Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Womens football, Paygap, how is this legal and why is no one talking about it?

136 replies

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 14:27

Just as the title says really. I don’t understand how it’s legal to pay the women footballers so much less. The equality’s act 2010 seems to support equal pay for effort put in.

Am I being stupid? Could someone explain to me how the law is applied in this instance that it’s legal for such pay disparity and why the media seems silent on addressing it?

The women footballers have done our country proud and surely they deserve the same remuneration as the men would.

thank you so much.

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman2 · 01/08/2022 15:41

so, for example, take Liverpool fc. The womens first team do a different job than the mens first team? . In terms of effort put in and job description? I had no idea? I thought a goalie is a goalie. Obviously good ones and bad ones. But the jd and effort required at premier level the same?

But the point is, the two Premier levels will never be the same. You can be the best female goalie in the world, but that doesn’t mean you can play to the same standard as top male goalies. Why should someone get the same pay as someone else who, by definition, does a better job?

Think of jobs like plumbing or the building trade that, even now, are still primarily associated with men. There’s no reason why a female plumber can’t be as good as a male plumber - and unless the job is fixing a men’s locker room whilst it’s in use, there’s no plumbing job she can’t do either. But a woman can’t play for a man’s team, or vice versa. It’s not possible for both genders to do the same job in this sense, as the roles are by definition only open to one gender.

So surely the clubs should divide the wages equally between the men and women and pay the men less if they can’t afford to pay women equally?

Would you work for less money than you were worth so that someone who can’t possibly be as good at the job as you are can earn the same as you?

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 15:35

@SammySammySammytheBetterfly it’s not so much that men should provide. I agree fully with your point. But there is still the issue that women have had disadvantages mainly caused by a historical patriarchal society and all the other things talked about on this forum constantly. So while I don’t think men should provide for women, there is a lot of catching up to do, that then men don’t need to do… I wonder if there was an even playing field in the beginning where we would be.
but I take your point and agree.

OP posts:
SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 15:34

wonderstuff · 01/08/2022 15:29

I’m sorry but that’s absolutely ridiculous. Grass roots football is subsidised by pro football, it’s selfish self interest because it ensures a fan base and stream of talent to the pro clubs. In addition schools and local councils and parishes build pitches using public money because they have health and social benefits for young people. Not just men, whole communities. The idea that we have this enormous well funded infrastructure but we should exclude women and girls from it because it belongs to men is just daft.

@wonderstuff

Its funded by the pros now. But how did it start? It started with next to no funding by men just getting out and making it because it was a new thing they enjoyed. Why can’t women do the same? Why always have to lean on men and compare to them?

I do think the FA ban was wrong. But I don’t think women are just owed by the male clubs their own teams and money. I also don’t think leaning on men as providers in that way is a good look for so called progress for women.

Zilla1 · 01/08/2022 15:32

Could be wrong but when Notts County closed their professional women's team in 2017 the annual salaries and coaching costs were around £500,000 and the total revenues from TV/ticket sales/sponsorship was £28,000. The figures won't be correct but if we assume 20 home fixtures and a £5 ticket price, that would have an attendance of 280? The game has grown but I understand the financials recently are still subsidised. Arguably appropriate to grow a game but perhaps not a sound base for equal pay. Genuine equal pay would presumably shutter many teams now though perhaps not in the future??

Kazzyhoward · 01/08/2022 15:31

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 15:00

@WomanStanleyWoman2 this is the bit I dont understand. You are correct in that.

so, for example, take Liverpool fc. The womens first team do a different job than the mens first team? . In terms of effort put in and job description? I had no idea? I thought a goalie is a goalie. Obviously good ones and bad ones. But the jd and effort required at premier level the same?
As you can tell I know very little about football. And no I won’t be watching more womens football because I don’t like football. But the reason womens football doesn’t get as much viewing figures is because less investment as been out in, a historical ban by the fa on women playing football and deep seated misogyny in the game and society in general. So there’s no even playing field. So surely the clubs should divide the wages equally between the men and women and pay the men less if they can’t afford to pay women equally? Bit like the issue at the bbc?

You really don't get it. It's entertainment! The more people who watch a match (in person or on TV), the higher the revenue. Revenue is what pays wages. The job of the footballer is to entertain. Like all entertainers, what they earn is linked to their popularity!

A team with 50k attendance every match and tens of millions watching online will attract huge amounts of revenue, sponsorship, advertising, etc.

A team with 5k attendance every match will get a tiny amount of that income.

Why should the team with 50k attendance and high revenue subsidise another team that barely anyone watches?

It's nonsense to suggest equality. That is, UNTIL, the women's matches get the same level of support, in terms of attendances, viewing numbers, etc as the men's matches. If there isn't more equality at that stage, then there is a problem!

SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 15:30

@Runwalkskijump

I don’t doubt the womens game will grow but in truth it may never grow to the level of the mens. There’s no real reason to believe men and women will ever have the exact same interest in watching sport.

Thats fine but I don’t think some people can handle the idea of them never making as much money as the men.

wonderstuff · 01/08/2022 15:29

SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 15:23

@YetiTeri

Men did what they did independent of women. Women were banned from their fields not from playing soccer itself. Those fields weren’t from the time of stongehenge, men made them. There are plenty of wealthy women these days and many fields - absolutely nothing is stopping women from starting their own leagues and teams independent to men, even making their own facilities to whatever level they can.

But of course if they aren’t attached to mens leagues and teams they will have to succeed or fail on their own - without the fail safe of being propped up by the mens leagues and being able to demand money from them.

I’m sorry but that’s absolutely ridiculous. Grass roots football is subsidised by pro football, it’s selfish self interest because it ensures a fan base and stream of talent to the pro clubs. In addition schools and local councils and parishes build pitches using public money because they have health and social benefits for young people. Not just men, whole communities. The idea that we have this enormous well funded infrastructure but we should exclude women and girls from it because it belongs to men is just daft.

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 15:29

@DashboardConfessional that is helpful yes. Makes sense

OP posts:
Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 15:28

Rushes!!! Not Raines 🤦🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 15:27

@Thatswhyimacat

Also women weren’t banned from playing soccer - but from FA fields. But nowdays what is stopping women setting up their own leagues if they want to independent of men? The truth is nothing.

I find it kind of disturbing but telling that so much “equality” seems to be gotten by attaching to men somehow and being provided for by them. And this is really apparent with womens sports teams that are affiliated with mens.

Could it be that we’ve transferred the idea of men being providers for women at home to the wider world and in this case sports - and this is what many see equality as? Getting men to give them their half of what men have and make?
Its a very gendered old fashioned mindset but for a modern world. Weird.

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 15:27

No need to be rude @GirlInACountrySong . I’m not looking to create drama. I did do some research but into the equalities act, not so much football.
I’m generating a discussion on a discussion forum, which has been interesting and educational to me. And perhaps others. Especially the different view pints in terms of equalling things up.

when people post asking how to make formula up, no one Raines to tell them to ‘do their research’. We all try and help them understand.

thank you to those of you who know more than me, for highlighting some of the issues. I think we can all appreciate that a mens team out perform a womens team. Which is why they play separately. And why we have sport separated by sex (for now). I was just curious how the big clubs get away with paying women less. I didn’t realise that a defender in the womens league is a different job to the mens one. I’m fact I still don’t really understand, but acknowledge my football knowledge is limited.

OP posts:
Runwalkskijump · 01/08/2022 15:26

Down to bums on seats and sponsorship.

There was a womens football agent on the radio today who said that basically a womens league match will get 2-3 maybe 4 thousand attendance whilst the mens sell ourt Arsenal, Man U etc weekly.

As she said it is growing and it will change but it isn't going to happen overnight.

Thatswhyimacat · 01/08/2022 15:25

Also to add, you only have to look at tennis or the 100m sprint to see that interest in male sports is ALWAYS higher.

wonderstuff · 01/08/2022 15:24

I think current male players do well and are in no danger of losing out to women!

SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 15:23

@YetiTeri

Men did what they did independent of women. Women were banned from their fields not from playing soccer itself. Those fields weren’t from the time of stongehenge, men made them. There are plenty of wealthy women these days and many fields - absolutely nothing is stopping women from starting their own leagues and teams independent to men, even making their own facilities to whatever level they can.

But of course if they aren’t attached to mens leagues and teams they will have to succeed or fail on their own - without the fail safe of being propped up by the mens leagues and being able to demand money from them.

Thatswhyimacat · 01/08/2022 15:22

YetiTeri · 01/08/2022 15:17

So women should ban the men for 50 years so they can grow the game slowly and organically? That's the way men did it.🙄

And that's a shame. But it doesn't mean that current male players should be paid less than their worth.

GirlInACountrySong · 01/08/2022 15:18

It's very simple op!!

Do a bit of research before trying to cause drama??

SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 15:17

@ihavespoken

How much physio support was there for a man playing the 1950’s? How much was he paid?

I find it sad and concerning that the way many see equality is by attaching women to what men do and making men give them a big slice. To me that’s men providing for women. Same as ever.

YetiTeri · 01/08/2022 15:17

SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 15:15

@ihavespoken

There is another way though. The way the men did it. Create something originally and grow it slowly in any way you can. If people are interested they will play and watch.

Theres no other way to get more money and exposure than is actually earned that is true.

So women should ban the men for 50 years so they can grow the game slowly and organically? That's the way men did it.🙄

JosephineGH · 01/08/2022 15:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 15:15

ihavespoken · 01/08/2022 15:07

What stadiums would they play at? Where would they get the facilities to train at, the physio support, the other infrastructure?
Where will they get the community of fans who have an emotional tie to the team/club, who will turn out and support them?

I do hope women's football will stand on its own feet in future but it would be utter madness not to be linked to the existing league clubs which are currently known for their men's teams - there's no other way.

@ihavespoken

There is another way though. The way the men did it. Create something originally and grow it slowly in any way you can. If people are interested they will play and watch.

Theres no other way to get more money and exposure than is actually earned that is true.

YetiTeri · 01/08/2022 15:13

A lot of people on this thread are talking out of their arses. Players are paid the same appearance fee when playing football for their country. However the bonuses are hugely different. So the England men got a lot more for losing the final than the women got for winning.

I actually don't think women's football should emulate the men's game in terms of pay. What made this tournament so incredible was how accessible it was to so many kids. Did you know there was no kids concession at the men's Euro's? That's bullshit. The ideal would be to take money AWAY from the men's game and invest it in the women's so you end up with something in the middle.

wonderstuff · 01/08/2022 15:12

In football pay is linked to talent and performance. Club teams are able to employ international players because of this, millions pass hands because x player is in the top however many players in the world, each player will negotiate each season based on their performance against others, budgets are set according to revenue from the gate and TV rights and kits sales. Beckham went to LA and was never going to play a huge amount but his fame meant they sold so many replica kits and got so much publicity that was more valuable than him actually scoring many goals.
I think women will start to see better pay, more are paying internationally, some clubs are increasing their budget, but it’s not going to get close to the mens game any time soon.

IcedPurple · 01/08/2022 15:12

so, for example, take Liverpool fc. The womens first team do a different job than the mens first team? . In terms of effort put in and job description? I had no idea? I thought a goalie is a goalie. Obviously good ones and bad ones. But the jd and effort required at premier level the same?

Liverpool FC men's team rake in vast amounts of money through TV rights, merchandise sales and ticket receipts. A top male footballer can command a high salary because of the amount of money in the game. If Liverpool aren't prepared to pay him, then Real Madrid or Man City will. It's market forces at work.

The same is not true of the women's game to anything like the same degree.

DashboardConfessional · 01/08/2022 15:12

Women's Premier League played 132 matches in 2021-2022. The men played 380. There are only 12 teams in the WSL versus 20 in the EPL. Does that help?

Swipe left for the next trending thread