Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Womens football, Paygap, how is this legal and why is no one talking about it?

136 replies

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 14:27

Just as the title says really. I don’t understand how it’s legal to pay the women footballers so much less. The equality’s act 2010 seems to support equal pay for effort put in.

Am I being stupid? Could someone explain to me how the law is applied in this instance that it’s legal for such pay disparity and why the media seems silent on addressing it?

The women footballers have done our country proud and surely they deserve the same remuneration as the men would.

thank you so much.

OP posts:
PlanetNormal · 01/08/2022 17:57

It’s amazing how many people fail to grasp the concept that professional sports are commercial businesses which pay players according to the revenues generated by the product they are selling, and not outposts of public sector equal opportunities departments. 🙄

easylisten · 01/08/2022 17:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

YetiTeri · 01/08/2022 17:46

Oh come on @SammySammySammytheBetterfly @ihavespoken

When men stopped allowing women to use the FA facilities women were barely able to vote. They didn't earn the money to be able to build the stadia from scratch to facilitate the crowds to get the money into the game. So yes it was a ban on playing football in a manner that allowed them to make a living from it.

When the ban was lifted the male dominated media wouldn't cover the games so then they couldn't attract sponsorship. It's not equality if one group holds all the power.

DillonPanthersTexas · 01/08/2022 16:35

Not sure how anyone finds the mens' game entertaining - they spend most of it rolling around the floor and surrounding the referees.

Women thankfully don't surround or swear at the referees but they are just as cynical as the men insofar as making a meal out of a tackle and tugging on shirts etc. Even the commentators yesterday were praising England for their 'tactical fouls' to waste time at the end and their ability to 'win a yellow card' for an oppo player. Of course it is called 'clever game management' rather then cheating!

DillonPanthersTexas · 01/08/2022 16:30

Then you have the men, who don't necessarily want to watch the women's game because it's so much slower and less entertaining.

I'm more of a rugby person then footie and live in SW London. Previously England women have played their internationals at Harlequins rather then the much larger Twickenham up the road, even then the 14,000 or so capacity ground was only half full and that was mostly made up by men, tickets only cost about £20 and you could even get in for free at half time. The games are advertised heavily locally and are broadcast on the BBC. For all the demands to grow the game and pay women more there are tragically few women willing to actually go and make that reality by paying to see a game.

SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 16:27

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 15:35

@SammySammySammytheBetterfly it’s not so much that men should provide. I agree fully with your point. But there is still the issue that women have had disadvantages mainly caused by a historical patriarchal society and all the other things talked about on this forum constantly. So while I don’t think men should provide for women, there is a lot of catching up to do, that then men don’t need to do… I wonder if there was an even playing field in the beginning where we would be.
but I take your point and agree.

@Stupidbonfire

But I think to think of it as “catching up” is a mistake. How do we even know that what we would do would be the same and in the same way as the men, if we did it without what they had done in mind as our aim to achieve what they have?
We act like that’s the case as they are all we have to aspire to be like in these regards.

But I don’t really think attaching to them like that till we’re on “their” level is any way to ever create something original. The worry is that that is all we ever do? Just attach to succes men have had and use it as a means for our own sucess?
What if one day for whatever reason men say no?
Women will have nothing, because we will have built nothing independent of men.

gatehouseoffleet · 01/08/2022 16:27

Then you have the men, who don't necessarily want to watch the women's game because it's so much slower and less entertaining

Not sure how anyone finds the mens' game entertaining - they spend most of it rolling around the floor and surrounding the referees.

However, women and men aren't employed by the same people - in fact are they employed at all, or are they are on contracts for supply of services? In the latter case they would not be subject to the legislation on paying both sexes the same for the same job anyway.

Thatswhyimacat · 01/08/2022 16:18

Womens football will never be as big as men's. Look how many people in this thread are prefacing with 'I don't like football but...' Think how many men are obsessed with sports vs women. It's a stereotype but it's largely true.

I can't think of a single sport where there is a huge demand for the female version that doesn't exist for the male version. If you liked football, then you'd want to watch the more skilled men playing it as well. Unless you genuinely only watch women's tennis etc?

Then you have the men, who don't necessarily want to watch the women's game because it's so much slower and less entertaining.

DillonPanthersTexas · 01/08/2022 16:17

Do different boxing or mma fights get paid differently (even within weight and sex categories)?

Like boxing, MMA fighters are paid a fee per bout (negotiated by their agents) by broadcasters, the winner of the fight will get a 'purse' in prize money. Obviously the top fighters in their class get paid more then some rookie.

Dotjones · 01/08/2022 16:15

I don't get this argument that female sportspeople should automatically get paid the same as their male counterparts. The reason sports stars get paid a shitload is because it's worth companies sponsoring them because enough people are interested and will buy their product because of it.

If you look at sports where the women can compete directly with men (snooker, darts, motor racing) the women never end up earning the same as the men because they're not as successful. Winning brings sponsorship and more money. A football team might be the ones who pay the players, but it's really the sponsors who pay the bills.

I've heard people argue "it should all be one pot of money and men and women should be paid equally" but that is nonsense. Basically it's saying people who are interested in one thing should be subsidising something they don't care about. By that logic, why not implemement a knitting tax? Many women like knitting but don't care about women's football, so why not tax wool and use it to fund women's football?

wordler · 01/08/2022 16:15

I think you might be confusing 'earnings'//appearance fees with prize money.

They prize money is vastly different for men and women in football. It's mainly because more people watch the men's games so the overall prize pot is bigger.

I do think the difference is shocking though.

The nation that wins the tournament will receive a total of around £1.9m/£2m (assuming they’ve won all their group games).
However, it pales in comparison to the money on offer in last year’s men’s tournament, Euro 2020, which saw eventual winners Italy handed a prize pot of almost £29 million – of which £10 million was awarded solely for winner the final.

www.scotsman.com/sport/football/womens-euro-2022-prize-money-what-will-england-lionesses-earn-if-they-win-is-it-equal-pay-3776136

On the other hand the women's prize pot for Euro 22 has doubled since Euro 17 so it's going in the right direction.

glamourousindierockandroll · 01/08/2022 16:10

The striker for Luton Town doesn't get paid the same as Christiano Ronaldo.

JauntyJinty · 01/08/2022 16:09

Namenic · 01/08/2022 16:01

Do different boxing or mma fights get paid differently (even within weight and sex categories)? Some people just want to see some events more than others - so revenue generated is higher. It’s supply and demand and isn’t really a surprise.

but Since I was little I’m glad that women’s sport (and now also para sport - in the commonwealth games) is getting more attention. I hope it will grow in popularity and help people want to see the games as entertaining and motivating in their own right (rather than a second best to the standard men’s games).

I was actually going to mention that Ronda Rousey was the highest paid figher in MMA for a while - just to back up what other have said about the pay being l inked to the revenue they bring into the sport

Going back to football, from a strickly legal standpoint, I'm not sure but I'm assuming all the players are technically self employeed and contracted to clubs rather than directly employed by them

luckylavender · 01/08/2022 16:09

It always makes me laugh when something like this happens & suddenly people who have no shown any interest in a subject previously, are experts.

Zilla1 · 01/08/2022 16:07

The situation in the tiny subset of films, 'Hollywood' stars
is interesting. Generally male stars get paid more than women though the argument has always been that some male stars can tentpole a movie and secure a larger audience and relatively few if any female stars can reliably deliver an audience. Could be wrong but the last research I saw showed no female star was a 'I'll go and see that film because X is starring' in the way Tom Cruise, Tom Hanks, Brad Pitt and others were found/thought to be able to. An essentially contested area and cause and effect will be difficult to disentangle.

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 01/08/2022 16:06

The men's game doesn't have a set wage - it not like every player earns x amount, not every player in every team earns the same amount, not every player in the same position earns the same amount. The system doesn't work that way. It's not all premier League players earn X or all Manchester United players earn Y or all goal keepers earn Z, each player has a unique contract that will give them a different salary, performance payments and bonuses to to everyone else. There are all sorts of factors at play - how much they were earning at their previous club, how marketable they are, which position they play in (broadly speaking goal scorers are the best paid), how much the transfer fee was for that player, how rich the club area, how much they want to retain the player. This is why (like actors) footballers have agents. The professional women are now earning broadly comparable amounts to professional men in the lower leagues. And the level of revenue generated are probably below that of a lower league male team.

Zilla1 · 01/08/2022 16:01

There may be significant historical discrimination that has affected the commercial development of the women's game, perhaps the reverse but in a similar way to supply and demand affecting rates of pay for fashion models. Could be wrong but I understand the rates of pay for equivalent levels involves men being paid around a quarter of what women get paid.

wonderstuff · 01/08/2022 16:01

SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 15:34

@wonderstuff

Its funded by the pros now. But how did it start? It started with next to no funding by men just getting out and making it because it was a new thing they enjoyed. Why can’t women do the same? Why always have to lean on men and compare to them?

I do think the FA ban was wrong. But I don’t think women are just owed by the male clubs their own teams and money. I also don’t think leaning on men as providers in that way is a good look for so called progress for women.

So women and girls should build new pitches, raise millions of pounds, to play football because leaning on men isn’t a good look? Should I get a reduction on my local taxes because sports infrastructure is mostly used by men and boys? How ridiculous. Men have and have always disproportionately owned assets and means of production. Women disproportionately take on unpaid domestic labour. The world isn’t fair but women certainly aren’t taking more than their fair share from men!

In 1921 when the FA banned women from their pitches womens football was attracting huge crowds, more than the mens game. Women had taken up the role of playing football during WW1 and it was incredibly popular. Killing the woman’s game for 50 years was absolutely a bad look, supporting it to become re-established seems only fair. It’s a multi billion pound industry.

Namenic · 01/08/2022 16:01

Do different boxing or mma fights get paid differently (even within weight and sex categories)? Some people just want to see some events more than others - so revenue generated is higher. It’s supply and demand and isn’t really a surprise.

but Since I was little I’m glad that women’s sport (and now also para sport - in the commonwealth games) is getting more attention. I hope it will grow in popularity and help people want to see the games as entertaining and motivating in their own right (rather than a second best to the standard men’s games).

StaunchMomma · 01/08/2022 15:52

Season tickets, general ticket sales, kit sales & merchandise & Sky/BT coverage deals bring in HUGE sums of money to Premier League clubs annually BUT that's all via the men's first teams, not the women's. I for one would rather the players get a fat chunk of this than owners and share holders creaming it all off so I'm fine with massive player wages (so long as the club can afford it and isn't being mismanaged).

Whether we like it or not, currently women's teams do not bring in the revenue to warrant equal pay.

If & when women's games start to draw equal sized crowds and are routinely televised then their pay would need to increase. I'd like to see that happen & I do hope clubs start selling more tickets to women's games on the back of the Euros
but it would take both time and a massive shift in viewer thinking.

The other difference is in the number of games played per season. Men's teams play a lot more games due to tournaments etc, plus their leagues are larger (so more teams to play home & away p/season).

I've really enjoyed the women's Euro's but honestly I'm 100 times more excited for the Prem to get going at the end of the week and I'm sure most football fans feel the same.

Rewis · 01/08/2022 15:47

I know this is an irrelevant point. But Liverpool women's team played last season in Champioonship and got promoted to super league (so essentially the women's premiere league) so they didn't play top level

DillonPanthersTexas · 01/08/2022 15:45

As she said it is growing and it will change but it isn't going to happen overnight.

Nope, and the only way it is going to change more quickly is if lots of the people on here start paying at the gate to watch their local women's team, buying merchandise, subscribing to whatever broadcaster is showing the games as well supporting the grass roots aspect of the sport by signing your daughters up to the local side and volunteering to help.

I have to confess when it comes to the expansion and developing the mainstream appeal of women's professional sports there is a whiff of it's someone else's job to do the actual leg work of physically going to watch your local side.

DashboardConfessional · 01/08/2022 15:41

A better analogy is that Corrie actors get paid more than Hollyoaks actors. They are all doing the "same" job but more viewers. The issue with football is the women can't get "cast" in men's footie and women tennis players can't choose to play a 5 set final.

Rewis · 01/08/2022 15:41

National team players should be (and are) paid the same by the FA. But you can't apply "equal work, equal pay" for club teams. It's not just Liverpool and they split profits. It's two different leagues and 2 different clubs. The other produces more profit and therefore employees make more. CEO of Amazon gets paid more than then CEO of Milton's bakery. Both are CEO and does similar work but they can't be paid the same.

I play football and regularly attend women's games. We need to support by going to games. We need to buy products with Leah Williamsons face on it so they'll get sponsorship. We need to watch games to get TV deals. I'd love to have all the national leagues for women to be professional but it can't be same pay at a club level. That's just not how it works. Maybe some point.

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 15:41

@Kazzyhoward actually I do get it now. I hadn’t really thought about it as entertainment…. Just sport, so the point you make resonates with me.

it’s just that the reasons for the mens sport having more viewing figures could be partly / mostly attributed due to my reasons above. So again some unfair advantage there

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread