Susan should be banned from keeping animals.
Jane should think before she speaks.
if the dog is dangerously reactive it’s not a happy dog and who on earth would take it on unless for Police or security work ( if that is at all possible)
Its a very sad situation, I’m a dog lover but you can’t leave a potentially dangerous dog to be adopted when it won’t know anything the vet is doing.

doodlywoodlydingdong · 01/08/2022 19:37

My dad always taught us that owning any animal was an immense privilege. It was our duty to make sure they don't suffer. For me that means putting to sleep at the correct time. I would never ever do it on a whim, or for minor issues though. I've got a rescue that has horrific issues, will likely never be fully house trained , can't seem to over come hey issues from human caused trauma etc. I love her and tolerate her behaviour. But if anything happened that meant I couldn't care for her any longer, she would be pts as a kindness. She couldn't handle another round of homes.

I often see a friend of my family that runs working dogs. At the end of their work life, they often don't understand why they aren't going to work anymore. They struggle to transition. Some of those dogs have had to be pts as a kindness. But the work they do is vital and they are much loved. Its a kindness to the dog.

I agree with you fully.

BitterAndOnlySlightlyTwisted · 01/08/2022 19:28

You’re a lot more reasonable than me. I would decline to foster a dog that’s people and dog reactive when I’ve got my own dogs in the house. Too risky.

You know why this cow is making trouble for you, it’s because she has a great plan in her mind and you’re not co-operating.

An off-the-cuff remark is no reason to try and destroy your reputation. This woman is a lunatic

QuestionableMouse · 01/08/2022 19:27

I agree. I've seen horses that are horribly lame, kept going on drugs because the owner "loves them too much to let them go".

A peaceful death is a blessing that not enough animals get.

CactusBlossom · 01/08/2022 19:27

You are not being unreasonable as abuse of an animal is far worse.
It's Susan that Jane should be going ballistic with. How can she keep taking on dogs then "replacing" them because she can't handle them? Susan needs to be reported. Why can't Jane take on the puppy? I think Susan needs to be stopped from having a healthy dog put to sleep when you know that she will get another puppy shortly afterwards. She should be banned from keeping dogs if she can't look after them properly. The dogs should not suffer because of her lack of knowledge.

NoSquirrels · 01/08/2022 19:27

You sound great.

Susan sounds like she should be banned from owning any dog at all. If anyone is getting banned from agility it should be Susan.

Jane sounds like a familiar type.

Fwiw, I agree with you 100%. But plenty of people who work in dog rescue think like Jane.

CalistoNoSolo · 01/08/2022 19:24

I agree with you, though I think such a young animal should very given a second chance if at all possible. Susan is clearly an irresponsible fuckwit. Jane's energy would very better spent on convincing Susan not to get another dog. Has nobody told her she's a twat?