Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think PTS is not the worse thing that can happen to an animal.

37 replies

Arashi · 01/08/2022 19:20

I breed dogs and have done for 20 years. In that time I've had 8 litters (including one now). I always keep a puppy, I am licenced, extensively health test, vet the homes, offer life time back up including offer free puppy training classes for my pups and lifetime "issue" support (I'm a qualified behaviourist). I have a waiting list and most people are on it an average of 18 months. I keep mine until they die of old age not replace them when their breeding days are done. They are part of the family and I love them all dearly.

I also am loosely involved in the breed specific rescue in that I offer my behaviour assessments free, have fostered on occasion, and provide transport around the country.

There is a woman, let's call her Susan, who I know vaguely from the agility circuit. She has a tendency to buy herself a large breed working dog, clearly not train it or invest time in it and then by the time it's 2/3 years old and large and unruly (and occasionally aggressive) she gets rid and gets another puppy and the circle starts again. Each time she swears she's train it better. She currently has an imported German Shepherd. The pup is 13 months and is extremely fear reactive. She is unpredictable, reacts to both dogs and people and honestly is a serious accident waiting to happen. She has bitten Susan (stiches required) who now wants to rehome her

I have been asked by the organiser of the agility group - Jane - if I could take the dog. As I have pups on the ground I said I could but not for another 6 weeks when they have gone as I just won't have the time right now. I provided a couple of rescues I thought might be able to help quicker but there is some concern about her worsening in a kennel environment and finding a suitable Foster home isn't easy. Susan doesn't want to wait and is proposing to PTS. Jane has rung me in a panic saying that if the dog is due to be PTS on Friday and I need to help. I've explained I can't and the reasons and as part of the conversation I said the exact words "PTS is not the worse thing that could happen to that dog"

Jane has gone ballistic and I mean ballistic. She has "reported" me to the charities I work with as unsuitable to work in rescue as I believe it's OK to kill animals. Is saying I clearly just want to kill them to make way for people to buy my puppies. And has banned me from the agility group.

It all seems a bit overdramatic but surely it is not that "controversial" of an opinion?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SarahSissions · 02/08/2022 17:16

Whilst I agree the PTS isn’t the worst thing that can happen. I do think there is a real difference with people buying dogs that are too much, not training properly and then killing the animal to deal with a problem that has caused directly by their negligence.

Motherofalittledragon · 02/08/2022 12:27

If Jane is so upset and outraged she should step up and take the dog, an animal being put to sleep is definitely not the worst thing that could happen to them.

Jalisco · 02/08/2022 08:07

I have a solution. Jane should adopt it. Susan should be banned from keeping any animal.

You are actually being beyond reasonable because I have some concerns about you adopting the dog. You sound like a really nice person and I think it was generous and kind to offer / get talked into it. A dog that is 14 months old can be retrained - but it is far from easy and best done by someone whose total focus is on the one dog. I know someone who kindly did the same thing for an 8 month old neglected lockdown Rottie. Except he had no skills (unlike you) and the dog has now lost him all his friends, ruined his other dogs life, bitten him too many times to think and attacked other dogs in the local area. And he still won't do the right thing for the dog and everyone else.

So no, PTS is the kindest thing if the dog can't be suitably and reasonably rehomed, and Jane is an idiot.

NetWithHoles · 02/08/2022 07:39

I couldn't agree more. I often feel guilty looking through rescue pages and thinking 'just PTS' when the rescue is spending thousands on cancer treatment and the dog is clearly so sad and hasn't a family to look after them, or a little puppy is very damaged at birth.

There was outrage recently when a family wanted an old dog of a deceased family member PTS. I may be guilty of anthropomorphism, but if I was a very old dog and my beloved owner of many years died, I would prefer to be PTS.

I think some doggy people project their own emotional issues onto dogs. I also suspect money is talking in this case.

How is Susan even part of am agility group with untrained dogs?

BerthaBetty · 02/08/2022 07:39

How dare she blame you for Susan's irresponsibility.

Why after all this time is Jane only getting involved with Susan's antics?

I think Jane is guilty she's not done anything sooner and won't take the blame.

CF.

Motorina · 02/08/2022 07:23

Jane is an emotionally manipulative bully.

Susan should be ashamed.

I'm sorry you've ended up taking the flack for their failures.

Hug your puppies and try not to get caught up in their dramas.

