Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't pay high energy prices protest

139 replies

Gmamaofboys13 · 01/08/2022 15:54

Drawing MN users attention to a campaign where 1 million people cancel their direct debits on the 1st of October as a protest against the high energy prices:

dontpay.uk/

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Discovereads · 05/08/2022 00:11

earsup · 01/08/2022 18:22

Well if you use EDF..their high uk prices subsidise the french customers as french owned for years so firstly ditch them....!!

My DH’s very large employer is ditching a U.K. energy firm in favour of EDF because EDF is the cheapest.

Discovereads · 05/08/2022 00:02

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 01/08/2022 16:37

It costs British Gas/the energy supplier £400 when a complaint against them is taken to the Ombudsman, whether they win a case or lose a case.

Taking a complaint to the Ombudsman, which you are within your absolute rights to do with any company regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (once you have made an initial complaint to the company), will simply cost THEM money. Even if the Ombudsman dismiss your complaint, the company will be out of pocket each time.

The more you know!

I’m pretty sure that £400 figure is a back of the envelope calculation as to the cost of the time to generate a response. It won’t cost £400 per response if they get duplicate complaints. They’ll only have to generate 1 generic response and tell the Ombudsman that it applies to all complaints about the high gas and electric prices.

apintortwo · 04/08/2022 23:58

Because without investment in the mid- to long term, we'll be paying FAR more in the near future than what we'll pay next year.

Exactly. Also why should the UN be meddling with individual governments' tax decisions?

Liebig · 04/08/2022 23:50

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 04/08/2022 13:39

A lot of people won’t be able to afford their energy bills when they end up being as high as their rent or mortgage payments. Even the UN had called on Governments to impose windfall taxes on them now. It’s getting beyond ridiculous. There is a whole load of profiteering going. I bet there are some hedge fund managers out there rubbing their hands together and waiting for the money to start rolling in. The rich will be getting richer off the back of ruined lives and peoples’ misery.

The likes of BP won't make some massive profit by the end of the year due to writing off their Russian assets.

To cover the increase in energy bills for the next two years would be on the order of £100bn+ depending on where you draw the price cap line (April's or August's) and if every household gets it out of the 28 million or so.

If you seriously think oil and gas executives are making off to a tenth of a trillion pounds, I've got a bridge to sell you.

Incidentally, that money they do rake in is likely a one off event if the global economy collapses, and with it, the CAPEX for getting us out of this situation. Because without investment in the mid- to long term, we'll be paying FAR more in the near future than what we'll pay next year.

Additionally, subsidising consumption is the dumbest thing people in power could do now. Do they think they can buy more gas than exists if we give everyone a tax break?

People need to wake up and actually read a physics and economics book sometime instead of assuming this is profiteering. Like suddenly shutting down 40% of Europe's energy means prices won't be affected? What the fuck?

Lunar270 · 04/08/2022 14:49

The militant in me likes the idea of this but it's really not been thought out. Basically they're neglecting the sad fact that millions simply won't be able to afford the increased bills in the first place. They may well end up cancelling their direct debits, but purely because they can't have all of their money taken out of the account with nothing left for other bills.

I'm lucky enough to be able to absorb some of this and so my protest will come in the form of less spending on everything else. It's a sad state of affairs as the high street and economy in general will suffer.

I've already read an article today saying that the high street is seeing fewer people spending money. After October it'll be like lockdown again. Depressing.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 04/08/2022 13:39

A lot of people won’t be able to afford their energy bills when they end up being as high as their rent or mortgage payments. Even the UN had called on Governments to impose windfall taxes on them now. It’s getting beyond ridiculous. There is a whole load of profiteering going. I bet there are some hedge fund managers out there rubbing their hands together and waiting for the money to start rolling in. The rich will be getting richer off the back of ruined lives and peoples’ misery.

Unphased · 04/08/2022 13:31

Mangolist
Good, because someone needs to tell them, most of them around me seem to have all these items and more

Mangolist · 03/08/2022 16:41

'it’s time to cut down on holidays, eating out, takeaways, subscription TV, Amazon prime, new phone, stop tumble drying, wear more clothes indoors, etc, pay your essentials first.'

Yep, I'll tell the families I see at Foodbank that. They just haven't thought through

Snoozer11 · 03/08/2022 16:14

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 01/08/2022 19:52

No, I'd like you to explain to me what you mean.

I'm not sure I see the problem with your friends being on holiday. Enjoying life. Helping other industries. Unless they're out there for an undisclosed unethical reason, of course.

Please elaborate.

Oh, you're a goady little fucker aren't you.

My point is that everyone I have seen who is getting behind this in real life can comfortably afford to pay an increase to their bills. They have a lot of disposable income and simply aren't prepared to sacrifice their luxuries but will happily refuse to pay for the energy they've used.

I think it cheapens this movement.

Cyclebabble · 03/08/2022 12:26

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 03/08/2022 11:35

Hello! Absolutely - you will need to go via your provider first, who will obviously not uphold the complaint Smile

Any company that is regulated by the FCA can have already raised complaints forwarded to the Ombudsman (FOS). This costs energy providers up to £400 per complaint, whether the FOS uphold the complaint or not.

During this time, they are NOT allowed to take any debt collective action on your account. The bill essentially gets put on pause whilst they investigate the complaint. For the purposes of this exercise, let's use British Gas as the example. BG will come back and offer you discount after discount after discount, wanting you to essentially close the complaint - do NOT do this! Keep the complaint open.

BG will get hit with an even bigger fine if they have too many complaints open. The general complaint fee, plus the enormous fine with too many complaints open will cost them too much money, too much time. This will also put them in breach of their licensing conditions and put their ability to trade at risk (yeah we know not much of a risk!) but this is a better way of protesting than just not paying altogether, if you can.

Sorry but I do not think you have a good grasp of some basics here. The Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) regulates only financial services (so banking, insurance). It does not consider complaints about energy costs.

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 03/08/2022 11:35

Cyclebabble · 02/08/2022 08:04

As with most complaint systems you need to go via your provider first. Ofgem is unlikely to consider a complaint purely on cost unless there is some aggravating factor-i.e. bill is wrong or the DD has been raised without reason- which is a fairly normal complaint. If you do not pay your bill, your risk a CCJ, a poor credit rating and you will be placed on a pre-payment meter. That way if you do not pay your utility company has no worries at all. I would be raising it with your MP being clear that this will decide how you vote.

Hello! Absolutely - you will need to go via your provider first, who will obviously not uphold the complaint Smile

Any company that is regulated by the FCA can have already raised complaints forwarded to the Ombudsman (FOS). This costs energy providers up to £400 per complaint, whether the FOS uphold the complaint or not.

During this time, they are NOT allowed to take any debt collective action on your account. The bill essentially gets put on pause whilst they investigate the complaint. For the purposes of this exercise, let's use British Gas as the example. BG will come back and offer you discount after discount after discount, wanting you to essentially close the complaint - do NOT do this! Keep the complaint open.

BG will get hit with an even bigger fine if they have too many complaints open. The general complaint fee, plus the enormous fine with too many complaints open will cost them too much money, too much time. This will also put them in breach of their licensing conditions and put their ability to trade at risk (yeah we know not much of a risk!) but this is a better way of protesting than just not paying altogether, if you can.

Liebig · 03/08/2022 10:20

LittleBearPad · 02/08/2022 14:19

Funnily enough countries like France have managed to keep bills low and their increase is about 4%. Why? because utilities are in public ownership and their politicians know full well people would take to the streets if they tried what is happening here.

Its actually primarily because considerably more French electricity comes from Nuclear Power stations (70%) than in the UK (less than 20%). We are far more dependent on fossil fuels

Actually, a big chunk of the energy crisis in Europe now is precisely because they have two dozen reactors offline due to poor condition. This means the Germans and others have to burn more coal and gas to offset the losses from France’s antiquated nuke fleet (the low river flow and high temperatures of said river don’t help either).

LittleBearPad · 02/08/2022 14:19

Funnily enough countries like France have managed to keep bills low and their increase is about 4%. Why? because utilities are in public ownership and their politicians know full well people would take to the streets if they tried what is happening here.

Its actually primarily because considerably more French electricity comes from Nuclear Power stations (70%) than in the UK (less than 20%). We are far more dependent on fossil fuels

Unphased · 02/08/2022 11:43

KettrickenSmiled
The French tax problem will still be picking up the bill for their government’s actions,
depends on what you call poverty, no heating in the house apart from a coal fire, single glassed windows, scraping ice of the inside in the winter, no car, but hey you job to conclusions

KettrickenSmiled · 02/08/2022 08:29

Unphased · 01/08/2022 16:21

What do you expect the government to do, electricity and gas is sold on the open market, if you don’t pay, you will get a key meter fitted for energy at a dearer price, if to many people do it all the remaining suppliers will go out of business, with no energy for any one, or , the energy companies will just sell the electric abroad,
You can’t go into a shop and refuse to pay your bill and walk out, this is no different,
it’s time to cut down on holidays, eating out, takeaways, subscription TV, Amazon prime, new phone, stop tumble drying, wear more clothes indoors, etc, pay your essentials first.

The French government has intervened, but it was smart enough to retain control of EDF, so is able to restrict & manage consumer pricing. I don't expect the UK government to tackle anything that benefits ordinary people though - their loyalty is to business, & they are happier cutting taxes than seeing children eat.

But I'm loving your casual assumption that I can afford to stay warm this winter by losing a load of luxuries that I don't have, @Unphased. The fact that 4 million UK children are currently living in poverty seems to have escaped you. How nice for you.

"Pay your essentials first" - my arse. You have clearly never experienced poverty. Millions of households do not have luxuries, & cannot afford basic essentials. But you keep lecturing from your high horse about how the peasants need to "cut down", we'll all be so grateful for your sterling advice as we tug our forelocks to your wisdom & insight.

justfiveminutes · 02/08/2022 08:09

Who are DontPayUK?

Why are people listening to them? I suppose it appeals to frightened people who can't think through to the inevitable end consequences of cancelling your dd to your energy provider.

You will be billed at an even higher price. If they have to chase you for it, or you pay late, they charge you for it. If you don't pay, it affects your credit score and they move you to a prepayment meter. The debt follows you if you move house.

Reporting them to the ombudsman is pointless. They will refer you back to your provider's complaints procedure. If your complaint is about high prices, it will be dismissed.

Their profits are not from residential sales. For anyone with a pension, your pension will be at least partly invested in energy.

The best we can hope for is even more government support that will ultimately be paid back through tax anyway.

Cyclebabble · 02/08/2022 08:04

As with most complaint systems you need to go via your provider first. Ofgem is unlikely to consider a complaint purely on cost unless there is some aggravating factor-i.e. bill is wrong or the DD has been raised without reason- which is a fairly normal complaint. If you do not pay your bill, your risk a CCJ, a poor credit rating and you will be placed on a pre-payment meter. That way if you do not pay your utility company has no worries at all. I would be raising it with your MP being clear that this will decide how you vote.

BalloonsAndWhistles · 02/08/2022 07:39

No way I’m doing this. I’m not risking poor credit/prepayment meter etc. I’d be OK with a complaint or a mass turn off of electricity for a couple of hours. Might work well if it was co-ordinated with reminders on social media 15 mins before, then 5 mins before. Then people can turn off for a minimum of 1 hour, more if possible. If you’ve got a mobile, surely you can just charge it up prior to that and just watch telly in the dark for a bit?

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/08/2022 07:23

But I guess there will always be those who love to play the martyrs and use the opportunities to criticise those who have no interest in getting back to Dickensian standards of living.

No, I just don't want my credit rating wrecked if I can help it.

On the subject of holidays, maybe some of these people booked them before prices shot up.

Madwife123 · 02/08/2022 00:04

I will be paying because I can’t afford to destroy my credit history but the current prices are crippling us.

I have a severely disabled adult son and as a result we use a significant amount of energy, over and above a normal household of our size. Our energy bills have now rocketed to £420 a month.

After tax, NI, student loan, work parking, pension deductions I am left with £1600 a month. My mortgage is £895. Just a roof over our heads and energy takes almost all my wages and leaves us scraping by and using food banks.

I can’t move as our home is adapted for my sons disabilities and if we move we need to repay the disabled facilities grant we had to help towards the adaptions. And we can’t afford to do that.

It shouldn’t be the case that working full time in the NHS, in a professional job, and still you can’t afford to live. Yet I apparently earn too much for any benefits or government support, god knows how!

People with disabilities are as usual disproportionately affected by this. Even the cost of living grants are disproportionate. £150 if you have a disability but £650 if on benefits. We won’t even get the £150 however as my son isn’t on the energy accounts.

I am very very worried for the future.

JosephineGH · 01/08/2022 22:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Liebig · 01/08/2022 22:25

Whitehorsegirl · 01/08/2022 22:21

''@Unphased
What do you expect the government to do, electricity and gas is sold on the open market, if you don’t pay, you will get a key meter fitted for energy at a dearer price, if to many people do it all the remaining suppliers will go out of business, with no energy for any one, or , the energy companies will just sell the electric abroad,You can’t go into a shop and refuse to pay your bill and walk out, this is no different,it’s time to cut down on holidays, eating out, takeaways, subscription TV, Amazon prime, new phone, stop tumble drying, wear more clothes indoors, etc, pay your essentials first.''

FFS...I always wonder how people get so indoctrinated that they start parroting this type of rubbish and blame people for not wanting to almost have to sell a kidney to pay for life's essentials.

Companies like British Gas have made enormous profit this year and are paying their shareholders fat dividends and their CEO a huge salary. Yet the consumer is supposed to freeze to death.

Funnily enough countries like France have managed to keep bills low and their increase is about 4%. Why? because utilities are in public ownership and their politicians know full well people would take to the streets if they tried what is happening here.

Yet in the UK we are supposed to just accept these absolute rip-off increases.

I do hope everyone cancel their direct debits and refuse to pay these ridiculous bills, full stop.

But I guess there will always be those who love to play the martyrs and use the opportunities to criticise those who have no interest in getting back to Dickensian standards of living.

If you seriously think the French gov't underwriting energy increases means they're not paying these prices, I don't know what to tell you.

Who do you think pays for nationalised energy infrastructure? I'll give you a hint: it begins with "tax" and ends with "payers".

This is like buying something beyond your means on credit card and thinking the bank has just bought you a new Range Rover and you didn't have to increase your monthly outgoings. It's painfully naïve.

Liebig · 01/08/2022 22:21

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 01/08/2022 20:25

I completely agree with you that we need to start living more sustainably. I am not disagreeing with this, but realistically without government help in other ways, that is a privilege for many people.

You mention people in other parts of the world who don't have access to this. Believe it or not, I think decent housing and living conditions are a basic human right and it is awful that they aren't given this option. Are you suggesting we should accept living like people in developing countries?

And lastly... you say that we shouldn't be allowed "cheap" energy but can you explain how is acceptable for British Gas to roll in BILLIONS of pounds worth of profit whilst we are all plunged in to poverty?

@amijustparanoidorjuststoned I'm saying that you won't have much choice on the matter. You can either pay the market price, or you can go without. That's how the system works.

There is no obligation for the world's energy markets to give discount energy to the UK. The gov't could nationalise Shell and BP, although I have a feeling their shareholders may object to this (especially the ones that are pension funds). You can have those profits distributed to the people, but that only works the once. The company needs to grow to sustain itself, so eventually, you're going to have to stop bailing out the consumer.

And when that happens, people will be thrown back into the free market, where price is dictated by the marginal barrel or cubic metre of oil and gas. Which is where the big price spikes occur as too little energy is sought after by too many people, hence, supply and demand curves.

A lot of the last major deposits of fossil fuels are owned by national oil and gas companies too. The ones we don't control. You're out of luck when it comes to dealing with them, especially as we may have to either keep paying in dollars (which are scarce right now), or even worse, maybe in a currency basket that the developing nations dictate at the behest of BRICS. And then you'll see what Sri Lanka dealt with when they ran out of currency to afford imported goods.

Whitehorsegirl · 01/08/2022 22:21

''@Unphased
What do you expect the government to do, electricity and gas is sold on the open market, if you don’t pay, you will get a key meter fitted for energy at a dearer price, if to many people do it all the remaining suppliers will go out of business, with no energy for any one, or , the energy companies will just sell the electric abroad,You can’t go into a shop and refuse to pay your bill and walk out, this is no different,it’s time to cut down on holidays, eating out, takeaways, subscription TV, Amazon prime, new phone, stop tumble drying, wear more clothes indoors, etc, pay your essentials first.''

FFS...I always wonder how people get so indoctrinated that they start parroting this type of rubbish and blame people for not wanting to almost have to sell a kidney to pay for life's essentials.

Companies like British Gas have made enormous profit this year and are paying their shareholders fat dividends and their CEO a huge salary. Yet the consumer is supposed to freeze to death.

Funnily enough countries like France have managed to keep bills low and their increase is about 4%. Why? because utilities are in public ownership and their politicians know full well people would take to the streets if they tried what is happening here.

Yet in the UK we are supposed to just accept these absolute rip-off increases.

I do hope everyone cancel their direct debits and refuse to pay these ridiculous bills, full stop.

But I guess there will always be those who love to play the martyrs and use the opportunities to criticise those who have no interest in getting back to Dickensian standards of living.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 01/08/2022 21:58

Not signing up to this.
We'll try to struggle through but I can't see how this can be fixed.
The energy companies fix their own prices, the government can only mitigate, if they can, to a certain extent.

Maybe we shouldn't have been so greedy as to buying British Gas shares, in the 80s , which millions did and promptly sold them to make a few quid. Energy companies bought them up by the barrel load.

This really is our doing. We should have protested against the sale of a nationalised institution. All profits were ploughed back in to the industry ( which would now be green energy) whereas shareholders now get massive dividends.

Swipe left for the next trending thread