Bemyclementine · 02/08/2022 07:17

I agree with everything you have said @Arashi . It is a really tough call but sometimes it's the better outcome. I have a very elderly pony, in fine form atm, but hadca bit if a "scare" with her in january. It's on my mind a lot as you say, I'd never forgive myself for leaving it too late.

FOJN · 02/08/2022 07:06

So Jane is furious you won't provide the solution to a problem Susan made. Susan choosing to put the dog to sleep, not you. What the hell is wrong with people?

I think it's a terribly sad situation, the dog has done nothing wrong, it simply had the misfortune of being owned by a selfish, halfwit. If a suitable foster cannot be arranged then I agree PTS is for the best, as awful as that is. A large, reactive dog cannot be re-homed by just anyone and it would be dangerous and irresponsible to do that just to avoid the solution Susan has chosen.

Jane and Susan are both unreasonable, you have said you can take the dog but just not right now. Perhaps Jane could direct some of her anger towards Susan who is refusing to keep the dog for another 6 weeks.

sausage767 · 02/08/2022 07:02

I do agree in a lot of cases. An older animal that is sick or injured should not be put through traumatic surgery or treatment. An animal disabled from birth. An older pet that cannot be quickly and happily rehomed, rather than being put in a shelter alone and afraid. An animal with severe behavioural issues that cannot be easily rehomed.

AnonymousMizs · 02/08/2022 06:58

You're absolutely not being unreasonable. A good death which prevents being passed from pillar to post and the high risk of abuse and/or harm to the dog and anyone or thing around it is not cruelty, it's kindness if there are no other options.

3ormoredogs · 02/08/2022 06:56

I’ve worked with a few Janes.

Quick to blame someone else for not taking a dog they aren’t willing to take themselves.

I have also euthanised a dog for severe aggression. Do I feel guilty? Yes, however the dog lived a highly stressed and very controlled life, always locked away or muzzled around anything that wasn’t me as she was downright dangerous. Not my fault, I rescued her for the behaviour and tried my best to turn it around but she was a genetic emotional wreck.

One day my guard slipped and she did bite someone, I had her PTS and I had loads of Janes saying you could have done X,Y or Z…yet I didn’t see any of them living with a biting rescue german shepherd or doing anything to help 🤔 The majority of them couldn’t have handled a savage toy poodle never mind anything else. The real life version of keyboard warriors.

Coffeaddict · 02/08/2022 06:52

Plumtreebob · 01/08/2022 20:37

Why isn’t Jane dropping everything to have the dog?

I fully agree with you.

Was just about to write something like this.
Jane's a fuckwit ignore her

Arashi · 02/08/2022 06:45

I dont agree with animals being pts to suit a human convenience

Everything about animals is based on human convenience. Whether it should be or not is a whole other debate about humans and their place on the planet.

We chose where they live, how they live, whether they classed as wild, pets, farm or vermin and then treat them accordingly.

Like a previous poster I think the concept of never put a healthy animals down is wonderful thing and truly admirable but what is healthy? There is a rescue kennels near me and many of the residents in that kennels have been there for 10 years plus. I an not saying they are not cared for because they are, they are fed, watered, given medical treatment and allowed 1 hour out either as a walk with volunteers or in the enrichment room. Some appear to be coping OK, some clearly have shut down. Would they be better off PTS. Arguably yes.

Older dogs being given up to rescue gives me the absolute rage. In most cases the dog has been a loyal companion for its whole life and most people aren't giving them up because they dickheads, but because work, housing, money, and because those people worry about the optics of putting a healthy dog to sleep they give it up instead. The kindest thing for that dog is to PTS in the arms of its owner even if thats for the convenience of their owners. The dog will likely spend the rest of its life in kennel which is a completely different environment to a home, its away from the people it's love its while life. Yes there are some Foster homes for these dogs but not as many dogs as there are.

Keeping animals alive for the convenience of humans is just as wrong. And indeed borders on despicable at times.

OP posts:
HannahDefoesTrenchcoat · 01/08/2022 23:22

I read that PTS is not a welfare issue as the dog doesn’t suffer. The ethical issue is around how much the dog is made to suffer to suit the humans.

Getoff · 01/08/2022 23:09

By "better for the animal to be PTS" I meant it would be best for the animal, not necessarily best for its owner.

Getoff · 01/08/2022 23:06

I dint agree with animals being pts to suit a human convenience.

I don't agree with animals being kept alive (by being given medical treatments) to suit the interests of their humans. Unless the treatment removes suffering immediately. I wince when I hear of an animal being treated for a serious condition that's potentially fatal. I suspect in nearly all such cases it would be better for the animal to be PTS.

Animals aren't people, they don't fear a PTS death, because they don't understand it. Killing an animal is not morally equivalent to killing a human.

People (like Jane) who think animals should be treated the way a human would be haven't thought things through.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 01/08/2022 21:14

I agree with you entirely, OP. Never putting a healthy dog down really doesn't apply to dogs who are dangerous. It's not the dog's fault, but keeping reactive dogs with a history of biting alive is usually a really bad idea.

Susan sounds like an absolute liability who shouldn't have dogs, and Jane needs an introduction to reality.

BenCoopersSupportWren · 01/08/2022 21:03

Having volunteered in animal rescue myself, one of the things I encountered time and again was the problem with the (completely admirable and laudable) aim of “never put a healthy animal down”.

The reason I call it a problem is because the definition of “healthy” is often too narrow and focused entirely on physical health. But animals deserve to live psychologically healthy lives too, and a dog that’s so stressed and fearful it has resorted to aggression as a standard ‘go-to’ response can’t be described as happy or healthy.

The biggest regret and most guilt I have from my pet owning history is over the dog we tried to keep going that little bit too long for our sake when he was struggling, not the ones I’ve let go a day too early.

thesurrealist · 01/08/2022 20:50

I dint agree with animals being pts to suit a human convenience. However, if this is a dog that's reactive to humans and animals, then realistically being pts is going to always be a risk with that animal. Unless they can gene placed with someone who can help the animal properly.
For the sake of a few weeks then the stupid woman should wait until you are able to take the dog. A decent human being would do that for the animal that they have ruined due to their own incompetence as an owner.
If not....then yes, you're right and the dog needs to be pts....which pains me to say as a dog owner who has a dog with several complex medical conditions but the strongest will in the world to live....and I'm so proud of my amazing dog for doing that....but this dog isn't happy and is a danger.
I think that Susan needs to be banned from owning animals and jane needs to grow up.

godmum56 · 01/08/2022 20:45

You are not unreasonable
Susan is not lovely she is a selfish thoughtless bitch.

Arashi · 01/08/2022 20:39

I didn't always think this way and it was my childhood horse that made the "good death" important to me.

She will forever be my regret. I let her go on too long burying my head in the sand and finding her collapsed in her stable broke me. Although she had been fine(ish) a hour or so previously, she was late 30s and I kept doing last summer / winter cycles. I like to think I gave her comfort at the end but honestly she deserved a better death than she got. She should have been in the field with the sun on her back and a bucket of all the treats she couldn't usually have due to cushings / lami.

It's difficult to know when the right Time is, but someone told me better a week to early than a day too late and that's stuck with me.i suppose.

OP posts:
Plumtreebob · 01/08/2022 20:37

Why isn’t Jane dropping everything to have the dog?

I fully agree with you.

Thatsenoughnow · 01/08/2022 20:30

Susan being a total irresponsible idiot isn't your problem to fix. Sad for the dog, but if it's a large breed that's bitten someone to the extent they need stitches then pts is probably for the best anyway.

If Jane feels so strongly about it, she can take the dog.

pastypirate · 01/08/2022 20:26

doodlywoodlydingdong · 01/08/2022 19:37

My dad always taught us that owning any animal was an immense privilege. It was our duty to make sure they don't suffer. For me that means putting to sleep at the correct time. I would never ever do it on a whim, or for minor issues though. I've got a rescue that has horrific issues, will likely never be fully house trained , can't seem to over come hey issues from human caused trauma etc. I love her and tolerate her behaviour. But if anything happened that meant I couldn't care for her any longer, she would be pts as a kindness. She couldn't handle another round of homes.

I often see a friend of my family that runs working dogs. At the end of their work life, they often don't understand why they aren't going to work anymore. They struggle to transition. Some of those dogs have had to be pts as a kindness. But the work they do is vital and they are much loved. Its a kindness to the dog.

I agree with you fully.

I completely agree with your dad - those are wise words indeed.

I have already told the dds that for our dog that pts when the time comes for him for whatever reason is part of giving an animal loving care - as others have said - a peaceful death is a kindness.

Whitney168 · 01/08/2022 20:24

Oh, and if the dog is to be PTS, it should be Susan who has to own her actions and take it - not pass the buck to someone else. Perhaps if it came to that, she just might stop and think a bit harder next time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread